JEFFERSON vs. PENN STATE (Your opinions are very important to me)

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

classylady06

New Member
10+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Feb 2, 2006
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Hi everyone,

I'm very lucky to get accepted to both Jefferson and Penn State medical schools, I like both of them, but can only choose one. So I hope to make a decision soon, so that I give a seat at one of these schools to other deserving students. Please give me some feedbacks on advantages and disadvantages of attending these schools. Thank you for your help and the best of luck to all of you.

Members don't see this ad.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
well, strictly looking at the MSAR, penn state has higher stats. not to diss out jefferson. both are great schools, but u shud take that into consideration i guess. and ya, i agree with bgreet, our opinions shouldn't matter to u that much.
 
Man, I wouldn't touch Penn State with a hundred-foot pole. It's been permanently ingrained on my psyche to bitterly hate anything that even vaguely resembles a Nittany Lion or Joe Paterno.

Go to Jefferson.

Don't even get me started about Buckeyes.

:meanie:
 
Come again? You don't like Penn State because of their mascot? Seriously, though, I'd be interested in this comparison as well.
 
ashabee4 said:
Come again? You don't like Penn State because of their mascot? Seriously, though, I'd be interested in this comparison as well.

I'll give you a hint. My name is LadyWOLVERINE.
 
I like Penn State better.
 
jefferson probably has a better reputation among M.D.s
-mota
 
I'm in the same situation (same schools) and to me it comes down to a couple of different factors that have little to do with rankings cause for the most part, they are very similar (jefferson has a better reputation because its older and there's more practicing physicians that are jeff alumni than another med school in the country. yada yada)

Location: Philadelphia (downtown of big city) or Hershey (suburban/rural area)
Cost: Jefferson (60,000/year) or Penn State (45,000/yr)
Reputation for Primary Care - Penn State
Reputation for Specialized Care - Jefferson

If money is not an issue, I would say go with whichever school you would feel happier at. don't worry about the other silly stuff. And if your still worried about which school to choose, go to both of their second looks and then decide - that way you wont have any regrets.

Hope that helps!
 
I would probably go to Jefferson. You can't loose either way, but I couldn't see myself living in Hershey for 4 yrs.
 
jefferson --> bunch o' hospitals around = good rotational exp; rank/prestige (if that matters to you); philadelphia.
 
ajs08 said:
I'm in the same situation (same schools) and to me it comes down to a couple of different factors that have little to do with rankings cause for the most part, they are very similar (jefferson has a better reputation because its older and there's more practicing physicians that are jeff alumni than another med school in the country. yada yada)

Location: Philadelphia (downtown of big city) or Hershey (suburban/rural area)
Cost: Jefferson (60,000/year) or Penn State (45,000/yr)
Reputation for Primary Care - Penn State
Reputation for Specialized Care - Jefferson

If money is not an issue, I would say go with whichever school you would feel happier at. don't worry about the other silly stuff. And if your still worried about which school to choose, go to both of their second looks and then decide - that way you wont have any regrets.

Hope that helps!

This guy/gal says it all, so take his/her post into serious consideration. They both have good reputations. However, I do feel that Hershey's reputation is bolstered mainly by the presence of Joe Paterno, and unfortunately, well, he's just not a doctor.
Personally I like Jefferson ALOT better, but that's because I'm planning on being a surgeon. If your not planning on doing any type of specialty care, probobly the most important factors would be location. Let me say that again. Probobly the most important factor would be location. Should I say it again?

Jefferson is located in a REALLY nice part of Philly (the part that is extremely fun, pretty safe, and full of young people -- as opposed to the rest of Philly which is....umm...not...), Hershey is located in a town with a VERY limited supply of young people, culture, fun, etc. Decide what type of student you are, what type of doctor you want to be, and what type of life you like. That should make the decision alot easier.

Also, it is also ALWAYS a good idea to check out the match stats the school has for what type of doctor you want to be. For someone planning on going into a super-hard-to-match specialty, that makes all the difference in the world.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
ajs08 said:
And if your still worried about which school to choose, go to both of their second looks and then decide - that way you wont have any regrets.

