MarWWel -- GAME THREAD

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Anyone else going to comment on my "Loki is the alien race that hates humans" theory because I feel like it's significant that it's in the writeup. He could be lying about his wincon even if he is a 3p.
 
genny said:
we also don't know that Bob isn't lying about 3P. Maybe he gambled that PSV lie detected him and decided to come out as 3P instead of wolf.
Click to expand...

That would be interesting.

I am, personally, inclined to believe the role/ability because it seems to fit well with the character and Loki is a very morally ambiguous character so fits the 3p as well. I know he could fakeclaim Loki, but I like the ability with it, which appears to have been confirmed by samac earlier
 
potentialsheltervet said:
Anyone else going to comment on my "Loki is the alien race that hates humans" theory because I feel like it's significant that it's in the writeup. He could be lying about his wincon even if he is a 3p.
Click to expand...
im sorry i really dont know marvel lore- i thought loki was thor's brother- arent they the same race?
 
violetvett said:
Right, but I'm wondering though if a wolf would get a 3P-specific cover role, instead of a village-specific one?
Click to expand...
If anything a 3p reveal is tbh more likely to move people off of his vote. As we're seeing.
Like I said I don't find cubs wolfy and I'm not confident in any other yeet direction so I'd rather dispose of Bob.
 
violetvett said:
Right, but I'm wondering though if a wolf would get a 3P-specific cover role, instead of a village-specific one?
Click to expand...

I would lean not but never say never. Cover roles aren't usually that specific. It would be more along the lines of "You are x clearly villanous villain. You have powers of x y z. Your cover role is x clearly heroic hero"
 
Can Do This All Day 3 Vote Tally (#3862)

cubs (4) - True, genny, SAR, violetvett
Bob (8) - samac, cubs, Zenge, DubZ, Dana, Bread, Barks, PSV
genny (1) - Bob

13/14

Winning: @BobLoblaw78
Missing: @kdswg

Vote/Yeet closes at 10pm ET/9pm CT/7pm Fantasyland on Saturday, 2/19/22 (~5.5 hours)
AllDay03.gif
 
potentialsheltervet said:
If anything a 3p reveal is tbh more likely to move people off of his vote. As we're seeing.
Like I said I don't find cubs wolfy and I'm not confident in any other yeet direction so I'd rather dispose of Bob.
Click to expand...
ok im gonna play devils advocate- lets say we yeet bob and confirm he's 3p. well who are you voting tomorrow then?
 
Dana_May_B said:
ok im gonna play devils advocate- lets say we yeet bob and confirm he's 3p. well who are you voting tomorrow then?
Click to expand...
I guess I would then yeet cubs.
To turn the tables: we yeet cubs and he's village. Who are you yeeting tomorrow?
Or even: we yeet cubs and he's a wolf. Who are you yeeting tomorrow?
 
potentialsheltervet said:
I guess I would then yeet cubs.
To turn the tables: we yeet cubs and he's village. Who are you yeeting tomorrow?
Or even: we yeet cubs and he's a wolf. Who are you yeeting tomorrow?
Click to expand...
if cubs is village (which i still doubt) then im looking more at violet and maybeeeee genny.
if cubs is a wolf im seeing him as very compatible with kdswg.
honestly kinda hoping its a 3 wolf pack with one lone wolf tho. especially if we believe bob to be 3p
 
I honestly believe that if there IS a 3P character, the obvious choice would be Loki.

Also, was it cubs who role revealed as Black Panther, or am I thinking of someone else?
 
He's a question: if Bob's cover role were village Loki would my lie detector have seen his "when I flip village" thing as true? What's the order of supremacy there, or is it mod specific?
 
potentialsheltervet said:
He's a question: if Bob's cover role were village Loki would my lie detector have seen his "when I flip village" thing as true? What's the order of supremacy there, or is it mod specific?
Click to expand...
if bob is a wolf, he wouldnt flip village, even if he was provided with cover role. so it was a lie. in the noob game, the wolves were given a list of songs to choose from as cover roles. all the wolves had songs from before or after the 2000-2010 era, so we needed songs to claim on thread in case anyone figured it out. but it didnt affect what song we had when we flipped
 
While I'm not a fan of Bob bouncing after dropping that 3P bombshell, I feel like we would get more info out of a cub flip than a Bob flip.
I mean, if Bob flips 3P than we're stuck in the dark again.
cubs flipping gives us more to go off of, but then again, I don't want to yeet a villager so aghhhhhhhhhh
 
violetvett said:
I honestly believe that if there IS a 3P character, the obvious choice would be Loki.

Also, was it cubs who role revealed as Black Panther, or am I thinking of someone else?
Click to expand...
Yes, it was cubs.
Let me clarify I don't necessarily think Bob is lying about his role. I just don't think we should avoid yeeting him because I strongly believe he is still anti-village.
 
violetvett said:
I honestly believe that if there IS a 3P character, the obvious choice would be Loki.

Also, was it cubs who role revealed as Black Panther, or am I thinking of someone else?
Click to expand...

Yes thats me.

And so if Bob is telling the truth this would probably put the game at 3 wolves with two 3P vs 4 wolves with two 3P, and one of those being a Lone Wolf. Which seems more likely?

Im the mods favorite!!!
 
potentialsheltervet said:
Yes, it was cubs.
Let me clarify I don't necessarily think Bob is lying about his role. I just don't think we should avoid yeeting him because I strongly believe he is still anti-village.
Click to expand...
See, I disagree. If he's actually 3P, I think he's both anti-village AND anti-wolf. Loki is anti-everyone except for himself.
 
Also if we're assuming
cubsrule4e said:
Yes thats me.

