This was their 3rd post and first two were basically nothing. Seems like a way to give themselves village cred by contributing little to nothing. Kind of a way to low-key get into mild village leans while laying low. Comes off as more of a sneaky entrance than town imo.
This was their 3rd post and first two were basically nothing. Seems like a way to give themselves village cred by contributing little to nothing. Kind of a way to low-key get into mild village leans while laying low. Comes off as more of a sneaky entrance than town imo.
For context genny is a player that is 'just genny' for their style of play and very hard to read. Last game they were scum and won.
I think their post still are on a 'genny' level of input/on their own game kind of vibe, but first impression feels very different from the genny that was more of an observer and didnt put much independent thought into the thread. Genny coming and giving 3 trs and moving along felt good to me
Just out of curiosity, how long have you been playing mafia?
I've been at it for 6 years, and I've seen some things. (For example, I played a Wizard of Oz game where the mods made Glinda a serial killer, and I still haven't forgiven them TBH.)
Just out of curiosity, how long have you been playing mafia?
I've been at it for 6 years, and I've seen some things. (For example, I played a Wizard of Oz game where the mods made Glinda a serial killer, and I still haven't forgiven them TBH.)
Since no edit, meant to say largely feels off right now. Mostly just handing out town reads and defending that he's played with Achro then deops a vote that seemed very out of nowhere and odd. Not sure I really understand the brief explanation either. Largely just feels off. Certainly not set here, but biggest concern at the moment.
If you see me handing out townreads, do you expect from me to have a vote that is from an expected place?
And how much do you remember about my D1 Stagg pls? Its super common for me to just give away easy townreads like almlst always? I have some times in where I just start biting aswell but not always the case?
And tbh I want you to be honest with yourself and look at how you've read me in past games with the 'off' vibe and how many times you were right about it .
I mean just last game you misread me (even after you were ded and sussing me from the graveyard) , and my start was cowclearing Zenge shshdhshsh
Excuse me, Glinda the Good gave Dorothy the shoes to keep them from the Wicked Witch of the West, as she should. Also, Dorothy didn't kill the Wicked Witch of the East, the tornado did. (Now, did Dorothy kill the WW of the West? Yes. Frankly, I think I'd accept Dorothy as an SK before Glinda.)
Like Im not going to question Gikkle because I can understand that sometimes tonally Im a mess and just spew things without consolidating much on where I want to go.
But from you I have a higher standard and expect at least more wavering or counciousness about it? I feel a bit like you are following what Gikkle said about feeling off + moon questioning my vote and trying to maybe capitalize that to put sus
If you see me handing out townreads, do you expect from me to have a vote that is from an expected place?
And how much do you remember about my D1 Stagg pls? Its super common for me to just give away easy townreads like almlst always? I have some times in where I just start biting aswell but not always the case?
And tbh I want you to be honest with yourself and look at how you've read me in past games with the 'off' vibe and how many times you were right about it .
I mean just last game you misread me (even after you were ded and sussing me from the graveyard) , and my start was cowclearing Zenge shshdhshsh
Like, I dont remember a single time that you outside of after mech were revealed townread me for you to have a grasp of when Im feeling off rather than you recognizing that usually you dont know how to read me or something along the lines
If you see me handing out townreads, do you expect from me to have a vote that is from an expected place?
And how much do you remember about my D1 Stagg pls? Its super common for me to just give away easy townreads like almlst always? I have some times in where I just start biting aswell but not always the case?
And tbh I want you to be honest with yourself and look at how you've read me in past games with the 'off' vibe and how many times you were right about it .
I mean just last game you misread me (even after you were ded and sussing me from the graveyard) , and my start was cowclearing Zenge shshdhshsh
There's a difference between me feeling you were sketchy in past games (which you ended up being town) and you feeling off/different this game. It's just a D1 early feeling and I'm far from committed, but I expect to see more actual solving or at least attempts at solving before D1 ends. And yes, you give out some town reads, but like I said I feel like that and the interactions with Achro are the only things you've done so far.
