MarWWel -- GAME THREAD

[WildZoo]

---

Members do not see this ad.

But… if you think there’s only one more wolf, when are you going to yeet Bob? That’s basically just letting him win with village, no?

I’m so talented that I’ve been able to extol all of my great qualities for almost 36 hours!

Why should I care if he wins with village?

 

[Zenge142]

If Bob is telling the truth and we yeet cubs and cubs is the last wolf, then Bob loses.

 

[WildZoo]

That’s 26% not village. That’s pretty higher.

26% is not high for separate factions

 

[samac]

If Bob is telling the truth and we yeet cubs and cubs is the last wolf, then Bob loses.

this is true.
And he never once pushed away from that wagon.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

unless we bring him to VoLo,

I'm not really planning on this game getting to VoLo given that there's still at least ten villagers left and probably 1-2 wolves. If we misyeet several villagers in a row I will be shocked.

 

[WildZoo]

For one, the numbers in the game. For two, the write ups pointing toward 4 anti village folks left.
For three, his 3P wincon as Loki may not be accurate.
I think this is still the right thing to do.

I'd rather yeet a wolf. He could be described as anti-village because of that misyeet requirement in the stated wincon.

It's Day 3 and we have two wolves and a lone wolf dead. We have wiggle room. I'd rather find a wolf.

 

[WildZoo]

I'm not really planning on this game getting to VoLo given that there's still at least ten villagers left and probably 1-2 wolves. If we misyeet several villagers in a row I will be shocked.

Then I don't see the problem

 

[samac]

I'd rather yeet a wolf. He could be described as anti-village because of that misyeet requirement in the stated wincon.

It's Day 3 and we have two wolves and a lone wolf dead. We have wiggle room. I'd rather find a wolf.

I agree I’d rather yeet a wolf.
But I still think he’s a wolf.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

If Bob is telling the truth and we yeet cubs and cubs is the last wolf, then Bob loses.

Exactly, which is why I think Bob is lying and thinks cubs is village. I think there could still be 2 wolves left. I just think Bob is one of them.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Then I don't see the problem

Problem is I think Bob is a wolf and if we don't ever yeet him we will lose. That is the problem.

 

[Dana_May_B]

If Bob is telling the truth and we yeet cubs and cubs is the last wolf, then Bob loses.

good point- even if bob wants to side with village as a 3p, why would he do something that would actively lose him the game?

 

[potentialsheltervet]

See, this is why me, cubs, and samac are a family. We get each other.

 

[WildZoo]

I don't see why Bob lying about thinking Cubs is a wolf would be mutually exclusive with him being 3p?

Meh. I will think some more.

 

[WildZoo]

Problem is I think Bob is a wolf and if we don't ever yeet him we will lose. That is the problem.

I don't think I ever said the words "don't ever yeet Bob"

 

[BobLoblaw78]

Yes.
I’m super wolfy.

Wasn’t referencing you but whatever. I’m trying to help you. And this just hurts a little. I was meaning PSV.

If I go down and you waste a yeet, I still want village to win. But again, whatever.

 

[samac]

Wasn’t referencing you but whatever. I’m trying to help you. And this just hurts a little. I was meaning PSV.

If I go down and you waste a yeet, I still want village to win. But again, whatever.

You think PSV concocted this lie detector story as a wolf to get you to admit you’re not village?

 

[WildZoo]

Tbh I've felt uncomfortable with the Bob vote all day so I'm sure my brain is looking for any reason not to go through with it.

I think it might actually be useful at this point to look back through Bob's posts and see if there was any where he said that he was not a wolf or something like that, to determine whether it would make sense for him to have claimed 3p instead at a time when he thought it was possible PSV had lie detected him. Perhaps Dana did that already.

 

[samac]

Tbh I've felt uncomfortable with the Bob vote all day so I'm sure my brain is looking for any reason not to go through with it.

I think it might actually be useful at this point to look back through Bob's posts and see if there was any where he said that he was not a wolf or something like that, to determine whether it would make sense for him to have claimed 3p instead at a time when he thought it was possible PSV had lie detected him. Perhaps Dana did that already.

Dana did. There was a “I’m going to flip village” or something along those lines post.

 

[WildZoo]

Dana did. There was a “I’m going to flip village” or something along those lines post.

I'm talking specifically about whether was a post that, if lie detected, would have made it impossible for a 3p claim to be true

 

[BobLoblaw78]

But… if you think there’s only one more wolf, when are you going to yeet Bob? That’s basically just letting him win with village, no?

I’m so talented that I’ve been able to extol all of my great qualities for almost 36 hours!

I don’t get the mindset of why you wouldn’t want me to win too. The more the merrier. Unless you have alternative motives.

I shouldn’t have pushed cubs, shouldn’t have tried to find a wolf besides cubs and shouldn’t have been transparent with reveal.

