MarWWel -- GAME THREAD

Started by Doggo Labs
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

Browse articles Compare schools My application plan Read Interview Feedback
Practice for interviews Ask an Advisor
The_Breadmann said:
But my feels from catching up yesterday:

Samac: Villager but more aggressive than I am used to (I think)?
AM: Village since she is pushing people to try and get more reads and beginning to establish a block as I have seen her do as a villager (not sure I have seen wolf AM before though)
Borky: Villager since the roll reveal and the push to defend herself up to yeet close
Dubz: More neutral up until this point
Mother Sporty: Still cannot read so I can go either way
Cubz: Was giving me a bit more of a village feel when he joined the thread
Fluff: More neutral and really not sure how I feel about her. Her wording on things are a bit shaky but she is also still a noob
True: Despite posting a lot I would still put them in my neutral pile. I want to go over what they have said so far but he seems to be in the running for highest content posters.

Everyone else I am completely unsure of
Click to expand...
God you’re up early
 
potentialsheltervet said:
Guys I've just had a bad thought.
What if there is no wolfpack? What if there are only 4ish lone wolves sprinkled throughout the game? I was pondering mechanics, and most of the Marvel villains don't really team up. It's typically a Big Bad and then some lesser goons. So, it sort of stands to reason that they wouldn't be in a cohesive group in this game. I mean, I'm having a hard time imagining a pack of, like, Kaecilius, Thanos, Mysterio, and Ultron.
Maybe I'm tinfoiling too hard, but with Mel's flip I feel like it isn't something we can rule out.
Click to expand...
Dont like this train of thought. If there were two lone wolves then maybe go down this avenue, but this is a bit too far out to think about right now. (yes I know I am far behind but I could not read any more after reading SOPs all day for training yesterday)
 
The_Breadmann said:
But my feels from catching up yesterday:

Samac: Villager but more aggressive than I am used to (I think)?
AM: Village since she is pushing people to try and get more reads and beginning to establish a block as I have seen her do as a villager (not sure I have seen wolf AM before though)
Borky: Villager since the roll reveal and the push to defend herself up to yeet close
Dubz: More neutral up until this point
Mother Sporty: Still cannot read so I can go either way
Cubz: Was giving me a bit more of a village feel when he joined the thread
Fluff: More neutral and really not sure how I feel about her. Her wording on things are a bit shaky but she is also still a noob
True: Despite posting a lot I would still put them in my neutral pile. I want to go over what they have said so far but he seems to be in the running for highest content posters.

Everyone else I am completely unsure of
Click to expand...
How far did you get in your catch-up?
 
We Are Groot Day 2 Vote Tally (#2060)

fluff (4) - samac, Zenge, fluff, SAR
cubs (3) - DubZ, Dana, cubs

7/17

Missing: a hefty amount

Vote closes at 10pm ET/9pm CT/7pm Fantasyland on Thursday, 2/17/22 (~14.5 hours)
we-are-groot-guardians.gif
 
Zenge142 said:
I'm still a bit conflicted, but here's the thing, this has dominated this cycle thus far. I can guarantee you, without a Fluff flip, it's going to keep dominating the thread until Fluff finally flips. It's better to rip the band-aid off.
Click to expand...

This is kind of my opinion as well - if we don't flip this now we're just going to talk in circles for the next few days cycles re-hashing it. Unless there is otherwise compelling evidence, I feel like we need the info
 
WildZoo said:
I can see the fluff is an egg that needs cracking argument but that also makes me sad because I always think "but what if village" and being in that situation as village sucks. It will be really helpful for me solidifying some shaky reads if she does flip wolf though.
Click to expand...
With the thread exit I’m gonna feel bad with the flip even if she’s wolf. My goal isn’t to push someone into a thread exit.
I’m gonna feel like a huge dingus if village.
 
WildZoo said:
I can see the fluff is an egg that needs cracking argument but that also makes me sad because I always think "but what if village" and being in that situation as village sucks. It will be really helpful for me solidifying some shaky reads if she does flip wolf though.
Click to expand...
Can you see the fluff is wolfy argument?
 
Zenge142 said:
Can you see the fluff is wolfy argument?
Click to expand...
I mean sure, I can see the potential rojo thing (that's why I quoted it in the first place) and there was something else too that I now can't remember where I was like "yeah ok, that could be wolfy". I could see her post thanking me (and I think True?) for defending her as a bit of furry nooblet pocketing. I can see it, I don't think it's unreasonable. I just don't 100% believe in it.
 
WildZoo said:
I mean sure, I can see the potential rojo thing (that's why I quoted it in the first place) and there was something else too that I now can't remember where I was like "yeah ok, that could be wolfy". I could see her post thanking me (and I think True?) for defending her as a bit of furry nooblet pocketing. I can see it, I don't think it's unreasonable. I just don't 100% believe in it.
Click to expand...
Honestly, part of what makes me feel anxious about voting for her is the fact that there has been so little defense. I think it's basically just been you and me, and I know that I'm a villager and I'm 98% sure that you are.

So either she's getting soft-bussed (I think that's the term), or I guess they might just feel like it's too risky to defend her? It just feels weird that a wolf would be left on their own this early in the game when the pack is still fully intact.
 
Truenamer said:
Honestly, part of what makes me feel anxious about voting for her is the fact that there has been so little defense. I think it's basically just been you and me, and I know that I'm a villager and I'm 98% sure that you are.

