MarWWel -- GAME THREAD

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
There’s a lone wolf lol

Yeah exactly though. If the (ish) part is lone wolf, then I'd be surprised with both those roles.

Unless the point you were trying to make is that both roles exist to catch the lone wolf in which sure I could see that argument
 
Why did you say this post samac tracking choice?
Because I don't need to say all my suspicions on thread. Look where it got me. I didn't want to fuel samac's wolf accusations, by saying I suspect she's a wolf with all the support she has.
 
Why did you say this post samac tracking choice?
And straight up said that samac is cleared for them
Re: Mel I would look into people who voted for Mel, just because he did not sound "wolfy." Probably not those of you who started the train, cause that would be such a risky move for wolves to just jump on another vote so close to the end of the cycle. So as much as I hate to say it True, Samac, DubZ are cleared for me.
 
Yeah exactly though. If the (ish) part is lone wolf, then I'd be surprised with both those roles.

Unless the point you were trying to make is that both roles exist to catch the lone wolf in which sure I could see that argument
If barks is village her role exists to catch anyone
If fluff is wolf tracker could exist to catch lone wolf
 
Because I don't need to say all my suspicions on thread. Look where it got me. I didn't want to fuel samac's wolf accusations, by saying I suspect she's a wolf with all the support she has.
I will stop focusing on you for the next hour if ya wanna make a case for wolf samac.
 
We Are Groot Day 2 Vote Tally (#2659)

fluff (9) - samac, Zenge, SAR, Dana, True, PSV, Barks, AM, Sporty
cubs (2) - DubZ, genny
True (2) - cubs, kdswg
Sporty (1) - fluff

14/17

Missing: @The_Breadmann @BobLoblaw78 @violetvett

Vote closes at 10pm ET/9pm CT/7pm Fantasyland on Thursday, 2/17/22 (~90 MINUTES)
we-are-groot-guardians.gif
 
And straight up said that samac is cleared for them
To which a lot of you replied that no one is cleared for the Mel train. And then I took it back. Besides I wasn't even able to track samac. Im not voting for her today. If you wanna question what could have been my tracking choice, go check BoWWling. I had 1x tracking ability and used it to track alleycat who was tunneling me in that game, without openly wolf reading her.
 
Because I don't need to say all my suspicions on thread. Look where it got me. I didn't want to fuel samac's wolf accusations, by saying I suspect she's a wolf with all the support she has.
Why do you care about what she thinks in a world where she's a wolf?
 
If barks is village her role exists to catch anyone
If fluff is wolf tracker could exist to catch lone wolf

I do like this theory. I also feel like in a game with clear main characters that it is at least probable that cover roles were provided.

At the very least, I don't intend to clear anyone from role or ability but I don't love the use of the ability as a slam-dunk village move
 
To which a lot of you replied that no one is cleared for the Mel train. And then I took it back. Besides I wasn't even able to track samac. Im not voting for her today. If you wanna question what could have been my tracking choice, go check BoWWling. I had 1x tracking ability and used it to track alleycat who was tunneling me in that game, without openly wolf reading her.
So do you think she's a wolf or a villager at this point?
 
Why do you care about what she thinks in a world where she's a wolf?
I didnt get any confirmation that she's a wolf okay? It just seemed that everything I said was being torn apart and examined for wolfiness. So I thought I'd track her. It was D1 and I wasn't in danger, and I didn't think it through that much.
 
Gonna post this before the thread gets away from me again.

Please read? I've been a single dad again today and I worked hard carving out the time to do this.

Presumably the "take one for the team" bit wasn't related to a PR though?

If you are going to get yeeted and it seems imminent, will you revel then? I'm just wondering how long before close you plan on giving village to evaluate, because a panicked village scrambling on where to vote usually doesn't end well.
If its close I'll give you half an hour.
Just going to agree that if I had that much heat on me as a villager, and had already admitted to having a good PR, I'd just role reveal. Or even just character reveal, unless we think the wolves were given fake characters that don't have a duplicate.


I do not understand why someone would vote themselves to die today to take one for the team but also won’t role reveal because they don’t wanna die
Especially in a game like this where only Dubz has made reference to any night action and presumably night skip is a 1x ability, you've already made yourself a huge wolf target just by saying you have a PR that you don't want to reveal.
Agree with these takes. Glad you role revealed, wish you'd done it sooner.

I mean, if there's a 🅱️ig reveal, I'd reconsider. Of either a major Marvel character, or the PR she's saying without any counterclaims. Either one. Just something more concrete.
I guess she did this? How do you feel, Zenge?

It was literally affecting my emotions IRL because there wasn’t much I could do to defend, and as stupid as it sounds was affecting my bowling which is an important part of my life and it’s also a team sport which isn’t fair to the other people, and you could see the difference in my scores once I let WW go for the moment. That’s why I left the thread at that time.
Sorry to hear that. It does make your exit feel less wolfy.

