Lindsay Clancy

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

Something that I haven't seen mentioned yet is that Massachusetts is rare among states in that its up to the prosecution to prove that someone was of sound mind when they committed a crime. Most places the defense has to prove they were psychotic.

This makes it much easier to get NGRI verdicts there. That's what the reasonable doubt part of this is, basically as a juror if you had any reasonable doubt that she wasn't firing on all cylinders then per the judge's instructions it should have been a NGRI verdict.

Its stupid and I think the lone juror here actually was working towards real justice, but that's the issue from the non-insane people who are mad at that guy.

You have to prove a negative.

You have to prove that she WASN'T having auditory hallucinations.

Just how are you supposed to do that?

In addition, psychiatric literature suggests that command hallucinations are very easy to fake.

I completely support jury nullification in this case.
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
There, I edited it. 😆
When we were doing IVF my wife's estrogen was insanely high. Like several thousand. I did something stupid, standard stupid nothing outside of the usual, and she full on yelled at me in the middle of Time Square in NYC. We drew attention away from the naked cowboy.
 
Multiple Lindsay Clancy copycats are popping up. Will they go free?


 
Multiple Lindsay Clancy copycats are popping up. Will they go free?


As long as they are middle class white women, it’s legal.
 
Multiple Lindsay Clancy copycats are popping up. Will they go free?



It was the voices ooooOOOOooooOOOOooooo!!!!
 
When we were doing IVF my wife's estrogen was insanely high. Like several thousand. I did something stupid, standard stupid nothing outside of the usual, and she full on yelled at me in the middle of Time Square in NYC. We drew attention away from the naked cowboy.
Dude, that is REALLY saying something. Times Square is where someone can dress in full Klingon dress and makeup, and not have anyone take a second look.
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Desronvil — a father from a Haitian immigrant family and a devout Christian with a history of abuse allegations — was the lone juror who refused to find Clancy not guilty of murder by reason of insanity

Reddington helped identify him in court by giving away his gender.

The goofball insane older female juror who keeps making the media rounds basically outed him.

NBC Boston hounded him and got his name

All of these jokers should get prosecuted for doing this. Basically intimidation.

Who would want to even be a juror on the re trial? They've successfully tainted the jury pool.

A jury of your peers is a frightening proposition in general after hearing everyone on this case.

The older female jurors admitted to trying to push some type of agenda under the false guise that women aren't getting enough mental health care. They Conveniently ignore the fact that she was doctor shopping and going through numerous mental health professionals while lying.

And you don't get post partum psychosis 8 months postpartum.
 
Reddington helped identify him in court by giving away his gender.

The goofball insane older female juror who keeps making the media rounds basically outed him.

NBC Boston hounded him and got his name

All of these jokers should get prosecuted for doing this. Basically intimidation.

Who would want to even be a juror on the re trial? They've successfully tainted the jury pool.

A jury of your peers is a frightening proposition in general after hearing everyone on this case.

The older female jurors admitted to trying to push some type of agenda under the false guise that women aren't getting enough mental health care. They Conveniently ignore the fact that she was doctor shopping and going through numerous mental health professionals while lying.

And you don't get post partum psychosis 8 months postpartum.

Redington should be disbarred.
 
Yeah, there is no scenario where a male veteran returns from the sandbox, kills his family, blames it on PTSD, and then guys with plate carriers and multicam show up to the courthouse to cheer him on as a hero for PTSD awareness. That world doesn’t exist, so we can dispense with the gender equity crap.

The the lack of a guilty verdict was bad but the societal response is far, far worse. I got to listen to a gaggle (ie more than 5) female ICU nurses discussing this case. The number of truly insane comments from seeming normal people was shocking. By normal, I’m talking 24-30 year old young ladies who largely look like the types that the crowd camera focuses on at a UGA vs Bama football game; not the tattooed and pierced freaks who choose their hair color from a bag of Skittles. These are people who would be trusted to care for you or your dad but seem perfectly comfortable with a mother committing infanticide of her own children.

Normally, I don’t contribute to such discussions but for this case I couldn’t resist. My only question to the most outspoken gaggler was, “Would you be as lenient if she had killed your family and claimed post-partum psychosis?”
 
Last edited:
Yeah, there is no scenario where a male veteran returns from the sandbox, kills his family, blames it on PTSD, and then guys with plate carriers and multicam show up to the courthouse to cheer him on as a hero for PTSD awareness. That world doesn’t exist, so we can dispense with the gender equity crap.

The the lack of a guilty verdict was bad but the societal response is far, far worse. I got to listen to a gaggle (ie more than 5) female ICU nurses discussing this case. The number of truly insane comments from seeming normal people was shocking. By normal, I’m talking 24-30 year old young ladies who largely look like the types that the crowd camera focuses on at a UGA vs Bama football game; not the tattooed and pierced freaks who choose their hair color from a bag of Skittles. These are people who would be trusted to care for you or your dad but seem perfectly comfortable with a mother committing infanticide of her own children.

Normally, I don’t contribute to such discussions but for this case I couldn’t resist. My only question to the most outspoken gaggler was, “Would you be as lenient if she had killed your family and claimed post-partum psychosis?”

The only thing worse than this is the nurses that i work with believing conspiracy theories that the husband killed the children and then pushed her out the window.
 
Some guy did man on the street interviews of white liberal women. Many of the responses were wild but this was my favorite.

Guy: "Should Lindsay Clancy be punished."

Lady: "No. She's been punished enough."

Guy: "How so?"

Lady: "She lost her 3 children."
 
She wasnt "on 10 psych meds and SSRIs"..... she was on many different routine SSRIs and benzos over the course of many years (not at the same time as they were implying). If you look at her meds and their timelines (which is available online) you can see they were very reasonable regimens.

The husband should sue for the almost 2million dollars she raised in gofundme.

The husband is just as much as a victim as the kids are. He lost his entire family and is now under scrutiny.