Milkshake - Game Thread

Started by Animal Midwife
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

Browse articles Compare schools My application plan Read Interview Feedback
Practice for interviews Ask an Advisor
I need to go eat dinner. I'm not getting wolfy feels at the moment but based on POE (I still need to decide if I should get rid of my POE).

I'm unsure of the Paws lynch. There are some posts that make me feel better about them. When I initially read the interaction between paws and SARs it seemed WxV but then I reread it the next day and could see it WxW possibly and now I'm back to leaning it as WxV.

lynch sporty

What makes me hesitate slightly is the NK choice for N1. I'm just unsure in general right now but need to go eat.
 
genny said:
i get the sense that no one is living up to your wolf-hunting standards. not me, not coop, no one. all of us, just a bunch of slackers in the wolf-hunting department.
Click to expand...

Actually I think wondering is doing a fairly good job, as was doggo before they disappeared mid day. I think Alissa has done well today, especially with the effort to catch up with less then a few hours left
 
Dead is @StayingPositive2017 Peanut Butter Milkshake, vanilla townie

1560187532444.jpeg

​

Roster
2. @Doggo Labs
3. @Coopah
5. @Sunbodi
8. @BigCats
10. @alissa14
11. @WonderingStudent
12. @Kota1000
13. @Barkley13
14. @SportPonies
15. @genny
 
Last edited:
Dead is @PippyPony Cherry Milkshake, vanilla townie

main-qimg-69aafcf25e2526266cb14788b3bdea31

​

Roster
2. @Doggo Labs
3. @Coopah
8. @BigCats
10. @alissa14
11. @WonderingStudent
12. @Kota1000
13. @Barkley13
14. @SportPonies
15. @genny
 
Last edited:
Also this should go without saying but if you’re a JOAT and you’re about to get lynched please claim and list off your past actions
 
Also JOATs should probably claim tomorrow because we have two mislynches til LyLo and it would be pretty neat to have some confirmed villagers before whatever mess happens at LyLo (aka I am NOT dealing with fake joat claims at LyLo, y’all can spit those out sooner than that)
 
My feelings for genny are the same. I want to do some examination of Paws and Sunni interactions today, but I have AP calc testing and a lot of homework for my college and other AP classes, so I don’t know how active I’ll be today.

lynch genny
 
Well... looks like Sunbodi was telling the truth after all... I’m finishing up my in depth page-by-page analysis and then I’ll post that. Mainly looking at barks and sporty as the remaining pack
 
JustPaws said:
After reread really didn't like this post because it basically says here are a bunch of sketchy things, but I can't see the as sketchy, they just seem village, which is how I usually feel when wolfing so it made me tingley
Click to expand...
I was more thinking out loud as I read through. And it’s helpful now that I’m not sure we should clear people based on the D1 lynch like I thought when I made that post
 
WonderingStudent said:
Are you putting them as village based on posts or voting pattern?
Click to expand...
Alissa was based on posts + voting pattern
Doggo was not based on posts because she’s been pretty echoey but is based on self prezzing to SAR over Sunni and how SAR voted her over Sunni too
Doggo Labs said:
Today I am feeling slightly better about paws. If sunni is woof, I don't think I can picture her (paws) being woof. I would be okay with flipping sunni. If sunni is not woof, I would feel worse about paws and genny
Click to expand...
So are you planning to vote for genny today then?
 
alissa14 said:
Well... looks like Sunbodi was telling the truth after all... I’m finishing up my in depth page-by-page analysis and then I’ll post that. Mainly looking at barks and sporty as the remaining pack
Click to expand...

Why do you think Barks and Sporty are a pack?
 
BigCats said:
Also JOATs should probably claim tomorrow because we have two mislynches til LyLo and it would be pretty neat to have some confirmed villagers before whatever mess happens at LyLo (aka I am NOT dealing with fake joat claims at LyLo, y’all can spit those out sooner than that)
Click to expand...
This is such a bad idea I'm giving you side eye. They should keep their freaking heads down until they have something important to share and even then, try without outting yourself. (lesson if a noob is JOAT)

Welcome to the wolf list.

