Kraazy

10+ Year Member
7+ Year Member
Feb 17, 2007
304
0
Status
MD/PhD Student
I'm currently in MS2 and I am thinking of going through with MS3 before starting grad school. I've already talked about it with a few students in my program who are doing the same thing, but they're all either in MS3 or G1. I would love to hear from someone who did MS3 before grad school and has either gone back to the wards or applied for residency. I am kind concerned about the timing of residency application and how that might affect my flexibility in terms of how much time I take for my PhD.

[Side note, I'm doing my PhD in Epidemiology, which means that I'll have a ton of coursework and I have to start grad school in the fall because of course sequences.]

Thanks for the advice!
 

Shifty B

10+ Year Member
Aug 13, 2008
452
97
Status
Attending Physician
I completed an MSTP program several years ago, and although I didn't do my MS3 before my PhD I will comment because I feel strongly about this. I think it is a bad idea on multiple levels. In fact, I cannot believe that your program even allows it. It seems like it would encourage people to bail out of their PhD.

First of all, the first two years of medical school are minimally relevant to your practice of medicine, so it doesn't really matter that you've forgotten most of it when you go back to the wards for your MS3. You can rapidly pick up the clinical skills that you need when you get back, and the little knowledge you need you can learn quickly However, when you become an intern, you want your practical medical knowledge (all from MS3) to be as close as possible. There is often not going to be anyone to tell you what to do.

You might say, well, you can brush up on your skills during your MS4. At most schools, MS4 is a joke that is basically designed to let you take leisurely electives during interviews.

Second, most of the knowledge needed for step 2 and step 3 is from your MS3. A large gap between them, particularly if you do a specialty (anesthesia, rads, derm), is only going to make step 3 more of a pain. Let's face it, your 6 year old knowledge of OB isn't getting any better.

Third, being that close to the end of the MD is going to make it all the more painful to finish your PhD for 4 long years when you know you have only 4 clinical months left and could just bail.

Finally, I might just ask what your actual motivation is, because it doesn't really change the timing. Moving your MS3 to before your PhD doesn't change the fact that there is going to be a critical time of the year after which you must finish or wait another year. It's just going to shift this deadline.

IMO, bad idea. Maybe someone else can offer you more constructive advice.
 

StIGMA

Doctor Professor
10+ Year Member
Jul 6, 2008
1,019
162
Status
Resident [Any Field]
Are you referring to doing part of 3rd year (like your IM rotation) before grad school (a few MD/PhD programs allow this) or your entire MS3 year?

There are some advantages to doing a 3rd year rotation before you PhD if you think it will significantly affect your dissertation research or you just absolutely can't wait to get your feet wet, but I agree with Shifty that doing MS3 many years before residency is just a flat out bad idea.