- Joined
- Jul 11, 2003
- Messages
- 187
- Reaction score
- 0
OK so I submitted a paper to a journal and 3 months later I finally got a response. They said that it needed "minor" revisions. The actual quote from the reviewer was:
Ok so this sounds like I have a decent chance of publication. However, this reviewer's critique is too vague. He didnt tell me anything about which part of the paper should be cut.
I didnt think it was that long anyways. In Microsoft Word, its about 30 pages, but thats double spaced large text. I'm assuming that when they actually publish it in the journal it will be much smaller in length because they use very small typeset and single spacing.
OK, so where I need help is what parts to cut out. Any and all comments appreciated.
You can find the paper online by clicking the link below. Unfortunately, I had to put all the figures/tables as separate files, because the web site had a maximum upload file size of 1 MB.
http://devildoc3.95mb.com/
This is an important manuscript. Local deliveryapproaches for the
management of BPH and cancer are increasing. For these to be rational, it
is critical to be able to evaluate the distribution of delivered agent. The
is the focus of the present manuscript. Overall, there is little to quibble
with in this manuscript other than it's length. The authors can reduce the
length by at least one-third without losing any detail needed.
Ok so this sounds like I have a decent chance of publication. However, this reviewer's critique is too vague. He didnt tell me anything about which part of the paper should be cut.
I didnt think it was that long anyways. In Microsoft Word, its about 30 pages, but thats double spaced large text. I'm assuming that when they actually publish it in the journal it will be much smaller in length because they use very small typeset and single spacing.
OK, so where I need help is what parts to cut out. Any and all comments appreciated.
You can find the paper online by clicking the link below. Unfortunately, I had to put all the figures/tables as separate files, because the web site had a maximum upload file size of 1 MB.
http://devildoc3.95mb.com/