lab question- cells on a petri dish

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

theonlytycrane

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Mar 23, 2014
Messages
2,127
Reaction score
2,276
Screen Shot 2016-06-29 at 4.40.47 PM.png


How does (B) work? My lab background is weak (basically none). Is the dish divided into more granular rows / columns and estimates made based on each section?

I thought that visual estimates would be inaccurate hence the use of estimation with fluorescence as in (D).

Members don't see this ad.
 
Accuracy here refers to how close is the estimation to the actual number of cells.

Basically, you have to count (estimate) how many target cells are present within an area. The most direct way is obviously counting all of them. This is impractical because the field of view of an instrument is limited in scope. Ignoring other complications, doing so would involve counting hundreds of thousand of FoVs. No one has time for that.

Alternatively, you can assume that any random FoV contains approximately the same number of target cells and multiply up to find the total. Of course, this assumption is wrong because density is not uniform. BUT if you have enough samples (n>>>1), the estimation becomes more accurate. That is the essence of the question. Currently, n = 30.

A: Not really. There is a limit to how much you can magnify. Like I said, you need hundreds of thousand of FoVs to cover everything. So unless you can magnify to the point where the covered areas are like orders of magnitude as large as the original, it makes no difference.

B: Yes, if n> 30, the average will be more representative.

C: Doing this will exacerbate the error.

D: There is no indication that there is a difficulty in identifying the target cells. At most, this will increase precision, not accuracy.

Edit: I never did this experiment but when I count, my n is like.... 4. N = 30 is definitely overkill 😀
 
@wizzed101 Just to clarify, for (B) do we make each FOV smaller, estimate how many cells fit into that smaller FOV, and multiply up to how many FOVs the dish has?
 
B is saying that you have to count more using the same FoV.

You have to average them first and then multiply up.
 
Top