Milkshake - Game Thread

[JustPaws]

---

Members do not see this ad.

@genny why didn't you vote for me last night? As I am rereading you, it just seems like I'm very high on your list. For ex: i just realized you implied that WZ was killed to make me look village

 

[Coopah]

well your sitting neutral (Coopah is most village -> Paws being more wolf), so your pretty in the middle, but less wolf in my top 3 suspects

Why do you feel this way about BC and genny in particular?

 

[genny]

@genny why didn't you vote for me last night? As I am rereading you, it just seems like I'm very high on your list. For ex: i just realized you implied that WZ was killed to make me look village

Did you want to be lynched? You’re still high on my list.

 

[JustPaws]

Did you want to be lynched? You’re still high on my list.

I just think it's weird that you pushed me all day and then let 3m get lynched instead of me. I know 3m was in you eel pot but I was surprised you didn't switch back

 

[JustPaws]

@BigCats what are your thoughts on genny?

 

[BigCats]

@BigCats what are your thoughts on genny?

Genny is like my top village read lol

 

[BigCats]

Honestly I’m trying to reconcile how wolfy Kota feels with her position on the SAR wagon. Like I’m not sure I can see a world where wolves would have decided to sacrifice SAR to send a noob into bussing territory and that seems awfully bold to try to do, but something just feels weird...

 

[JustPaws]

Honestly I’m trying to reconcile how wolfy Kota feels with her position on the SAR wagon. Like I’m not sure I can see a world where wolves would have decided to sacrifice SAR to send a noob into bussing territory and that seems awfully bold to try to do, but something just feels weird...

Can you qoute some examples of Kota seeming wolfy? I'm not seeing it

 

[BigCats]

I think the kill choice is extra weirding me out too. mpm was probably the least cleared based on vote position and I really just don’t get it unless they thought she was a joat? Like it’s so bizarre that it makes me wonder about how “cleared” the folks I’ve semi-cleared based on vote position actually are.

 

[BigCats]

Can you qoute some examples of Kota seeming wolfy? I'm not seeing it

On mobile rn but her reads yesterday were so weird- iirc she had alissa and genny as wolfy and voted for both of them, which I flat out do not agree with, and she made some comment about you that I didn’t interpret as making you sound particularly village but ended it with village reading you. I should really dig up the exact quote but it’s weird that she thought you were village, voted to save you last night if I’m recalling the votes correctly, and now you’re her wolfiest suspect.

 

[Barkley13]

Honestly I’m trying to reconcile how wolfy Kota feels with her position on the SAR wagon. Like I’m not sure I can see a world where wolves would have decided to sacrifice SAR to send a noob into bussing territory and that seems awfully bold to try to do, but something just feels weird...

I want to see the people on the SAR vote as clear because what would be the point of bussing on day 1 but I know at some point I’m gonna have to consider it. Also there’s the thought of what if sunni is also a wolf so that kinda messes with things

 

[BigCats]

Thanks for this! Really helpful for info, and I didn’t want to be the only one to post long reads. here’s my reads on people:

I think Paws has been fairly confrontational this game, but it seems in line with last game as well when they flipped village, so I’m leaning more village on them, although I’d like to see more wolf hunting effort. Also, I don’t like that they switched MO without mentioning it in the actual thread and not the sign ups, but that’s just my opinion because once I sign up I usually don’t go back and read the sign ups except to see the final roster.

Sporty, Doggo and Barks I need to hear more from, so they are in my neutral pile.

Although, Barks did ask “why is SAR sketchy?.” When they SAR lynch was happening, although maybe they hadn’t caught up.

And doggo did give some opinions, but they were very vague and not super helpful, so sketch points for that.

Moose, I am leaning more village on as they seem to be trying to wolf hunt through their questions, answers to questions directed at them have details, and they provide good reasoning for their lynches so far. One thing that bothers me is that they asked Sporty what they though of barks even though barks posted very minimally, and then MPM said that they asked the question on a random player.

