ChasingMavericks
Full Member
- Joined
- Apr 29, 2020
- Messages
- 28
- Reaction score
- 10
Title says it all.
What do you guys think about this?
What do you guys think about this?
On the surface: no. Many anesthesiologists make a great income doing great work without fellowship training. I suspect this will continue to be the case.
On deeper dive: you should just do whatever you want. We plan, God laughs. We have A LOT of naysayers, cynics and clairvoyants on this board, and none predicted a pandemic. I did fellowship, and it so happens that in this unpredictable, bizarre environment, I didn’t have the pay cut or furlough experiences that some of my buddies doing mainly outpatient work experienced. But I did what I wanted, and I have a niche that works for me and my employer. I don’t think everyone NEEDS a fellowship, but you should do one if you want to, and don’t if you don’t want to.
So your cardiac guys don’t have the ability to do general cases?Very much agree with this. I was more in the “fellowship is job security camp” ... then the pandemic came along. I was a big proponent of cardiac (strongly biased of course), but our volume is down a staggering 90% and those that were 100% cardiac were basically out of a job for the better part of 6 weeks.
So your cardiac guys don’t have the ability to do general cases?
I would think with low volume the guy who can do cardiac + general + peds is the most valuable. More cases, less personnel
For me I did cardiac and ccm and I do general and peds and it certainly paid off job security wise as well as financially. There is a also a massive CRNA influx and u should have something they don't for sure. Definitely do it even though there aren't many cases. By having a cardiac fellowship u will be more or less bound to hospitals if that's ok with u.
Also heart surgeons seem to still have a choice ehobthey prefer to work with and love to blame their disasters on us.
Pain fellowship gives u independence from surgeons and it will tie u to surgery centers but I'm hearing there's little money in it now and tons of work and paperwork plus dealing with difficult patients.
Correct me where u think I'm wrong everyone.
Sent from my SM-F900U1 using Tapatalk
There is a also a massive CRNA influx and u should have something they don't for sure.
So your cardiac guys don’t have the ability to do general cases?
While I hear variations of this statement often, I'm sick of hearing it. He/she WILL have something CRNAs don't. They'll have a medical degree and a residency. I get that hospitals don't necessarily see the difference there and you can argue that as a reason to do a fellowship. I know you know the difference between a non-fellowship trained anesthesiologist and a CRNA thanks to their difference in training, but I don't like your wording which suggests otherwise.
Title says it all.
What do you guys think about this?
I have a question about your logic here:Yes. It’s a must going forward. Glorified CRNA if you don’t do a fellowship. No guarantees even if you do one but as both providers reach parity in the O.R. The fellowship will help distinguish you from the Doctor Nurses.
All you will hear from those not willing to do a fellowship is the lost money. What matters most over 30 years is not 1 year of lost income but rather job satisfaction and career advancement. I’d argue you are more likely to obtain both after a fellowship.
Not sure what you mean about this “career advancement”. the vast majority of us will only be doing cases or signing charts from day 1 of being an attending until the day we retire, weather they are general, peds or cardiac cases. The regulations surrounding CRNA’s and the overall surgical demand will determine our income and working conditions....Yes. It’s a must going forward. Glorified CRNA if you don’t do a fellowship. No guarantees even if you do one but as both providers reach parity in the O.R. The fellowship will help distinguish you from the Doctor Nurses.
All you will hear from those not willing to do a fellowship is the lost money. What matters most over 30 years is not 1 year of lost income but rather job satisfaction and career advancement. I’d argue you are more likely to obtain both after a fellowship.
Yes. It’s a must going forward. Glorified CRNA if you don’t do a fellowship. No guarantees even if you do one but as both providers reach parity in the O.R. The fellowship will help distinguish you from the Doctor Nurses.
All you will hear from those not willing to do a fellowship is the lost money. What matters most over 30 years is not 1 year of lost income but rather job satisfaction and career advancement. I’d argue you are more likely to obtain both after a fellowship.
What's happening to the general anesthesiologists in the 27 opt out states now? Do the CRNAs have to collect the full 50 states to start their morphing time?Guys..gentlemen, doctors: nobody is saying if u don't have a fellowship u're not better then a CRNA ! Were trying to help a young colleague have the best chances in his career. As CRNAs are getting to work independently now in the VA system, in Arizona etc they will be gaining ground and taking away employment opportunities from the DOs and MDs. It's going to be worse than it is now ! And likely even harder in 5-10-15 years !
There is going to be fewer jobs for non-fellowship trained anesthesia doctors ! Very little doubt this is not going to happen. A peds fellowship is good for doing neonates, sick neonates etc. Cardiac is good. CCM - few opportunities and competition frompulmonologists. It's also really a different specialty, it's not really anesthesia. OB fellowship only if u wanna do academic work. Pain is separate, not much money in it any longer I hear ?
