Marriage Proposal Suggestions

bananaface

Pharmacy Supernerd
Moderator Emeritus
Lifetime Donor
15+ Year Member
Joined
Apr 24, 2004
Messages
42,023
Reaction score
159
One of my friends just bought an engagement ring is trying to figure out how he wants to propose to his girlfriend. They have been ring shopping together for a couple of weeks, so it's not going to be a total surprise. But, he would like to make it as much of a surprise as possible, and to do something sweet and memorable. My suggestion was that they arrange to go to lunch and then ring shop some more, and that he surprise her by proposing at lunch. We are trying to brainstorm more ideas, though. Does anyone have any more ideas to contribute?

Members don't see this ad.
 
Perhaps take her out on a surprise weekend vacation? Doesn't have to be anything too expensive. My roommate took his gf to a bed and breakfast hotel weekend deal (dont' know the specifics) for her bday.
 
Depending how sappy he wants to make it....my male cousins made "memory books" like scrapbooks detailing their relationship together etc. They were big into re-creating the "firsts"...this is the bus that we met on (in school), first this and that...and then they went on some sort of treasure hunt visiting all these places. Their families were all involved and it was a production to say the least. Won't be most people's cup-o-tea but just thought I'd throw it out. Usually just any moment that is unexpected is nice.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
If they are close to Vegas, at the Venetian is that gondola ride. I think it would be awesome to propose there...it has the whole Italy feel without the crazy cost. 👍

Proposals... *sigh* 😀
 
I am not sure that a trip would be feasible time-wise, as they are both current students. He wants to do it in the very near future, since he has a hard time not telling her that he bought the ring. My guess is that it will be Saturday or Sunday. The other idea he had was to tie the ring to her cat's collar and see how long until she noticed. That's semi-cute, but chances the ring being lost. And, I am not sure how he'd work in an actual proposal with that.
 
Some ideas

1) Dress up as a Bear-VERY VERY CUTE! 😍

I think one of the cutest proposal stories I have ever come across was that of a collegue of mine in dental school. He dressed up as a bear and approached his sweetie's teacher and asked if he could do his proposal during on of the classes. He walked into the large lecture hall (with about 150 students present) and placed a slide on the projector which said " I love you ****** Will you marry me?" And his sweetie was in complete shock! 😱 LOL! :laugh:

2) Rose Petals

This was another proposal story I head about through another collegue at school. For Valentine's Day her boyfriend left a trail of red rose petals from the house main door until her bedroom, and design a big heart over the bed with the box and the diamond engagement ring in the middle.

3) Tell Her Her Fortune

I remember one proposal scene in a movie I saw starring Hugh Grant called "Mickey Blue Eyes" in which the lead caracter proposed to his girlfriend with a fortunte cookie in a chinese restaurant but the waitress brought it to the wrong table- it was a hilarious scene! LOL! :laugh:

Steam a fortune cookie until it's malleable. Open the cookie, place the diamond ring inside with a note telling her how she'll be loved by you forever.

4) Love is in the air

Go to the beach or another open place, hire a plane to fly over you with a banner of "I love you (bride's name), will you marry me?" and wait her reaction with the engagement ring in hand!
 
A girlfriend of mine drove her usual route to work one day. Hanging from the overpass (sure this isn't legal) was this huge banner, "MARRY ME JESSICA"
It was memorable.
Goofy, but memorable.
🙂
 
bananaface said:
I am not sure that a trip would be feasible time-wise, as they are both current students. He wants to do it in the very near future, since he has a hard time not telling her that he bought the ring. My guess is that it will be Saturday or Sunday. The other idea he had was to tie the ring to her cat's collar and see how long until she noticed. That's semi-cute, but chances the ring being lost. And, I am not sure how he'd work in an actual proposal with that.

Lol, i don't think the cat idea is very romantic. Shes gonna want a story that she can tell all her friends about for many many years to come, and i don't think finding a ring on your cats collar would be a very memorable thing.