Alissa is in my neutral- leaning wolf pile, and I’d like to hear more from them. I feel like the content they provided has been very shallow with quick explanations that don’t really contribute much to wolf hunting, or they have been echoing others. They also don’t seem as active as usually, but it’s only D1. However, nothing they have done has stood out as super sketchy to me.

So 3m has done a lot of lynching based on people’s actions that don’t seem to significant in my opinion, and didn’t change their lynch for something more concrete - lynching Paws for her posting style this game, and lynching Sporty for a comment on not being able to read people based on feels D1. They also just sort of disappeared before lynch fest. I didn’t like the 3m X Dubz exchange early on regarding Paw’s posting style, but it seems in character for 3m. Right now I am placing her in my slight village lean pile.

Genny wasn’t super active later on, but they did post a lot to start. I feel like they haven’t contributed much in terms of wolf hunting. They also jumped on Sunny really quick, and lynched her without providing a reason. Then later made a comment about the being a wolf. They also made the comment that “I don’t think I deserve special treatment in this game,” which I found a little odd. Lastly, they have been throwing a lot of jokes and sarcasm around. So for now they are going in my suspect pile after the reread of D1.

It was this post I was thinking of. I think it was actually her read on 3m that confused me, not you, my bad.

 

[deleted804295]

Genny is like my top village read lol

Idk how genny can be anyones top village read.

 

[deleted804295]

I think the kill choice is extra weirding me out too. mpm was probably the least cleared based on vote position and I really just don’t get it unless they thought she was a joat? Like it’s so bizarre that it makes me wonder about how “cleared” the folks I’ve semi-cleared based on vote position actually are.

Yeah if warriors are any indication we should be most suspicious of people who are 'cleared'

 

[JustPaws]

Yeah if warriors are any indication we should be most suspicious of people who are 'cleared'

so say again who you are suspecting?

 

[Barkley13]

I wanted to look at who was on doggo D1 again and two of the four people are dead (SAR and dubz), one is me, and the fourth is paws. First I wanted to see if maybe there was a wolf on that lynch but then I realized duh SAR voted there and not that I don't believe that two wolves wouldn't have voted there but I'm not really conviced paws is wolfy

 

[Kota1000]

Why do you feel this way about BC and genny in particular?

I feel like BC is usually a lot more helpful in wolf hunting, and besides giving out 2 large paragraphs on people, they hadn't done a lot that stood out to me for actively wolf hunting. So I would like to ISO them today.

For genny, I feel like they have been pretty snarky this game, and while they have been in past games I feel like the attitude over showers their efforts to wolf hunt, which hasn't been very prominent to me.

On mobile rn but her reads yesterday were so weird- iirc she had alissa and genny as wolfy and voted for both of them, which I flat out do not agree with, and she made some comment about you that I didn’t interpret as making you sound particularly village but ended it with village reading you. I should really dig up the exact quote but it’s weird that she thought you were village, voted to save you last night if I’m recalling the votes correctly, and now you’re her wolfiest suspect.

I had paws as village, but after rereading and things other people pointed out, I moved her back to my wolfy pile this morning, I still need to do an ISO. I felt that later in D2 she had a lot better questioning method that made her seem more village, but after 3m flipped village, I want to reevaluate her so I put her in my wolfy pile again.

As far as 3m, I had her leaning village after D1. Then after a whole other day and reading her posts (or lack of), I was a little suspect of them. I also decided to Lynch her because she hadn't voted or mentioned anything about SAR being suspect D1.

For Alissa, I had made my initial read based on her earlier posts and not the SAR Lynch, so once that was pointed out, after a little bit of back and forth regarding why I thought her posts were a little wolfy, I decided to agree with those who pointed out that it made no sense for Alissa to break the tie between Doggo and SAR unless they were all 3 wolves for some reason, but I do not think doggo is a wolf.

