- Joined
- Apr 6, 2014
- Messages
- 14,146
- Reaction score
- 22,778
Bing, really? A 36 is 97th percentile.
Very misleading to try and cast public seats as the majority of an applicant's options like that. In reality most people have their own state school(s) to apply to, a few that are friendly to out of state applicants, and then mostly private schools filling out their list. An Ivy applicant with a 3.5 / 35 can make a fine list using only private schools. Regardless of alma mater, a 3.5 / 35 that gets in nowhere likely has problems other than their numbers that explain their outcomes.
I don't understand your bit about that source earlier - saying that high SAT scores predict high earnings regardless of alma mater does not establish anything about whether premeds get a boost in med admissions from attending top private schools.
Note I'm mostly in your camp on this issue (with exceptions for cases I listed earlier), I think students have to be very cautious before enrolling at a lot of elite colleges because of the stiff competition and high weedout.
Very misleading to try and cast public seats as the majority of an applicant's options like that. In reality most people have their own state school(s) to apply to, a few that are friendly to out of state applicants, and then mostly private schools filling out their list. An Ivy applicant with a 3.5 / 35 can make a fine list using only private schools. Regardless of alma mater, a 3.5 / 35 that gets in nowhere likely has problems other than their numbers that explain their outcomes.
I don't understand your bit about that source earlier - saying that high SAT scores predict high earnings regardless of alma mater does not establish anything about whether premeds get a boost in med admissions from attending top private schools.
Note I'm mostly in your camp on this issue (with exceptions for cases I listed earlier), I think students have to be very cautious before enrolling at a lot of elite colleges because of the stiff competition and high weedout.