I thought it was the right thing but my mind just doesn’t see it the way you guys do

 

[Dana_May_B]

Tbh I've felt uncomfortable with the Bob vote all day so I'm sure my brain is looking for any reason not to go through with it.

I think it might actually be useful at this point to look back through Bob's posts and see if there was any where he said that he was not a wolf or something like that, to determine whether it would make sense for him to have claimed 3p instead at a time when he thought it was possible PSV had lie detected him. Perhaps Dana did that already.

dana did!!!!!!

I will get you anything you want. Just as long as I get the same when I flip village. So worse case scenario I break even!!

He started off different from previous game. That was to be expected. He continued to sound slightly off. Just enough that I couldn’t move him to village. I have a soft spot for his humor so I tend to village read him quicker than I should. But not this time. Then, the thing that bothered me most was that he started sussing me some. And usually it is him vouching for my shady behavior. And I know I’ve been playing it straight and not wolfing. So something is off with him. Then you throw in the fluff defense. And his and fluffs best impression of synchronized wolfing with self vote and exit.

Sense then it feels like he felt caught and is playing with house money

and i shared these quotes with the bolded before bob claimed 3p. so yeah, there was a possibility he thought sheltervet lie-detected the "I've been playing it straight and not wolfing" comment.

 

[BobLoblaw78]

And thinking I am a genius wolf that has retroactively planned a Loki reveal and behaved this way for a fake claim is a compliment. I guess

 

[WildZoo]

I mean don't get me wrong, a 3p claim is often a trapped wolf's best bet, but unless I missed it (possible) PSV had not actually said who or what she "lie detected" yet at the time Bob claimed, so it feels a bit hasty to me on first impression.

But I am gonna sit down and read through things again.

 

[BobLoblaw78]

For one, the numbers in the game. For two, the write ups pointing toward 4 anti village folks left.
For three, his 3P wincon as Loki may not be accurate.
I think this is still the right thing to do.

Samac. Plz. I truly want you to have the most epic game ever. You can yeet me D1 and NK me N1 from here to eternity guilt free. I’m not lying. Go find the last wolf. It isn’t me. Cubs. Bread. Idk. I do know it isn’t me. Promise

 

[BobLoblaw78]

I swear on genny’s cats if that helps

(Don’t worry Genny. I would never endanger your cattos)

 

[SARdoghandler]

Dubz pls
I think he’s just flat out lying

It amuses me to no end that people are trying to talk Dubz back into a Bob yeet

When I was like "nah, still cubs" it was like everyone was just all "meh, on brand for SAR. She's chaos even when she isn't"

 

[Dana_May_B]

Samac. Plz. I truly want you to have the most epic game ever. You can yeet me D1 and NK me N1 from here to eternity guilt free. I’m not lying. Go find the last wolf. It isn’t me. Cubs. Bread. Idk. I do know it isn’t me. Promise

but but bob how does us finding the last wolf make sense for your proposed wincon??? if we yeet you today, you lose, if we yeet the last wolf today and your role reveal was true, then you also lose!

 

[cubsrule4e]

I don’t get the mindset of why you wouldn’t want me to win too. The more the merrier. Unless you have alternative motives.

I shouldn’t have pushed cubs, shouldn’t have tried to find a wolf besides cubs and shouldn’t have been transparent with reveal.

I thought it was the right thing but my mind just doesn’t see it the way you guys do

Maybe things changed during my hiatus but I’ve never seen people WANTING to win with third party, unless they provided some kind of true advantage to village, and even then people weren’t all about a “shared” win.

Parade starts soon!! I’ll keep checking in but may be sporadic the rest of the evening. Y’all gotta experience Mardi Gras sometime!

I’ve got such great taste in beer!

 

[SARdoghandler]

Maybe things changed during my hiatus but I’ve never seen people WANTING to win with third party, unless they provided some kind of true advantage to village, and even then people weren’t all about a “shared” win.

Parade starts soon!! I’ll keep checking in but may be sporadic the rest of the evening. Y’all gotta experience Mardi Gras sometime!

I’ve got such great taste in beer!

 

[SARdoghandler]

As long as win con isn't my-faction exclusive of course

 

[samac]

Maybe things changed during my hiatus but I’ve never seen people WANTING to win with third party, unless they provided some kind of true advantage to village, and even then people weren’t all about a “shared” win.

Parade starts soon!! I’ll keep checking in but may be sporadic the rest of the evening. Y’all gotta experience Mardi Gras sometime!

I’ve got such great taste in beer!

3Ps helped win the game in Bioshock for village. But they were true neutral, no alternate agenda but to survive.