Doing some ISOs on paws, genny and BC shortly

 

[Barkley13]

Honestly I’m trying to reconcile how wolfy Kota feels with her position on the SAR wagon. Like I’m not sure I can see a world where wolves would have decided to sacrifice SAR to send a noob into bussing territory and that seems awfully bold to try to do, but something just feels weird...

Ugh I keep thinking this while I'm rereading the thread from yesterday
Kota feels so off but whyyyy would she tie it up if she was a wolf

 

[BigCats]

Ugh I keep thinking this while I'm rereading the thread from yesterday
Kota feels so off but whyyyy would she tie it up if she was a wolf

The only way I can rationalize it is that would be an excellent way to give a brand new baby wolf some village cred to get her started. I don’t like that I’ve been thinking that every single person on SAR’s lynch was village- too easy, especially since I feel better about you and Sporty and I’m kind of running out of people to suspect lol.

 

[BigCats]

I’ve talked myself in circles and I think it feels right for now.

lynch Kota

 

[Barkley13]

Okay hear me out

What if SAR had a strong feeling she was going to get lynched early because of hannibal or whatever so she had the other wolves bus on purpose?

 

[Kota1000]

So here is my genny iso, it's pretty long so I am putting it in a spoiler.

Spoiler

First in my genny ISO, this exchange between Paws and Genny stood out. I find it rather weird. Maybe its just joking around since the game just started, but I think it's an odd exchange:

Thank you!!!!!!! So far:
genny N
BC v
Paws Very Vill!!!!!!!!
Everyone else missing!!!!!!!!!!

Why are there no exclamation points with my N?

It's also my 12th wedding anniversary. Does that make me lynch proof today too?

You are lynch proof for a bit cuz it's your practice!!!!!!!

I don't think I deserve special treatment in this game.

I think it's fine to not lynch you d1!!!!!

Also in these posts, genny is a little inconsistent with the following:

It's also my 12th wedding anniversary. Does that make me lynch proof today too?

I don't think I deserve special treatment in this game.

She asked about being Lynch proof, and then a few posts after said that that she doesn't deserve any special treatment this game.

Next, many of Genny's posts are similar to the following and lack substance other then jabs towards others or sarcasm:

This is fine. We have a 5-way tie with 7 hours left. Plenty of time for people to start talking to each other, right? Bueller?

Wow, what an insight. I don't think anyone has commented on that yet today!

I can't tell if this is serious or sarcastic

are you sure you got the appropriate level of outrage to pass as a villager in this post? Didn't overdo it with the caps lock?

Lastly, when I asked if they had any reads on people, this was their initial response

Yes, and I am expressing them now.

When I continued to push them they said the following

I'm not making a list. I'm not Santa Claus.

Her reads are as follows:

Current POE after making a lynch tracker: BC, Paws, 3m, Suni, Stagg/Wondering, Sporty

So if you go back and look at when Doggo placed her vote, the tally was SAR and Suni tied at 3 apiece, with Dubz and Doggo close behind with 2 each. The flurry of votes on Doggo happened after she voted, not before. Doggo's vote pushed SAR ahead in the tally. Do you think she'd try a bus like that on Day 1, when she could have voted Dubz or Suni?

Not that Barks specifically sounds wolfy, but that she hasn't sounded as villagey as BC and Wondering have in their posts today. Barks also did some light questioning of the SAR lynch yesterday.

Wondering subbed for the absent Stagg, so we have no data for that player for day 1. That's why lynching there is tempting - an absent wolf on day 1 could have made it easier for village to lynch SAR. The things that Wondering has posted today kind of align with the way I was thinking after day 1, so either I'm being misled by wolves, or Wondering is having the same village thoughts that I am.

She doesn't really give much reasoning as to why she feels some players are wolfy and other's aren't, except regarding wondering which she also mentioned earlier:

Wondering's thoughts sound similar to what I was thinking this morning.

