MarWWel -- GAME THREAD

[SARdoghandler]

Advertisement - Members don't see this ad

Why in the world would he come in the game and mention his own role on par with thanos

Wow I would never just blatantly mention my role on thread

Or make it my profile picture or anything, obvs

 

[samac]

Wow I would never just blatantly mention my role on thread

Or make it my profile picture or anything, obvs

Blatantly mention your role on thread grouped with villains?

 

[cubsrule4e]

I have never in my entire WW career cared about whether a 3p won as long as village beat the wolves. I just don't care. Same when I'm wolfing, if a 3p wants to tag along for the ride, so be it. I only care a little bit more about exclusives.

Then what’s the point of even looking for 3Ps? Cause that certainly happens.

I’m running out of steam! Mods have mercy! I’m a good cook though!

 

[Zenge142]

Don’t 🤔 me Dana! I bet your pockets are VERY cozy!

 

[WildZoo]

Of everyone on the list it makes the most sense to me follows by Genny. Or I guess bread then Genny. Then I get paranoid and it’s Dana.

No trust in my read there, huh? Well okay then

 

[Zenge142]

No trust in my read there, huh? Well okay then

After Cubs and Bob, who would you see before KDS?

 

[WildZoo]

Then what’s the point of even looking for 3Ps? Cause that certainly happens.

I’m running out of steam! Mods have mercy! I’m a good cook though!

I'm not a 3p hunter. I can barely hunt wolves as it is.

 

[WildZoo]

After Cubs and Bob, who would you see before KDS?

genny or Dana currently

 

[WildZoo]

But you know there's still a part of me that thinks cubs is a wolf

 

[Dana_May_B]

genny or Dana currently

you're teetering on the edge of losing your dana reading card haha

 

[WildZoo]

you're teetering on the edge of losing your dana reading card haha

I was not aware I ever had one

 

[Dana_May_B]

I was not aware I ever had one

well then things are not off to a good start!!! 🤣

 

[WildZoo]

I think I'd have a little bit of a hard time supporting a genny vote today. It's not impossible this is w/w. But my first impression is that it's not, and I don't think sporty asking me about the genny way later felt like she was asking me about a packmate either. I think genny is one I would circle back around to if things get dicey, maybe.

Oh I just switched tabs and apparently I said this yesterday lol

 

[WildZoo]

well then things are not off to a good start!!! 🤣

That's fine, there's only space for two reading cards in my wallet at a time.

 

[Truenamer]

Time for a patented Truenamer Catch-up Poststravaganza!!!!!

Spoiler: BIG Spoiler to prevent shorty Angaries

I'm not a lie detector. I have no special abilities. I strongly think Bob is wolfing or at least not village-friendly, so I laid a trap and waited to see if someone would take the bait.
Feels a bit like an dingus move but it worked with stoat/Dana in the noob game.

It was so hard not saying anything and giving away the game, you really knocked it out of the park with this one. Stoaty has been singing your praises all day while we drove around getting groceries and trying to get a new phone (guess who dropped hers seven stories?)

We’ve not had a misyeet yet, we’re in very good shape and he’s going to provide a distraction going forward.

True, but he's kinda harmless, right?

I don't consider 3p of that type a distraction but ymmv

I agree, now that we know his game he can just be along for the ride.

I’m not an anti 3P person, but I just think it’s too convenient and don’t believe him with the numbers.

OH, we're saying maybe he's faking it? I don't think Loki matches the mod's description of the villains; he's not a "race that hates humans," that would make much more sense as the Chitauri or the Frost Giants as a whole (maybe the Deviants?)

If Bob is telling the truth I'd agree with the that there's probably only one more wolf

I also don't really care to yeet 3p at this point and the role and abilities fit in my opinion so

Unyeet Bob

I think I side with Dubz on this. Let's hunt woofs.

But… if you think there’s only one more wolf, when are you going to yeet Bob? That’s basically just letting him win with village, no?

I’m so talented that I’ve been able to extol all of my great qualities for almost 36 hours!

So? More the merrier, also who says we're going to misyeet tonight?

For one, the numbers in the game. For two, the write ups pointing toward 4 anti village folks left.
For three, his 3P wincon as Loki may not be accurate.
I think this is still the right thing to do.

I don't think, if he's not lying, that he counts as anti-village. Maybe. I just don't think Loki matches the bad guys in the write-ups, and Bob's play makes a lot of sense when viewed through a neutral 3P lens.

Why should I care if he wins with village?

Exactly.

I also think Bob revealed because he thought he was caught when PSV said she caught a wolf.
The only way he would know that is if he thought cubs would flip village cause Bob is gonna flip wolf.

This is fair, but he may have also thought that his role is neutral enough that it would be better to get out in front of an accusation instead of taking it on the chin.