I would surprise her with a romantic dinner on the beach, with champagne and the works.... then ask her as the dinner processed. 👍
 
Smilemaker100 said:
3) Tell Her Her Fortune

I remember one proposal scene in a movie I saw starring Hugh Grant called "Mickey Blue Eyes" in which the lead caracter proposed to his girlfriend with a fortunte cookie in a chinese restaurant but the waitress brought it to the wrong table- it was a hilarious scene! LOL! :laugh:

That was the funniest scene!!! :laugh: :laugh: :laugh: :laugh: The look on the other girl's face when he went to grab the ring back!
 
Pop out of a cake holding a ring. If she says no, just pie her (with some cake) in the face. 👍
 
N1DERL& said:
That was the funniest scene!!! :laugh: :laugh: :laugh: :laugh: The look on the other girl's face when he went to grab the ring back!

I KNOW ! :laugh: Can you imagine what the non-intended target of the fortune cookie felt like when she realized it was a mistake? 🙄

I love Hugh Grant's films. 👍
 
Members don't see this ad :)
NRAI2001 said:
Pop out of a cake holding a ring. If she says no, just pie her (with some cake) in the face. 👍

LOL! Right on! :laugh:
 
toofache32 said:
This worked for me: "Nice shoes. Wanna get married?"

Ya, that is DEFINITELY unforgettable! Simple but original! :laugh:
 
I never got proposed to but I like hearing stories because I am such a PATHETIC hopeless romantic . 😍 I spent some time surfing the net for a little while and came across some really cute ideas.

SECRET CODE PROPOSAL

Submitted by: Anonymous

My fiancée proposed November 6th 2004. It was the most amazing day of my life and of course a complete surprise. The proposal started seven months before he got down on one knee, not that I realized it at the time.

He was sending me flowers once a month starting in March. The flowers in order are

Mums
Anemones
Roses
Roses
Yarrow

Mums
Echinacea

He took a picture of me with each of the flowers "for his monitor at work" and I was too happy getting flowers to see the alternative motive.

About a month after the Echinacea my sister and her husband came up for their one month anniversary and a trip to the Finger Lakes for wine tasting.

It was a great trip that had been meticulously planned. The day before he went to our favorite winery (Atwater) and dropped off 20 by 30 pictures of me with each of the flowers with the names of the flowers printed on them. He then went to my parents house to ask permission with a New York Times (another long story about my sister's engagement which has turned into a family joke).

After we arrived we were tasting the wine and just as a tour bus crowded in the staff revealed the pictures of me to the room. My sister's husband looked up and said, confused “Lillie - isn't that you!" Shocked, I looked up and there were huge pictures of me with the flowers on the wall.

Jason then paraded me into the middle of the crowed and got down on one knee. He of course had recited a poem that he had written especially for the occasion.

I realized (after looking at the photos) that the flowers that he had sent had a secret message and the photos of the flowers revealed it in a more obvious way. I'm glad he had given up on the subtleties and asked me to be his wife in a way that could not be mistaken!

I was in such shock I gave him my right hand, I started to put out my left which he snatched and presented a gorgeous ring to seal the deal. After nearly knocking him to the ground with a big hug I managed to say yes as soon as enough of the shock wore off. We celebrated with Champagne; he even had them make us our own label, with names and date!

I was amazed by his creativity and planning and I know that I can look forward to many more surprises in the years to come.


MARRY ME NO FOOLIN'

It was Tuesday, April Fool's Day 2003--just an ordinary day in the middle of the week, (NOT when a girl would expect a proposal). Tuesday nights my sweetheart's daughter had drama practice at our church, so he'd dropped her off and come over to my house--just like usual. We'd been sitting on the sofa watching TV when I got up to do some laundry. I was carrying a load from the dryer to the bedroom when he turned off the TV and said, "Can you come sit down... we need to talk."

I knew it was something serious because men don't turn off the TV for just anything; so I put down the clothes and sat down on the edge of the sofa facing him. I was thinking that it might be a problem with his daughter or the church or something that he wanted to talk over with me. He put his hand on my leg and got very serious when he said to me, "I said I'd never do anything to hurt you and I don't want to hurt you, but we need to break up."

Ha! I immediately knew that was an April Fool's joke, so I laughed and said, "Yeah right! April Fool's!". We get along great, so this was such a lame joke to me! The more serious he tried to be, and the more he tried to tell me that it just wasn't working out and we needed to break up, the more I laughed at his attempts until I was almost rolling in the floor!