The Doggo/Sar/Suni read was more restating what happened, which was helpful but did not give insight into what she was thinking regarding the 2 that were still alive. Additionally, her reasoning for lynching Barks was just because they didn't sound as village as BC or Wondering, and she didn't really give reasonings or examples as to why she thought BC or Wondering were village.

In conclusion, I still feel like genny may be a wolf. And with going back and looking at the exchanges between genny and others, I feel like wondering could also be.

I am revising my list to the following after this iso:
Coopah
Doggo
Alissa
Barks
Sporty
BC
Paws
Wondering
Genny

Coopah->Barks I am leaning village on
Sporty I am neutral
BC->Genny I am suspect on, so I have to ISO more to reduce my list of potential wolves cause I know there are only 2 left.

 

[Barkley13]

I'm also wondering why sunbodi is lurking and not answering paws question

 

[Kota1000]

The only way I can rationalize it is that would be an excellent way to give a brand new baby wolf some village cred to get her started. I don’t like that I’ve been thinking that every single person on SAR’s lynch was village- too easy, especially since I feel better about you and Sporty and I’m kind of running out of people to suspect lol.

Do you have any other suspects besides me? If no, who are you feeling most strongly is village?

 

[BigCats]

Okay hear me out

What if SAR had a strong feeling she was going to get lynched early because of hannibal or whatever so she had the other wolves bus on purpose?

Omg stop feeding into my tinfoil

 

[genny]

So here is my genny iso, it's pretty long so I am putting it in a spoiler.

I refuse to spoon feed you. If you want to lynch me for it, be my guest. I have given reads, I just don't put them in a cute little list arranged from least wolfy to most wolfy so that wolves can pick them off one by one.

 

[BigCats]

Do you have any other suspects besides me? If no, who are you feeling most strongly is village?

My main village bucket is genny, Coop, alissa, Wondering, Doggo. Sporty is in a surrounding ring, Barks is in a slightly farther ring. Sunbodi I think is just wrong lol. That would leave you and Paws, which I don’t really hate as a partnership given how you saved her yesterday and she’s been asking why I think you’re sketchy today.

 

[genny]

Yeah if warriors are any indication we should be most suspicious of people who are 'cleared'

Yes, let's skip lynching all the sketchy people and go straight for the ones who don't seem nearly as sketch. Sounds like a great plan.

lynch suni

 

[Barkley13]

So here is my genny iso, it's pretty long so I am putting it in a spoiler.

Spoiler

First in my genny ISO, this exchange between Paws and Genny stood out. I find it rather weird. Maybe its just joking around since the game just started, but I think it's an odd exchange:








Also in these posts, genny is a little inconsistent with the following:


She asked about being Lynch proof, and then a few posts after said that that she doesn't deserve any special treatment this game.

Next, many of Genny's posts are similar to the following and lack substance other then jabs towards others or sarcasm:





Lastly, when I asked if they had any reads on people, this was their initial response

When I continued to push them they said the following


Her reads are as follows:




She doesn't really give much reasoning as to why she feels some players are wolfy and other's aren't, except regarding wondering which she also mentioned earlier:


The Doggo/Sar/Suni read was more restating what happened, which was helpful but did not give insight into what she was thinking regarding the 2 that were still alive. Additionally, her reasoning for lynching Barks was just because they didn't sound as village as BC or Wondering, and she didn't really give reasonings or examples as to why she thought BC or Wondering were village.

In conclusion, I still feel like genny may be a wolf. And with going back and looking at the exchanges between genny and others, I feel like wondering could also be.

I am revising my list to the following after this iso:
Coopah
Doggo
Alissa
Barks
Sporty
BC
Paws
Wondering
Genny

Coopah->Barks I am leaning village on
Sporty I am neutral
BC->Genny I am suspect on, so I have to ISO more to reduce my list of potential wolves cause I know there are only 2 left.

Why do you keep leaving sunbodi off your lists

 

[Kota1000]

Here is my wondering ISO.

I feel like she started off on the right foot. She provided reads and put in the effort to catch up after being subbed in N1.

