Malignant OB/gyn program? is there such a thing???

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

new2dis

New Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Jan 22, 2011
Messages
9
Reaction score
0
Points
4,551
  1. Medical Student
I often here people describe certain ob/gyn residencies as being malignant. I wanted to find out what others' thoughts are on this issue and if this is really true. If so, what does it mean for a program to be malignant? thanks a lot for your responses.
 
I often here people describe certain ob/gyn residencies as being malignant. I wanted to find out what others' thoughts are on this issue and if this is really true. If so, what does it mean for a program to be malignant? thanks a lot for your responses.

I'd like to know this as well! I've talked to a few residents but nobody can really verify which programs are malignant or what exactly is meant by that term, other than, "You don't want to go there." Not helpful.
 

Members do not see ads. Register today.

Uh really? Do you think there is a reason Hopkins struggles to fill their program every year?
 
Uh really? Do you think there is a reason Hopkins struggles to fill their program every year?

Are you talking about the Hopkins Ob/Gyn residency program? If so, you are completely incorrect. This program fills with top candidates. Easily. There is no struggle. Before you malign a program, get the facts straight. You should be ashamed.
 
Take it easy folks!

The original post was asking for general comments regarding "malignant" programs (if there are any), so please refrain from mentioning specific programs unless you have a specific reason. On that note, I find it hard to believe that a program's malignant nature would lead to un-matched spots especially at a competitive program. Instead, it would likely lead to departures by existing residents.


Nevertheless, please let's keep the dialogue professional regardless of our personal feelings.
 
I often here people describe certain ob/gyn residencies as being malignant. I wanted to find out what others' thoughts are on this issue and if this is really true. If so, what does it mean for a program to be malignant? thanks a lot for your responses.

Malignant for me basically means a crappy place to train. Not because you work hard but because you're getting beaten down as a resident by faculty, upper level residents, ancillary staff etc for anything and everything.

In general, malignant places are missing residents from various years as people have slowly dropped out. This is tricky in OB though as the attrition rate is naturally high due to the nature of the profession and even great programs may have some residents drop out based on personal reasons.

I tend to think of some inner city programs in NY fitting the bill of malignant fairly well. Won't name any programs at this point.

The easiest way to tell if a program is malignant is just by talking to the residents. They won't outright say they are miserable but you can get a vibe just by how they act.

Uh really? Do you think there is a reason Hopkins struggles to fill their program every year?

Uh, do you even know what you're talking about?

Training at Hopkins, like any academic program, will put you through the ringer but they are some of the best trained residents/fellows you will meet out there. And as far as I know, they've been doing pretty well in the match.

I don't have any formal connection to Hopkins but know some very well trained OB-Gyns from there who finished relatively recently.
 
Last edited:
Are you talking about the Hopkins Ob/Gyn residency program? If so, you are completely incorrect. This program fills with top candidates. Easily. There is no struggle. Before you malign a program, get the facts straight. You should be ashamed.


I did not mean to start a feud 🙂. Just wanted a general idea of what is meant by this term. No need to mention specific program names.

thanks
 
Top Bottom