Wow I would never just blatantly mention my role on thread

Or make it my profile picture or anything, obvs

So you're saying you're... a certain Captain?

After Cubs and Bob, who would you see before KDS?

I could see Bread or Genny, but I'd personally pick KDS simply because her pushes seemed to be very closely aligned with Sporty's. Could have been pocketed, but...

 

[WildZoo]

i will feel so vindicated if its cubs hahaha

Hmm maybe this post felt pure though

 

[Truenamer]

tl;dr: I think Bob is telling the truth and don't see the harm in letting him live. I don't think Loki matches the bad-guy descriptions in the write-ups. I won't be upset if he's yeeten, but I'd rather continue looking for wolves, and I still feel worst about Cubs.

 

[WildZoo]

If samac, Zenge, and I all considered the possibility that PSV was lying about the lie detection, then who is to say the woof(s) didn't also?

 

[samac]

Time for a patented Truenamer Catch-up Poststravaganza!!!!!

Spoiler: BIG Spoiler to prevent shorty Angaries

It was so hard not saying anything and giving away the game, you really knocked it out of the park with this one. Stoaty has been singing your praises all day while we drove around getting groceries and trying to get a new phone (guess who dropped hers seven stories?)


True, but he's kinda harmless, right?


I agree, now that we know his game he can just be along for the ride.


OH, we're saying maybe he's faking it? I don't think Loki matches the mod's description of the villains; he's not a "race that hates humans," that would make much more sense as the Chitauri or the Frost Giants as a whole (maybe the Deviants?)


I think I side with Dubz on this. Let's hunt woofs.


So? More the merrier, also who says we're going to misyeet tonight?


I don't think, if he's not lying, that he counts as anti-village. Maybe. I just don't think Loki matches the bad guys in the write-ups, and Bob's play makes a lot of sense when viewed through a neutral 3P lens.


Exactly.


This is fair, but he may have also thought that his role is neutral enough that it would be better to get out in front of an accusation instead of taking it on the chin.


So you're saying you're... a certain Captain?


I could see Bread or Genny, but I'd personally pick KDS simply because her pushes seemed to be very closely aligned with Sporty's. Could have been pocketed, but...

I don’t think he was getting out ahead of it though.
For all he knew it was cubs who got lie detected because she said she found a wolf. Not anti village.

Just believing the claim feels crazy to me.

 

[Zenge142]

you're teetering on the edge of losing your dana reading card haha

That AtE is brutal.

Spoiler: Dana to Dubz

 

[samac]

If samac, Zenge, and I all considered the possibility that PSV was lying about the lie detection, then who is to say the woof(s) didn't also?

Why would Bob do that though? Seemed he believed it.

 

[cubsrule4e]

Of everyone on the list it makes the most sense to me follows by Genny. Or I guess bread then Genny. Then I get paranoid and it’s Dana.

When it ends up being genny, I want some cred even if I’m dead!

Also, how does one know that a 3P is telling the truth about inclusive win cons (not referring to Bob here, just a part of the general discussion we were having)? I was chaos in underWWear, and I’m pretty sure people still yeeted me for that, but I dont remember the exact details cause that was a while ago.

I do have a great memory about other things though!

 

[WildZoo]

That AtE is brutal.

Spoiler: Dana to Dubz

I'm glad that gif made such an impression on you that you've now used it twice 🤣

 

[samac]

When it ends up being genny, I want some cred even if I’m dead!

Also, how does one know that a 3P is telling the truth about inclusive win cons (not referring to Bob here, just a part of the general discussion we were having)? I was chaos in underWWear, and I’m pretty sure people still yeeted me for that, but I dont remember the exact details cause that was a while ago.

I do have a great memory about other things though!

I just don’t think it’s genny.
I’m having a hard time reconciling someone other than Bob as the last wolf.

 

[WildZoo]

When it ends up being genny, I want some cred even if I’m dead!

Also, how does one know that a 3P is telling the truth about inclusive win cons (not referring to Bob here, just a part of the general discussion we were having)? I was chaos in underWWear, and I’m pretty sure people still yeeted me for that, but I dont remember the exact details cause that was a while ago.

I do have a great memory about other things though!

Exclusive wincons are rare outside of serial killers and cults. Most of the time if village just wolfhunts they're fine. If you get in a bind you can surely yeet an outted 3p in MarVolo most of the time, but it doesn't have to come to that. I mean, even in French QWWarter I didn't have to win alone if village hadn't choked so hard.

 

[WildZoo]

That AtE is brutal.

Speaking of which, it seems I need to harden my outer shell so that people stop directing their AtE at my squishy insides, it has been entirely too much this game

 

[WildZoo]

Why would Bob do that though? Seemed he believed it.

Consider all commentary from me as coming from a "I believe in Bob's 3p claim" perspective.