My initial thoughts that I noted last night when reading the thread:

- Doggo:
broke tie toward SAR (between SAR and sunni in the last 30 mins), probably village; I don't think SAR would shade his fellow wolf D1 but I don't know SAR's style too well


; SAR moved and voted doggo for self-prez

-Coop - feels fine for now, she voted for SAR; seems casual tonally which doesn't mean much

- alissa - broke tie between SAR and Doggo (unless Doggo is also a wolf - which I doubt - this makes me lean village)

- Kota - SAR voted to lynch her; could be to distance from teammates but I'm leaning toward probably not

I feel like she has was vert perceptive about SAR and her Lynch:
Initially she says

- Kota - SAR voted to lynch her; could be to distance from teammates but I'm leaning toward probably not

which is using SAR's reads to analyze others, but then she later says that she wouldn't put much stock into it; however, in the first quote she does say "probably not," so I don't think it is super AI at this point.

Are you referring to SAR's reads on certain people and how that reflects on those individuals? I don't put much stock into it. It's difficult to say if she would put players who she knows are villagers so that those players feel better about her because she called them village/other players can look back once those individuals flip to see that SAR's good at "reading people." Or if she slipped her wolfmate(s) in to push perception of them to village as positive early.

On the SAR Lynch topic, she later notes that analyzing how players vote for a know wolf can reveal information whereas their reads often are lies/not as helpful, which is consistent with the last two quotes.

leaning 3m and mpm village based on posts feels and how they have had similar thoughts to myself.

Based on posts today, coop has become more suspicious but I think it's more telling who players voted for based around a known wolf (ie voting for SAR yesterday). Wolves can string any post together they want to seem village for reads and questioning players but I'm putting more stock in voting as slightly more telling atm as when there are already a few votes on their wolfy comrade it doesn't seem great to vote there since you are trying to use your village power (your lynch vote) to get rid of villagers.

Other then that, she hasn't given many reads besides this last POE and her vote on sporty, which I would have liked to know more about her reasoning for.

I gotta get to work. Based on POE I have in neutral right now (others are more village based on posts/voting)
sunbodi
paws
bc
bark
sporty
genny

lynch sporty

Hate to put a vote on someone that hasn't given much of reads yet but she feels lower down on my village feels than others so I'm putting my vote there and I gotta leave so this is what we are getting.

After this ISO, I don't think Wondering is suspect, so I am moving her back to neutral, although I would like some more reads today please!
Genny, I am keeping as my top wolfy suspect for now until I get some more ISOs done.

 

[Kota1000]

I refuse to spoon feed you. If you want to lynch me for it, be my guest. I have given reads, I just don't put them in a cute little list arranged from least wolfy to most wolfy so that wolves can pick them off one by one.

I don't want spoon feeding, and I do not need it. I just think giving some reads - any reads that actually have reasoning would be nice other then just a POE and a few comments. Other people's reads are what I heavily base my wolfy/village ranking off of based on the quality, amount, and feelings towards others. So far you have provided very lacking-in-quality reads. I honestly could care less about a POE list, or who is in your wolfy suspects or who you think is village, it just would be nice to hear your opinions on others. I feel like you are not putting a ton of effort into wolf hunting, which is why I find you suspect.

My main village bucket is genny, Coop, alissa, Wondering, Doggo. Sporty is in a surrounding ring, Barks is in a slightly farther ring. Sunbodi I think is just wrong lol. That would leave you and Paws, which I don’t really hate as a partnership given how you saved her yesterday and she’s been asking why I think you’re sketchy today.

Okay, thanks. I respect your suspicions. I honestly have changed my mind so many times about Paws, which is why I want to ISO her.