Lynch BC
 
alissa14 said:
Paws - mpm was not high on my radar AT ALL. The night kill choice was super weird plus paws voted to try to lynch her yesterday.. not super significant but I felt worth noting
Click to expand...
This sticks out to me knowing how paws flipped. Were you giving paws sketchy points for mpm dying? And if not I don’t understand how mpm dying has to do with paws
alissa14 said:
By the way if it wasnt clear I’m gonna lynch sporty. The way that the vote just casually moved towards 3M and away from paws and sporty that close to lynch close really rubbed me the wrong way. I think that sporty and paws while both high on my sketch radar are w/v
Click to expand...
What are your updates thoughts on this today?
 
Coopah said:
This is such a bad idea I'm giving you side eye. They should keep their freaking heads down until they have something important to share and even then, try without outting yourself. (lesson if a noob is JOAT)

Welcome to the wolf list.

Lynch BC
Click to expand...

I like this analysis. BC was in my neutral pile after I ISO’s yesterday, but after paws flipped they are my only other alive suspect besides genny now that I had feels on yesterday. I might have to do more isoing today.
 
Barkley13 said:
This sticks out to me knowing how paws flipped. Were you giving paws sketchy points for mpm dying? And if not I don’t understand how mpm dying has to do with paws

What are your updates thoughts on this today?
Click to expand...
I’m about to post my reads and my page by page analysis but I’ll respond to this first. The mpm paws theory was that mpm was the first vote on paws and it gained traction. I had a little tinfoil that mpm’s death could’ve been a revenge kill because I can’t think of any other explanation for it. So yes I gave paws a few sketch points for mpm’s death. Obviously we know now that that wasn’t the case because both have flipped village.

you’ll see my updated thoughts on sporty when I post my long analysis and reads list. I think on analysis sporty looks worse but I’ll hold off voting there until she responds because that’s only fair IMO (I went after her pretty hard...)
 
Okay so here’s my page by page notes that I have. Some pages have more comments than others because some pages just don’t have a lot that I feel need to be commented on. I typed up the majority of this in my phone notes last night and couldn’t quote anyone because the thread was locked. I finished the last 7 or so pages just now. I also updated my reads as I went and that will be in the next post. If anyone has questions tag me because my mom is bugging me to clean out my car. She’s mad at how much mud I’ve tracked in since I’ve been going to my internship at the farm lol


Genny lynches sunbodi D1 without any reasoning. Kinda curious... @genny was this a random vote or is this based on some previous game or..

Literally 0 thoughts. Everyone here either had no noteworthy content for me to mention or is dead

Again nothing to see here other than everyone debating on what MU is like and yadda yadda

@SportPonies 5-9 @ 8:37

“This is a fun question since she posted like, 2 times when you asked this. Not sure what I'm supposed to gather out of that.”

This is in response to mpm asking about Sporty’s thoughts on barks. Weirdly defensive IMO. @SportPonies do you have any thoughts on barks now?



Dubz submits a lynch vote for SAR based on a soul read. Quite impressive actually even though she didn’t stay on the SAR lynch. AM is there an awward for that? Lol

@Barkley13 5-9 @ 9:40 PM

“Why is SAR sketchy”

Were you just not reading the same level of sketch as everyone else? I get it that everyone makes mistakes but this quote doesn’t age well.

@ 9:45 there was a 3-way tie between SAR, sunbodi, and Doggo. I’m sure this has been mentioned before, but if doggo were SAR’s wolfy partner she could’ve easily made up some reason to switch her lynch to sunbodi and save both herself and SAR. There was enough time to make something up. But she didn’t. This basically clears doggo as village in my book.