 

[kaydubs]

Can Do This All Day 3 Vote Tally (#4041)

cubs (5) - True, genny, SAR, violetvett, Bob
Bob (6) - samac, cubs, Dana, Bread, PSV, kdswg
genny ()
kdswg (1) - Zenge

12/14

Winning: @BobLoblaw78
Missing: @Barkley13 @WildZoo

Vote/Yeet closes at 10pm ET/9pm CT/7pm Fantasyland on Saturday, 2/19/22 (~2 hours)

 

[Barkley13]

Well I did a bread ISO. For his game related posts, he felt about about TME day 1, had a changing dubz read, and was being pushed by sporty. Both of his reads on the two confirmed wolves were hedgey but I think Dana's collection of quotes showed that he was being pushed by sporty a good amount. So not outside the realm of possibility that he's a wolf but I'm not really feeling it

Spoiler: Quotes

I am not sure where to vote yet so it is just a shot in the dark. I am going to change as I catch up but I just wanted something on board.

Almost caught up and do not like my RNG vote


###unvote Dubz###


Not feeling super good about TME but still have a couple pages to catch up on

I think I am going to put my vote down on TME

###Yeet TME###


Was really not liking this post

wolves know who the villagers are so if you happen to order them in a similar way to someone else does not clear you.

Also not quite seeing anything to strike against Borky so far besides trying to survive until Friday for Gal's birthday (which I am definitely a sucker for this appeal)

Also still catching up...

Really? Does (Mel) not seem scummy when he is scum? He seems less shady from what I have read so far this game

How did you know that I was going to ask? I just RNG my vote earlier. I was kinda leaning more village after catching up a little bit. And I do not recall you asking even though I have been trying to keep an eye (my good one) on my notifications

oh... I am not sure. I was just not feeling wolfy I guess?

I was just saying not very wolfy. Why did you change votes?

But my feels from catching up yesterday:

Samac: Villager but more aggressive than I am used to (I think)?
AM: Village since she is pushing people to try and get more reads and beginning to establish a block as I have seen her do as a villager (not sure I have seen wolf AM before though)
Borky: Villager since the roll reveal and the push to defend herself up to yeet close
Dubz: More neutral up until this point
Mother Sporty: Still cannot read so I can go either way
Cubz: Was giving me a bit more of a village feel when he joined the thread
Fluff: More neutral and really not sure how I feel about her. Her wording on things are a bit shaky but she is also still a noob
True: Despite posting a lot I would still put them in my neutral pile. I want to go over what they have said so far but he seems to be in the running for highest content posters.

Everyone else I am completely unsure of

I would not say that I had a light village lean, just more of a non-wolf lean up to that point. That is why Sporty was kinda bugging me when she was pushing why I had cleared you when I did not entirely clear you

I am going to have some stuff going on later in the evening and gotta step away for a bit, but for now I am going to


###Vote Bob###

I have never been good at getting a read on bob and I need to do a catch up on his posts (and a ton more). Not feeling wolf!cubz and what I have read. It could be said that his early defense of Fluff was questionable but I was seeing it more as him sticking up for a noob. Especially since Samac was going hard on the paint

 

[WildZoo]

yeet cubs

A tie!

 

[samac]

Well I did a bread ISO. For his game related posts, he felt about about TME day 1, had a changing dubz read, and was being pushed by sporty. Both of his reads on the two confirmed wolves were hedgey but I think Dana's collection of quotes showed that he was being pushed by sporty a good amount. So not outside the realm of possibility that he's a wolf but I'm not really feeling it

I also don’t see wolf!bread being this absent tbh

 

[WildZoo]

Well I did a bread ISO. For his game related posts, he felt about about TME day 1, had a changing dubz read, and was being pushed by sporty. Both of his reads on the two confirmed wolves were hedgey but I think Dana's collection of quotes showed that he was being pushed by sporty a good amount. So not outside the realm of possibility that he's a wolf but I'm not really feeling it

I really don't think sporty pushes a busy bread like that if he was a packmate. So I agree with your take.

 

[WildZoo]

I also don’t see wolf!bread being this absent tbh

I feel like he's done it before...

 

[WildZoo]

But regardless of his activity I think his interactions with sporty are enough to put him on the backburner

 

[Barkley13]

I don't really know what to do now
I can see bob's claim being true and I'm still holding on to my cubs village read
I feel good about samac, dubz, and shelty and okayish about zenge, true, SAR, bread
Also feel that genny sounds different than last game in a good way
Which leaves violet, dana, kdswg OR I'm totally wrong and moving people village for wrong reasons

 

[WildZoo]

Oh I just switched tabs and apparently I said this yesterday lol

Oh but after I said that I talked about how it could be distancing. Why don't I keep notes?!?

