************
Last edited:
Just wanted to get a feel of what third year is like. I haven't talked to any medical students about this and wanted to hear what your experience was like.
During 3rd year:
< 1. Average hours of free time per week >
< 2. Average hours of sleep per week >
< 3. Number of shifts per week that are greater than or equal to 18 hours >
< 4. Most amount of hours on duty at one time >
< 5. Average happiness 1 through 5 (1 being completely unhappy, 5 being very happy) >
Thank you for your responses! 🙂
This varies immensely from something like gen surgery to psych.
On average, discounting surgery and OB, which are nuts:
1. I try to spend an hour or so, listening to my iPod or reading a book. Or on here. But some days you are just too tired to study at all.
2. During weekdays you get 6-8 hours a night. Unless you are on call, where you may be up all night.
3. Um.... 0-1? They shouldn't give you too many calls.
4. 30 Hours, post call plus morning rounds.
5. About a 4. Not every rotation is fun, and it IS hard. But also several kinds of awesome. You'll love it.
If you want, I can PM you a message I sent to a friend, telling her exactly what IM was like.
I'm almost done with MS2 and I'd love to see this message if you get a chance 😀
Just wanted to get a feel of what third year is like. I haven't talked to any medical students about this and wanted to hear what your experience was like.
During 3rd year:
< 1. Average hours of free time per week >
< 2. Average hours of sleep per week >
< 3. Number of shifts per week that are greater than or equal to 18 hours >
< 4. Most amount of hours on duty at one time >
< 5. Average happiness 1 through 5 (1 being completely unhappy, 5 being very happy) >
Thank you for your responses! 🙂
Keep in mind that this is for IM, coming from a guy who wants to go into IM. But a couple folks wanted to see, so I thought I would post it.
Then you get to SIGN the note, and IT GOES IN THEIR CHART FOREVER! "
Not only is school to school variable, but even at the same hospital its completely resident dependent.Only about 20% of this is applicable to the IM rotation I experienced. Needless to say, school-to-school variation is significant - for every rotation, I would imagine.
Actually when charts are sent to medical records after a patient is discharged the MS3 notes either get ripped out and trashed (if they're on their own paper) or they get black-markered out.
Actually when charts are sent to medical records after a patient is discharged the MS3 notes either get ripped out and trashed (if they're on their own paper) or they get black-markered out.
Keep in mind that this is for IM, coming from a guy who wants to go into IM. But a couple folks wanted to see, so I thought I would post it.
"For Internal Medicine, we get there at 7 AM for morning report, where we go over how our patients did throughout the night. We get assigned two patients to follow throughout the day. Then we have a morning lecture/case study. This goes till 8:15 and is educational, because they lecture on stuff like how to work up GI bleeds or manage nausea.
The next thing to do is to see your patients. You see them by yourself, one on one!!! So first you do some research on your patient, based on the Physician Computer Report we have access to, which prints off lab results, their list of medications, and plenty of room to write on. Then you look up radiology and additional test results, admission report, H & P, and so on, then you go talk to them!
It usually takes a half hour or more, because we are slow. Then you write a SOAP note, which I am sure you are familiar with. Subjective stuff is like how their symptoms are, how they feel, etc, then the O lists pertinent labs, like my gal had anemia, so I wrote down CBC, PT/PTT and BMP. Plus radiology, EKG, and an Echo, and so on.
Plus the physical exam findings you do. It isn't the whole exam. I just do General, Cardiac, Pulmonary, Abdominal and Legs. The legs are important because Deep Vein Thrombosis (DVT) is a big problem in bed ridden patients who have heart or lung problems, recent surgeries, cancer, or are old or obese (basically everyone). The best part of that is getting to use all the acronyms, like CTAb stands for clear to auscultation bilaterally. s/nt/nd/+bs stands for an abdominal exam which is soft, nontender, nondistended with bowel sounds. Everyone understands the jargon. You save time. Plus there is a way to write out CBC and BMP results in an easy to remember table.
