Milkshake - Game Thread

Veterinary Science Graduate Programs from U. of I.
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
genny said:
What's your opinion on Paws?
Click to expand...
Definite sketch lean, posting style aside I think her position on the Doggo wagon as well as SAR’s interactions with her are weird. But then I also have to wonder if SAR would really be saying 15 minutes before getting lynched that one of her wolfy partners is playing in her village meta or if SAR read the writing on the wall and was trying to set up a mislynch for a future day.
 
WonderingStudent said:
My initial thoughts that I noted last night when reading the thread:

- Doggo:
broke tie toward SAR (between SAR and sunni in the last 30 mins), probably village; I don't think SAR would shade his fellow wolf D1 but I don't know SAR's style too well


; SAR moved and voted doggo for self-prez

-Coop - feels fine for now, she voted for SAR; seems casual tonally which doesn't mean much

- alissa - broke tie between SAR and Doggo (unless Doggo is also a wolf - which I doubt - this makes me lean village)

- Kota - SAR voted to lynch her; could be to distance from teammates but I'm leaning toward probably not
Click to expand...
What's your opinion of that SAR post you quoted?
 
genny said:
There's a difference between claiming wolf and leaning wolf? And you think a player who tipped a lynch toward a wolf belongs in one of those categories?
Click to expand...

If I say someone is leaning wolf they’ve done some suspect things to make me question them, but if I say they are wolfy, then they usually have more then a few posts/actions to suggest that. That’s usually how I categorize people if they are suspect, irs just my opinion.

I think it is possible that a wolf might tip the lynch towards another wolf, especially if they need to self prez (like SAR did, or Doggo), but D1 would be a little early to do so.
 
genny said:
So much WIFOM there.
Click to expand...
I KNOW that’s why especially given the close timing to lynch close I’m not sure how I want to classify it yet. Last-minute distancing-by-not-distancing? Last-minute setting up of a mislynch? I think my confusion means that whatever it was worked lol
 
BigCats said:
I KNOW that’s why especially given the close timing to lynch close I’m not sure how I want to classify it yet. Last-minute distancing-by-not-distancing? Last-minute setting up of a mislynch? I think my confusion means that whatever it was worked lol
Click to expand...

Also on this, SAR mentioned why would paws as a wolf give her a post restriction, and then paws said NAI regarding it. That is a little odd, why not just let it be as it was in her defense to make her seem more village.
 
genny said:
What's your opinion of that SAR post you quoted?
Click to expand...
SARdoghandler said:
Feeling village on paws, Coop, Genny. Susp on Kota and you for the most part. Everyone else files into a neutral category
Click to expand...
Are you referring to SAR's reads on certain people and how that reflects on those individuals? I don't put much stock into it. It's difficult to say if she would put players who she knows are villagers so that those players feel better about her because she called them village/other players can look back once those individuals flip to see that SAR's good at "reading people." Or if she slipped her wolfmate(s) in to push perception of them to village as positive early.
 
Lynch sporty
I find it odd that she couldn't tell WZ was vill
I've got doggo as vil, genny tentative vil lean
More in a bit
final_5c11541fb472020012f692e0_156750.jpg
 
lynch genny
I don’t like how vague her posts have been, and I feel like she hasn’t contributed much to wolf hunting. She hasn’t given any solid reads, and seems to be dodging doing so, instead she seems to echo other people’s opinions or just post disagreements, and not provide anything new.

I still want to here more from sporty, although I appreciate the early short reads I would like more details as why you labeled people as suspect of village. And I want more posts from Doggo and Barks.

Paws I am still leaning village on, although I think the SAR and paws exchange regarding Paw’s posting style is odd
 
Kota1000 said:
lynch genny
I don’t like how vague her posts have been, and I feel like she hasn’t contributed much to wolf hunting. She hasn’t given any solid reads, and seems to be dodging doing so, instead she seems to echo other people’s opinions or just post disagreements, and not provide anything new.

I still want to here more from sporty, although I appreciate the early short reads I would like more details as why you labeled people as suspect of village. And I want more posts from Doggo and Barks.

Paws I am still leaning village on, although I think the SAR and paws exchange regarding Paw’s posting style is odd
Click to expand...

I guess Paws posted the early short read. Boy I need to pay more attention to who posts what and not read so fast. So [mention]StayingPositive2017 [/mention] why do you have doggo and genny as village? And do you have any more reason for lynching sporty?
 
Day 2 Lynch Tally
Sporty (1) - Paws
genny (1) - Kota

2/13
lynch close in ~10 hours
 
Gotta go on a grocery run for my mama! I’ll be back with reads after that! Happy Mother’s Day to the moms out there! (Which i think in this particular thread is just paws... 😍 )
 
Kota1000 said:
I guess Paws posted the early short read. Boy I need to pay more attention to who posts what and not read so fast. So [mention]StayingPositive2017 [/mention] why do you have doggo and genny as village? And do you have any more reason for lynching sporty?
Click to expand...
The things you post dont make sense to me. Are you saying that you liked my super short read at the beginning of the game?
 
StayingPositive2017 said:
Ok thanks for clarifying. genny sounds like vil genny to me
Click to expand...

Okay, sorry I type really fast so sometimes I mistype stuff, and sometimes I type stuff that make sense in my head but sometimes no one else understand lol. What about doggo?
 
genny said:
Current POE after making a lynch tracker: BC, Paws, 3m, Suni, Stagg/Wondering, Sporty
Click to expand...

Thank you! Do you think your going to vote for Bc?

I have suspicions about them as well, especially considering the quick move off SAR and onto Doggo
 
Kota1000 said:
Thank you! Do you think your going to vote for Bc?