There's a difference between me feeling you were sketchy in past games (which you ended up being town) and you feeling off/different this game. It's just a D1 early feeling and I'm far from committed, but I expect to see more actual solving or at least attempts at solving before D1 ends. And yes, you give out some town reads, but like I said I feel like that and the interactions with Achro are the only things you've done so far.
Eh, not going to tell you how to get a town read from me, I do usually come around to you just being a somewhat sketchy villager even if it doesn't always outwardly feel that way.
Like I feel its super early on D1 to paint an 'not enough solving' or 'just that' statement when I think compared to other slots im doing more and townreads *involve* solving so its just nonsense.
And still I dont know what are you seeing as 'different' or what is your image of me to say that.
Yikes I think one of the two last games we played I was shrug yeeting genny most of D1 because it felt like the yeet I had less trouble doing so . Which is super similar to why I am voting shinichi rn wowee
I always try and kill Dubz. It's not WW on SDN if I don't. Zenge was mostly a joke in regards to the cow, thought you'd get that. He feels decent right now tough. Moon is on my radar. So far I think D1 has a few things to look back at already.
I always try and kill Dubz. It's not WW on SDN if I don't. Zenge was mostly a joke in regards to the cow, thought you'd get that. He feels decent right now tough. Moon is on my radar. So far I think D1 has a few things to look back at already.
Yikes I think one of the two last games we played I was shrug yeeting genny most of D1 because it felt like the yeet I had less trouble doing so . Which is super similar to why I am voting shinichi rn wowee
Moon is more, which I find interesting since I don't know them. Seems like they were reading into a lot very early. Not sure where I stand with that but it's notable. Dubz feels like typical D1 Dubz. I admit I suck at reading her and don't usually get a feel for a while with her. I don't have a ton to go off of Zenge, but feels like typical Zenge. In his wolf game I felt he was off pretty quickly and I'm not getting that right now.
Other example, genny seems pretty aggressive early. Not sure how I feel about that but I think it's more of a positive than a negative there.
It was melee . I voted genny in RVS and maintauned it quite a bit because I only had townreads and was looking at the people I would be less bothered if they got yeeted atm
Moon is more, which I find interesting since I don't know them. Seems like they were reading into a lot very early. Not sure where I stand with that but it's notable. Dubz feels like typical D1 Dubz. I admit I suck at reading her and don't usually get a feel for a while with her. I don't have a ton to go off of Zenge, but feels like typical Zenge. In his wolf game I felt he was off pretty quickly and I'm not getting that right now.
Other example, genny seems pretty aggressive early. Not sure how I feel about that but I think it's more of a positive than a negative there.
You answered the more or less only about moon and then switched to talking once again how you feel about them .
My point was making you realize that painting what I've doing as 'just that' feels super crazy / non-real since I think I've doing the same or more to most of the slots playing rn
I don't have the meta that santy has, so from my perspective these posts are nothing special. If another person familiar with genny's meta aside from Santy can confirm that genny has a meta of not really providing independent thoughts as a wolf (and that these posts in this game are outside of that wolf meta), then I'd be willing to trust in a >rand town genny (for now)
That being said, @genny could I get some explanations for these reads?
Gikkle feels null so far, not much there. This felt off though:
This was their 3rd post and first two were basically nothing. Seems like a way to give themselves village cred by contributing little to nothing. Kind of a way to low-key get into mild village leans while laying low. Comes off as more of a sneaky entrance than town imo.
The way Shinichi phrases that top post rings some bells for me (the "if anything the slot should currently just be null" part), but it's nothing strong. More like a "I feel like wolves are more inclined to say something like that bc it makes them look like they have are contributing to the discussion in some way"
Don't really get any kind of vibe from this, but it does sort of unpair Achromatic & Santy in my mind. Just feels like a weird way to talk about a partner right off the bat.
Yeah I think your name was on the back on my mind from maybe seeing you as a spec or something. I didnt play any of these games here but we could've played on MU for sure a mash or my brain has skill issue.
Needing to check if you did a snapread from an unknown or at least you had some sort of vibe from me
Also in regards to Achro townreading me I think it can come mostly from Achro kinda knowing I tend to be OMGussy , and last time we were both town together we vibed real good.
