Milkshake - Game Thread

[Coopah]

---

Members don't see this ad.

Can’t decide between Kota and sporty

Ok well one of those people voted for a wolf and one has not, go from there

 

[Coopah]

I'm mostly waiting for people to return to answer questions that I asked to make my decision.

Who are you thinking of again?

 

[Doggo Labs]

You have one sketchy post and it’s just me saying that genny is neutral? 😕
also I have no idea what game you’re referring to because I don’t even remember the last time I was a wolf

I didnt realize that game was that long ago... I thought it was only like 3 or 4 max... But as I said in my post, rereading parts of the thread have made you go down further on my list, the sketchy feels were initial and apparently not very strong on reread

 

[BigCats]

You're telling me that even though Kota could have successfully saved SAR, D1, she bussed her for credit? How does that make sense? I might be down to lynch her eventually for this but ultimately you're a much better suspect considering your VCA and the fact we're not essentially having to go off your tinfoil.

Literally how bad does it look to be the one to vote to save a wolf when folks start flipping? That’s a 2-for-1 special right there.

 

[WonderingStudent]

Who are you thinking of again?

I have posed questions to genny and sporty.

 

[Doggo Labs]

@ everyone who hasn’t voted yet, who are you thinking? Or are y’all just trying not to hammer?

I'm thinking between Kota, genny, and sport

 

[Doggo Labs]

Going to go make food, I'll be back later

 

[alissa14]

OOOoooo, i get what you were quoting my quote about now... the noob wolf you think is BC

Oooo I would NOT call BC a noob wolf. She power wolfed through the noob game and then led her team to victory. She also has a good track record as far as wolfing goes. She’s a strong player all around and I recommend you never underestimate her

 

[Coopah]

Literally how bad does it look to be the one to vote to save a wolf when folks start flipping? That’s a 2-for-1 special right there.

Except there was no way to know if SAR would go down the next day.

You literally were arguing that SAR was in imminent danger, then when I showed she wasn't you changed your tune. Just flip so I can be right please

 

[Kota1000]

I’m gonna five BC credit, they are very persistent. I think if they were a wolf they wouldn’t be pushing so hard on one thing. Going back to my genny lynch, and I’ll probably stay there unless something super AI unfolds

unlynch Bc
Lynch genny

 

[Coopah]

Oooo I would NOT call BC a noob wolf. She power wolfed through the noob game and then led her team to victory. She also has a good track record as far as wolfing goes. She’s a strong player all around and I recommend you never underestimate her

I wouldn't essentially call her a noob wolf either, but she still kinda is. She's prone to panic just like any noob

 

[Coopah]

I’m gonna five BC credit, they are very persistent. I think if they were a wolf they wouldn’t be pushing so hard on one thing. Going back to my genny lynch, and I’ll probably stay there unless something super AI unfolds

unlynch Bc
Lynch genny

 

[alissa14]

Kota/Sporty last two wolves, change my mind

Honestly Sporty has been on my radar for so long... I’m starting to see what y’all are saying about Kota 😱

 

[alissa14]

I will say that if sporty doesn’t come back to defend herself I’ll probably be with y’all on the Kota lynch. I think I’m pretty good with doggo right now

 

[alissa14]

Oops I meant barks. Both are dog related okay? Sometimes I get mixed up in my head. It especially didn’t help when they hydra’d in hannibal

 

[BigCats]

Except there was no way to know if SAR would go down the next day.

You literally were arguing that SAR was in imminent danger, then when I showed she wasn't you changed your tune. Just flip so I can be right please

SAR was ABSOLUTELY in imminent danger, I’m so confused by you rn. Like idk if you’re misinterpreting what I’m saying or I’m misunderstanding you but SAR was in very real danger and I can guarantee you she knew it.

 

[Coopah]

To be completely honest, you want to defend. Fight to the bitter end just like BC. However, that is by no means a reason not to lynch someone.

Can you just kill me tonight so I don't have to deal with this ish the rest of the game?

 

[Coopah]

SAR was ABSOLUTELY in imminent danger, I’m so confused by you rn. Like idk if you’re misinterpreting what I’m saying or I’m misunderstanding you but SAR was in very real danger and I can guarantee you she knew it.

If kota was a wolf, could very easily save SAR, no one would know. Hell she could've voted Sunni and SAR could've jumped to save herself. It wouldn't have been obvious. There were six minutes left in the lynch. You're saying she just bussed a wolf D1 and **** the consequences? Why?

