Saw the ASA email recently about their plan to fight the 28% medicare to commercial reimbursement for anesthesiologists. I've heard this mentioned a few times on this forum, about the unfair reimbursements. Trying to learn more about this since i know nothing about billing. Doesnt this happen to a lot of specialties? Private insurance often pays >2x medicare dont they? do we get paid the lowest by medicare compared to commercial? And why did this happen to us?
-
CycleTrack and SDN are teaming up to make medical school admissions more transparent and accessible! Read the announcement to learn how we’re supporting the future of CycleTrack’s free application-tracking tools .
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Medicare rates
Started by anbuitachi
Get help with your application
Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.
D
deleted941485
Saw the ASA email recently about their plan to fight the 28% medicare to commercial reimbursement for anesthesiologists. I've heard this mentioned a few times on this forum, about the unfair reimbursements. Trying to learn more about this since i know nothing about billing. Doesnt this happen to a lot of specialties? Private insurance often pays >2x medicare dont they? do we get paid the lowest by medicare compared to commercial? And why did this happen to us?
I wouldn’t worry too much between the balence billing legislation and inevitable single payor that will follow. You will be lucky to get Medicare rates in the future. Everyone will be equal.
Private insurance companies are using balance billing legislation to race to the bottom and have parity with Medicare rates. In our market private insurance rates range from $76 —$95 per unit and Medicare is $25 /unit. Medicaid is $15 per unit. Our revenue is -30% from private insurance by claim (>60% of total revenue). So, basically if the insurance companies have their way then my W2 will drop by about 45-60%.
Correct on all counts. Medicare rates is a possible death sentence for physician anesthesiologists likely to be replaced by nurse anesthesiologists.
Other specialties typically get paid 75-80 percent of commercial rates by Medicare.
They get a haircut while you get a scalping.
Medicare for all means lack of physician Anesthesiologist for many as early retirements occur and new graduates shun the field. Residency programs will rely on IMGs to fill the void.
The silver lining will be a great deal of job openings over a short period of time
Other specialties typically get paid 75-80 percent of commercial rates by Medicare.
They get a haircut while you get a scalping.
Medicare for all means lack of physician Anesthesiologist for many as early retirements occur and new graduates shun the field. Residency programs will rely on IMGs to fill the void.
The silver lining will be a great deal of job openings over a short period of time
Correct on all counts. Medicare rates is a possible death sentence for physician anesthesiologists likely to be replaced by nurse anesthesiologists.
Other specialties typically get paid 75-80 percent of commercial rates by Medicare.
They get a haircut while you get a scalping.
Medicare for all means lack of physician Anesthesiologist for many as early retirements occur and new graduates shun the field. Residency programs will rely on IMGs to fill the void.
The silver lining will be a great deal of job openings over a short period of time
why hasn't the ASA targetted this garbage payment sooner? or have they and failed? it seems ridiculous we get reimbursed so little vs other fields. they sounds like a major issue that needs to be fixed..
why hasn't the ASA targetted this garbage payment sooner? or have they and failed? it seems ridiculous we get reimbursed so little vs other fields. they sounds like a major issue that needs to be fixed..
The ASA has allowed this to go on for 30 plus years. That ship sailed decades ago.
A matrix model for valuing anesthesia service with the resource-based relative value system - PMC
The purpose of this study was to propose a new crosswalk using the resource-based relative value system (RBRVS) that preserves the time unit component of the anesthesia service and disaggregates anesthesia billing into component parts (preoperative ...
The ASA has allowed this to go on for 30 plus years. That ship sailed decades ago.
that sounds pretty messed up.
D
deleted941485
that sounds pretty messed up.
About to get a whole lot worse
The NYT wrote some bizarre article about how to get doctors to work for less. It was nauseating to read. Basically trying to pull some cheap behavioral psychology.
20% isn’t a haircut that’s a knife in the back
40% that’s disembowelment
Last edited by a moderator:
D
deleted643396
About to get a whole lot worse
The NYT wrote some bizarre article about how to get doctors to work for less. It was nauseating to read. Basically trying to pull some cheap behavioral psychology.
20% isn’t a haircut that’s a knife in the back
40% that’s disembowelment
The NY Times doesn’t have to write that article. Getting people to work more for less has been the subject of an enormous amount of corporate research for decades. Doctors are now just employees of those corporations.
It's a great learning opportunity for Anesthesiologists to learn to manage 6-8 rooms at the same time, and see at least 20 pts or cases per day.
It's a great learning opportunity for Anesthesiologists to learn to manage 6-8 rooms at the same time, and see at least 20 pts or cases per day.
