is it ok to buy older edition books

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

jellygreen2001

Junior Member
10+ Year Member
7+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Sep 25, 2005
Messages
34
Reaction score
0
please help me guys. I am totally stressed out cause I can't figure out if I should get books that are one edition old (it would save me a ton of money if I do this) Would i be at a big disadvantage if I did this. Please help, any feedback would help

thanks

Members don't see this ad.
 
Hey, for classes that I just need a pass in I bought the used version, the only differences will be so minor that it will only really affect you if you are trying to ace the class. If you're tryin to rock it out I would splurge on the newer versions of the text. Also talk to some of your second years as some books really aren't necessary at all if you're not gunning it.
 
Hey, for classes that I just need a pass in I bought the used version, the only differences will be so minor that it will only really affect you if you are trying to ace the class. If you're tryin to rock it out I would splurge on the newer versions of the text. Also talk to some of your second years as some books really aren't necessary at all if you're not gunning it.

how different RE PREVIOUS BOOK EDITIONS? sometimes i feel they are exactly the same
 
Members don't see this ad :)
i dont think it makes any difference.

sometimes its a pain in the ass when the professor references page numbers instead of chapters, but besides that, why not save a few bucks.

in the end we're all learning the same BS anyway for step 1.
 
please help me guys. I am totally stressed out cause I can't figure out if I should get books that are one edition old (it would save me a ton of money if I do this) Would i be at a big disadvantage if I did this. Please help, any feedback would help

thanks

Some things rarely change and so you can use older editions. For example, nothing has changed in human anatomy for many years and people are still relying on Netter many decades after Netter has passed. So too something like embryology. By contrast, in courses like biochem, pharmacology, etc there will be new information in most texts every year, as the area is full of new discoveries. Whether a single year of developments will necessitate buying a new book depends on how "state of the art" your course is. If your professors are using their same noteset year after year, then the old book should suffice as well. Just bear in mind that page references in course materials may not be valid if you are not using the same edition.
 
please help me guys. I am totally stressed out cause I can't figure out if I should get books that are one edition old (it would save me a ton of money if I do this) Would i be at a big disadvantage if I did this. Please help, any feedback would help

thanks


Hey. I think it all depends on the subject. For example, in a course like Gross Anatomy, I don't think that anyone will be discovering a new muscle or artery any time soon! I know guys who have anatomy books 3 editions old!!! They only have minor problems in refrencing, sometimes. However, in courses like Biochem or even phys, it's better to have the latest edition. Cuz there are always new discoveries in those fields. Another issue to consider is whether the book has a supplemented CD. It always pays to have the newest version of that.


I'm out>>>
 
If it's Netter Atlas, then go for it!

For medicine (e.g. Harrison's), it's vital to have the latest additions, as even 5 years will change the face of treatment of many conditions (e.g. newer classes of drugs, new surgical procedures and investigative methods).

For other subjects (physiology, biochem etc): the 'new discoveries' aren't that significant, but newer editions often have better diagrams and improved presentation, making study that much easier.

I agree with the person above who recommended looking for 2nd hand copies of current edition textbooks.

And don't forget, there is always the library!
 
in courses like biochem, pharmacology, etc there will be new information in most texts every year
I have studied biochem for several years, and new discoveries are VERY SLOW to enter text books, so as long as the book was published within the last 5 years, you should be fine. Your prof will likely highlight relevant, new discoveries.
 
I have a gray's anatomy 1958 which I thumb threw now..but I'm not a medical student....but for some reason I like the feel of the old books in certain cases. Just go by a case by case basis..some times the new books are nicer...but if you can save a bunch of money by going one edition down then why not?
 
There is no better study material than class handouts and my own notes... assuming I showed up for class that hour. And most textbooks are now available online, so I tried to avoid buying any of the books, even the 'required' ones. The books that I did buy merely collected dust on the shelves until I sold them to other students. I wish I had bought more board review series books and used them throughout the first two years rather than wasting time muscling through dense fat books. And during third year, there was nothing better than sharing a pool of books with a group of friends handed down for free from the previous year (etc. blueprints, pretest, recall). Now that I'm a resident, I've dumped almost all the books I spent money on, except for the obvious ones like Netter (free), Harrisons, Stedmans, and Robbins.
 
My housemate used to bring home books written in the 1960's, probably found in some corner of a library, covered in dust. They used to be huge texts, and we called him the professor.

Either way, there is no discernable differences between older versions that are maybe one or two editions old. Publishers just revamp a few things, colourise the text, add a few bits and bobs, but mainly the reenergise the edition to sell more texts. The bulk of the actual content is the same.

For medical student needs, a slightly older (and much cheaper) edition is fine! Alternatively, a library provides it for free! (if u want a 1960s copy!) 😱 😱
 
Top