# Melting point and impurities

Discussion in 'MCAT Study Question Q&A' started by DJtiesto, Sep 2, 2009.

1. SDN is made possible through member donations, sponsorships, and our volunteers. Learn about SDN's nonprofit mission.
1. ### DJtiesto 7+ Year Member

152
0
Apr 5, 2009
I know that impurities in a solution will cause it to decrease its vapor pressure, have a higher boiling point, and a lower freezing point, but what is the effect on melting point? I can't seem to find this in any of my books. Thanks

3. ### Omni 5+ Year Member

779
3
Sep 17, 2007
Michigan
I have a question to add to this as well:
I've always heard that impurities affect the hydrogen bonds in water, which lower the BP of water. What impurities are they talking about? Why don't solutes like NaCl salt lower the BP instead? Is it because salts are charged?

4. ### Omni 5+ Year Member

779
3
Sep 17, 2007
Michigan
This is weird.
This whole time the thing has been telling me "unable to post" and whenever I clicked refresh, none of these messages showed up so I kept trying and then now I see a bunch of these.

5. ### inaccensa 7+ Year Member

512
1
Sep 5, 2008
It will decrease the melting pt,since it will affect the crystallization. Imagine pure water forming crystals and now you add some solute like salt. It interferes with the process, hence decreasing the mp.

6. ### jung1 2+ Year Member

134
0
Aug 14, 2009
Michigan
I imagine the MP and BP are nearly the same. I mean, if it transitions from a solid to liquid, then it will transition from a liquid to solid at the same temp in a reverse reaction right? I guess at equilibrium, if there is such a thing, same amounts would be melting and freezing.

Dissolving a non-volatile substance decreases vapor pressure of the solution and thus increases boiling point because there is simply less volatile substance in a given mass of solution. It's a dilution effect. That means adding a volatile solute would decrease the boiling point of that solution.

7. ### inaccensa 7+ Year Member

512
1
Sep 5, 2008

That is an incorrect statment. MP - Substances go from Solid-Liquid
BP - Substances go from Liquid -gases

8. ### PiBondCall me Bond...PiBond 7+ Year Member

634
18
Aug 12, 2009
Boston
It will definitely decrease melting point (or equivalently, decrease the freezing point).

The presence of solute particles interferes with the efficient arrangement of solvent molecules into a solid lattice. Therefore, it will take colder temperatures (freezing point will decrease) for the solution to effectively freeze. Melting point decreases because, due to the effect the solute particles interfering with efficient arrangement, the intermolecular forces between solvent molecules are not as strong to prevent disruption when heated. Therefore, it will melt at a lower temperature (or be more easily melted).

Hope that helps.

9. ### Hah 5+ Year Member

239
0
Sep 4, 2009
I actually did this experiment in orgo lab a year ago. MP DECREASES with impurities like water or other substances. In addition, the MP RANGE INCREASES. For example, pure substance X has a mp of 142 C - 143C. An impure sample of substance X would have a mp of 90 C -120 C.

Hope this helps!

EDIT: As the person who posted before me said BP AND MP are not the same but MP and Freezing point IS (since freezing is liquid to solid and melting is solid to liquid). So you basically answered your own question when you said in your original post that Freezing point decreases with impurities. Since MP=FP, logic dictates MP will decrease too.

Last edited: Sep 28, 2009

1,375
22
Dec 31, 2007