Why do you feel this way about BC and genny in particular?
Did you want to be lynched? You’re still high on my list.
I just think it's weird that you pushed me all day and then let 3m get lynched instead of me. I know 3m was in you eel pot but I was surprised you didn't switch back
Genny is like my top village read lol
Can you qoute some examples of Kota seeming wolfy? I'm not seeing it
On mobile rn but her reads yesterday were so weird- iirc she had alissa and genny as wolfy and voted for both of them, which I flat out do not agree with, and she made some comment about you that I didn’t interpret as making you sound particularly village but ended it with village reading you. I should really dig up the exact quote but it’s weird that she thought you were village, voted to save you last night if I’m recalling the votes correctly, and now you’re her wolfiest suspect.
I want to see the people on the SAR vote as clear because what would be the point of bussing on day 1 but I know at some point I’m gonna have to consider it. Also there’s the thought of what if sunni is also a wolf so that kinda messes with things
It was this post I was thinking of. I think it was actually her read on 3m that confused me, not you, my bad.
Idk how genny can be anyones top village read.
Yeah if warriors are any indication we should be most suspicious of people who are 'cleared'
so say again who you are suspecting?
I feel like BC is usually a lot more helpful in wolf hunting, and besides giving out 2 large paragraphs on people, they hadn't done a lot that stood out to me for actively wolf hunting. So I would like to ISO them today.
Ugh I keep thinking this while I'm rereading the thread from yesterday
The only way I can rationalize it is that would be an excellent way to give a brand new baby wolf some village cred to get her started. I don’t like that I’ve been thinking that every single person on SAR’s lynch was village- too easy, especially since I feel better about you and Sporty and I’m kind of running out of people to suspect lol.
She asked about being Lynch proof, and then a few posts after said that that she doesn't deserve any special treatment this game.
When I continued to push them they said the following
She doesn't really give much reasoning as to why she feels some players are wolfy and other's aren't, except regarding wondering which she also mentioned earlier:
Do you have any other suspects besides me? If no, who are you feeling most strongly is village?
Omg stop feeding into my tinfoilOkay hear me out
What if SAR had a strong feeling she was going to get lynched early because of hannibal or whatever so she had the other wolves bus on purpose?
I refuse to spoon feed you. If you want to lynch me for it, be my guest. I have given reads, I just don't put them in a cute little list arranged from least wolfy to most wolfy so that wolves can pick them off one by one.
My main village bucket is genny, Coop, alissa, Wondering, Doggo. Sporty is in a surrounding ring, Barks is in a slightly farther ring. Sunbodi I think is just wrong lol. That would leave you and Paws, which I don’t really hate as a partnership given how you saved her yesterday and she’s been asking why I think you’re sketchy today.
Yes, let's skip lynching all the sketchy people and go straight for the ones who don't seem nearly as sketch. Sounds like a great plan.
Why do you keep leaving sunbodi off your lists
which is using SAR's reads to analyze others, but then she later says that she wouldn't put much stock into it; however, in the first quote she does say "probably not," so I don't think it is super AI at this point.
On the SAR Lynch topic, she later notes that analyzing how players vote for a know wolf can reveal information whereas their reads often are lies/not as helpful, which is consistent with the last two quotes.
I don't want spoon feeding, and I do not need it. I just think giving some reads - any reads that actually have reasoning would be nice other then just a POE and a few comments. Other people's reads are what I heavily base my wolfy/village ranking off of based on the quality, amount, and feelings towards others. So far you have provided very lacking-in-quality reads. I honestly could care less about a POE list, or who is in your wolfy suspects or who you think is village, it just would be nice to hear your opinions on others. I feel like you are not putting a ton of effort into wolf hunting, which is why I find you suspect.
Okay, thanks. I respect your suspicions. I honestly have changed my mind so many times about Paws, which is why I want to ISO her.
Oh I copied the one from my notes in my phone, which I guess I never updated. I will update my notes lol. But I still am feeling more neutral on her so far.
Oh yeah and I meant to ask about this
I've done this. You actually quoted some of them. Just because it comes with a joke doesn't mean that I don't have a point.
I’m surprised that multiple people seem to disagree with me on this (you, Sunbodi, Kota), she feels pretty slam-dunk village to me through tone and actions. Is there something in particular you disagree with me on?
I think her good feels about others were from the D1 list.
^ the V is supposed to be a W
Well then it would be obvious.
I don’t have her wolfy or anything, I just haven’t seen anything that screams super villagey
I know that you were doing your analysis/posting while you went (so you may have not gotten up to this point in the thread when you posted) and just in case you missed this on the reread: Paws said in the signup thread that they would be doing that posting style (an MU style) if they were either affiliation so I don't think that evidence is that great for leaning Paws one way or the other on affiliation.
Have not forgotten to respond. I just didn't pull quotes last night and I want to post what I have in my notes that I wrote last night at work then I'll go and look for what I'm talking about.
Have you played with wolf BC before? [Genuine question.] I'm not sure if you kept reading noob game after you died D1. Just making sure you are saying that BC sounds village to you not that you are comparing her to wolf!BC (since I don't really know if you've been in a game long enough with wolf!bc to know what her wolf self is like. Personally, I can’t tell when she’s wolf vs village so even if I see village feeling posts I still keep her in neutral.
Why? What are your current reads in general?
I know you no longer need a response but for the benefit of everyone else that list of neutral names I posted was not in any particular order. They're listed in the order players are on the rooster since I just went down the list and wrote names down as I went to ensure I listed everyone and didn't forget anyone.
If you want to get people behind you on your wolf suspect then ask them questions 😊 If they still seem wolfy to you then you'll have more evidence to point to to get others on your side. Citing female intuition gets you only so far and doesn't really push other villagers to get behind you. We can't trust that you aren't a wolf trying to use your intuition to make fake reads. Intuition isn't always correct anyway (see WWarriors).
did you every state why you felt better about barks? and forgive me if you have already stated, but what is your current read on barks?unlynch Barks
lynch 3m
Oh there I just wanted to make a 3-way tie to see what would happen haha. I feel better about Barks today than I did yesterday but not lock-village by any means. Weirds me out looking at your lynch tracker how she's the first vote on both the Doggo counterwagon as well as the 3m wagon.
I was weirded out by you switching from barks for no apparent reason (still none apparently) to following barks onto the 3m lynch