Kota then ties up lynch between SAR and doggo at 9:54. At this point I think Kota is also clear from being a wolf. If doggo is village (based on VCA I think that’s the case), then why would Kota tie up lynch with a fellow wolf (SAR). Unless both SAR and doggo are wolves and are going for the ultimate bus of the century to gain hella village cred for a noob wolf, this scenario is highly unlikely. I tried to tie up the lynch because I thought both seemed kinda wolfy and wanted to see how they flipped but Kota beat me to it.



@ 9:57 BigCats questions if she likes the SAR lynch.



Kota comes in at 10:09 AM the following day with some solid reads



Poor BC, tricked by SAR again tsk tsk 😉

Low key I haven’t been able to read thread in depth as closely as I have tonight and I’m so sad at all the genny snark I missed! I especially like “I’m not making a list. I’m not Santa Claus”

@Barkley13 5-10 @ 12:41 PM

“Is the post you quoted why you’re saying she’s wishy washy? Because if so, how does saying she’ll be back later = wishy washy?”

In the other sporty quote it was sporty defending barks. Here it’s barks defending sporty. Is it possible these our are remaining wolves? I’ll keep reading and see.



More debate on the SAR lynch... I’ve already given my thoughts on it

Not seeing much from sporty yet...

Nothing really here except sunbodi came back



Again, I love reading the genny snark I missed.

Sunbodi - “a healthier approach to WW”

This made me lol



@WonderingStudent ties the Paws/Sporty lynch at 7:41 PM



Barks gives a good, long read list

I have nothing to say other than sunbodi is back

@Doggo Labs 5-10 @ 9:14

“Okay thanks”

This was super weird. You then explained some sort of phone glitch? Can you please re-explain what happened here? I’m confused if this was an actual glitch or we all are dumb and missed a rojo.



BigCats makes a 3 way tie between Sporty, Paws, and 3M at 9:28

@BigCats you were on barks’ lynch vote, then you moved off of the barks vote and on to 3M’s lynch (where barks was also sitting) without providing reasoning. Basically you switched your lynch from barks to the person that barks was lynching. Why did you do this? To create a tie? Weird move for you but I would say this isn’t something wolf!BC would go for.



Starting to think I took the bait on Barks’ post regarding 3M. Maybe she pushed the lynch that way??

Kota unlynches paws and swings over to 3M which leads to her lynch. Not a good look IMO but I still think Kota is relatively cleared from the D1 SAR lynch.

Barkley has some shiny tinfoil

Kota gives some in depth reads. I disagree with the genny read though

Wondering also gives in depth reads. Loving how she sounds here

@BigCats 5-11 @ 3:40 PM

“I feel better about Barks today than I did yesterday but not lock-village by any means. Weirds me out looking at your lynch tracker how she's the first vote on both the Doggo counterwagon as well as the 3m wagon.”

Yeah I noticed this too and gave barks some wolf points. I feel like she might be driving the lynch in the wrong direction and will keep an eye out for how she votes today

@BigCats 5-11 @ 6:00 PM

“Neato burrito, glad we had this chat”

You really kill me sometimes with the things you say lol although I think 1-800-IMA-WOLF is still my fave quote from you



Honestly based on the Suni interactions here I’m shocked not only was she the night kill choice but she also actually was telling the truth. If she was still alive I’d probably be lynching here today

I have no comment here other than the abundance of shiny tinfoil. I’m worried we’re letting the tinfoil get the best of us and it’s leading us nowhere. Don’t forget, wolves like shiny tinfoil too!

I strongly disagree with sporty’s analysis of BigCat’s here. She voted to lynch BC and it seems everyone disagreed with her. Idk why but it feels like sporty was trying to lead village in other directions. Especially since this was posted about an hour before lynch is closed.



Sporty puts out some shiny tinfoil that she thinks paws and coop are wolves without any explanation. This was done with less than an hour before lynch close.. idk it just feels like a distraction to me... especially since we now know paws is village

I think it’s weird based on the tie that Paws didn’t self prez on to Sunni... I also think based on the tie and the traction sunni was getting that she was the night kill choice.