I would also say to go to the second looks at the given schools and try to get a better feeling for the two. While it would be selfish to continue to hold places at schools that you are no longer considering, if you really are genuinely thinking about both schools, then do not worry about holding your place for now. With the general policy of overaccepting, it is likely that the spot won't be filled until after May 15 anyways, since (if I'm correct and please correct me if I'm wrong) most schools have an approximate number of students that they'll accept initially, then they'll wait to see how many intend to matriculate, and then start accepting off the wait list. However, this varies from school to school, and I am not familiar with the specifics of Penn State or Jeff's policies.

Also keep in mind that if you want an urban med school, Jeff has an amazing location. Philly is also a great place to be a student, because there is much more than you'll ever have the time to do (at least during med school) and its relatively cheap compared to Boston, NYC, DC, San Fran etc. You can also very easily and relatively cheaply get to NYC when you have the time.
 
You have to decide which is right for you, and why, of course.
But, since you asked, I'd go to Jefferson, because the two doctors I have the most respect for and who I think are the greatest people & surgeons in the world both went there. But I'm not biased or anything 😉
 
If Penn State were like some other state schools, with a tuition that's actually significantly lower than private, it would be much more attractive to me. As it is, I'm comparing spending $30k for tuition to spending $38k for tuition each year. And yeah, that's a difference, but it's not enough of a difference to really be a decision-maker for me. Penn State does have lower cost of living, slightly, so their budgets look different.

For some reason the thing that stuck out most in my mind when I was at Penn State was the students telling me about their first anatomy exam. There was an essay question that said, "Tell me about the knee." So, yeah....I don't want to have tests like that. But the students all seemed pretty happy, and personally I love the rural location.

Jefferson has a fairly good reputation (and, if it matters to you, USNews ranks it). They have a nice hospital system. Their curriculum seems pretty cool, and they post mp3s online. But I just can't get over what I personally feel is the bad attitude/arrogance of the students. I just haven't ever met a Jefferson student that I really liked a lot, and I've met a lot (I live in Philly around a lot of med students).

my 2 cents
 
LadyWolverine said:
Man, I wouldn't touch Penn State with a hundred-foot pole. It's been permanently ingrained on my psyche to bitterly hate anything that even vaguely resembles a Nittany Lion or Joe Paterno.

Go to Jefferson.

Don't even get me started about Buckeyes.

:meanie:
Nothing beats a turtle. Luckily Maryland fans hate PSU as well!
 
Hi, I'm currently an upper year med student at Jeff- I'd be more than happy to share my experiences thus far, feel free to email me if you have any questions
 
red dot said:
Jefferson

damn. i wish you had put up your myspace link while i was still up north so i could've made a move
-mota
 
classylady06 said:
Hi everyone,

I'm very lucky to get accepted to both Jefferson and Penn State medical schools, I like both of them, but can only choose one. So I hope to make a decision soon, so that I give a seat at one of these schools to other deserving students. Please give me some feedbacks on advantages and disadvantages of attending these schools. Thank you for your help and the best of luck to all of you.


Go to Jeff and help out all of us on hold at PS-Hershey
 
drmota said:
damn. i wish you had put up your myspace link while i was still up north so i could've made a move
-mota

too bad -- i've been needing a little of that! :laugh:
 
I don't have much to offer, other than you can't really use US news because Penn State doesn't participate.
 
Reputation for Primary Care - Penn State
Reputation for Specialized Care - Jefferson

This is pretty much wrong. I am pretty familiar with Penn State and there is nothing to indicate that psu has a reputation for primary care or jefferson has one for specialized.

As far as cutting edge research, Penn State wins hands down.

Location? Jefferson wins hands down.

In my opinion, these two schools are virtually identical in quality. Among MDs, you are very likely to find that they have the same reputation. However, I do believe PSU is constantly growing and getting stronger (a product of being attached to a big name university), something I am not sure of about Jefferson

Bottom line? If you are set on living the city life and experiencing diverse patients while in med school, and money is not a factor, choose Jeff. If you are thinking about saving money or are interested in research, choose Penn State because both schools are great quality.
 
Anybody else notice that the OP was in '06?

Anyways, besides the location, rep, etc, one thing to consider is the type of patient that you'll see. Penn State see less trauma cases vs Jeff, and virtually no infectious disease (AIDS for eg).