Why do you keep leaving sunbodi off your lists

Oh I copied the one from my notes in my phone, which I guess I never updated. I will update my notes lol. But I still am feeling more neutral on her so far.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Day 3 Lynch Tally
Kota (1) - BC
Suni (1) - genny

2/11
lynch close in ~7.5 hours

 

[Barkley13]

I really don't feel great about sunbodi, kota, wondering +/- sporty
Feel neutral about BC, paws, coop, genny
And villageish about alissa and doggo
I think that's everyone

 

[Barkley13]

This really isn't great timing because genny just voted here but I have to leave for work soon so what can ya do

lynch sunbodi

 

[Barkley13]

Genny is like my top village read lol

Oh yeah and I meant to ask about this

 

[genny]

it just would be nice to hear your opinions on others

I've done this. You actually quoted some of them. Just because it comes with a joke doesn't mean that I don't have a point.

 

[genny]

Kota, if I was a wolf, you'd totally be dead by now because you're annoying the snot out of me. That's your proof that I'm village. 😛

 

[BigCats]

Oh yeah and I meant to ask about this

I’m surprised that multiple people seem to disagree with me on this (you, Sunbodi, Kota), she feels pretty slam-dunk village to me through tone and actions. Is there something in particular you disagree with me on?

 

[Kota1000]

I will start off my Paws Iso bye saying I think its weird that she just dropped the whole !!!!! post styled D1, but I think its NAI.

I was very surprised that she had reads so early on in the game. She also said that genny was village a few posts later.

Thank you!!!!!!! So far:
genny N
BC v
Paws Very Vill!!!!!!!!
Everyone else missing!!!!!!!!!!

Ahhhhhh that's right!!!
Unlynch WZ for her graduation. There us always tomorrow!!!!

I think it's fine to not lynch you d1!!!!!

She also didn't post another full reads list since then, and most of her posts have either been questions or comments and not her opinions on others. Some I did see was:

I'm not sure who to vote for. Lots of people with no real impression yet, feeling good about several others!!!!!

I think her good feels about others were from the D1 list.

Lynch sporty
I find it odd that she couldn't tell WZ was vill
I've got doggo as vil, genny tentative vil lean
More in a bit

I dont feel like SAR and doggo were WvV yesterday so SARs flip makes me think doggo is vil

^ the V is supposed to be a W
Also D1 she decided to Lynch doggo for pressure, as well as lynching MPM until she ISO'd people.

Ok thanks for clarifying. genny sounds like vil genny to me

I think these reads are rather straight forward, and also align with her reads from D1. But, her Doggo and Sporty Lynch make me nervous just because of the reasoning behind them, as the reasoning doesn't really point towards wolfiness. I am keeping her in my suspect list.

I will do a BC Iso In a few hours, my sister has an online AP test so I have to get off the internet because our internet sucks.

 

[Kota1000]

Kota, if I was a wolf, you'd totally be dead by now because you're annoying the snot out of me. That's your proof that I'm village. 😛

Well then it would be obvious.

Lynch genny since I got to go and she is my top suspect at the moment

 

[Barkley13]

I’m surprised that multiple people seem to disagree with me on this (you, Sunbodi, Kota), she feels pretty slam-dunk village to me through tone and actions. Is there something in particular you disagree with me on?

I don’t have her wolfy or anything, I just haven’t seen anything that screams super villagey

 

[WonderingStudent]

Dubz and Paws are way too enthusiastic. Paws would not put a target this easily on their back so I'm leaning paws in village pile for now.

I know that you were doing your analysis/posting while you went (so you may have not gotten up to this point in the thread when you posted) and just in case you missed this on the reread: Paws said in the signup thread that they would be doing that posting style (an MU style) if they were either affiliation so I don't think that evidence is that great for leaning Paws one way or the other on affiliation.

What about coop's posts seem suspicious to you?

Have not forgotten to respond. I just didn't pull quotes last night and I want to post what I have in my notes that I wrote last night at work then I'll go and look for what I'm talking about.

Y are people attacking BC???