Meh. I'm not a bandwagoner and never have been. There isn't only one wolf in the game and we don't need a consensus. I think cubs is a wolf too so :shrug:
This is fair, and I agree that Cubs is sus.

Unless they get an extra kill if they know roles. Oh no. Why did I think about that after I said it. Dammit dubz.
🙁 I'm really sorry, I should have thought more before asking.

The wolfy people always include themselves in their own list.
Gonna request that @BobLoblaw78 explain the reference to the last game to Cubs.

I feel like the fluff vote is covered, and I think a fluff/ true pack makes sense. I’m fine with either going today but i wasnt ready to vote off wagon until Cubs did
In what way does a Fluff/True pack make sense? I felt bad about voting for her, then came around. Meanwhile, you seem to be fishing for a way to get the votes off of her. Why wouldn't a kdswg/fluff pack make even more sense?

If I was pushing you to role reveal, you'd call me fishy and sketchy. So NO. I ain't doing it. Yeet me all you want.
This radiates anti-village and makes it very hard to defend you.

Yeah the opening pages felt village, but theres been a build up of side-eye type posts and continued what i phrased "over the topness" that have him leaning the other way now.
Would love if you could pull some actual quotes instead of making this backhanded remarks repeatedly.
Excited for the apology when I eventually flip <3

I’m still confused by this
Who is “us” then?
The people in my orange-reds. Quoted this to remind you of how you felt when you were writing these posts, before you understood; that focused suspicion is what tunneling feels like. When you see that I'm village, remembering what made you feel this way will probably help improve your True-reading powers in the future.

Innocent child.
This wasn't necessary, @kdswg asked a legitimate question.

Add to that, the fact that even after those interactions yesterday he had the person who has not posted yet this entire cycle as his top wolf read, but voted for someone in a lower tier because he expected it might get more votes...that feels a little icky.

I could be tunneling. I'm still thinking on it. But I'm having a hard time seeing village cubs here.
He and kdswg feel like they were fishing to see if they could divert the train off of Fluff. Granted, this won't look as wolfy if she flips village, but if she flips wolf I'm going to insist we yeet Cubs next.

Sporty please don't "hmm" this without responding. Every time someone has "hmm"ed my posts I've wound up dying.
She's "hmm'd" approximately a million of my posts (most of them in wolf chat, admittedly), so I'm doomed.

But you should be proud, you’ve gotten so good at getting people to read you not-villlage:heckyeah:
Methinks I need to re-recalibrate, this is exhausting. Dubz, teach me pls (or @Lawpy, I desire lawpish energies)

Well, it'll certainly be interesting for me to see how we went from this to all-in on fluff.
Eh, basically Samac tunneled her for a while and her self-defense read as sketchy enough to enough people that a big wagon formed. And then it sort of got the energy of "if we don't flip her, we'll just spend all of tomorrow talking about her too" and here we are.

Taking a break from my homework a bit. I guess everyone's still convinced I'm a wolf?
As much as I hate to admit it, samac, AM, Bob, genny, Dana you're right. I'm not gaining anything by waiting. Although I'd rather die than stay and keep defending myself day after day but I'm giving you all a chance to see me differently.
I'm Black Widow and a tracker.
I want to buy this. Is anyone else Widow? Feels bold to pick such a popular character unless the wolves were given actual "cover" roles.

I don’t believe it.
Uuuugh why are you making me feel like we've all fallen down a tunnel with you?

I just don’t believe it. There is no way that they held that they’re a main character and a tracker this long and be village. Maybe wolves are given cover roles.
She definitely held her role too long and I don't think this wagon has brakes, but why would her being a main character and a tracker affect things? If I was a tracker, I wouldn't want the wolves to know.

Not moving off my fluff vote because her flip will be moderately clarifying, but for the record this day has felt really bad to me. Maybe that's just because I'm being tunneled / targeted for a misyeet for the first time?
 
Last edited:
**************************************
spoilers are
fun
and
everyone should use them
wall posts.

I tried to be cheeky and the forum said no.
***************************************
 
Gonna post this before the thread gets away from me again.

Mods let me know if you want me to put this in spoilers, but it was a lot of work so I don't really want to hide it away.



Just going to agree that if I had that much heat on me as a villager, and had already admitted to having a good PR, I'd just role reveal. Or even just character reveal, unless we think the wolves were given fake characters that don't have a duplicate.


Sorry to hear that. It does make your exit feel less wolfy.



Agree with these takes. Glad you role revealed, wish you'd done it sooner.


I guess she did this? How do you feel, Zenge?


This is fair, and I agree that Cubs is sus.


🙁 I'm really sorry, I should have thought more before asking.


Gonna request that @BobLoblaw78 explain the reference to the last game to Cubs.


In what way does a Fluff/True pack make sense? I felt bad about voting for her, then came around. Meanwhile, you seem to be fishing for a way to get the votes off of her. Why wouldn't a kdswg/fluff pack make even more sense?