Choose a fellowship where u will learn TEE very well. Cardiologists who are doing more and more invasive work like Watchman, TAVR, MV clipping will be doing more such procedures and will ask for you if u get TEE board certification ! Financially it doesn't even compare - u will get 25-30% more than others - u can calculate the amount yourself. I am happy my son isn't in your shoes - I'd make him do the cardiac fellowship for sure - in 10 yrs there will be CRNAs everywhere and u will b lucky if they let u sign charts. However painful this sounds to many it is the truth. And even if it's not gonna happen that fast it will still make u feel more protected.
Sent from my SM-F900U1 using Tapatalk
What's happening to the general anesthesiologists in the 27 opt out states now? Do the CRNAs have to collect the full 50 states to start their morphing time?
You'll see (and should decide) in 2025-2030 then. 😉I agree in 2020 a fellowship is not a must but we are talking about 2025...2030..
If I were a smart PD, interested in excellence, I wouldn't hire new grads unless I had no choice, or they were geniuses. Even a few years of attending-level practice make for a world of difference.Very few people go back..it's a rarity.
I agree in 2020 a fellowship is not a must but we are talking about 2025...2030..
In 2020 a fellowship is not a MUST. There are plenty of generalist jobs available all over the country. It’s not like a few years ago in rads where no one could get a job without 1 or 2 fellowships - that was a MUST situation. Not remotely close to that in anesthesia right now. Down the road - who knows???
But they can mostly choose what surgeries they want to do. 😉Same with ortho. I haven’t seen a new orthopedist without a fellowship in 15 years.
So then plead for a CARDIAC fellowship, not just any. Nobody will contradict you about that...yes a fellowship is done in 2020 but it stays with you and will be more important in 2025 and later because of the influx of CRNAs. I have done a fellowship and there was always a need for some cardiac work. I always got better money and was always needed for my knowledge of TEE.
Whoever can do a fellowship and doesn't do it is foolish - it's just 12 months and u can usually get in a good name program, Cleveland Clinic etc.
I'm not sure if doing a regional fellowship is any good, most people learn blocks by themselves from YouTube these days and most residents without a fellowship can do blocks already.
Sent from my SM-F900U1 using Tapatalk
There are a lot of BS fellowships that really don't teach enough to make the year of investment worth it (ex. cardiac fellowships that only do bread and butter with subpar echo training, regional fellowships that only do bread and butter blocks, etc. - These "fellowships" are basically looking for cheap labors in return for a certificate.
So then plead for a CARDIAC fellowship, not just any. Nobody will contradict you about that.
I remember exactly the "genius" who kept advising people to do a CCM fellowship (among others) years ago, because it swayed me, too, back when I knew even less than the nothing I know now. I loved my fellowship, hate the job market.
I know CCM Anesthesia docs doing hearts. Quite a few actually. I would argue that for some practices a CCM trained MD is more than adequate to do Cabg and Valves.
The fact that the ABA wastes time during the residency process is the reason every resident can’t be CCM boarded. I’d argue to change the program to include CCM as part of the 4 year residency like in Europe. Despite the blow back on this board I’d argue that a 5 year program which includes CCM and a subspecialty like peds or Cardiac is exactly what this profession needs. That extra year gives you the option of both CCM boards and another subspecialty. We should stop watering the field down with outpatient cases and ridiculous electives and refocus on what it is important.
That certificate is often your only ticket in. I'd make the case that peds hearts and advanced cardiac make a difference in terms of clinical skill. Everything else, you should be good enough to do once graduating from a decent residency. No ticket = no entry. That's the price of doing business and this will only escalate once CRNA's gain their independence.
The thought is good, however don't forget that IM folks must do 2-3 years of fellowship to be CCM board eligible. So during this extra year of anesthesia residency the individual will need to actually be treated as and given the responsibilities of a fellow. Until they aren't H&P and progress note monkeys the extra year is just a way of extending residency.I agree with this sentiment, but many, if not most, ICU experience for ca 1-3 is basically doing intern work. Doing more “intern level work” in icu wont prepare anesthesiologists to be able to cover ccm.
icu experience for anesthesiology residents should change to mirror IM residents’ experience. You do intern level work as intern, and you take on senior role as senior, overseeing all of the patients, and making appropriate decisions. Only very few anesthesiology residency give this icu experience to residents.
I agree with this sentiment, but many, if not most, ICU experience for ca 1-3 is basically doing intern work. Doing more “intern level work” in icu wont prepare anesthesiologists to be able to cover ccm.
icu experience for anesthesiology residents should change to mirror IM residents’ experience. You do intern level work as intern, and you take on senior role as senior, overseeing all of the patients, and making appropriate decisions. Only very few anesthesiology residency give this icu experience to residents.
As more and more of us become employed that really makes no difference. Your employer will to the tough peds and heart cases at the facility so money can be made off elective Ortho and plastics. My feeling is that independent CRNA’s can ( unfortunately) cover the bread and butter cases safely enough overall...I was under impression that Peds doesn't pay that well because medicaid. And Cardiac doesn't pay that well because medicare? But I'm not in either of those fields to know. I hated cardiac and do not enjoy those tertiary referral peds cases, so I'm just generalist. I do feel poorly for the overall future and hence saving aggressively.