Also, the Penn State staff is hands down the most friendly, caring, and genuinely compassionate people I've met.

I also second Jeff's MS being pompous asses.
 
I might add that as a medical student, in response to the poster who said he was going to "Jeff because he is going to be a surgeon", it really doesn't matter what reputation the school has for "primary care" or for "specialized care". You do the same rotations at both schools and have plenty of access to primary care at Jeff and specialized care at Hershey. Medical school is about getting a good, well-rounded education. It is not about learning specialty care; that's what residency is for. You can do anything you want, from any medical school - the significant factor is not the "reputation" of the school for "field X" but rather YOU, your USMLE scores, LORs, etc.

I may be biased, but somehow Hershey was able to graduate many people who went on to become surgical specialists...I saw their pictures everyday when walking through the Surgery Department halls.
 
This is pretty much wrong. I am pretty familiar with Penn State and there is nothing to indicate that psu has a reputation for primary care or jefferson has one for specialized.

As far as cutting edge research, Penn State wins hands down.

Location? Jefferson wins hands down.

In my opinion, these two schools are virtually identical in quality. Among MDs, you are very likely to find that they have the same reputation. However, I do believe PSU is constantly growing and getting stronger (a product of being attached to a big name university), something I am not sure of about Jefferson

Bottom line? If you are set on living the city life and experiencing diverse patients while in med school, and money is not a factor, choose Jeff. If you are thinking about saving money or are interested in research, choose Penn State because both schools are great quality.

Jefferson is growing - building a better campus and admitting more students. We have a new President, Dr. Barchi, who has a really ambitious plan for Jeff. I'd write more (maybe I will later), but I'm in a huge rush.

Jeff's reputation for strong specialities prob. come from its association with Wills Eye and Rothman and Jeff Hospital for Neurosci (esp. Neurosurg)

Anybody else notice that the OP was in '06?

Anyways, besides the location, rep, etc, one thing to consider is the type of patient that you'll see. Penn State see less trauma cases vs Jeff, and virtually no infectious disease (AIDS for eg).

Also, the Penn State staff is hands down the most friendly, caring, and genuinely compassionate people I've met.

I also second Jeff's MS being pompous asses.

Well, you'll see a lot of ID in PSU too - as long as there are a fair amount of people, there will be HIV. It might be less than what you'd see in Philadelphia, but still a fair amount.


I'm sorry you and Lunaire came away with the negative impression of Jeff students (especially because, based on Lunaire's other posts s/he seemed eager to go to Jeff). I am a Jeff med student, and I don't think that I'm a pompous ass. (Hope not, in any case!) My ~1000 school mates aren't either. If you could tell me how you got that impression, maybe I'd understand better, but, as it is, I'm puzzled by your opinion. All I can tell you is that my classmates have overwhelmed me with their generosity and help, and really are a great bunch of people.
 
Jefferson has a fairly good reputation (and, if it matters to you, USNews ranks it). They have a nice hospital system. Their curriculum seems pretty cool, and they post mp3s online.

Jefferson has improved its lecture recording system - now it's not just mp3s. The mp3s are synched with the powerpoint presentation and the professors can use a computer pad and stylus to point things out, underline, or add helpful diagrams. (Think "Monday Night Football" analysis) I don't think that Hershey records its lectures.

Jefferson also provides its students with a free, pre-printed packet of lecture notes for all lectures. I don't think that Hershey does this - they're free online, but students have to print them out themselves. Not a big deal to some people, but it would be for me.
 
I'd say the two things you need to consider are location and environment. Hershey has some great facilities, but there's absolutely nothing to do other than go to Hershey Park (a pretty good theme park) and shop at outlets. The main thing to do on the weekend is go into Harrisburg, which is about 15 minutes away, and has some ok bars. Jefferson is right in the middle of center city Philadelphia, so that's hard to beat.

I spent a month doing a program at Hershey (as a PSU undergrad) and all the students and faculty there are the nicest people you could meet, and they alone made me consider going to Hershey despite my desire to be in an urban setting. I've met a grand total of one Jeff student I like, and I've ran into quite a few over the years. They really think highly of themselves, and refuse to admit that they're not the best med school in Philly.

So if you want a really nice, relaxed rural experience, I'd go with Hershey. If you want to live in the city, and come out of med school with an inferiority complex to Penn, go to Jeff.
 