Then out of nowhere, he takes my hand and slips the ring on my finger.

I thought it was the next joke! I thought that since the break-up joke didn't work, he's going to try the proposal joke. I thought it must be a ring from a um ball machine--until I looked at it. STOP EVERYTHING!

I said "Oh my gosh! This is REAL!" (probably about three times). He said, "Yes, this is real." My heart fluttered and my tummy flipped and we looked at each other. Then he got down on one knee in my living room floor and said, "Linda, will you marry me?"
 
Oh for heck's sake. Why surprise at all?? Why not just have an adult discussion about your goals in life and all that crap, then say "so do ya wanna get married? When?". Then you can give her a ring to make it official.

What's with this surprise crap?? What's so romantic with surprising somebody with what's going to happen with *HER* LIFE?? Doesn't she get some say in this too?

Then again I'm soon to be a divorcee, and my brilliantly romantic marriage-from-hell began with a surprise proposal. So, next time I think I'd be more than happy with just an adult discussion and an agreement to get married.
 
thirdunity said:
Oh for heck's sake. Why surprise at all?? Why not just have an adult discussion about your goals in life and all that crap, then say "so do ya wanna get married? When?". Then you can give her a ring to make it official.

What's with this surprise crap?? What's so romantic with surprising somebody with what's going to happen with *HER* LIFE?? Doesn't she get some say in this too?

Then again I'm soon to be a divorcee, and my brilliantly romantic marriage-from-hell began with a surprise proposal. So, next time I think I'd be more than happy with just an adult discussion and an agreement to get married.

*Ouch* 🙁 I am sorry to hear about your divorce. Sure, there should be some sort of "adult discussion" but doesn't every woman want to be *surprised* ? 🙄 I personally don't think being *surprised* is a big deal but it's nice to have something that is expected (which has been discussed) to be "officially" announced in an unexpected fashion. I also don't even care if I get a silly engagement ring to go show off to the other gals because that's not the kind of person I am.

Relationships can be magical sometimes if you just find the right person. Not just romantic/lifetime relationships but in general. If you don't have a love for life and a love for people in general, where is the *sparkle* or magic in life? I like to make surprises for my friends on special occasions like their birthdays/graduations/achievements or just randomly get flowers etc. and do that for family too.

Life should be exciting! Romance life- romance your friends, romance everyone around you! Passion is not just expressed in a relationship but one must have passion into every thing one does!

What matters in the end is NOT the engagement proposal and NOT the type of ring but the quality of the relationship. I know so because my parents had a very low key wedding and my mom never officially got an engagement ring. But 33 years after they met, my parents are still happily married. 😍 And my mom can definitely attest that most of her friends who had engagement rings and fancy weddings didn't fair too well in their marriage as much as she has.

Geez, I hope you find a special man who will make you believe that life can be beautiful and magical every day! 😍
 
Oh no! I'd vote for anything surprising and romantic. Something in public. The sillier, goofier, sappier the better! My hubby came home one day and said, "My friends think it's about time we got married." GROAN! I've always resented just a tiny bit the lack of enthusasm the idea generated in the man!! 😳

Maybe they could go to a museum, mall, ball park, restaurant etc. and have it announced on the loudspeaker? "Smith's party of two...will you marry him?"

Sorry no good ideas, but definitely hope he makes it special! Tell them congrats, BTW. :luck:
 
thirdunity said:
Oh for heck's sake. Why surprise at all?? Why not just have an adult discussion about your goals in life and all that crap, then say "so do ya wanna get married? When?". Then you can give her a ring to make it official.

What's with this surprise crap?? What's so romantic with surprising somebody with what's going to happen with *HER* LIFE?? Doesn't she get some say in this too?

Then again I'm soon to be a divorcee, and my brilliantly romantic marriage-from-hell began with a surprise proposal. So, next time I think I'd be more than happy with just an adult discussion and an agreement to get married.
They have ring shopped. It is something they both want. He wants to do a formal proposal. I had the discussion instead of the proposal. I'm divorced. Sometimes things just suck regardless of their origin.
 
thirdunity said:
What's so romantic with surprising somebody with what's going to happen with *HER* LIFE?? Doesn't she get some say in this too?
Yep. It's when she answers the question.
 