So either she's getting soft-bussed (I think that's the term), or I guess they might just feel like it's too risky to defend her? It just feels weird that a wolf would be left on their own this early in the game when the pack is still fully intact.
Click to expand...
i think cubs has also been defending her a bit too tho. which is why flipping her would also help me with my read on cubs. but i get what you're saying, and there hasn't really been any major pushback to the fluff vote today. everyone has kinda just come on to say we need to flip fluff so that this convo doesn't drag out over several day cycles.

cubsrule4e said:
I can see how people are seeing it they way they are, but is not that a pretty standard question for a noob who hasnt encountered that mechanic before? I still get confused myself on how 3p affect the numbers sometimes.
Click to expand...

cubsrule4e said:
Oho! And if she flips village? Open season on you? So youre convinced fluff/barks was w/v?
Click to expand...

cubsrule4e said:
So youre willing to go all in on a wolf read without having even evaluated important content between her and another player? Youre starting to give me the twitch, mi amore.
Click to expand...
 
Dana_May_B said:
i think cubs has also been defending her a bit too tho. which is why flipping her would also help me with my read on cubs. but i get what you're saying, and there hasn't really been any major pushback to the fluff vote today. everyone has kinda just come on to say we need to flip fluff so that this convo doesn't drag out over several day cycles.

Click to expand...
I feel like there’s been a lot of defense and I’ve done 2+ days of screaming to get here.
 
Truenamer said:
Honestly, part of what makes me feel anxious about voting for her is the fact that there has been so little defense. I think it's basically just been you and me, and I know that I'm a villager and I'm 98% sure that you are.

So either she's getting soft-bussed (I think that's the term), or I guess they might just feel like it's too risky to defend her? It just feels weird that a wolf would be left on their own this early in the game when the pack is still fully intact.
Click to expand...
Tiny bit of defense from cubs too (in calling the barks/fluff argument v/v) but it was very slight. I think others said similar things but I can't remember who.

But yeah not much hard defending. Still, I wouldn't say there are that many wolves who will stick their neck out like I did with kdswg last game or samac did with Vis the game before. In a wolf!fluff world it depends on the pack and how much village goodwill the other wolves have to spend on defending her. If they're on shaky ground themselves they're less likely to try it.

And there have definitely been games (*cough*Emojis*cough*) where the "No one is defending them even though we know the pack is intact" argument was used as a reason to think the player in question was village, and it turned out that they were a wolf and wolves were just using other tactics to keep them from getting voted out.

So I don't see that in and of itself as a strong reason not to go there.
 
samac said:
I feel like there’s been a lot of defense and I’ve done 2+ days of screaming to get here.
Click to expand...
yes definitely more defense in the time it took to get to where we are now- but the current vibe on thread im sensing is that theres a general consensus we need to flip fluff
 
Dana_May_B said:
i think cubs has also been defending her a bit too tho. which is why flipping her would also help me with my read on cubs. but i get what you're saying, and there hasn't really been any major pushback to the fluff vote today. everyone has kinda just come on to say we need to flip fluff so that this convo doesn't drag out over several day cycles.

Click to expand...
This is the post that really gets me:
justafluff said:
So you've never mistakenly defended a wolf before?
Click to expand...
I don't know how fluff says that as a villager about another player that may or may not be a wolf. It just sounds like her talking about a packmate.
 
samac said:
I feel like there’s been a lot of defense and I’ve done 2+ days of screaming to get here.
Click to expand...

I agree with this. I feel like there's been a lot of soft defending. Which, if it was a Rojo, I can see woof pack members doing that type of soft defense to see if they can dig their way out without incriminating themselves too badly. If it were a super obvious Rojo that wouldn't be an option but ambiguity like that means there's a chance
 
genny said:
This is the post that really gets me:

I don't know how fluff says that as a villager about another player that may or may not be a wolf. It just sounds like her talking about a packmate.
Click to expand...
Wait since I’ve called that out didn’t you say you don’t understand the fluff push and you wanted to yeet me for manufacturing it?
 
unyeet cubs, yeet fluff

as much as it saddens me, i just dont see how some of the things she's said would make sense as a villager, and i also dont want this question mark about her to continue to tickle us all game.
 
WildZoo said:
Tiny bit of defense from cubs too (in calling the barks/fluff argument v/v) but it was very slight. I think others said similar things but I can't remember who.

But yeah not much hard defending. Still, I wouldn't say there are that many wolves who will stick their neck out like I did with kdswg last game or samac did with Vis the game before. In a wolf!fluff world it depends on the pack and how much village goodwill the other wolves have to spend on defending her. If they're on shaky ground themselves they're less likely to try it.

And there have definitely been games (*cough*Emojis*cough*) where the "No one is defending them even though we know the pack is intact" argument was used as a reason to think the player in question was village, and it turned out that they were a wolf and wolves were just using other tactics to keep them from getting voted out.

So I don't see that in and of itself as a strong reason not to go there.
Click to expand...
Okay, I hear you. I just... she's the fluffy mayor, you know? 😔

Yeet Fluff
 
genny said:
This is the post that really gets me:

I don't know how fluff says that as a villager about another player that may or may not be a wolf. It just sounds like her talking about a packmate.
Click to expand...

Looking at that post again it does look really bad and I'm probably letting my squishy heart get to me too much lol
 
You must log in or register to reply here.