Penn State.

Everyone harps on the suburban/rural location of Hershey, but I personally prefer it to the city. Hershey was safe, comfortable, quiet, conducive to studying. Everyone was really friendly and down to earth as well.
 
I'm sorry you and Lunaire came away with the negative impression of Jeff students (especially because, based on Lunaire's other posts s/he seemed eager to go to Jeff). I am a Jeff med student, and I don't think that I'm a pompous ass. (Hope not, in any case!) My ~1000 school mates aren't either. If you could tell me how you got that impression, maybe I'd understand better, but, as it is, I'm puzzled by your opinion. All I can tell you is that my classmates have overwhelmed me with their generosity and help, and really are a great bunch of people.

A agree. I actually found Jefferson students to be some of the friendliest and down to earth of all my interviews.
 
I'm sorry you and Lunaire came away with the negative impression of Jeff students (especially because, based on Lunaire's other posts s/he seemed eager to go to Jeff). I am a Jeff med student, and I don't think that I'm a pompous ass. (Hope not, in any case!) My ~1000 school mates aren't either. If you could tell me how you got that impression, maybe I'd understand better, but, as it is, I'm puzzled by your opinion. All I can tell you is that my classmates have overwhelmed me with their generosity and help, and really are a great bunch of people.

Actually, that was a mistake on my part. I have no problem with the students. The students that I met have all been absolutely great. I wasn't paying attention to what was said. My problem has all been with Jeff administration. I'd rather not go to into it on a public forum but I've had nothing but negative interactions with every faculty member I've met from that school. And when I say everyone, I'm including people who aren't even involoved in the admissions process.
 
I'm sorry you and Lunaire came away with the negative impression of Jeff students (especially because, based on Lunaire's other posts s/he seemed eager to go to Jeff). I am a Jeff med student, and I don't think that I'm a pompous ass. (Hope not, in any case!) My ~1000 school mates aren't either. If you could tell me how you got that impression, maybe I'd understand better, but, as it is, I'm puzzled by your opinion. All I can tell you is that my classmates have overwhelmed me with their generosity and help, and really are a great bunch of people.

Yup, I love Jeff, but not for the students. I'm not much of a people person, so this doesn't really affect my opinion of the med school.

Ok, why I called the MSs pompous? Because they openly belittled other med schools I asked their opinion on (for comparison). Perhaps it was not intentional, and that instead of looking down on other schools, the students were just really proud to be in an excellent med school, but it was a turn off nonetheless.
 
Yup, I love Jeff, but not for the students. I'm not much of a people person, so this doesn't really affect my opinion of the med school.

Wow! So why exactly are you going into medicine???
 
I've met a grand total of one Jeff student I like, and I've ran into quite a few over the years. They really think highly of themselves, and refuse to admit that they're not the best med school in Philly.

That's interesting to hear, because that's the total opposite of what my classmates and I say. I honestly don't really give Temple, Drexel, or Penn, a 2nd thought most of the time - not because I think that Jeff is "better" than those schools, but because I just don't have the mental energy.

We definitely don't think that highly of ourselves - it would be impossible to.

1) A lot of us have friends and neighbors who attend Drexel, Temple, Penn, or PCOM. I've run into a few students from Temple and Penn while studying in Center City, and my main feeling is that of empathy - I definitely can relate to how tired they must be.

2) It's hard to have an exalted opinion of yourself as a med student, in general, when you're constantly being reminded of how dumb you really are. "I studied for 8 days straight...and I STILL didn't get above a 75%?!?!" Positive, encouraging thoughts like that.)

Yup, I love Jeff, but not for the students. I'm not much of a people person, so this doesn't really affect my opinion of the med school.

Ok, why I called the MSs pompous? Because they openly belittled other med schools I asked their opinion on (for comparison). Perhaps it was not intentional, and that instead of looking down on other schools, the students were just really proud to be in an excellent med school, but it was a turn off nonetheless.