 

[BigCats]

If kota was a wolf, could very easily save SAR, no one would know. Hell she could've voted Sunni and SAR could've jumped to save herself. It wouldn't have been obvious. There were six minutes left in the lynch. You're saying she just bussed a wolf D1 and **** the consequences? Why?

Arrrrrrgghhhhh this is the only thing you’ve said that actually makes sense

 

[Coopah]

Arrrrrrgghhhhh this is the only thing you’ve said that actually makes sense

IT'S WHAT I'VE BEEN SAYING THE WHOLE TIME

 

[BigCats]

IT'S WHAT I'VE BEEN SAYING THE WHOLE TIME

IM TRYING MY BEST OKAY

 

[Coopah]

Where the **** is Kota? why have I been defending her all damn day and she's hiding in my shadow?

 

[BigCats]

Ughhhh okay time to recalibrate my brain. And Kota unvoting me just now even though that ties us is not a wise wolfy move. Ughhhhh

 

[BigCats]

Unless she’s purposefully staying off a wagon to see where it goes but ughhhhh

 

[Coopah]

Oops I meant barks. Both are dog related okay? Sometimes I get mixed up in my head. It especially didn’t help when they hydra’d in hannibal

Are you voting? I've lost track of the tally

 

[alissa14]

I've been trying to think of the same. I can't make it fit genny unless my shiny shiny improbable tinfoil is true.

I honestly have no idea who’s kill choices these are... what’s your genny tinfoil because I can’t even come up with a tinfoil that would make sense other than wolves are doing something dumb like RNG every night or flipping a coin! I don’t even know!!

 

[alissa14]

@ everyone who hasn’t voted yet, who are you thinking? Or are y’all just trying not to hammer?

Waiting for sporty to come back. Might ping her on Snapchat because I feel like she has a lot of people to answer to

 

[Animal Midwife]

Reminder that Outside Communication is not allowed unless it's between mafia members.​

 

[Animal Midwife]

Day 4 Lynch Tally
Kota (1) - BC
genny (1) - Kota
BC (1) - Coop

3/9
lynch close in ~2.5 hours

 

[Kota1000]

Where the **** is Kota? why have I been defending her all damn day and she's hiding in my shadow?

I have tried to defend my self multiple times BC just won’t listen, I’ve decided not to waste my efforts. Also, I had my AP calc test today and AP chem homework and all sorts of other RL stuff so I’m not really in the mood to try and salvage my reputation at the moment, hence my reveal as a vanillager which no one seems to care about, so what the **** is the point of a role reveal anyway if no one believes?

 

[Kota1000]

Unless she’s purposefully staying off a wagon to see where it goes but ughhhhh

I wouldn’t call 2 votes a wagon, there are still 6 people who have not voted anyways.

 

[WonderingStudent]

(Credit to paws for lynch tracker for D1 and 2)
D1 Lynch Tracker
SAR - BC
WZ - paws
Sunni - genny
doggo - bark
WZ - paws
WZ - sporty
stagg/wonder - WZ
3m - paws
paws - coop
paws - coop, 3m
WZ - sporty, kota
paws - coop, 3m
sporty - 3m
bc - alissa
SAR - bc
sunbodi - genny, bc
bc - alissa
sunbodi - genny, bc, alissa
3m - paws
kota - SAR
stagg/wonder - WZ
SAR - WZ
SAR - WZ, mpm
doggo - bark, paws
paws - coop
SAR - WZ, mpm, coop
SAR - WZ, mpm, coop, doggo
SAR - WZ, mpm, coop, doggo
doggo - bark, paws, WZ
kota - SAR
doggo - bark, paws, WZ, SAR
WZ - sporty, kota
SAR - mpm, coop, doggo, kota
sunni - genny, bc, alissa
SAR - mpm, coop, doggo, kota, alissa

Final Day 1 Lynch Tally
SAR (5) - mpm, Coop, Doggo, Kota, alissa
dubz (1) - Sporty
Suni (2) - genny, BC
Doggo (4) - Barks, Paws, dubz, SAR
Stagg/wonder () -
3m () -
Paws () -
Sporty (1) - 3m
BC () -
Kota () -