 

[WildZoo]

But it's probably not genny

 

[SARdoghandler]

That's fine, there's only space for two reading cards in my wallet at a time.

Does a soul read count as a card? 🤔

So you're saying you're... a certain Captain?

Lol no this was direct reference to the England game where I was THE BLOODY QUEEB and promptly changed my avatar to a gif of HRH then died like N1 because the wolves got extra kills if they identified the target as a female monarch.

I wouldn't do that to myself twice... Or would I? 🤔 🤔 🤔

 

[WildZoo]

Does a soul read count as a card? 🤔

No, a soul read is transcendent and lives within. No need to fit it in my wallet 😉

 

[Barkley13]

So on violet's ISO there were a couple interesting things:

1. Her first vote on D1 was for sporty for her "stereotypical wolf intro post". And then she continued to push sporty throughout the day saying that she hadn't really posted anything of substance.

Spoiler: Sporty quotes

Yeet sporty.

For now. It's a stereotypical wolf intro post, so yeah. I'll probably change it later when my brain isn't as broken.

A stereotypical wolf intro post?

Yeah, just commenting on how many pages there are. It's an easy post.

Okay, I'm not really sure what to think of Sporty since they haven't really posted anything of substance yet.


(Lol, I wrote that first line before you posted this)

She asked about the Barks vote and put her one cent in, but that's it. I don't know if that's a wolfy quietness or a I'm-busy-and-can't-analyze-right-now quietness? Maybe someone more experienced with sporty's nature can help me out there.

TME does have some of that classic "wolf trying to help out noobs to avoid suspicion" at the beginning of the thread, which they were doing while wolfing in the noob game, but I feel like it's not nearly as much right now. TME in general has been doing a good amount of wolfhunting with valid reasoning that I could get behind. They also did defend me though, so maybe that's some unconscious bias I have

Keeping my sporty vote for now though actually. I expected her to post something to change my mind by now, but it hasn't come up yet.

oh no, my first angry 🙁 sorry sporty, but apparently yesterday's brainless!violet was kind of right.

2. There was this thing with fluff where she thought fluff deleted a post. I have some paranoia but I also think this wouldn't make sense to keep talking about it if they were both wolves?

Spoiler: Fluff quotes

I missed it, why are you voting barks (besides the cubs thing)?

...am I going crazy or did you delete a post @justafluff
About your reasons for voting bark

Does anyone else remember this? I swear fluff posted something after I said something, but there wasn't anything there when I went back.

Idk if that was the exact message or not, but I remember seeing fluff post something after I asked her for her reasons for voting barks and wondering if she was going to directly reply to me or not.

Ok, ty! Maybe I'm thinking of some previous exchange I saw before in the thread and got confused.
Not sure I like your reasons for voting barks, though, it's kind of shaky reasoning imo.

Ohhhh, I know how I got confused now. Sorry @justafluff , my brain got you and True mixed up., I was curious about why he was going with the Mel vote without any reasoning and then he posted reasons in a response to someone else. I was wondering if he would directly respond to me or not, and I was also waiting on a response from you at the same time. Sorry!

Otherwise she didn't agree with mine or TME's wagons on D1, was pushing true a bit

TLDR I still don't know who to vote for today

 

[Truenamer]

So on violet's ISO there were a couple interesting things:

1. Her first vote on D1 was for sporty for her "stereotypical wolf intro post". And then she continued to push sporty throughout the day saying that she hadn't really posted anything of substance.

2. There was this thing with fluff where she thought fluff deleted a post. I have some paranoia but I also think this wouldn't make sense to keep talking about it if they were both wolves?

Otherwise she didn't agree with mine or TME's wagons on D1, was pushing true a bit

TLDR I still don't know who to vote for today

Violet has not felt Wolfy to me at all.

 

[Dana_May_B]

Violet has not felt Wolfy to me at all.

which is also why im still unhappy with the reads cubs has provided.

 

[Zenge142]

Unyeet KDS

Yeet Cubs

I have all the information I was going to get from that ploy.

 

[WildZoo]

Unyeet KDS

Yeet Cubs

I have all the information I was going to get from that ploy.

Why must there be chess at every corner 🥲

 

[samac]

Unyeet KDS

Yeet Cubs

I have all the information I was going to get from that ploy.

Do tell

 

[Barkley13]

Well all I've done is narrow down the people I would vote for. And since I need to eat dinner and haven't voted I'm going to reluctantly

yeet bob

 

[samac]

Why must there be chess at every corner 🥲

Fun

 

[WildZoo]

Oh great, it's a tie even if you look closely

 

[WildZoo]

Fun

The game is hard enough for us simple folk

 

[Dana_May_B]

i know i said i would stay on bob but god its gonna be so hard not to break that tie in favor of yeeting cubs