The A and P are your problem list for the patient for the day. Like what they came in with. So a patient with renal failure might also have diabetes, headaches, hypertension and pain too, and might also need DVT prophylaxis and nausea prophylaxis, and also need help paying for meds. So all these go on the problem list, then you write down how they are to be treated! Like a person with the hypertension, you say if it is stable, and what level it is that day. Then the meds they are on, and dosages, and say to continue if acceptable,
or recommend an increase. We put "consider this or that" because we arent official.
So for my patient, number 4 looked like this.
4. HTN- Patient 156/108 this morning. Consider adding HCTZ to CCB.
-Monitor vitals
-Consider U/S for Renal Artery Stenosis secondary to kidney dz.
Or say that their ascites needs an ultrasound guided paracentesis. Then you get to SIGN the note, and IT GOES IN THEIR CHART FOREVER! Nobody listens to it, but its THERE, and the doctors DO read it, to evaluate us and to see what the patient said, because we may have picked up something!!
Like today my one patient had severe leg pain that the resident missed but I found, so I mentioned it could be DVT and we checked it. It was nothing to worry about, but still, I helped.
And the interns will help you with note writing. So you get better.
Then we round. During rounds we either do Walking Rounds for a few hours, or have Sit Down Rounds, or both. And the Chief Resident and the Attending will try to "pimp" you on your notes, where they ask you question after question after question. Like if a patient has Diabetic Ketoacidosis, he'll ask who else has ketoacidosis besides diabetics. Answer: Alcoholics. And what the cut offs are for stage I and II Hypertension.
And they make all these suggestions about how to add more stuff. Yesterday the attending gave two of us an impromptu exam, and told us to listen to a patient's heart and lungs and report what we found. I got it right!!! He has a Mitral Regurgitation Murmur and coarse Right lung Rales! Sometimes you get something wrong, like in terms of a dosage question (I hate pharm) or a diagnostic point, but its ok because we are LEARNING!
The afternoon is lectures, presentations, and studying. And lunch, where we eat our free food and complain about how our feet hurt and chill out. Some of this is us working on the rounds presentations and lectures WE have to give to the teams, like on why we give heparin for DVTs.
Then maybe study, see another patient. Leave at 5, after sign out.
Calls are great too. You help with the initial work up in the ER and admit them, and do the H&P."
The length of this post sounds about right...![]()
I don't get it.😕
Like I said, I really liked IM.
And when we auctioned off our cycles, I spent all my points getting into a good hospital for IM where we could do stuff.
Just wanted to get a feel of what third year is like. I haven't talked to any medical students about this and wanted to hear what your experience was like.
During 3rd year:
< 1. Average hours of free time per week >
< 2. Average hours of sleep per week >
< 3. Number of shifts per week that are greater than or equal to 18 hours >
< 4. Most amount of hours on duty at one time >
< 5. Average happiness 1 through 5 (1 being completely unhappy, 5 being very happy) >
Thank you for your responses! 🙂
The answer is going to be rotation dependent (surgery is a lot more hours than something like psych), and is going to depend on the policies of your med school -- at some places the med students take overnight call, others have to go home at 11 or don't take overnight at all. At some places the med students have to abide by the 80 hour work week, at others they don't. Given these constraints:
1. On a heavy rotation (surgery, inpatient IM, OB), you may be working an average of 6 days a week, with a total of hours in the ballpark of 70-80 hours/week. You probably will do 1-2 overnights a week. On top of that you may be asked to present topics by the attendings for which you have to prepare at home, and you have to study for a shelf exam at the end of the block. However much free time you have after all that is yours.
2. On the heavier rotations I slept between 5-6 hours a night, except call nights. On the lighter rotations if you didn't get 8 hours of sleep a night it was by choice.
3. On heavier rotations you probably have overnight call twice a week that would be greater than 18 hours. Up to this past year, up to 30 hour call was the norm. It remains to be seen how long med students are kept now that interns can't do 30 hour shifts. But there are no external rules protecting you guys, just a given hospital's own policy, if any.