You won't like that type of job for very long.
The only thing I can envision myself learning from that situation is that I hate it...It's a great learning opportunity for Anesthesiologists to learn to manage 6-8 rooms at the same time, and see at least 20 pts or cases per day.
The only thing I can envision myself learning from that situation is that I hate it...
3 rooms is enough for me to learn that i hate it.. unless healthy, straightforward cases, it's hard to provide good care. kind of just rushing a lot at that point
I have always said that the day my salary plummets to that of a family med doc will be the day I default on my loans and leave this country. I am sure I am not alone here in this view.
Can't default from student loans unless you have a fake death certificate.
D
deleted941485
You’d probably have to move to Mexico or something. Those loans follow you to the grave.
The day your salary plummets is a day you should be actively planning for now.
Non clinical work
Consulting
Real estate
Back to school
Admin
Maybe add to the list if you’ve got ideas.
If you have any nice toys or homes, I’d consider selling those.
The day your salary plummets is a day you should be actively planning for now.
Non clinical work
Consulting
Real estate
Back to school
Admin
Maybe add to the list if you’ve got ideas.
If you have any nice toys or homes, I’d consider selling those.
Last edited by a moderator:
D
deleted643396
A lot of “sky is falling” in this thread. IF Medicare for all ever becomes a reality and IF insurance companies just shrug and say “well we had a good run” and IF Medicare rates stay the same for anesthesia then the hospitals will have to find a way to supplement anesthesia income. Even cheap, solo CRNAs won’t be dumb enough to take call on nights, weekends, and holidays for $100k a year. If the hospitals want the ORs to run, they will have to pay for it...someone will have to pay for it. There’s a lot of “IFs” there, though.
Otherwise pay off debts and stop buying boats.
Otherwise pay off debts and stop buying boats.
why hasn't the ASA targetted this garbage payment sooner? or have they and failed? it seems ridiculous we get reimbursed so little vs other fields. they sounds like a major issue that needs to be fixed..
I’m still a relatively new attending, but personally, I don’t see much that the ASA has done to benefit the field. Everything is reactive in nature.
Lol leave this country? Unless you’re a Swiss citizen, idk where you’re gonna go to find a more lucrative job in a politically stable country.I have always said that the day my salary plummets to that of a family med doc will be the day I default on my loans and leave this country. I am sure I am not alone here in this view.
A lot of “sky is falling” in this thread. IF Medicare for all ever becomes a reality and IF insurance companies just shrug and say “well we had a good run” and IF Medicare rates stay the same for anesthesia then the hospitals will have to find a way to supplement anesthesia income. Even cheap, solo CRNAs won’t be dumb enough to take call on nights, weekends, and holidays for $100k a year. If the hospitals want the ORs to run, they will have to pay for it...someone will have to pay for it. There’s a lot of “IFs” there, though.
Otherwise pay off debts and stop buying boats.
I do NOT see Medicare for all anytime soon. Warren would be lucky just to get a public option limited to those 55 and older added to the exchange. The support for Medicare for all just isn’t there among many Democrats.
So, there is no immediate need to panic or make plans for Mexico. I do think Medicare for all is possible down the road in 10-15 years but highly unlikely with the next administration
Now you've done itLol leave this country? Unless you’re a Swiss citizen, idk where you’re gonna go to find a more lucrative job in a politically stable country.
Someone will be along shortly to talk about some great $$$ opportunities in the United Arab Emirates or perhaps North Korea
I do NOT see Medicare for all anytime soon. Warren would be lucky just to get a public option limited to those 55 and older added to the exchange. The support for Medicare for all just isn’t there among many Democrats.
So, there is no immediate need to panic or make plans for Mexico. I do think Medicare for all is possible down the road in 10-15 years but highly unlikely with the next administration
i dont even think our system will be fixable. either they ration care or they tank salaries. i dont see why people will become doctors if salary goes down anymore. Its simply not worth it at all. Then if they do that they will have to make medicine/residency less rigorous, then care suffers. i guess only solution is to replace MD w NP/PA.
Now you've done it
Someone will be along shortly to talk about some great $$$ opportunities in the United Arab Emirates or perhaps North Korea
Or as an O-5 in Kanazawa or Okinawa.
Military retention for physicians is going to get a huge boost if Medicare for all becomes a reality.
Lol leave this country? Unless you’re a Swiss citizen, idk where you’re gonna go to find a more lucrative job in a politically stable country.
I have heard of some pretty good jobs in NZ and Australia. Also, for all the talking points about Canada being a
terrible place I have spoken to two docs (one EM and one anesthesia/pain) and they do very well and it’s easy to game their system.