And so if Bob is telling the truth this would probably put the game at 3 wolves with two 3P vs 4 wolves with two 3P, and one of those being a Lone Wolf. Which seems more likely?

Im the mods favorite!!!
Click to expand...
The former imo. Finding the last official wolf is going to be more challenging and I'm of the opinion we shouldn't start hacking through villagers until we know for sure about Bob.
 
Oh, by the way: since the lie detector is obviously silent, why was cubs so confident I would be clearing him? I have mixed feelings about it because the quote sounds like he's assuming me naming who I thought was the last wolf would definitively clear him. Bob/cubs are probably mutually exclusive as packmates but not as a 3p/wolf duo.
@cubsrule4e Can you explain that?
 
BobLoblaw78 said:
Yes. 3P.

I even messed with fluff about Loki. Anti hero stuff. I called Loki a villain and she called him antihero

Someone said earlier “oh god”

I replied “yes”
Click to expand...
Could you clarify your wincon again?
BobLoblaw78 said:
I’m Loki. You know he had to be in the game. I can win either wolf or village. I must be on a wolf yeet and a villager misyeet and survive to win. I can be either team.

I get to send one message per night. Sent to fluff bc fluff was begging to be Loki.

Last night I sent Samac a crazy tinfoil bc I thought she would appreciate it. And she was obviously village
Click to expand...
So you just have to have two votes (one good yeet and one misyeet) and survive until parity/all wolves are gone right?
 
BobLoblaw78 said:
Where is Samac when you need her?? I summon thee you mewling cow!!!

(Lokis words, not mine)

Which reminds me. I was supposed to cause chaos. But I’m already so sus that it is hard to do without hosing myself
Click to expand...
Pretty sure the line was a little more ruder than that, but I appreciate you downgrading it 😂
 
BobLoblaw78 said:
Yes. 3P.

I even messed with fluff about Loki. Anti hero stuff. I called Loki a villain and she called him antihero

Someone said earlier “oh god”

I replied “yes”
Click to expand...
Going back through your posts, you've been an excellent Loki. I really like how you've been playing this game now that I know your role
 
genny said:
no... i could plausibly see a wolf arguing that loki is a villager, so it could be a cover role given to a wolf.
Click to expand...
I guess I'm not understanding you because I can't tell whether you're saying Bob is more wolfy because of his role reveal or looking like a genuine 3p because a wolf would've claimed Loki is a villager as a cover role.
 
cubsrule4e said:
He could just as easily be a wolf with a cover role or made up a nice sounding 3P role to buy time.

Im too sexy for my shiiiirrttt!
Click to expand...
I’d rather have my real role of Loki. (You know he is in the game). 3P can win with either side. If someone yeeted me or NK’s me they are wasting a chance.

Your role is black panther. Possible cover role.

Which reminds me. If I was villain, I would likely have cover role. And it wouldn’t be Loki.

I didn’t want to reveal Loki bc it doesn’t help. But is sure as heck is authentic and real
 
potentialsheltervet said:
Oh, by the way: since the lie detector is obviously silent, why was cubs so confident I would be clearing him? I have mixed feelings about it because the quote sounds like he's assuming me naming who I thought was the last wolf would definitively clear him. Bob/cubs are probably mutually exclusive as packmates but not as a 3p/wolf duo.
@cubsrule4e Can you explain that?
Click to expand...
I have a thought but I’ll let him reply
 
potentialsheltervet said:
Oh, by the way: since the lie detector is obviously silent, why was cubs so confident I would be clearing him? I have mixed feelings about it because the quote sounds like he's assuming me naming who I thought was the last wolf would definitively clear him. Bob/cubs are probably mutually exclusive as packmates but not as a 3p/wolf duo.
@cubsrule4e Can you explain that?
Click to expand...

Nah i wasnt saying Id be cleared, it was more of a jokey comment about you being family helping me out and then I threw in the poem. But if there was only one wolf left obviously the game would have ended, and that would have cleared me.

Im a great manator too!
 
Okay so if Bob is actually a village-leaning 3p and, for my sake, we're assuming cubs is village (bear with me on that), where next?
 
Wait, so assuming bob is telling the truth and made it to the endgame, would he win WITH village, or would he be stealing the village win for himself?
 
violetvett said:
Wait, so assuming bob is telling the truth and made it to the endgame, would he win WITH village, or would he be stealing the village win for himself?
Click to expand...
Because if it's the latter, than we want to yeet him eventually.
 
genny said:
no... i could plausibly see a wolf arguing that loki is a villager, so it could be a cover role given to a wolf.
Click to expand...
Sure. Anything is possible. But you guys love stretching so thin on trying to make me a wolf when just giving me an iota of objectivity would make it all make more sense.

Why was I so desperate to get a last second vote down that would look sus on D1????

BC I WANTED TO MAKE SURE I WAS ON A VILLAGE MISYEET AS WELL AS A WOLF YEET! I didn’t want an opportunity to slip by. I would’ve flipped over to Mel had I thought he was truly going to be the vote leader. I truly rushed through the reads and placed my vote on who I thought was leading. I couldn’t find a vote count to know who was most in the lead
 
If he can be either team then he would win WITH village. Or if the wolf/wolves reached parity with him still being alive he would win with the wolves. I think.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
67K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
48K
chicandtoughness
chicandtoughness
WildZoo
Supernatural: Angels & Demons WW Game Thread
121 122 123 124 125
Replies
6K
Views
81K
GoSpursGo
GoSpursGo
supershorty
GGoats ThWWee: Here It GGoats Again - GAME THREAD
93 94 95 96 97
Replies
5K
Views
69K
vampyrica
vampyrica
Animal Midwife
Matrix - Game Thread
77 78 79 80 81
Replies
4K
Views
95K
samac
samac
Top