MarWWel -- GAME THREAD

Started by Doggo Labs
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

Browse articles Compare schools My application plan Read Interview Feedback
Practice for interviews Ask an Advisor
SportPonies said:
Up until then I had him neutral but that post and some of his following posts were very village Zenge. I feel rather comfortable with that read at this time.
Click to expand...
I actually don’t think he was very village zenge. Yesterday he had a tone to him that was different. Can you tell me what was village zenge?
 
Does SDN let you split quotes that you have in your multi-quote thing? I add things to my quote list as I go but then when I respond to everything in the same post it gets all cluttered. I am definitely not trying to buffer my post number.
 
potentialsheltervet said:
Does SDN let you split quotes that you have in your multi-quote thing? I add things to my quote list as I go but then when I respond to everything in the same post it gets all cluttered. I am definitely not trying to buffer my post number.
Click to expand...
You have to do it manually. Cut the ones you want to put into a different post and then paste them.
 
Dana_May_B said:
but what youre not taking into consideration is that i posted my reads list this morning, after two players have flipped and we have a vote to analyze, and TME posted her reads list early yesterday. like i said before, dubz was not relatively high on my list when TME posted her reads.
Click to expand...
Okay but generally reads are evolutions, so presumably Dubz and AM didn’t have very far to travel to get to where they are on your list from last night to today.

Also 2 players flipping is irrelevant here. Mel, being a lone wolf is a completely irrelevant flip, and TME flipping village, clearly shouldn’t be having any impact on this discussion since she had Dubz and AM at the bottom of her list and you’ve chosen to ignore her thoughts all together.

All this to say, there hasn’t been very much new information between TME posted her list, and you posted yours, so unless you were wolf reading Dubz and AM and they did something to make you do a 180, they presumably your read on them didn’t evolve much in that short time, and it would have been relatively close to what it is now, at the time of TME’s list, and thus, having an extreme difference of opinion in not one but two players.

Hence, you should be in agreement that even at the time of it being posted, it was a weird list. If not, that’s fine, I just don’t quite get how, given the logical progression of the thread state I’ve laid out.
 
samac said:
I actually don’t think he was very village zenge. Yesterday he had a tone to him that was different. Can you tell me what was village zenge?
Click to expand...
Can you point out what tone he had that was different so I can evaluate as I finish the catch up?

I’m still trying to wrap up at work so I don’t really feel like going back and pulling exact quotes about what felt villagey, but I can at home
 
SportPonies said:
Can you point out what tone he had that was different so I can evaluate as I finish the catch up?

I’m still trying to wrap up at work so I don’t really feel like going back and pulling exact quotes about what felt villagey, but I can at home
Click to expand...
@samac I would actually prefer you didn't do this so we can get sporty's untainted read
 
WildZoo said:
Me when anyone else village reads me: "Excuse me, are you a wolf?"
Me when samac village reads me:
"Okay :heckyeah: "
Click to expand...
I could physically feel your side eye yesterday when I called you warm and fuzzy tho.
SportPonies said:
Can you point out what tone he had that was different so I can evaluate as I finish the catch up?

I’m still trying to wrap up at work so I don’t really feel like going back and pulling exact quotes about what felt villagey, but I can at home
Click to expand...
You read the same stuff I did.
 
Zenge142 said:
Okay but generally reads are evolutions, so presumably Dubz and AM didn’t have very far to travel to get to where they are on your list from last night to today.

Also 2 players flipping is irrelevant here. Mel, being a lone wolf is a completely irrelevant flip, and TME flipping village, clearly shouldn’t be having any impact on this discussion since she had Dubz and AM at the bottom of her list and you’ve chosen to ignore her thoughts all together.

All this to say, there hasn’t been very much new information between TME posted her list, and you posted yours, so unless you were wolf reading Dubz and AM and they did something to make you do a 180, they presumably your read on them didn’t evolve much in that short time, and it would have been relatively close to what it is now, at the time of TME’s list, and thus, having an extreme difference of opinion in not one but two players.

Hence, you should be in agreement that even at the time of it being posted, it was a weird list. If not, that’s fine, I just don’t quite get how, given the logical progression of the thread state I’ve laid out.
Click to expand...
Dana_May_B said:
i can appreciate what youre saying, and i will take back my statement that it seemed retaliatory. however, i ranked dubz a lot higher on my list this morning than i would have before the vote last night, and i gave a lot of thought to what TME was saying about dubz when she posted that reads list. dubz was a solid neutral for me around the time TME posted her reads.
Click to expand...
im not quite sure how to argue with you about what you *think* my reads list looked like around the time TME posted hers. you're making a lot of assumptions about a reads list you never saw and i never posted. i did change some of my reads pretty drastically (example: true) between yesterday morning and after last night because of the way things went down with the vote, even if mel was a lone wolf.
 