13/15
Missing: Stagg, Suni



Lynch Tracker Day 2
sport (1) - paws
genny (1) - kota
sport (2) - paws, 3m
paws (1) - mpm
genny () - kota
BC (1)- kota
doggo (1) - coop
paws - (2) - mpm, genny
doggo () - coop
paws (3) - mpm, genny, coop
BC () - kota
paws (4) - mpm, genny, coop, kota
paws (3) -mpm, genny, coop, kota
barks (1) - genny
kota (1) - sunni
sport (3 ) - paws, 3m, wondering
kota () - sunni
wondering (1) - sunni
sun (1) - alissa
sun () - alissa
doggo (1) - sport
barks (2) - genny, BC
3m (1) - barks
3m (2) - barks, alissa
barks (1) - genny, BC
sun (1) - genny
doggo () - sport
bark () - BC
3m - bark, alissa, BC
sun (2) - genny, doggo
sporty (2) - paws, 3m, wondering
paws (2) - mpm, coop, kota
3m (4) - bark, alissa, BC, kota
mpm (1) - paws
paws (3) - mpm, coop, sport

Final Day 2 Lynch Tally
Sporty (2) - 3m, Wonder
genny () -
Paws (3) - mpm, Coop, Sporty
BC () -
Doggo () -
Barks () -
Kota () -
Wonder (1) - Suni
Suni (2) - genny, Doggo
3m (4) - Barks, alissa, BC, Kota
mpm (1) - Paws

13/13

Lynch Tracker Day 3

Kota - BC
suni - genny
suni - genny, bark
genny - kota
BC - sport
Kota - BC, coop
suni - genny, bark, paws
coop - sun
suni - genny, bark, paws, doggo
suni - genny, bark, paws, doggo
sport - alissa
sport - alissa
paws - alissa
genny - kota
paws - alissa, kota
Kota - BC, coop
paws - alissa, kota, coop
sport - wonder

Final Day 3 Lynch Tally
Kota (1) - BC
Suni (3) - Barks, genny, Doggo
genny () -
BC (1) - Sporty
Coop (1) - Suni
Sporty (1) - Wonder
Paws (3) - alissa, Kota, Coop

10/11
Missing: Paws

 

[alissa14]

Reminder that Outside Communication is not allowed unless it's between mafia members.​

Oop sorry Animal EnforcerWife pls don’t mod kill me

 

[Coopah]

I have tried to defend my self multiple times BC just won’t listen, I’ve decided not to waste my efforts. Also, I had my AP calc test today and AP chem homework and all sorts of other RL stuff so I’m not really in the mood to try and salvage my reputation at the moment, hence my reveal as a vanillager which no one seems to care about, so what the **** is the point of a role reveal anyway if no one believes?

Will you at least self prez? Because dear god if one more person doesn't do this I will scream. It will be loud, you may hear it.

 

[alissa14]

Are you voting? I've lost track of the tally

I’d like to see sport come back before I put my vote there

 

[Coopah]

(Credit to paws for lynch tracker for D1 and 2)
D1 Lynch Tracker
SAR - BC
WZ - paws
Sunni - genny
doggo - bark
WZ - paws
WZ - sporty
stagg/wonder - WZ
3m - paws
paws - coop
paws - coop, 3m
WZ - sporty, kota
paws - coop, 3m
sporty - 3m
bc - alissa
SAR - bc
sunbodi - genny, bc
bc - alissa
sunbodi - genny, bc, alissa
3m - paws
kota - SAR
stagg/wonder - WZ
SAR - WZ
SAR - WZ, mpm
doggo - bark, paws
paws - coop
SAR - WZ, mpm, coop
SAR - WZ, mpm, coop, doggo
SAR - WZ, mpm, coop, doggo
doggo - bark, paws, WZ
kota - SAR
doggo - bark, paws, WZ, SAR
WZ - sporty, kota
SAR - mpm, coop, doggo, kota
sunni - genny, bc, alissa
SAR - mpm, coop, doggo, kota, alissa

Final Day 1 Lynch Tally
SAR (5) - mpm, Coop, Doggo, Kota, alissa
dubz (1) - Sporty
Suni (2) - genny, BC
Doggo (4) - Barks, Paws, dubz, SAR
Stagg/wonder () -
3m () -
Paws () -
Sporty (1) - 3m
BC () -
Kota () -