Smilemaker100 said:
I never got proposed to but I like hearing stories because I am such a PATHETIC hopeless romantic . 😍 I spent some time surfing the net for a little while and came across some really cute ideas.

SECRET CODE PROPOSAL

Submitted by: Anonymous

My fiancée proposed November 6th 2004. It was the most amazing day of my life and of course a complete surprise. The proposal started seven months before he got down on one knee, not that I realized it at the time.

He was sending me flowers once a month starting in March. The flowers in order are

Mums
Anemones
Roses
Roses
Yarrow

Mums
Echinacea

He took a picture of me with each of the flowers "for his monitor at work" and I was too happy getting flowers to see the alternative motive.

About a month after the Echinacea my sister and her husband came up for their one month anniversary and a trip to the Finger Lakes for wine tasting.

It was a great trip that had been meticulously planned. The day before he went to our favorite winery (Atwater) and dropped off 20 by 30 pictures of me with each of the flowers with the names of the flowers printed on them. He then went to my parents house to ask permission with a New York Times (another long story about my sister's engagement which has turned into a family joke).

After we arrived we were tasting the wine and just as a tour bus crowded in the staff revealed the pictures of me to the room. My sister's husband looked up and said, confused “Lillie - isn't that you!" Shocked, I looked up and there were huge pictures of me with the flowers on the wall.

Jason then paraded me into the middle of the crowed and got down on one knee. He of course had recited a poem that he had written especially for the occasion.

I realized (after looking at the photos) that the flowers that he had sent had a secret message and the photos of the flowers revealed it in a more obvious way. I'm glad he had given up on the subtleties and asked me to be his wife in a way that could not be mistaken!

I was in such shock I gave him my right hand, I started to put out my left which he snatched and presented a gorgeous ring to seal the deal. After nearly knocking him to the ground with a big hug I managed to say yes as soon as enough of the shock wore off. We celebrated with Champagne; he even had them make us our own label, with names and date!

I was amazed by his creativity and planning and I know that I can look forward to many more surprises in the years to come.


MARRY ME NO FOOLIN'

It was Tuesday, April Fool's Day 2003--just an ordinary day in the middle of the week, (NOT when a girl would expect a proposal). Tuesday nights my sweetheart's daughter had drama practice at our church, so he'd dropped her off and come over to my house--just like usual. We'd been sitting on the sofa watching TV when I got up to do some laundry. I was carrying a load from the dryer to the bedroom when he turned off the TV and said, "Can you come sit down... we need to talk."

I knew it was something serious because men don't turn off the TV for just anything; so I put down the clothes and sat down on the edge of the sofa facing him. I was thinking that it might be a problem with his daughter or the church or something that he wanted to talk over with me. He put his hand on my leg and got very serious when he said to me, "I said I'd never do anything to hurt you and I don't want to hurt you, but we need to break up."

Ha! I immediately knew that was an April Fool's joke, so I laughed and said, "Yeah right! April Fool's!". We get along great, so this was such a lame joke to me! The more serious he tried to be, and the more he tried to tell me that it just wasn't working out and we needed to break up, the more I laughed at his attempts until I was almost rolling in the floor!

Then out of nowhere, he takes my hand and slips the ring on my finger.

I thought it was the next joke! I thought that since the break-up joke didn't work, he's going to try the proposal joke. I thought it must be a ring from a um ball machine--until I looked at it. STOP EVERYTHING!

I said "Oh my gosh! This is REAL!" (probably about three times). He said, "Yes, this is real." My heart fluttered and my tummy flipped and we looked at each other. Then he got down on one knee in my living room floor and said, "Linda, will you marry me?"

The second story was lame.
 
What about a hot air ballon ride?
 
oh! That sounds like fun!! Just don't drop the ring! 😱
 
I like the cat idea but it will be tough to pull off since he'll be staring at it the whole time. It would be safe if secured to her collar like on a keychain. Women love their cats.