BC is coming off as village BC to me

Have you played with wolf BC before? [Genuine question.] I'm not sure if you kept reading noob game after you died D1. Just making sure you are saying that BC sounds village to you not that you are comparing her to wolf!BC (since I don't really know if you've been in a game long enough with wolf!bc to know what her wolf self is like. Personally, I can’t tell when she’s wolf vs village so even if I see village feeling posts I still keep her in neutral.

I'd be fine with a Kota, Sunni or paws lynch

Why? What are your current reads in general?

I'm getting mostly a feeling that you're busy based on posts and I just want to feel better about clearing you based on your D1 vote.

Is this arranged in any particular order of more towards village/less towards village?

I know you no longer need a response but for the benefit of everyone else that list of neutral names I posted was not in any particular order. They're listed in the order players are on the rooster since I just went down the list and wrote names down as I went to ensure I listed everyone and didn't forget anyone.

My two sus candidates are stag/wonder and mpm. My intuition just makes me find them weird

Well I disagree with this post wondering made which makes me lean them wolf. Mpm feels off to me and it's weird that they're choosing two people who haven't talked a lot to analyze as their village reads

If you want to get people behind you on your wolf suspect then ask them questions 😊 If they still seem wolfy to you then you'll have more evidence to point to to get others on your side. Citing female intuition gets you only so far and doesn't really push other villagers to get behind you. We can't trust that you aren't a wolf trying to use your intuition to make fake reads. Intuition isn't always correct anyway (see WWarriors).


Side note: It's really annoying to write posts/analyze at night when you can't pull quotes from thread and copy/paste them. It takes me so much longer to post in the morning when I have to find all of the quotes again with just their number post.

Side-side note: I'm sad that Stagg just said that they now have time to play but AM isn't letting them do so. I just subbed in to make sure no one was modkilled or anything of the sort. 🙁

 

[JustPaws]

D1 Lynch Tracker
SAR - BC
WZ - paws
Sunni - genny
doggo - bark
WZ - paws
WZ - sporty
stagg - WZ
3m - paws
paws - coop
paws - coop, 3m
WZ - sporty, kota
paws - coop, 3m
sporty - 3m
bc - alissa
SAR - bc
sunbodi - genny, bc
bc - alissa
sunbodi - genny, bc, alissa
3m - paws
kota - SAR
stagg - WZ
SAR - WZ
SAR - WZ, mpm
doggo - bark, paws
paws - coop
SAR - WZ, mpm, coop
SAR - WZ, mpm, coop, doggo
SAR - WZ, mpm, coop, doggo
doggo - bark, paws, WZ
kota - SAR
doggo - bark, paws, WZ, SAR
WZ - sporty, kota
SAR - mpm, coop, doggo, kota
sunni - genny, bc, alissa
SAR - mpm, coop, doggo, kota, alissa

Final Day 1 Lynch Tally
SAR (5) - mpm, Coop, Doggo, Kota, alissa
dubz (1) - Sporty
Suni (2) - genny, BC
Doggo (4) - Barks, Paws, dubz, SAR
Stagg () -
3m () -
Paws () -
Sporty (1) - 3m
BC () -
Kota () -

13/15
Missing: Stagg, Suni



Lynch Tracker Day 2
sport (1) - paws
genny (1) - kota
sport (2) - paws, 3m
paws (1) - mpm
genny () - kota
BC (1)- kota
doggo (1) - coop
paws - (2) - mpm, genny
doggo () - coop
paws (3) - mpm, genny, coop
BC () - kota
paws (4) - mpm, genny, coop, kota
paws (3) -mpm, genny, coop, kota
barks (1) - genny
kota (1) - sunni
sport (3 ) - paws, 3m, wondering
kota () - sunni
wondering (1) - sunni
sun (1) - alissa
sun () - alissa
doggo (1) - sport
barks (2) - genny, BC
3m (1) - barks
3m (2) - barks, alissa
barks (1) - genny, BC
sun (1) - genny
doggo () - sport
bark () - BC
3m - bark, alissa, BC
sun (2) - genny, doggo
sporty (2) - paws, 3m, wondering
paws (2) - mpm, coop, kota
3m (4) - bark, alissa, BC, kota
mpm (1) - paws
paws (3) - mpm, coop, sport