13/15
Missing: Stagg, Suni



Lynch Tracker Day 2
sport (1) - paws
genny (1) - kota
sport (2) - paws, 3m
paws (1) - mpm
genny () - kota
BC (1)- kota
doggo (1) - coop
paws - (2) - mpm, genny
doggo () - coop
paws (3) - mpm, genny, coop
BC () - kota
paws (4) - mpm, genny, coop, kota
paws (3) -mpm, genny, coop, kota
barks (1) - genny
kota (1) - sunni
sport (3 ) - paws, 3m, wondering
kota () - sunni
wondering (1) - sunni
sun (1) - alissa
sun () - alissa
doggo (1) - sport
barks (2) - genny, BC
3m (1) - barks
3m (2) - barks, alissa
barks (1) - genny, BC
sun (1) - genny
doggo () - sport
bark () - BC
3m - bark, alissa, BC
sun (2) - genny, doggo
sporty (2) - paws, 3m, wondering
paws (2) - mpm, coop, kota
3m (4) - bark, alissa, BC, kota
mpm (1) - paws
paws (3) - mpm, coop, sport

Final Day 2 Lynch Tally
Sporty (2) - 3m, Wonder
genny () -
Paws (3) - mpm, Coop, Sporty
BC () -
Doggo () -
Barks () -
Kota () -
Wonder (1) - Suni
Suni (2) - genny, Doggo
3m (4) - Barks, alissa, BC, Kota
mpm (1) - Paws

13/13

Lynch Tracker Day 3

Kota - BC
suni - genny
suni - genny, bark
genny - kota
BC - sport
Kota - BC, coop
suni - genny, bark, paws
coop - sun
suni - genny, bark, paws, doggo
suni - genny, bark, paws, doggo
sport - alissa
sport - alissa
paws - alissa
genny - kota
paws - alissa, kota
Kota - BC, coop
paws - alissa, kota, coop
sport - wonder

Final Day 3 Lynch Tally
Kota (1) - BC
Suni (3) - Barks, genny, Doggo
genny () -
BC (1) - Sporty
Coop (1) - Suni
Sporty (1) - Wonder
Paws (3) - alissa, Kota, Coop

10/11
Missing: Paws

HOLY ****! I'VE GOT IT

 

[Coopah]

(Credit to paws for lynch tracker for D1 and 2)
D1 Lynch Tracker
SAR - BC
WZ - paws
Sunni - genny
doggo - bark
WZ - paws
WZ - sporty
stagg/wonder - WZ
3m - paws
paws - coop
paws - coop, 3m
WZ - sporty, kota
paws - coop, 3m
sporty - 3m
bc - alissa
SAR - bc
sunbodi - genny, bc
bc - alissa
sunbodi - genny, bc, alissa
3m - paws
kota - SAR
stagg/wonder - WZ
SAR - WZ
SAR - WZ, mpm
doggo - bark, paws
paws - coop
SAR - WZ, mpm, coop
SAR - WZ, mpm, coop, doggo
SAR - WZ, mpm, coop, doggo
doggo - bark, paws, WZ
kota - SAR
doggo - bark, paws, WZ, SAR
WZ - sporty, kota
SAR - mpm, coop, doggo, kota
sunni - genny, bc, alissa
SAR - mpm, coop, doggo, kota, alissa

Final Day 1 Lynch Tally
SAR (5) - mpm, Coop, Doggo, Kota, alissa
dubz (1) - Sporty
Suni (2) - genny, BC
Doggo (4) - Barks, Paws, dubz, SAR
Stagg/wonder () -
3m () -
Paws () -
Sporty (1) - 3m
BC () -
Kota () -

13/15
Missing: Stagg, Suni



Lynch Tracker Day 2
sport (1) - paws
genny (1) - kota
sport (2) - paws, 3m
paws (1) - mpm
genny () - kota
BC (1)- kota
doggo (1) - coop
paws - (2) - mpm, genny
doggo () - coop
paws (3) - mpm, genny, coop
BC () - kota
paws (4) - mpm, genny, coop, kota
paws (3) -mpm, genny, coop, kota
barks (1) - genny
kota (1) - sunni
sport (3 ) - paws, 3m, wondering
kota () - sunni
wondering (1) - sunni
sun (1) - alissa
sun () - alissa
doggo (1) - sport
barks (2) - genny, BC
3m (1) - barks
3m (2) - barks, alissa
barks (1) - genny, BC
sun (1) - genny
doggo () - sport
bark () - BC
3m - bark, alissa, BC
sun (2) - genny, doggo
sporty (2) - paws, 3m, wondering
paws (2) - mpm, coop, kota
3m (4) - bark, alissa, BC, kota
mpm (1) - paws
paws (3) - mpm, coop, sport