4. Most amount of hours at a time as a med student, for me, was 30ish hours. Usually overnights during med school were closer to 25.
5. Happiness? I would say this is rotation dependent, hospital dependent, resident dependent, attending dependent, and maybe even dependent on the given patients you were carrying. On average probably netted out to a 3.
During 3rd year:
< 1. Average hours of free time per week >
< 2. Average hours of sleep per week >
< 3. Number of shifts per week that are greater than or equal to 18 hours >
< 4. Most amount of hours on duty at one time >
< 5. Average happiness 1 through 5 (1 being completely unhappy, 5 being very happy) >
IM is notorious for really long notes with tons of information, whereas surgery tends to be on the other end of the spectrum. Not good or bad, but just illustrates the different personalities that are attracted to each specialty. I remember sitting there while some internists were talking about the differential for some guy and what they needed to do. They were discussing this for long enough that I just decided my time was better invested zoning out and staring at a wall. When we all parted ways, I asked one of them what the difference in treatment was and got a reply somewhere along the lines of, "Oh, there isn't any real difference in treatment....just wanted to figure out what it was."
that sounds pretty crappy compared to most med schools. Q4 call? Med schools tend to be easy on their students now... our surgery call is q14 haha.
Not sure you can generalize... you should talk to students at other med schools...
Not sure you can generalize... you should talk to students at other med schools...
IM is notorious for really long notes with tons of information, whereas surgery tends to be on the other end of the spectrum. Not good or bad, but just illustrates the different personalities that are attracted to each specialty. I remember sitting there while some internists were talking about the differential for some guy and what they needed to do. They were discussing this for long enough that I just decided my time was better invested zoning out and staring at a wall. When we all parted ways, I asked one of them what the difference in treatment was and got a reply somewhere along the lines of, "Oh, there isn't any real difference in treatment....just wanted to figure out what it was."
We don't take any call on general surgery. And we're required to leave at 6pm. Guess there are some perks to paying $60,000 a year 🙄
med students are supposed to be in the hospital for gyn-onc by 4A.
I'm a very naive MS1 (so take what I say with a grain of salt) -- but I guess I wouldn't look at this as a positive. Even though I have an idea of what I want to go in to, I'd rather get a total perspective of the residency than work a weird short schedule and not get as much of a feel for it.
Why? Are they required to watch late night infomercials in the call room before pre-rounds?
I'm a very naive MS1 (so take what I say with a grain of salt) -- but I guess I wouldn't look at this as a positive. Even though I have an idea of what I want to go in to, I'd rather get a total perspective of the residency than work a weird short schedule and not get as much of a feel for it.
*nothing* will give you an adequate perspective for a residency in general surgery. Even a Sub-I at most places. People who apply have an idea of what they're getting into because they've talked with a lot of residents, not because they did some rotation that enlightened them. To a degree, this is true for all residency programs.
Our course director made the change a few years back because she realized students actually needed to study for the shelf exam ... realizing rightly that general surgery teaches you very little testable knowledge when in the OR or on the floor.
yakko said:Why? Are they required to watch late night infomercials in the call room before pre-rounds?
Perhaps that's fair, though I'd make the argument that you would garner a better perspective from actually doing the legwork for 6 weeks during your rotation rather than going home at 6. I think your point is valid, though, that the best way to get an idea about residency is to talk to current residents.
I have heard from several recent grads that the surgery shelf was a total bitch since they didn't have any time to study, it covers a huge breadth of material, and the rotation doesn't prepare you at all for the exam -- so definitely a disadvantage of the "hardcore" surgery rotation that seems to be favored by our program.
No idea -- just what's printed in our handbook for the wards. Mattchiavelli's explanation makes sense to me.
that sounds pretty crappy compared to most med schools. Q4 call? Med schools tend to be easy on their students now... our surgery call is q14 haha.
We don't take any call on general surgery. And we're required to leave at 6pm. Guess there are some perks to paying $60,000 a year 🙄