- Joined
- Jul 24, 2003
- Messages
- 50
- Reaction score
- 0
Public Health:
I understand where you're coming from, but having a special program separate from medical school distances the mental health profession from other fields of medicine. Part of the goal of medical school and residency is to acquire a shared body of knowledge and experience with other medical specialists. The point of this is to know how to recognize pathology outside of your field of expertise and when to refer.
I know that the program that you are proposing may cover some of these concerns. However, as I've been stating, why replicate a parts of a curriculum that already exists within medical school and residency? I realize that medical school and psychiatry residencies are deficient in areas where clinical psychology are strong, namely psychotherapy and psychometric testing. But why not improve these compenents within psychiatric residencies rather than embarking on a radical campaign to create a new degree? Or, why don't we just allow clinical psychologists to continue doing what they do, but with more collaboration with psychiatrists?
You seem to like my idea of expanding medical school seats in rural areas as a means to expand mental health care coverage. I'm glad that there are rural DO branches, but what i think we also need to do is to recruit existing medical students into psychiatry and to provide financial incentives for physicians in general to practice in rural areas (e.g., loan forgiveness, better compensation, etc.).
I understand where you're coming from, but having a special program separate from medical school distances the mental health profession from other fields of medicine. Part of the goal of medical school and residency is to acquire a shared body of knowledge and experience with other medical specialists. The point of this is to know how to recognize pathology outside of your field of expertise and when to refer.
I know that the program that you are proposing may cover some of these concerns. However, as I've been stating, why replicate a parts of a curriculum that already exists within medical school and residency? I realize that medical school and psychiatry residencies are deficient in areas where clinical psychology are strong, namely psychotherapy and psychometric testing. But why not improve these compenents within psychiatric residencies rather than embarking on a radical campaign to create a new degree? Or, why don't we just allow clinical psychologists to continue doing what they do, but with more collaboration with psychiatrists?
You seem to like my idea of expanding medical school seats in rural areas as a means to expand mental health care coverage. I'm glad that there are rural DO branches, but what i think we also need to do is to recruit existing medical students into psychiatry and to provide financial incentives for physicians in general to practice in rural areas (e.g., loan forgiveness, better compensation, etc.).