Final Day 2 Lynch Tally
Sporty (2) - 3m, Wonder
genny () -
Paws (3) - mpm, Coop, Sporty
BC () -
Doggo () -
Barks () -
Kota () -
Wonder (1) - Suni
Suni (2) - genny, Doggo
3m (4) - Barks, alissa, BC, Kota
mpm (1) - Paws

13/13

Lynch Tracker Day 3

Kota - BC
suni - genny
suni - genny, bark
genny - kota
BC - sport
Kota - BC, coop
suni - genny, bark, paws
coop - sun
suni - genny, bark, paws, doggo
suni - genny, bark, paws, doggo
sport - alissa
sport - alissa
paws - alissa
genny - kota
paws - alissa, kota
Kota - BC, coop
paws - alissa, kota, coop
sport - wonder

Final Day 3 Lynch Tally
Kota (1) - BC
Suni (3) - Barks, genny, Doggo
genny () -
BC (1) - Sporty
Coop (1) - Suni
Sporty (1) - Wonder
Paws (3) - alissa, Kota, Coop

10/11
Missing: Paws

They've been walking down the line of who voted for SAR. Not a foolproof theory but look at the lynch tracker. It's the only thing that makes sense. The other thing I've just thought of was that they thought Sunni was lying about being a vanillager so they killed her.

 

[Barkley13]

HOLY ****! I'VE GOT IT

What

 

[Barkley13]

They've been walking down the line of who voted for SAR. Not a foolproof theory but look at the lynch tracker. It's the only thing that makes sense. The other thing I've just thought of was that they thought Sunni was lying about being a vanillager so they killed her.

Only mpm ended up on SAR though? Unless you mean people that voted for her at some point in the day

 

[alissa14]

They've been walking down the line of who voted for SAR. Not a foolproof theory but look at the lynch tracker. It's the only thing that makes sense. The other thing I've just thought of was that they thought Sunni was lying about being a vanillager so they killed her.

I don’t know about that... that’s such an odd way to decide night kills unless it’s two noob wolves by themselves...

 

[Coopah]

Only mpm ended up on SAR though? Unless you mean people that voted for her at some point in the day

Well think about it, dubz started the SAR train plus she's a strong player, might as well get rid of her early, then mpm is basically cleared because of her position on the SAR lynch. Then they thought (I'm totally guessing) Sunni was JOAT and killed her.

 

[Coopah]

I don’t know about that... that’s such an odd way to decide night kills unless it’s two noob wolves by themselves...

I mean the night kills were odd. There's no debating that. I don't think this'll give us much info I just wanted to point this out for others.

 

[Coopah]

Paws (3) - alissa, Kota, Coop

10/11
Missing: Paws

PAWS WHY?! 😢

 

[alissa14]

Well think about it, dubz started the SAR train plus she's a strong player, might as well get rid of her early, then mpm is basically cleared because of her position on the SAR lynch. Then they thought (I'm totally guessing) Sunni was JOAT and killed her.

It’s an interesting theory for sure and I can see how that would make sense. Based on this theory, who do you think would be tonight’s choice?

 

[Coopah]

It’s an interesting theory for sure and I can see how that would make sense. Based on this theory, who do you think would be tonight’s choice?

me

 

[WonderingStudent]

PAWS WHY?! 😢

I already said you all need to lynch me to get out of your tunnels or I'm gonna get dragged to end game on purpose as the mislynch

I understand why paws didn't self-prez. Was for the good of the village in a sense so people would get out of tunneling them.

 

[BigCats]

unlynch Kota

while I ruminate

 

[BigCats]

It’s an interesting theory for sure and I can see how that would make sense. Based on this theory, who do you think would be tonight’s choice?

Holy sketchballs alissa omg

 

[Kota1000]

Will you at least self prez? Because dear god if one more person doesn't do this I will scream. It will be loud, you may hear it.

If it gets to that yes I will, there’s still plenty of time

 

[Animal Midwife]

Day 4 Lynch Tally
Kota () -
genny (1) - Kota
BC (1) - Coop

2/9
lynch close in ~2 hours