I'm sorry to hear this. I think, if you ask students (especially 1st and 2nd years) to comment directly on other schools, you're basically asking for very biased, and not very tactful answers. It's practically a guarantee that you will not get a fair and balanced answer. This is particularly true if you ask it on an admissions day-type event. Because they're trying to persuade you come to their school, offering an objective answer is hard, and rarely happens. If you've read a lot of the similar threads on SDN (School A vs School B), this phenomenon happens all the time: Someone who goes to school A makes sweeping (and somewhat inaccurate) generalizations about why his school is so much better than School B, and why he'd rather die than attend that school. In real life, the student at School A probably doesn't actively look down upon School B, but, in the context of the situation, that's how it comes across as. (I've probably been guilty of this myself to be honest.) Like I said, though, it's such a waste of energy for Jefferson students to look down on others, and that's definitely not what the students here really think. I mean - we have guest professors from Penn and Drexel come to lecture us in the first 2 years! Our SNMA and PSR (Physicians for Social Responsibility) chapters also team up with Penn and Drexel to host a lot of events and seminars. I think if you actually attend med school in Philadelphia, you'll find a collegial atmosphere, rather than an actively competitive one.

Actually, that was a mistake on my part. I have no problem with the students. The students that I met have all been absolutely great. I wasn't paying attention to what was said. My problem has all been with Jeff administration. I'd rather not go to into it on a public forum but I've had nothing but negative interactions with every faculty member I've met from that school. And when I say everyone, I'm including people who aren't even involoved in the admissions process.

I'm also sorry to hear this. The teaching faculty at Jefferson is usually really helpful, and tries to help students out. Our path professor bends over backwards to help the students do well on the exams. The JMC administration (Student Deans, Dr. Rattner, Dr. Callahan) and the Minority Affairs office are very helpful and supportive as well. I can't speak for the Jefferson University Administration and staff, but the JMC teaching faculty here is so helpful and supportive, I really can't tell you how much I appreciate them.
 
Wow! So why exactly are you going into medicine???

Do you seriously think that all premeds are entering medicine for the opportunity to interact with sick people everyday? I know a lot of great doctors who care more about the disease than the patient, and more than a few who're in it for the money. There's so much more that medicine has to offer besides the humanistic side.

Oh, and smq, I hope I didn't offend you by my generalization of Jeff students. It's just that I happen to really like some of the school that was dissed, and it just left an unpleasant impression.
 
Oh, and smq, I hope I didn't offend you by my generalization of Jeff students. It's just that I happen to really like some of the school that was dissed, and it just left an unpleasant impression.

Oh, no - not at all. I can understand how they came across as pompous to you. I was just eager to try and explain to you that, really - we're not all the enamoured with ourselves, and anyone at Jeff who was really that pompous would have a very hard time making friends here.

Do you seriously think that all premeds are entering medicine for the opportunity to interact with sick people everyday? I know a lot of great doctors who care more about the disease than the patient, and more than a few who're in it for the money. There's so much more that medicine has to offer besides the humanistic side.

I think that all med students and doctors need to be, on some level, "people persons." Not because you have to be a lovey-dovey, bleeding heart to be a good doctor, but because, at the very least, you have to be an effective teacher and communicator. Our pathology coordinator, Dr. Kocher, is a pathologist, and there is a stereotype that pathologists choose not to work with (living) patients because of their poor people skills. Dr. Kocher, though, is an incredibly kind and humane person, who is also one of the best professors I've ever had. He can take these ridiculously esoteric concepts, and break it down to understandable chunks. He explains things very well and naturally, so that you really understand where he's coming from and the disease process in general. Almost all of the radiologists that we've had in lecture so far at Jefferson have been the same way.

On that note - are you interested in pathology? It's a really cool intersection between clinical medicine and pure science, and they always invite students to come in and observe autopsies if they want - the path department here welcomes students with open arms. Radiology is also pretty popular among 4th year students around here, too.
 
I think that all med students and doctors need to be, on some level, "people persons." Not because you have to be a lovey-dovey, bleeding heart to be a good doctor, but because, at the very least, you have to be an effective teacher and communicator. Our pathology coordinator, Dr. Kocher, is a pathologist, and there is a stereotype that pathologists choose not to work with (living) patients because of their poor people skills. Dr. Kocher, though, is an incredibly kind and humane person, who is also one of the best professors I've ever had. He can take these ridiculously esoteric concepts, and break it down to understandable chunks. He explains things very well and naturally, so that you really understand where he's coming from and the disease process in general. Almost all of the radiologists that we've had in lecture so far at Jefferson have been the same way.

