Is it bad to interview early?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

R Sterling

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
I got an invite from a program and they said they wanted me to interview soon. The actually offered to interview me the next day but I turned it down. I am interviewing this tuesday. Is this too soon? I was told I am going to be the only person they are interviewing on that day. Any advice? Also, I'm a IMG. Does that have anything to do with it? Any tips for interview day?
 
I got an invite from a program and they said they wanted me to interview soon. The actually offered to interview me the next day but I turned it down. I am interviewing this tuesday. Is this too soon? I was told I am going to be the only person they are interviewing on that day. Any advice? Also, I'm a IMG. Does that have anything to do with it? Any tips for interview day?

I'm not applying til next year, but from the sound of it they are really interested in you and you should interview with them and ace it as soon as you can! If you like it there, and they clearly like you, you could perhaps pre-match as an IMG and avoid the whole stressful albeit "fun/interesting" match process altogether...
ace it by doin' all the usual: know all about yourself and why you want psych and know all about them and how they can get you to your goals
 
The advantage to interviewing early is if you want to pre-match. My experience is that sometimes programs will offer to pre-match someone before they've finished interviewing everyone so if you wait until the end of the season they may have already given the pre-match to someone else.
The problem with interviewing early at somewhere that you really like is that you may be more nervous and less polished at the beginning of the season than the end (by the end, you'll have learned what kind of questions to expect and you'll probably have refined some good answers to all of them). Anecdotally, I also noticed that programs seem to be more likely to do interviews that consist only of "So what questions do you have for me?" or "Tell me something that's not in your application" (questions that often suggest the interviewer didn't bother to look at your app and doesn't know what to ask you about 😛 ) whereas it seems like later in the season they usually have more meaningful questions ready.
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Interviewing early is not a disadvantage. The busy season for interviews is mid-Nov to mid-Jan. During this time both programs and applicants are sometimes hard pressed to get all the interviews in. Going early not only gets it done but allows you the time to do another later on in its place.
 
Agree with all the above. You can prematch. I've written about this in other threads but prematching has it's pros and cons.

1-if you prematch, you might be cutting off opportunities to see other programs.
2-if you prematch, you could be cutting short a process that could be very trying, or enlightening, depending on how your interview process goes.
3-the interview process for many is extremely expensive, time-consuming, and stressful. A prematch could get rid of all these woes.

I was offered a few prematches and I'm glad I didn't take any of them. I was too green at the time to know what I could've been missing out on. It worked out for me, but for others, prematching may be the way to go.

I will say if you prematch, fight the urge to sign the paper and think about it. Most medstudents are in a position where after years of self-denial, it's nice to have someone want you to join them very quickly. That urge could knock your senses a bit.

You really have to weigh everything-e.g. the strength of the program (how will you know unless you see other programs?), the pay (base salary, moonlighting opportunities), the atmosphere of the program, etc.

Otherwise, the timing of the interview in relation to the season may matter per program, but it likely differs with each program. Some programs I've seen want to see the people they like best first. Others don't have any particular order to the timing. IF you see them at the end of the season, you could make a stronger mark on their memory. In others, the program already has it's mind set on who it'll pick even before the last set of people come it.

Bottom line: it could matter, but there's no way you'll know unless you have insider information, so just focus on being calm, confident and having a good interview day.

I've sat through 3 program directors in my program. Each one had a very different style.
 
The interview went very well!!!! I interviewed with the PD last, and he said to me (without even asking!) that interviewing this early is not a disadvantage. He also said that they interview around 60 people total for about 7 positions, and that I was in the first 10 they interviewed. I was not offered a prematch on the spot (who really is?) but he did say to me that if I get an offer elsewhere and I want to come to his hospital, let him know. (I think around January he said?) I'm hoping that is a good thing that I can use to my advantage. I do want to end up at that hospital in particular, primarily because of the location. The program seems very strong also. I sent a thank you email and I enquired about prematching. Any ideas of what I can do to get in there???