Those are far smaller countries that cant accommodate large influx. If it’s actually easy to transition there and prosper, you can bet that hordes of American physicians would. They would then saturate the market there or those countries would change the rules so foreigners can’t encroach on their market.I have heard of some pretty good jobs in NZ and Australia. Also, for all the talking points about Canada being a
terrible place I have spoken to two docs (one EM and one anesthesia/pain) and they do very well and it’s easy to game their system.
The reality is that the government here knows they have us cornered.
It's a great learning opportunity for Anesthesiologists to learn to manage 6-8 rooms at the same time, and see at least 20 pts or cases per day.
This is a ridiculous mindset. A response of someone who is ready and willing to be a meek sheep. The mindset of someone who lives to work as opposed to works to live.
Why stop at 6-8 rooms? 10-12 is even more. Why not see 30-40 patients? Why work 60+ hours when you can work 80+ or even 100+ hours? Who needs to see their families, friends, or pursue outside hobbies?
Those of us who supervise are essentially there to oversee inferior practitioners perform the job we love to do. We're there to pray that nothing goes awry or to put out fires as they arise. As it stands I can barely execute a slightly higher level plan on a more challenging patient while covering 3-4 rooms. 6-8 rooms and i'm there just to sign the chart and push the propofol + sux while hoping the CRNA doesn't extubate in stage 2 and calls me to save their ass.
Those are far smaller countries that cant accommodate large influx. If it’s actually easy to transition there and prosper, you can bet that hordes of American physicians would. They would then saturate the market there or those countries would change the rules so foreigners can’t encroach on their market.
The reality is that the government here knows they have us cornered.
strike strike strike!
That's actually not a bad idea.strike strike strike!
If the government decides to make me a government servant, then I'm joining the government physician union.
I want daily minimum of $3000 per 8 hour shift, no mandatory call, no production incentives, full pension after 15 years, no legal liability, 16 weeks vacation.
If we don't get our demands, we're shutting down all the operating rooms.
That's actually not a bad idea.
If the government decides to make me a government servant, then I'm joining the government physician union.
I want daily minimum of $3000 per 8 hour shift, no mandatory call, no production incentives, full pension after 15 years, no legal liability, 16 weeks vacation.
If we don't get our demands, we're shutting down all the operating rooms.
There will be plenty of CRNAs who will work for $1,500 per 12h shift, no pension, and 4 weeks of vacation.
The OR will remain open with or without anesthesiologists.
That's actually not a bad idea.
If the government decides to make me a government servant, then I'm joining the government physician union.
Physicians being able to unionize might actually be a (very faint) silver lining to everyone becoming an employee. But don't get too carried away with what you imagine that will actually mean.
I want daily minimum of $3000 per 8 hour shift, no mandatory call, no production incentives, full pension after 15 years, no legal liability, 16 weeks vacation.
If we don't get our demands, we're shutting down all the operating rooms.
This is a naive fantasy.
Do you remember what True Republican Hero President Reagan did when air traffic controllers tried to strike?
Also, remember that there wasn't an army of "midlevel" air traffic controllers waiting in the wings, desperate for a chance to fill those positions, to prove that they were just as good as real air traffic controllers.
The public was overwhelmingly supportive of Reagan when he absolutely crushed the striking air traffic controllers. Cancelled flights were just a vacation inconvenience to most Americans. You think the public won't get behind the government hammer when it's their healthcare in question?
Incidentally, Reagan didn't just stop at firing them, he also banned them for life for ever working for the federal government again. That was upheld in court, by the way, and wasn't reversed until the Clinton years. We've already seen states (e.g. Massachusetts) make attempts to tie physician licensing to acceptance of state medicaid, even if those payments are below the cost of providing the service.
Careful what you wish for.
$3000/day LOL
Seriously? “Game their system?” Is that something you flaunt and are proud of?I have heard of some pretty good jobs in NZ and Australia. Also, for all the talking points about Canada being a
terrible place I have spoken to two docs (one EM and one anesthesia/pain) and they do very well and it’s easy to game their system.
And there are plenty of family docs making 250k. That will make you leave the country?
I do NOT see Medicare for all anytime soon. Warren would be lucky just to get a public option limited to those 55 and older added to the exchange. The support for Medicare for all just isn’t there among many Democrats.