I have suspicions about them as well, especially considering the quick move off SAR and onto Doggo
Click to expand...

Or Sunbodi not doggo. It was Dubz that switched to doggo
 
Day 1 lynch tracker

SAR (1) - BC
WZ (1) - Paws
Suni (1) - genny
Doggo (1) - Barks
WZ (0) - Paws
WZ (1) - Sporty
Stagg/Wonder (1) - WZ
3m (1) - Paws
Paws (1) - Coop
Paws (2) - Coop, 3m
WZ (2) - Sporty, Kota
Paws (1) - Coop, 3m
Sporty (1) - 3m
BC (1) - alissa
SAR (0) - BC
Suni (2) - genny, BC
BC (0) - alissa
Suni (3) - genny, BC, alissa
3m (0) - Paws
Kota (1) - SAR
Stagg/Wonder (0) - WZ
SAR (1) - WZ
SAR (2) - WZ, mpm
Doggo (2) - Barks, Paws
SAR (3) - WZ, mpm, Coop
SAR (4) - WZ, mpm, Coop, Doggo
SAR (3) - WZ, mpm, Coop, Doggo
Doggo (3) - Barks, Paws, WZ
Kota (0) - SAR
Doggo (4) - Barks, Paws, WZ, SAR
WZ (1) - Sporty, Kota
SAR (4) - mpm, Coop, Doggo, Kota
Suni (2) - genny, BC, alissa
SAR (5) - mpm, Coop, Doggo, Kota, alissa

Missing: Suni, Stagg/Wonder
 
Kota1000 said:
Okay, sorry I type really fast so sometimes I mistype stuff, and sometimes I type stuff that make sense in my head but sometimes no one else understand lol. What about doggo?
Click to expand...
Pretty sure I already explained doggo and you clarified a typo. Are you just asking questions to look busy?
 
StayingPositive2017 said:
Pretty sure I already explained doggo and you clarified a typo. Are you just asking questions to look busy?
Click to expand...

Well you said based on SAR’s flip you think doggo is village. Is it just because of how they interacted? Or because of the fact that doggo and SAR were the leading lynches yesterday.

Why would I question to look busy? I just want people to fully explain things rather then giving partial or no answer. You answered about doggo being Village based on SAR’s flip, but why does SAR’s flips warrant doggo being village? (I guess is what I should asked)
 
SportPonies said:
I’ll be back with more. Have thoughts brewing but need to check and make sure I’m not misremembering things
Click to expand...

I’m still leaning sporty as wolf...

The post about not being able to read people on D1 and the wishy
washy-ness today come off wolfy

So for now

Lynch sporty
 
Kota1000 said:
Well you said based on SAR’s flip you think doggo is village. Is it just because of how they interacted? Or because of the fact that doggo and SAR were the leading lynches yesterday.

Why would I question to look busy? I just want people to fully explain things rather then giving partial or no answer. You answered about doggo being Village based on SAR’s flip, but why does SAR’s flips warrant doggo being village? (I guess is what I should asked)
Click to expand...
If doggo was also a wolf why would sar self prez there? Why not suni? Or do you think we nailed it so hard that all three wolves were on the board at lynch close D1?
 
StayingPositive2017 said:
If doggo was also a wolf why would sar self prez there? Why not suni? Or do you think we nailed it so hard that all three wolves were on the board at lynch close D1?
Click to expand...

I don’t think that. I was just wondering there was any other reason, when SAR self prezzed. So do you think since SAR self prezzed to Doggo that Sunny is a wolf?
 
StayingPositive2017 said:
Wolves ask questions to look like they are wolf hunting when they are not. I feel like I already answered but hopefully now you can see clearly
Click to expand...

Yes but if I was a wolf trying to look like I’m wolf hunting I’d probably ask way stupider questions. Sorry for trying to get clarifying information
 
I had a lot of thoughts last night after the thread closed that I don’t totally remember right now

I didn’t like how it seemed like people were really harping on paws exclamation points even after she explained them (and it’s still getting mentioned) because it really is NAI and I was sketched out mostly by 3m and kota (snd thought kota sounded different too)

3ms voting position last night doesn’t help her out much

On the other hand kotas voting position does help her out quite a bit with how she moved back onto SAR at the end
 
Barkley13 said:
What I quoted. Why didn’t you want to be the only one posting long reads
Click to expand...

Oh! I just feel bad when I post long reads and people have to read them. I usually like to do a previous day recap the next morning, but they can get really long, hence why I broke my SAR activity reads and post reads into multiple posts
 
Barkley13 said:
I had a lot of thoughts last night after the thread closed that I don’t totally remember right now

I didn’t like how it seemed like people were really harping on paws exclamation points even after she explained them (and it’s still getting mentioned) because it really is NAI and I was sketched out mostly by 3m and kota (snd thought kota sounded different too)

3ms voting position last night doesn’t help her out much

On the other hand kotas voting position does help her out quite a bit with how she moved back onto SAR at the end
Click to expand...

I may have fallen asleep while curled up with my dog #noshame
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
56K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
40K
Clem J
Clem J
supershorty
GGoats ThWWee: Here It GGoats Again - GAME THREAD
93 94 95 96 97
Replies
5K
Views
57K
vampyrica
vampyrica
Animal Midwife
Matrix - Game Thread
77 78 79 80 81
Replies
4K
Views
90K
samac
samac
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
PokeWWon: A Wild Kanto Adventure - Champs Season 12 Practice Game Thread
87 88 89 90 91
Replies
5K
Views
61K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
Top