meaning he himself is not one of the med students who aids/assists/takes an active role in the admissions process at xyz med school
That's evident, but I think everyone else is more interested in what Myuu has to say. I'm always interested to hear the ADCOM side of things. I know people who have been accepted to Hopkins/Harvard/(name your top few schools) who weren't even granted an interview at other elite schools...and these are kids who applied June 1 with 3.9/35+ MCATs, great ECs and/or research, and really compelling personal statements. From where I stand, there does seem to be quite a bit of randomness to the process. I can't imagine this isn't the case, since plenty of schools see "perfect" applicants in the first month the AMCAS is open...there are only so many slots just for interviews!
Myuu, please share your pearls of wisdom. Seriously, it's more valuable to all of us (you were here not so long ago) to hear from the "other side," rather than speculation from a multitude of pre-meds who aren't privy to the information you have. One of my classmates was not offered an interview at Duke (her top choice, which is informally 6th in the country?), but has been accepted to 14 schools including Harvard, Case, Mayo, Hopkins, Columbia, and many others. She has a 3.96 (one A- ever), 40 MCAT, eight years of experience working for a particular volunteer-based organization, four years of research including two second author publications, and a true hardship story that includes losing her mother and father before she was 20. She's annoyingly likable, to boot
Of course she's attained the grail, and would be hard-pressed to get sympathy from anyone, but why didn't Duke even grant her a glance at admissions? Not that hers is a sob story, but if the "perfect applicant" didn't even get an interview at her top choice, isn't there SOME randomness to the process? And what chance do regular folks with 3.6-3.8GPA/30-34 MCAT scores have?