@SportPonies you seem very frustrated that we didn’t lynch BigCats... I’m kind of wondering why.. I felt like your read of her was grasping at straws.. no offense. Maybe you just disagreed with her tone? Idk... her tone sounds like village!BC if you ask me



@BigCats 5-12 @ 10:38

“Also JOATs should probably claim tomorrow because we have two mislynches til LyLo and it would be pretty neat to have some confirmed villagers before whatever mess happens at LyLo (aka I am NOT dealing with fake joat claims at LyLo, y’all can spit those out sooner than that)”

Mehhh I have to disagree with this. Today being N4 means that JOATs have used their 3 abilities and will have some sort of results. Today they have the choice between all of their abilities. I suppose if JOATs outed themselves they could protect each other for one night. However, they would be open for wolves the following night and I just can’t see how it would be beneficial to village for them to out themselves. Plus people can still lie and there’s no way for us to know if someone is telling the truth. I think I may give you some wolf points for this
 
For the record I timestamped and tagged people in my analysis since I couldn’t quote
 
genny - the genny snark reads to me as super village genny. She also has given some very insightful reads that I’ve agreed with. Her line of questioning also seems very pro wolf-hunting so I have genny as my top village read. Village

WonderingStudent - you had some catching up to do but I think you’ve subbed in seamlessly. I’ve appreciated your reads and the effort you’ve put in to the game. I feel that you are acting in village’s best interests. Village

BigCats - it pains me a little to have you this high up 😉 but you’ve played as village!BC and I think we’ve played enough games together that I should be able to read you pretty well. Yeah you had some slip ups like the SAR lynch, but I think the 3 way tie you made sounded much better to me. I originally had you as village above wonder but your JOAT post from today made me reconsider. Village neutral

Doggo Labs - while i agree with your reads lists, I wish some of them had more content behind the reasoning of specific placements. I hope to see more from you so that I can move you higher up because while you feel village, I’d like to see more reasoning/content from you. Village Neutral

Coopah - looking back I found myself disagreeing with some of your thoughts and agreeing with others... wish I had more to say here but... I want to put you more as village but I can’t seem to decide to put you one way or the other... Dead neutral

Kota1000 - your D1 move on the SAR lynch bought you a lot of village points. Unless you are a wolf noob going for the ultimate bus. However, I’ve been seeing some of your moves as slightly wolfy like the 3M lynch... that’s what pinged me the most I think. I also have not always agreed with some of your reads and analysis but I appreciate the effort you’re putting in. Wolf Neutral.

Okay for these next two reads you’ll have to look back at my page by page analysis. I feel like in a lot of games I’ve played wolves have low key defended a fellow wolf once or twice so I really tried to look for that in the thread and I found some links between Sporty and Barks. I’ve been more suspicious of how Sporty has been so she’s my top wolf read. Barks also doesn’t look great on VCA.... I think I am also hesitant on Barks because it’s pinging me that she’s read me pretty consistently village throughout the game. While this is accurate, I feel like I usually get more backlash (not sure if this is the right word... maybe flack? Criticism? Critique? Push?) from her and that’s pinging me as weird too. Same for sporty, I feel like she fights me more than she has during this game. I am still deciding if sporty flips wolf, will that make Barks village or wolf? My gut says wolf but I need to ISO her more later.

Barkley13 - see above

SportPonies - see above

More notes on sporty: of the 3 way tie was sporty, paws, and 3M. Both 3M and paws flipped village and I find it kind of unlikely that it was v/v/v so that doesn’t help with my suspicions of sporty. Especially since I feel like she has slipped out of the lead these past few days..
Tl;dr I think sporty is the most wolfy candidate and I’m eager to see how she flips today. I will likely be voting to lynch there if I’m not satisfied with how she responds to my posts
 
You must log in or register to reply here.