So, there is no immediate need to panic or make plans for Mexico. I do think Medicare for all is possible down the road in 10-15 years but highly unlikely with the next administration
though I agree with you, had Hilary won I bet we would be in the early stages of a single payer right now
Obamacare was a precursor the the ultimate plan of single payer
correct me if I’m wrong, but wasn’t it pretty much a foregone conclusion were getting single payer before trump won?
one thing I bank on is this is America, there will always be a private sector because people will pay for it. (Cash hospitals etc etc) However, those jobs will be hard to come by
TheSingularity
Full Member
Popping over from EM
Same **** happening over here
M4A probably not a political reality anytime soon, but the immediate danger, which was already mentioned, is the balance billing legislation which seeks to set out of network reimbursement to average in network reimbursement. Which, if you see what the insurance industry is trying to do by lowering in network reimbursement, you can see how this will go.
Everyone should be contacting their representatives in Congress about this.
With regards to "supervision," I quit a place where we were being forced to see 2 patients per house on our own and then supervise another 2 pph with the midlevels. We have been sheeped by the corporations. Run.
Sent from my Pixel 3 using SDN mobile
Same **** happening over here
M4A probably not a political reality anytime soon, but the immediate danger, which was already mentioned, is the balance billing legislation which seeks to set out of network reimbursement to average in network reimbursement. Which, if you see what the insurance industry is trying to do by lowering in network reimbursement, you can see how this will go.
Everyone should be contacting their representatives in Congress about this.
With regards to "supervision," I quit a place where we were being forced to see 2 patients per house on our own and then supervise another 2 pph with the midlevels. We have been sheeped by the corporations. Run.
Sent from my Pixel 3 using SDN mobile
Seriously? “Game their system?” Is that something you flaunt and are proud of?
And there are plenty of family docs making 250k. That will make you leave the country?
If my country has beaten it into the brains of its citizens that education and achievement are the ultimate goals, allows the rigging of the student loan industry while simultaneously cutting the salaries of its citizens not by market forces but by legislation pushed by industry; that’s not really a place I want to live and raise my family in. And not to brag but a 250K salary would be about 250k less than I currently make and I am definitely not living like I make that kinda money. A huge portion of my income goes to pay for my and my spouse’s student loans.
A little anecdote for you about student loans. When I finished training I sat down and created several spread sheets with our student loans and various scenarios to pay them off. I thought it strange that between my loans and my spouses our debt had changed hands about six times in four years. I also found it interesting that Navient kept telling my spouse to defer defer defer. I also found it interesting that when I logged on to the servicer’s website it was purposely confusing and removed several things you would obviously assume would be clearly present on a loan statement, such as the interest rate and months of repayment. I called one of my loan companies and found that I would be 71 when the loan was paid off at the terms they “automatically” enrolled me in. See, this is a game to milk people for the rest of their lives. Make it difficult to understand the loans, make it difficult to see your terms, make it difficult to repay in a timely fashion. Navient and several others are being sued for taking advantage of borrowers by forcing them into deferment. And you say I am gaming the system.
You yourself said it honey. Not me. Don’t put words on my keyboard.If my country has beaten it into the brains of its citizens that education and achievement are the ultimate goals, allows the rigging of the student loan industry while simultaneously cutting the salaries of its citizens not by market forces but by legislation pushed by industry; that’s not really a place I want to live and raise my family in. And not to brag but a 250K salary would be about 250k less than I currently make and I am definitely not living like I make that kinda money. A huge portion of my income goes to pay for my and my spouse’s student loans.
A little anecdote for you about student loans. When I finished training I sat down and created several spread sheets with our student loans and various scenarios to pay them off. I thought it strange that between my loans and my spouses our debt had changed hands about six times in four years. I also found it interesting that Navient kept telling my spouse to defer defer defer. I also found it interesting that when I logged on to the servicer’s website it was purposely confusing and removed several things you would obviously assume would be clearly present on a loan statement, such as the interest rate and months of repayment. I called one of my loan companies and found that I would be 71 when the loan was paid off at the terms they “automatically” enrolled me in. See, this is a game to milk people for the rest of their lives. Make it difficult to understand the loans, make it difficult to see your terms, make it difficult to repay in a timely fashion. Navient and several others are being sued for taking advantage of borrowers by forcing them into deferment. And you say I am gaming the system.
My loans are easy to understand and yes they have changed hands a few times but I have never had an issue deciphering what was owed and the interest rates. I don’t relate to anything you are saying here.
If Navient screwing people over, then I am glad someone is suing them.
If you want to game the system and want to move to Canada because you can’t possibly survive off 250k, then go for it. But I bet it’s not gonna be as easy as you think.
ASA and in particular the AMA!!!The ASA has allowed this to go on for 30 plus years. That ship sailed decades ago.
