Reasonably so. I will claim nothing approaching a "reading card" on this one, but I think he has looked more like himself the more he has played, especially once he had the opportunity to get into his usual solving methods (votes and association).How much do you trust your read of Nate here?
-
CycleTrack and SDN are teaming up to make medical school admissions more transparent and accessible! Read the announcement to learn how we’re supporting the future of CycleTrack’s free application-tracking tools .
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Kirby - Game Thread
Started by Animal Midwife
Get help with your application
Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.
Oh come on how perfect would it be if you were a jailer lol
It would be, maybe in another lifetime
This is a very restrictive POE, which is wonderful if it's accurate -- but there's the rub. If I am wrong, who am I wrong about?Zenge
Pippy
samac
Boquise
Nate
genny
mighty
DrWilgy
moonster
mothy
Dina
mayo
Gave moonster her own color, because Nate's point about the wolf agenda was difficult for me to answer.
Can you explain your Wilgy vote? TLDR?It would be, maybe in another lifetime![]()
Gonna quickly remind myself why mighty is town.
I think part of PSV's read was that Dubz might have been pushing Pippy to help you out, since you were a wagon at the time.Gotcha. in that case, I agree it is. But PSV did point it out, so
I guess this is okay. There's definitely wifom in it, so take care.Dubz/mighty interactions
Dubz on mighty:
The noteworthy thing here is that mighty voiced a town read of Dubz and doubts about the wagon when it had swelled to size. I don't think that's a "problem" necessarily, and from the standpoint of typical-wolf-behavior, initiating this kind of view while your partner is getting slaughtered would be atypical. The only counterpoint would be the last post there, in which mighty implies that the vote can still be moved to someone else (me I believe in this context) in the last ten minutes. So, sure I guess. I don't think this looks that bad overall.
These are all direct responses to mighty. This stuff looks generally unaligned, as Dubz both shaded mighty for "not actually reading my posts" and being "disingenuous", and also kept on her DEFENSIVE SMEAR CAMPAIGN to make ME look like her TEAMMATE (in response to his suspicions).
Conclusion:
I think the more telling posts come from Dubz, and they reflect well on mighty. He's not a suspect for me today.
mightyrunner7
Full Member
The trenchcoat, of courseGonna quickly remind myself why mighty is town.
Can you explain your Wilgy vote? TLDR?
The TLDR is the timing of the dubz vote with the town read on her earlier in the cycle
DrWilgy
Full Member
I thought you were town reading me?I like this game concerning current reads on the board:
JJJ > Wilgly = Dina > moonster > mayo
Day 2 Yeet Tally
Wilgy (2) - Pippy 65, Dina 50
Boq () -
Dina (3) - Boq 66, Wilgy 59, Zenge 35
mighty () -
JJJ (3) - mighty 37, mayo 46, moth 49
moon (2) - JJJ 146, samac 142
mayo (2) - Nate 72, moon 49
12/13
Missing: genny 24
yeet close in ~25 minutes
Wilgy (2) - Pippy 65, Dina 50
Boq () -
Dina (3) - Boq 66, Wilgy 59, Zenge 35
mighty () -
JJJ (3) - mighty 37, mayo 46, moth 49
moon (2) - JJJ 146, samac 142
mayo (2) - Nate 72, moon 49
12/13
Missing: genny 24
yeet close in ~25 minutes
DrWilgy
Full Member
Oh, nvm. Neutral W. I remembered specifically you saying that you liked the analysis and that's what stuck with me.@DrWilgy - neutral (W). I was going to put the doc into the POE, but then the flurry of activity this morning brings me pause. I appreciate the wolf pack analysis, because I think this will be the best approach to game solving. It's just something that I dont think I have enough data to effectively replicate. The other reads are fairly benign. I need more time to digest.
Wilgy and mighty aren't paired
This is a very restrictive POE, which is wonderful if it's accurate -- but there's the rub. If I am wrong, who am I wrong about?
Me for one.
But there is one of two good reasons for that
What’s your Wilgy read?Wilgy and mighty aren't paired
@genny holding her vote is interesting
Is it? Is she known for playing fast and loose with her votes?@genny holding her vote is interesting
Mostly town. I have had nagging doubts, but I don't think they're well-founded. He seems quite town to me when he makes posts, and I have to sell myself on suspicion when I get into review mode.What’s your Wilgy read?