 

[samac]

Samac. Plz. I truly want you to have the most epic game ever. You can yeet me D1 and NK me N1 from here to eternity guilt free. I’m not lying. Go find the last wolf. It isn’t me. Cubs. Bread. Idk. I do know it isn’t me. Promise

I wouldn’t say it takes away from the epicness of this if you do flip as you claim cause you’re still not village.

 

[BobLoblaw78]

but but bob how does us finding the last wolf make sense for your proposed wincon??? if we yeet you today, you lose, if we yeet the last wolf today and your role reveal was true, then you also lose!

Bc I am actually like how True comes across (is I assume). I just don’t translate as well through texts. I’m okay with village winning and me not. As a wolf I couldn’t betray the pack by not trying. But this would be fine.

Also, I think the odds are in favor of a village misyeet. So that helps. But I’ll vote wherever.

 

[WildZoo]

Maybe things changed during my hiatus but I’ve never seen people WANTING to win with third party, unless they provided some kind of true advantage to village, and even then people weren’t all about a “shared” win.

Parade starts soon!! I’ll keep checking in but may be sporadic the rest of the evening. Y’all gotta experience Mardi Gras sometime!

I’ve got such great taste in beer!

I have never in my entire WW career cared about whether a 3p won as long as village beat the wolves. I just don't care. Same when I'm wolfing, if a 3p wants to tag along for the ride, so be it. I only care a little bit more about exclusives.

 

[kaydubs]

Can Do This All Day 3 Vote Tally (#4033)

cubs (4) - True, genny, SAR, violetvett
Bob (6) - samac, cubs, Dana, Bread, PSV, kdswg
genny (1) - Bob
kdswg (1) - Zenge

12/14

Winning: @BobLoblaw78
Missing: @Barkley13 @WildZoo

Vote/Yeet closes at 10pm ET/9pm CT/7pm Fantasyland on Saturday, 2/19/22 (~3 hours)

 

[kaydubs]

I have never in my entire WW career cared about whether a 3p won as long as village beat the wolves. I just don't care. Same when I'm wolfing, if a 3p wants to tag along for the ride, so be it. I only care a little bit more about exclusives.

Finally. I had about lost hope.

 

[BobLoblaw78]

I wouldn’t say it takes away from the epicness of this if you do flip as you claim cause you’re still not village.

Oh. So cavalier about my life. 😞

What about the villager who will die bc of extra NK. They don’t matter either?

Okay. Sorry. I tried

 

[WildZoo]

It amuses me to no end that people are trying to talk Dubz back into a Bob yeet

When I was like "nah, still cubs" it was like everyone was just all "meh, on brand for SAR. She's chaos even when she isn't"

Idk why anyone thinks I'm reasonable, I literally stayed off fluff while convincing other people to vote for her, I'm legit broken

 

[BobLoblaw78]

Unyeet genny

Yeet cubs

i’ll be back. hopefully

 

[WildZoo]

Oh when did Zenge move? I missed that

 

[kaydubs]

Can Do This All Day 3 Vote Tally (#4041)

cubs (5) - True, genny, SAR, violetvett, Bob
Bob (6) - samac, cubs, Dana, Bread, PSV, kdswg
genny ()
kdswg (1) - Zenge

12/14

Winning: @BobLoblaw78
Missing: @Barkley13 @WildZoo

Vote/Yeet closes at 10pm ET/9pm CT/7pm Fantasyland on Saturday, 2/19/22 (~2.75 hours)

 

[samac]

I also think Bob revealed because he thought he was caught when PSV said she caught a wolf.
The only way he would know that is if he thought cubs would flip village cause Bob is gonna flip wolf.

 

[samac]

So like
He thought he was caught
So he revealed
But it was all for giggles

 

[WildZoo]

Hey, are y'all forgetting we have at least one (TME) kill of unknown origin? We absolutely can not confidently say Bob has no killing ability.

I think it's much more likely TME's death had to do with Mel

 

[WildZoo]

Unyeet Bob

Yeet KDS

Why kdswg?

 

[samac]

Yeet Samac

Samac just screams marvel villain. Provocative, camping and don't get me started on the name. (thanos, loki, samac. Tell me that name don't fit)

Why in the world would he come in the game and mention his own role on par with thanos

 

[Zenge142]

Why kdswg?

If they’re both dead and flip village I’d look somewhere in the KDS/Violet/Genny area, with Violet being the least likely of the 3.

I wanted to see what would happen

 

[WildZoo]

I wanted to see what would happen

Yeah
but
why kdswg

 

[WildZoo]

@Zenge142 to clarify, I'm asking why kdswg is next in your wolfy pile

 

[Zenge142]

@Zenge142 to clarify, I'm asking why kdswg is next in your wolfy pile

Of everyone on the list it makes the most sense to me follows by Genny. Or I guess bread then Genny. Then I get paranoid and it’s Dana.