Final Day 2 Lynch Tally
Sporty (2) - 3m, Wonder
genny () -
Paws (3) - mpm, Coop, Sporty
BC () -
Doggo () -
Barks () -
Kota () -
Wonder (1) - Suni
Suni (2) - genny, Doggo
3m (4) - Barks, alissa, BC, Kota
mpm (1) - Paws

13/13

 

[WonderingStudent]

I'm gonna go eat some lunch/breakfast/whatever it is since I just woke up and haven't eaten. Rather not have all/most of my posts be when I'm sleep deprived/when I haven't eaten. That doesn't seem like level headed thinking scenarios. 😕

 

[JustPaws]

unlynch Barks
lynch 3m

did you every state why you felt better about barks? and forgive me if you have already stated, but what is your current read on barks?

 

[kaydubs]

Day 3 Lynch Tally
Kota (1) - BC
Suni (2) - genny, Barks
genny (1) - Kota

4/11
lynch close in ~6.5 hours

 

[JustPaws]

Ok I'm rereading everything and just got through day 1

I didn't like BC's first post and I see how someone thinks she's echoey already since genny made a comment about people being quiet and then bc made a very similiar comment about people needing to talk. Seeing her post again about how she didn't like the SAR lynch still sketches me out and felt like a wolf defending another wolf.

3m seemed like a mixture of defensive and throwing a lot of shade around to see what sticks on D1 and seemed pretty bothered by paws's vote on her

Alissa was really really focused on sunbodi's one post about being a vanillager and posted about it multiple times and not much else but also broke the tie toward SAR so don't see her as wolf either

Kota had an odd reaction to paws joking around and changing her quote. I also feel like a lot of her posts have been off but have a hard time seeing her as wolf based on where her vote ended up yesterday

Doggo's another one that has felt off but her voting for SAR over sunbodi makes me lean her more village in spite of the fact that her reads seem to echo other peoples

So basically the people I thought were sketchy based on posts/tone ended up voting for SAR so I'm having trouble seeing them as anything but village. So alissa, kota, and doggo are village rn

BC and 3m are sketchy

After reread really didn't like this post because it basically says here are a bunch of sketchy things, but I can't see the as sketchy, they just seem village, which is how I usually feel when wolfing so it made me tingley

 

[BigCats]

did you every state why you felt better about barks? and forgive me if you have already stated, but what is your current read on barks?

Oh there I just wanted to make a 3-way tie to see what would happen haha. I feel better about Barks today than I did yesterday but not lock-village by any means. Weirds me out looking at your lynch tracker how she's the first vote on both the Doggo counterwagon as well as the 3m wagon.

 

[JustPaws]

other thoughts:
I don't think Alissa and sunni are in a pack together, and I don't think alissa and BC are in a pack together
still feel better about sporty and I'm sorry I gave you **** about your hmm rxns cause they are well placed as more flips happen
I wondered if sunni is hiding as a wolf by not posting cuz she gets people riled up. Where is she today?
I am trying to think through why SAR asked me about my 5th post village read on BC like it was a serious read - any ideas would be appreciated
- she can't have thought i knew something because it's an open game, maybe to just look busy?
I had a thought about a genny/BC pack but I think genny is slight village still
Personally, I haven't really had any thoughts on Barks until today so I am trying to look into her more
I am also wondering why doggo didn't die N2

 

[JustPaws]

Oh there I just wanted to make a 3-way tie to see what would happen haha. I feel better about Barks today than I did yesterday but not lock-village by any means. Weirds me out looking at your lynch tracker how she's the first vote on both the Doggo counterwagon as well as the 3m wagon.

I was weirded out by you switching from barks for no apparent reason (still none apparently) to following barks onto the 3m lynch