Who's the 3rd wolf in your Dubz/JJJ world?Me for one.
But there is one of two good reasons for that
Is it? Is she known for playing fast and loose with her votes?
Yeah. She's usually not the timid type.
I suspect she's just busy
DrWilgy
Full Member
I'd honestly say that Genny is causing me the most tinfoil paranoia of everyone.@genny holding her vote is interesting
Like if I'm wrong on BOTH Dina and one in Moon/JJJ then it's just gotta be Genny right?
mightyrunner7
Full Member
Remember when I stated that we could have big changes in the last 10 minutes? I feel a hectic vote close coming@genny holding her vote is interesting
This is too spread to not be chaotic.Remember when I stated that we could have big changes in the last 10 minutes? I feel a hectic vote close coming
Not enough time for this today, but it would be a great homework assignment for the town team moving forward. If I'm there add me if you want and/or whoever else, but these are the people either in or adjacent to my POE. Finding the two-way associations could solve the game outright. I am posting this just in case anyone is bold and brave enough, but I acknowledge that it's a workload.
Who's the 3rd wolf in your Dubz/JJJ world?
Moonshine or Dr. Wz would be the first two I would look at
Dina and yourself not off the table.
maybe i just like the tie@genny holding her vote is interesting
This is too spread to not be chaotic.
Which honestly isn't a great sign
Worth noting that both of the leading wagons are parked off wagon at the moment
maybe i just like the tie
Don't tempt me with a good time
i find it interesting the neither dina nor jj are voting for each other.
unvote moon
vote Dina
vote Dina
Why am I, pippy, zenge, and you not on this?View attachment 369238
Not enough time for this today, but it would be a great homework assignment for the town team moving forward. If I'm there add me if you want and/or whoever else, but these are the people either in or adjacent to my POE. Finding the two-way associations could solve the game outright. I am posting this just in case anyone is bold and brave enough, but I acknowledge that it's a workload.
too late, i'm already having oneDon't tempt me with a good time
You could come back to the Dina vote and reduce the chaosThis is too spread to not be chaotic.
i find it interesting the neither dina nor jj are voting for each other.
I said this thing, but less eloquently
Will it hammer?You could come back to the Dina vote and reduce the chaos
Every individual name you add to this kind of thing makes the workload explode factorially. Even one more person means adding like nine more investigations, so I'm trying to keep it reasonable. Anyone not-me that does can throw me in there if they want to.Why am I, pippy, zenge, and you not on this?
Oh good call I forgot about the 🔨Will it hammer?
You could come back to the Dina vote and reduce the chaos
What specifically was your change of heart on JJ?
If I’m alive tomorrow I’m going to do this exercise.Every individual name you add to this kind of thing makes the workload explode factorially. Even one more person means adding like nine more investigations, so I'm trying to keep it reasonable. Anyone not-me that does can throw me in there if they want to.
Don’t have time to put the effort needed in 15 minutes
She's at 4, hammer is 7Will it hammer?
3 votes short of majority as of right nowWill it hammer?
unvote DrW
vote JJJ
vote JJJ
Unyeet moon yeet DinaShe's at 4, hammer is 7
Definitely not the time right now, but something to prepare for tomorrow yesIf I’m alive tomorrow I’m going to do this exercise.
Don’t have time to put the effort needed in 15 minutes
well even if I die, I'm happy I passed post min 😎
Reading though J’s posts, remembering what PSV said, and generally how I felt he was approaching the game and responding to pressure.What specifically was your change of heart on JJ?
isn't hammer 7? so you've got a ways to goOh good call I forgot about the 🔨
Why am I, pippy, zenge, and you not on this?
Because once again he is trying to create a village bloc that includes him by default.
Like he's been doing from D1
This has been a headache of a day phase for me, so I just want to thank people for showing me the respect to read my posts and listen to what I have to say. That goes a long way toward promoting a winning town climate, no matter who is being suspected.
Tbf if you’re creating a village blocc and leaving yourself out of it, you’re doing it wrongBecause once again he is trying to create a village bloc that includes him by default.