This radiates anti-village and makes it very hard to defend you.


Would love if you could pull some actual quotes instead of making this backhanded remarks repeatedly.
Excited for the apology when I eventually flip <3



The people in my orange-reds. Quoted this to remind you of how you felt when you were writing these posts, before you understood; that focused suspicion is what tunneling feels like. When you see that I'm village, remembering what made you feel this way will probably help improve your True-reading powers in the future.


This wasn't necessary, @kdswg asked a legitimate question.


He and kdswg feel like they were fishing to see if they could divert the train off of Fluff. Granted, this won't look as wolfy if she flips village, but if she flips wolf I'm going to insist we yeet Cubs next.


She's "hmm'd" approximately a million of my posts (most of them in wolf chat, admittedly), so I'm doomed.


Methinks I need to re-recalibrate, this is exhausting. Dubz, teach me pls (or @Lawpy, I desire lawpish energies)


Eh, basically Samac tunneled her for a while and her self-defense read as sketchy enough to enough people that a big wagon formed. And then it sort of got the energy of "if we don't flip her, we'll just spend all of tomorrow talking about her too" and here we are.


I want to buy this. Is anyone else Widow? Feels bold to pick such a popular character unless the wolves were given actual "cover" roles.


Uuuugh why are you making me feel like we've all fallen down a tunnel with you?


She definitely held her role too long and I don't think this wagon has brakes, but why would her being a main character and a tracker affect things? If I was a tracker, I wouldn't want the wolves to know.

Not moving off my fluff vote because her flip will be moderately clarifying, but for the record this day has felt really bad to me. Maybe that's just because I'm being tunneled / targeted for a misyeet for the first time?
Holy wall posts, Batman!
 
**************************************
spoilers are
fun
and everyone should use them for wall posts.

I tried to be cheeky and the forum said no.
***************************************
I will edit because I'm new, but I genuinely want to know:

When someone posts five times in a row, no spoilers. Everyone can fully see all the work they put in.

When I do a condensed post with the same amount of material, I have to hide it behind spoilers. Why?
 
Methinks I need to re-recalibrate, this is exhausting. Dubz, teach me pls (or @Lawpy, I desire lawpish energies)
You just have to believe you're the villageriest villager that ever villaged. The belief is contagious.
 
I will edit because I'm new, but I genuinely want to know:

When someone posts five times in a row, no spoilers. Everyone can fully see all the work they put in.

When I do a condensed post with the same amount of material, I have to hide it behind spoilers. Why?
****************************
Because it's harder to pick out the most important parts of a wall post and people don't like reading, plus it's a pain to scroll through. It's why I do tl;drs at the top of my ISO posts and then have all the quotes spoilered; so people can check my work if they want to, but don't have to scroll through an entire big post if they don't want to.
****************************
 
Not moving off my fluff vote because her flip will be moderately clarifying, but for the record this day has felt really bad to me. Maybe that's just because I'm being tunneled / targeted for a misyeet for the first time?
Seriously True, you re not being tunneled until you exit the thread and cry in the bathroom.
 
I want to buy this. Is anyone else Widow? Feels bold to pick such a popular character unless the wolves were given actual "cover" roles.
if someone is don’t you ****ing dare say anything
This just made me think it could be a ploy to try and find a main character by them coming out and saying “nuh huh im widow!”
 
I will edit because I'm new, but I genuinely want to know:

When someone posts five times in a row, no spoilers. Everyone can fully see all the work they put in.

When I do a condensed post with the same amount of material, I have to hide it behind spoilers. Why?
At least for me, if I get pulled away I can come back to wherever I was on the thread and keep reading individual short posts. But if I get pulled away while I'm in the middle of reading a wall post I have to then come back and figure out where tf I was and also all the scrolling makes my eyes glaze over and then my broken brain kicks in and I get distracted.

I did read your entire post and sometimes when I'm responding to individual quotes from different people I format it the way you did too without spoilers because each comment is kind of its own thing, but individual posts just feel more digestible than wallposts. To me anyway.
 
This wasn't necessary, @kdswg asked a legitimate question.
True pls, that's a legitimate answer
In case it isn’t clear, Innocent Child is an actual role. They can, at any one time claim Innocent Child like “I am an innocent child” And the mods will come on the thread and confirm that.

It’s an exclusively village role, with the exception of bastard games.
 
Last edited:
Other things from my catch-up:
Dubz is not giving me the ick so far.
I don't think zenge is wolfy.
samac is ruffling my feathers but I'm not sure why.
updates on these reads?

but actually I like your points on True and he's next on my ISO list while I finish looking at TME

Unvote Barks
Vote TME
I know this has long since past, but this is the wolfiest wolf Mel post ever.

@Barkley13 @justafluff

Please stop this nonsense pls and find a wolf pls.
hmm.
 
Top