Love anatomy ?!

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Arthur E. Jan

New Member
5+ Year Member
Joined
Apr 15, 2017
Messages
5
Reaction score
1
Points
2,601
  1. Medical Student
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
I want to know how can anatomy be easier ? I mean what do textbooks lack . There are tremendous amount of them and I have friend who wants to make another . (Oh my God !) He says we should love it to learn it . Textbooks are made to help us learn but also LOVE the subject. So what is your opinion what do you hate in your anatomy textbooks ?
 
Anatomy textbooks just blow. How can you read/learn something that you need to understand three dimensionally? Just like learning roads in a new town - you gotta look at a map first, and then go to it yourself without a map for things to sink in.
Agreed, we were all given copies of Netters and I never even opened it. It was so much better to see the structures in real life and just google what I wasn't sure of.
 
So what is your opinion what do you hate in your anatomy textbooks ?

Netter's is an atlas so it has its limits. During first year several of us tackled it while watching Ackland Videos
Acland's Video Atlas of Human Anatomy | Home

I initially didnt want to deface my Netter's text but I got over that quickly. I pulled out highlighters of several different colors, drew arrows and stars on pages, plus the text came in really handy for Step 1 prep. Tear apart your Netter's. Dont be squeamish like I was.

Dr. Robert Ackland was instructive, inspiring, a true anatomist. he was a truly elegant and brilliant professor but watching the videos could be a tad tedious. we got through it. I Loved his british accent. Sexy. He died last year which was sad.
Robert D. Acland's Obituary on Courier-Journal

Cadaver was nothing like Netters or Ackland but still we did pull out Netter's during lab. Got formaldehyde and other stuff on the pages. Yuk.

Moore's is OK and some of us used it during first year as our initial resource for explaining concepts. We learned in time it was deficient. Many classmates turned to Univ. of Michigan SOM and other websites.

I bought "Gray's Anatomy: The Anatomical Basis of Clinical Practice, 40e" and found it fantastic. Huge book, there is a newer edition now, and I found it to be a beast.



Know anatomy cold. It will bite you on Step 1 otherwise.
 
Last edited:
Never cracked open an anatomy textbook in med school.

I just used in-lab dissector manuals, lecture notes, and frequent trips to the anatomy lab.

As you prepare for Step 1 your question banks and review sources should cover the relevant material you need. Also your surgery rotation during 3rd year will be a great anatomy learning experience.
 
i thought the title was implying something else lol
 
i thought the title was implying something else lol
May be , and I am really sorry , yet I really find it difficult to study anatomy yet my friend love it till death and want to make textbook! I wanted to know is there anyone who love it and why ? And those who hate it, what do they really hate?
Sorry! However what about you ?
 
Anatomy textbooks just blow. How can you read/learn something that you need to understand three dimensionally? Just like learning roads in a new town - you gotta look at a map first, and then go to it yourself without a map for things to sink in.
So it is about atlas not textbooks and he should better think of making atlas with little explanation at margins rather than making new textbook
 
i thought the title was implying something else lol
Sorry ! What have you expected . I wrote that because my friend love anatomy till death and I just can't go through it . I wanted to know whether many people like anatomy and why ? And those who hate it , what do they really hate ?
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Ummm..
I did not love anatomy when i first started learning it.
I didn't enjoy the feeling of being overwhelmed by how little I knew and how much of anatomy was based on rote memorization (at least for me - at the start). Didn't jive well with my type A personality. It was more of an acquired taste. Like everything else in medicine, it was an acquired skill, similar to trying to learn a new language. the speed with which they expect to you learn fluency is breath taking though. Literally. I did horribly on my first spotter exam. they gave me pity points if I wrote "tendon", my exam. it took a huge chunk of my time to improve my grades in this area (I would say effort too..but the concepts to anatomy are fairly simple, again i found it to be more based on rote memory compared to physiology anyway. i.e. that is nerve Y, or that hole is in the skull is hole X and is Latin for "hole"). It wasn't until later after i'd become (forcibly) familiar with it, that i began tolerating it. we're all built a bit differently, I had friends who loved anatomy from the start, because they loved how they could work with their hands (to no one's surprise, they ended up down the surgical track).

It was during my surgical rotations that I actually began to like it, years after first touching anatomy. The context helps a lot. Also being around people who love anatomy as much as many surgeons do. It comes through in how they teach you. Your surgical rotations are indeed, as someone commented above, a great way to learn anatomy. Better than any textbook in some ways. Granted you have to go through textbooks or other materials to build a foundation first.

there was no particular 'beginner' textbook that I found particularly helpful either. Everyone has their own particular poison. I also used the Acland videos. Otherwise as a reference, I used Gray's too, but by no means did I love Gray's. Neither replaced gross anatomy labs with cadavers, as much as I hated that back in the day, I needed that "3D"ness that a 2D image couldn't give me. Acland's was close though. I went through a lot of trial and error to find anatomy resources that suited me.

In the end the textbook I maybe enjoyed the most was Last's anatomy: Regional and Applied, 9th Ed. by McMinn.
A UK text that was written for surgical trainees/residents in preparation for their surgical anatomy exams. That's what I used as a text during my surgical rotations. I wouldn't recommend it as a 'intro' textbook, it has very few images for example. But it made anatomy in the context of surgery, easier for me to understand. I resorted to Netter's atlas for images (i didn't come to appreciate Netter's until surgical rotations once I had a better handle on anatomy).

also, there's a couple of ways you could interpret the title of your thread.
(to answer your other q)
Love anatomy?! could mean:
tenor.gif

Or in the sense of..don't you love it too?!
RdQp_f-maxage-0_s-200x150.gif

which is initially what I thought you meant. ha.
 
Last edited:
Netter's is a beautiful book. I don't know what ya'll are bitchin' about.
 
[deleted]
I liked coloring books too.
Like productive mindfulness at the same time.
Particularly when you're artistically impaired like I am, its easier than drawing it out by hand. I had classmates who did that. Could have framed some of the anatomy sketches they did of the cadavers.
 
Top Bottom