On that note - are you interested in pathology? It's a really cool intersection between clinical medicine and pure science, and they always invite students to come in and observe autopsies if they want - the path department here welcomes students with open arms. Radiology is also pretty popular among 4th year students around here, too.

I agree that we all have to be 'people person' to a certain level. What I meant in my original statement is that I classify myself as an introvert, so I really don't need that much external stimulus to keep me happy.

Re: specialty, I'm trying to keep an open mind. I just got my acceptance letter last week, and it feels like a whole new world's just opened up to be explored, you know? Now that you've advocated it, I'll definitely look closely into pathology as well.😀
 
If Penn State were like some other state schools, with a tuition that's actually significantly lower than private, it would be much more attractive to me. As it is, I'm comparing spending $30k for tuition to spending $38k for tuition each year. And yeah, that's a difference, but it's not enough of a difference to really be a decision-maker for me. Penn State does have lower cost of living, slightly, so their budgets look different.

For some reason the thing that stuck out most in my mind when I was at Penn State was the students telling me about their first anatomy exam. There was an essay question that said, "Tell me about the knee." So, yeah....I don't want to have tests like that. But the students all seemed pretty happy, and personally I love the rural location.

Jefferson has a fairly good reputation (and, if it matters to you, USNews ranks it). They have a nice hospital system. Their curriculum seems pretty cool, and they post mp3s online. But I just can't get over what I personally feel is the bad attitude/arrogance of the students. I just haven't ever met a Jefferson student that I really liked a lot, and I've met a lot (I live in Philly around a lot of med students).

my 2 cents

Just wanted to add that Penn State does not submit info to US News (to the best of my knowledge), so it has no chance of being ranked. We don't know if they would be ranked or not if they did decide to distribute their info...
 
As far as research rankings go, neither school has made any gains over the past two decades, and both have actually been trending downward.

As a general rule of thumb, though, when you're looking at two schools of similar caliber, the more established school in the more urban area is usually the one that can do more for your career.

Because Jefferson is a known commodity and its graduates are everywhere, you're not going to be totally shut out from any top-notch programs simply because of pre-conceived notions about the pedigree of your med school. If you're qualified, you'll have a fighting chance, and in some places, you'll stand to benefit from alumni connections.

That said, looking over recent match lists, both schools seem to place students into programs of similar caliber, and PSU appears to have no problem matching students into competitive specialties. (The "reputation for primary care" claim sounds totally off base.)

In the end, despite Jeff's marginally better rep, I would personally go with the less-reputed PSU simply to avoid living in Philadelphia. There are few cities in the developed world that appeal to me less than that armpit of a town (no offense to you Philly people).
 
As far as research rankings go, neither school has made any gains over the past two decades, and both have actually been trending downward.

Once again, PSU does not submit its info for ranking so we cannot make any assessments in this area, but PSU is better for research than Jeff. If you are interested in research, I would definitely go to PSU. They really push student research there - in fact, it's required for graduation. Before, I had never really thought of PSU as being very good in research but I have recently been hearing its praises by professors at top research institutions. For example, one area I work in is optical imaging (not affiliated with PSU), but I know that PSU is regarded as the leaders in small animal imaging.

That being said Jefferson probably has better clinical opportunities, so it all depends on what you personally are interested in.
 
bump...I'm looking for opinions about these 2 schools. I've been accepted to Jeff, but I was also hoping to get an interview at Penn State. I'm debating whether to send them a 3rd update.
 
However, I do feel that Hershey's reputation is bolstered mainly by the presence of Joe Paterno, and unfortunately, well, he's just not a doctor.

Umm, I hope you realize that there is a significant distance between State College, PA, where the main campus of Penn State's undergrad college is, and Hershey, PA where the med school is. JoePa is definitely located in State College, and not Hershey. I would say Hershey's reputation is bolstered by the chocolate factory.
 
Umm, I hope you realize that there is a significant distance between State College, PA, where the main campus of Penn State's undergrad college is, and Hershey, PA where the med school is. JoePa is definitely located in State College, and not Hershey. I would say Hershey's reputation is bolstered by the chocolate factory.

🤣
 
Top