It also depends on her personality...I personally would have hated a public proposal. My now hubby had flowers, candles, and a "present" with my favorite dinner ready when I got to his place for the usual friday night dinner. And he asked my parents first. It was a total shock and we got to enjoy the time with each other, not with a bunch of peering-eyed strangers who don't give a crud.

If she is the type to like a big show, go with the public thing.

PS - we never ring shopped, but we did discuss marriage and our intentions were clear.
 
kassie said:
It also depends on her personality...I personally would have hated a public proposal. My now hubby had flowers, candles, and a "present" with my favorite dinner ready when I got to his place for the usual friday night dinner. And he asked my parents first. It was a total shock and we got to enjoy the time with each other, not with a bunch of peering-eyed strangers who don't give a crud.

If she is the type to like a big show, go with the public thing.

My good friend hated the idea of a public proposal so her fiance, now husband, went out to one of those pottery places and painted on her a plate "will you marry me?" on it. He made dinner for her and put her food on that plate. It was such a cute idea and perfect because it was at home and there weren't all these people staring.

The plate now sits in their china cabinet and comes out for anniversaries. 🙂
 
N1DERL& said:
My good friend hated the idea of a public proposal so her fiance, now husband, went out to one of those pottery places and painted on her a plate "will you marry me?" on it. He made dinner for her and put her food on that plate. It was such a cute idea and perfect because it was at home and there weren't all these people staring.

The plate now sits in their china cabinet and comes out for anniversaries. 🙂

I like that one. When I proposed to my wife, we'd been dating for about 6 years. Anyway, we were both in school and poor students at the time. She was doing her med intern year, and was working lots-o-hours. I just made a quiet, simple, candlelit dinner at home in our flat. I had sold my truck to buy the ring. I bought a small book of poetry that had a nice cover (title: Poems of Love) for like a dollar. I glued all of the pages together, then hollowed out a hole for the ring inside. I wrote a proposal poem inside, too. After dinner I asked her to read me a poem.

The poem was something like:
This my love,
A ring I bear,
This symbol of,
A love we share.
Share my love,
Share my life,
Wear this ring,
And be my wife!
 
Phil said:
I like that one. When I proposed to my wife, we'd been dating for about 6 years. Anyway, we were both in school and poor students at the time. She was doing her med intern year, and was working lots-o-hours. I just made a quiet, simple, candlelit dinner at home in our flat. I had sold my truck to buy the ring. I bought a small book of poetry that had a nice cover (title: Poems of Love) for like a dollar. I glued all of the pages together, then hollowed out a hole for the ring inside. I wrote a proposal poem inside, too. After dinner I asked her to read me a poem.

The poem was something like:
This my love,
A ring I bear,
This symbol of,
A love we share.
Share my love,
Share my life,
Wear this ring,
And be my wife!

That's really cute! You must have really wanted her if you sold your truck!
It's not the amount of money you use to propose (eg. expensive dinner, roses etc.) but the way you propose. I know it sounds cliche but it really is the thought that counts.

Seriously, though, sometimes I wonder why women insist on having an engagement ring in the first place given how expensive they are...
 
Phil said:
I like that one. When I proposed to my wife, we'd been dating for about 6 years. Anyway, we were both in school and poor students at the time. She was doing her med intern year, and was working lots-o-hours. I just made a quiet, simple, candlelit dinner at home in our flat. I had sold my truck to buy the ring. I bought a small book of poetry that had a nice cover (title: Poems of Love) for like a dollar. I glued all of the pages together, then hollowed out a hole for the ring inside. I wrote a proposal poem inside, too. After dinner I asked her to read me a poem.

The poem was something like:
This my love,
A ring I bear,
This symbol of,
A love we share.
Share my love,
Share my life,
Wear this ring,
And be my wife!


:laugh: Thats a good idea 👍
 
Smilemaker100 said:
That's really cute! You must have really wanted her if you sold your truck!
It's not the amount of money you use to propose (eg. expensive dinner, roses etc.) but the way you propose. I know it sounds cliche but it really is the thought that counts.

Seriously, though, sometimes I wonder why women insist on having an engagement ring in the first place given how expensive they are...

Well, its only a truck, after all. Maybe I could write a country song about that. :laugh: I just don't care much about material stuff, so it was a no brainer to sell the truck.