So good idea to pocket me either as town or mafia , and I'll let it happen for now. Scum must be murdered.
I think we played some games together (some on MU / mashes and that kind of stuff) , but those are a few. I think the most notable to me at least is Misplay Mafia on the syndicate .
We were both town and I was kinda salty at the majority of the town for a while, and with Achro they kinda madr an effort to see me in the eyes and our souls aligned and GOATed and yeeted scum!Mac which felt great :hmmyes:
(In the end town lost that game was just rough wowee)
For context genny is a player that is 'just genny' for their style of play and very hard to read. Last game they were scum and won.
I think their post still are on a 'genny' level of input/on their own game kind of vibe, but first impression feels very different from the genny that was more of an observer and didnt put much independent thought into the thread. Genny coming and giving 3 trs and moving along felt good to me
Um, I wanna say we did? Maybe last year's Champs practice here, or another game? I can't remember off hand.
(I've played Kirby Mafia, NeWW Girl, and dwungeons and dwagons here, if those ring any bells. Suppose it's also possible we've played on MU; pretty sure I've specced you there, at least?)
IDK about Achro, but mine isn't. I just felt like it was an overly explained excuse to immediately leave the thread. His next couple posts trend a little better, though (didn't actually leave thread, mildly pushed back on a townread of him), so I'd agree null is accurate at the moment.
It's good practice for champs, which may really kill some of us, LOL.
FWIW, I'm aiming for 2 posts an hour over 20 hours, partly to guarantee postmin, and party to try for a better mafia/life balance. (Achro and I were in a mash in March where I 100-posted multiple times over 12 hours, but, uh, that wasn't exactly the most healthy experience for me...)
See, the problem is I hyper focus too well and don't do the forgetting bit, whoops. So, I'm trying a new approach, and if it works maybe I won't retire after champs.
I was hardly exaggerating; it was a lean scum on 2 posts, I'm not out here death tunneling or anything.
Comparing Santy's entrance to Zenges' (and Dubz' after), it just seemed a bit worse. Neither of them felt the need to immediately explain their (in)activity; Santy doing that at all felt overexplained, regardless of length. But I acknowledged while making the initial read that it could be NAI, so I didn't really walk anywhere to walk back from.
Cooould be getting pocketed here? But I actually did like the very last post here. Doubling down on the TR after saying I distrust people who TR me is a fairly good look imo.
potentialsheltervet - no posts
holdthemayo - no posts
There's a difference between me feeling you were sketchy in past games (which you ended up being town) and you feeling off/different this game. It's just a D1 early feeling and I'm far from committed, but I expect to see more actual solving or at least attempts at solving before D1 ends. And yes, you give out some town reads, but like I said I feel like that and the interactions with Achro are the only things you've done so far.
Eh, not going to tell you how to get a town read from me, I do usually come around to you just being a somewhat sketchy villager even if it doesn't always outwardly feel that way.
I always try and kill Dubz. It's not WW on SDN if I don't. Zenge was mostly a joke in regards to the cow, thought you'd get that. He feels decent right now tough. Moon is on my radar. So far I think D1 has a few things to look back at already.
Moon is more, which I find interesting since I don't know them. Seems like they were reading into a lot very early. Not sure where I stand with that but it's notable. Dubz feels like typical D1 Dubz. I admit I suck at reading her and don't usually get a feel for a while with her. I don't have a ton to go off of Zenge, but feels like typical Zenge. In his wolf game I felt he was off pretty quickly and I'm not getting that right now.
Other example, genny seems pretty aggressive early. Not sure how I feel about that but I think it's more of a positive than a negative there.
Excuse me, Glinda the Good gave Dorothy the shoes to keep them from the Wicked Witch of the West, as she should. Also, Dorothy didn't kill the Wicked Witch of the East, the tornado did. (Now, did Dorothy kill the WW of the West? Yes. Frankly, I think I'd accept Dorothy as an SK before Glinda.)
Look calling myself Clem the Kind wouldn't excuse kicking people in the shins every time they say gif wrong, self styled good witches encouraging the looting and plundering of dead bodies is no system of footwear distribution!