WildZoo said:
woah woah woah why am I there I didn't authorize this
Click to expand...
Because I'm 99% sure you're villaging this time!
WildZoo said:
I'm realizing as I'm reading through that I have absolutely zero idea who I want to vote for today, so that's...good
Click to expand...
Yep, me too. Voting cubs would make me sad because family, voting fluff would make me feel guilty...
WildZoo said:
Note that I have not completely cleared barks because watcher can be a wolf ability and we don't know if cover roles exist. But I probably won't vote there today.
Click to expand...
I'm not really understanding this cover role thing. When I was wolfing and got backed into a corner I just... lied?
cubsrule4e said:
Wow, I’m honored and insulted at the same time.
Click to expand...
I'M SORRY
 
cubsrule4e said:
Is that a possibility or should I just accept defeat with no way to defend?
Click to expand...
It is but I am about to go into silks so I might not get to a lengthy post about tonight.

But basically it feels like you've been hanging back a lot and not contributing as much substance/original thought as I'd expect, even from before powervillage!cubs times.
 
potentialsheltervet said:
Because I'm 99% sure you're villaging this time!

Yep, me too. Voting cubs would make me sad because family, voting fluff would make me feel guilty...

I'm not really understanding this cover role thing. When I was wolfing and got backed into a corner I just... lied?

I'M SORRY
Click to expand...
Some mods give cover roles to wolves.
 
Dana_May_B said:
im not quite sure how to argue with you about what you *think* my reads list looked like around the time TME posted hers. you're making a lot of assumptions about a reads list you never saw and i never posted. i did change some of my reads pretty drastically (example: true) between yesterday morning and after last night because of the way things went down with the vote, even if mel was a lone wolf.
Click to expand...
Okay well can you explain your Dubz Evolution a little more?

Where was Midwife last night compared to today?
 
Animal Midwife said:
I'm talking about your list today. You posted the POE today in between many posts about the switch being suspicious unless you no longer believe wolves were collectively attacking Mel.

I'm talking about today. No where did I mention sheeping.
Click to expand...
No. I no longer believe wolves were attacking Mel. I only believed that at 8:55pm last night as a split second assessment. I was explaining my vote for TME and the reasoning behind it. I was explaining all of that as I was catching up since I had no time to do it last night. All of my posts about TME, Mel and vote swing were referencing last night.
 
BobLoblaw78 said:
No. I no longer believe wolves were attacking Mel. I only believed that at 8:55pm last night as a split second assessment. I was explaining my vote for TME and the reasoning behind it. I was explaining all of that as I was catching up since I had no time to do it last night. All of my posts about TME, Mel and vote swing were referencing last night.
Click to expand...
Okay. I'm interested in seeing what you do today.
 
potentialsheltervet said:
What about the last four?
Click to expand...
Fluff says some sus stuff but I take it as sincere player misstep, not wolfish. The other 3 are lowposting my patience away to the point I think I should apply pressure (and it conveniently keeps me from making a tough decision on someone that isn't lowposting)
potentialsheltervet said:
I haven't received this memeo. (This was a typo but I'm leaving it.)
Click to expand...
I think it is seen as wasting time without further proof. Some like. Some don't.
 
Zenge142 said:
Okay well can you explain your Dubz Evolution a little more?

Where was Midwife last night compared to today?
Click to expand...
of course-
i started with dubz as neutral as I was told last game that's a safe spot to start her out at. she had a lot of joke-posts in the beginning, and i remember not liking her comment that she could understand the violet suspicion when i wasnt seeing the logic there.
however, as the vote progressed last night i found myself agreeing a lot more with her posts. i also dont see her being a wolf in the context of her interactions with samac based on how much they were on the same page last night.

i put AM as a village-lean on my list after my interaction with her about my reads on TME and the samac/fluff convo very early on in the game. i didnt really agree with her vote on TME, but i have been following her logic/reasoning and i liked her pushes on bob last night
 
justafluff said:
I think he got that ability after you died? But nvm, carry on.
Click to expand...
Unimportant, but he would have got when whoever died in the day 1 yeet presumably. Unimportant.
potentialsheltervet said:
Rojos are red
Your posts are suspicious
You asked for some votes
Now sleep with the fishes
Click to expand...
Good god I love you wolfet
justafluff said:
So you've never mistakenly defended a wolf before?
Click to expand...
………..
That’s a real weird response.

CAN WE YEET HER NOW
 
samac said:
WHY WOULD A VILLAGER SAY THIS IN REFERENCE TO SOMEONE DEFENDING THEM

I will not get off this train. I’ll ride it to derailment.
Click to expand...
Look if you find me wolfy and want to yeet me, yeet along! But what does cubs have to do with it? In fact, I really don't get why some of you find cubs wolfy. It seems like it's your reads only and whoever questions them ends up in the wolf pile.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.