I truly do love her though and would give my life for her. We've been together 15 years this month. 😍
 
Phil said:
Well, its only a truck, after all. Maybe I could write a country song about that. :laugh: I just don't care much about material stuff, so it was a no brainer to sell the truck.

I truly do love her though and would give my life for her. We've been together 15 years this month. 😍

Holy monkey, how old are you guys? Why didn't you ask her before?
 
NRAI2001 said:
Holy monkey, how old are you guys? Why didn't you ask her before?

I'm 39, she's 35.
 
Phil said:
I'm 39, she's 35.

Oh, so you were waiting for her to be grown up enough to know whether to say, "yes," or not. Good call.
 
samenewme said:
Oh, so you were waiting for her to be grown up enough to know whether to say, "yes," or not. Good call.

Not really, we always knew we'd be together but it started getting to the point that we were risking never actually having a ceremony. We didn't want it to turn into never getting married. That, and all of our money was going towards her med school.

NRAI2001 said:
Why now? I guess kids aren't an issue anymore?

Not really "now". We've been married 7 years. 3.56 kids. The .56 is at ~22 weeks.
 
Phil said:
Well, its only a truck, after all. Maybe I could write a country song about that. :laugh: I just don't care much about material stuff, so it was a no brainer to sell the truck.

I truly do love her though and would give my life for her. We've been together 15 years this month. 😍

Wow! You're sure special! She is a lucky woman! Maybe you should write a "country" song 😉 :laugh:
 
Smilemaker100 said:
Wow! You're sure special! She is a lucky woman! Maybe you should write a "country" song 😉 :laugh:

Thanks, life is give and take though.

Any other proposal ideas? I guess you have to think about what she likes, and work that in somehow. Or hide it somewhere in her morning routine.
 
Phil said:
Not really, we always knew we'd be together but it started getting to the point that we were risking never actually having a ceremony. We didn't want it to turn into never getting married. That, and all of our money was going towards her med school.



Not really "now". We've been married 7 years. 3.56 kids. The .56 is at ~22 weeks.

O i see, misread your original post 👍
 
My SO and I slowly eased into getting married bit by bit, and have been planning our November wedding for about two months without an official proposal, so when he actually presented the ring to me I knew it wasnt going to be some fantasic surprise. I knew the ring had shown up and I was very unsubtley hinting that I wanted it.

Here is us last night:

Time: 10:30pm
Place: Cuddling in bed (actually I was plucking his eyebrows)
Him: I love you very much DownonthePharm. Are you sure that you want to marry me?
Me: Yes I do. Are you finally asking? (grinning like a fool)
Him: Yes, will you marry me? (ring appears)

Not super romantic, but honest and straightforward, much like us. 😍

I think its because I wore pink that day 🙂 Statistically men are more likely to propose when you are wearing pink. 😀

P.S. I think the cat thing is cute.
 
DownonthePharm said:
My SO and I slowly eased into getting married bit by bit, and have been planning our November wedding for about two months without an official proposal, so when he actually presented the ring to me I knew it wasnt going to be some fantasic surprise. I knew the ring had shown up and I was very unsubtley hinting that I wanted it.

Here is us last night:

Time: 10:30pm
Place: Cuddling in bed (actually I was plucking his eyebrows)
Him: I love you very much DownonthePharm. Are you sure that you want to marry me?
Me: Yes I do. Are you finally asking? (grinning like a fool)
Him: Yes, will you marry me? (ring appears)

Not super romantic, but honest and straightforward, much like us. 😍

I think its because I wore pink that day 🙂 Statistically men are more likely to propose when you are wearing pink. 😀

P.S. I think the cat thing is cute.

So he pruposed to you when you were plucking his eyebrows????? What would he have done if you were waxing his legs that day instead????? :laugh:
 
:laugh: Leg waxing is out of the question. I like my men with body hair, but I also like them with two seperate eyebrows, thus I pluck the unibrow. 🙂
 
DownonthePharm said:
:laugh: Leg waxing is out of the question. I like my men with body hair, but I also like them with two seperate eyebrows, thus I pluck the unibrow. 🙂

:laugh: See, now that's what I'm talking about. But, does he really call you DownonthePharm? 🙄
 
Top