ASA and in particular the AMA!!!
why does teh ama care about us?
D
deleted87051
why does teh ama care about us?
Isn’t the AMA a life insurance company?
D
deleted87051
Surprise out of network medical bills were a gift to the insurance industry by greedy shortsighted medical care providers. The highly publicized stories were outrageous ($500k dialysis bill, $75k surgical assist fee, $75k neuromonitoring fee) and the insurance industry ran with it. Now we have a wave of surprise medical bill legislation which will disarm any leverage we had during in-network contract negotiations. Why would any insurance company negotiate in good faith knowing our OON charges are limited to 120% of Medicare.
Last edited by a moderator:
The real problem is the entire anesthesia payment structure. Why does private insurance pay $800-900 for 15 min colonoscopy and Medicare pays $150 if u are lucky.
vs gi docs getting $500-600 for private and $350 for Medicare.
are there any other specialists who get OVERPAID like we do for private Insurance (come on we all know the private insurance is ridiculous payments) and severely UNDERPAID (relative to private insurance payments) for medicare rates
most specialities get roughly 60%
anesthesia is less than 30% or even less if the amc $100-120/unit billing for private is accounted for.
vs gi docs getting $500-600 for private and $350 for Medicare.
are there any other specialists who get OVERPAID like we do for private Insurance (come on we all know the private insurance is ridiculous payments) and severely UNDERPAID (relative to private insurance payments) for medicare rates
most specialities get roughly 60%
anesthesia is less than 30% or even less if the amc $100-120/unit billing for private is accounted for.
D
deleted87051
The real problem is the entire anesthesia payment structure. Why does private insurance pay $800-900 for 15 min colonoscopy and Medicare pays $150 if u are lucky.
vs gi docs getting $500-600 for private and $350 for Medicare.
are there any other specialists who get OVERPAID like we do for private Insurance (come on we all know the private insurance is ridiculous payments) and severely UNDERPAID (relative to private insurance payments) for medicare rates
most specialities get roughly 60%
anesthesia is less than 30% or even less if the amc $100-120/unit billing for private is accounted for.
Yep I agree $600 for a 5min nerve block is not really reasonable.
The real problem is the entire anesthesia payment structure. Why does private insurance pay $800-900 for 15 min colonoscopy and Medicare pays $150 if u are lucky.
vs gi docs getting $500-600 for private and $350 for Medicare.
are there any other specialists who get OVERPAID like we do for private Insurance (come on we all know the private insurance is ridiculous payments) and severely UNDERPAID (relative to private insurance payments) for medicare rates
most specialities get roughly 60%
anesthesia is less than 30% or even less if the amc $100-120/unit billing for private is accounted for.
Yep I agree $600 for a 5min nerve block is not really reasonable.
Is that all inclusive? is that money going toward paying for the equipments/drugs as well? or is that separate
D
deleted87051
Is that all inclusive? is that money going toward paying for the equipments/drugs as well? or is that separate
No just professional fee. Facility fees are charged separately by the hospital or surgicenter and they generally dwarf the professional fees.
Yep I agree $600 for a 5min nerve block is not really reasonable.
Gotta say I disagree with this. I’d pay that out of pocket for a working nerve block that would get me through a substantial period of time pain free. It potentially saves an overnight hospital stay and let’s you feel “normal”by avoiding a bunch of opioids. I feel for patients that are limited to IV meds for pain relief honestly.
Compared to the reimbursement for an emergency airway though...that’s an issue. 2 units for a life saving measure compared w 8-10 units for a nerve block—doesn’t make any sense to me.
D
deleted87051
Gotta say I disagree with this. I’d pay that out of pocket for a working nerve block that would get me through a substantial period of time pain free. It potentially saves an overnight hospital stay and let’s you feel “normal”by avoiding a bunch of opioids. I feel for patients that are limited to IV meds for pain relief honestly.
Compared to the reimbursement for an emergency airway though...that’s an issue. 2 units for a life saving measure compared w 8-10 units for a nerve block—doesn’t make any sense to me.
Agree if you’re talking about value to the patient. I was talking more about the effort and energy required on my part....it’s not much.
Someone please tell me how to Bill 8 units for a nerve block 😱
D
deleted162650
Someone please tell me how to Bill 8 units for a nerve block 😱
Brachial plexus blocks are 8 units. Use U/S and you can bill 2 more for a grand total of (get this) 10 units!!

Brachial plexus blocks are 8 units. Use U/S and you can bill 2 more for a grand total of (get this) 10 units!!![]()
i was told medicare/medicaid doesnt pay for blocks for postop pain in ny?