I like mongrain too, but they are radically different styles. One thing, John's main focus is on the 11 string (he rips off that octave G). Erik kind of specializes in the tapping..although he is a very good fingerstyle/strummer player as well. I've seen his normal 6 string, and while it is good..it isn't spectacular. Better than me, but that isn't saying much. I still want his Rainsong guitar though. John isn't really doing tapping FOR the song as much as part of the song...also slightly tougher when you're hitting the strings at once. For a song like air tap, at least he can throw on some heavier strings and add mass to those high strings...getting it a little louder, in addition to the insanely high near lapsteel level action on the guitars for tapping. If you saw August Rush, all that tapping was done by a girl by the name of Kaki King. If I wanted to listen to crazy talented or hard acoustic stuff then I'd probably wind up with Tommy Emmaneul, Andy McKee, Michael Hedges, Leo Kottke etc. I use a 12 string as my main instrument lately though, and I am a huge fan of open tunings, bottle neck, AND drumming. All of which John incorporates (Leo does too). If you want to check out some pretty cool slide on an 11 string, then betterman or pickapart is up there with the good groove.
[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a0mqLRsjzWU&feature=related[/YOUTUBE]
[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UySmu-QaPW0&feature=related[/YOUTUBE]
Also, John's band is insanely talented...makes him sound better usually. I wish I could half hang with their drummer. (I play drums too...although not much lately) The band in the second video of pickapart is not his current band. There is a reason it is John Butler Trio...he tends to sub in new guys, although the last 2 albums I don't think he has.
Oh, and as an aside. If any of you like acoustic stuff then I highly recommend you look up all those people mentioned in addition to Erik Mongrain as posted above. I can probably list off 10 or 15 others, but I'm lazy...if you really want to know then PM me and I'll tell you. I doubt many of you give a damn though.