Need help choosing a challenge/adversity essay topic

[minnie123]

---

Members do not see this ad.

Hi! I'm working on my challenge essay and had two possible ideas to go off, and wanted to see if anyone has advice on which one I should choose.

1) Growing up in a homophobic family and realizing I was bisexual. I knew I would lose their support if I came out, but overcame this by forming by own support system through close friends, people who've gone through the same experience, and LGBT+ groups on campus. I wanted to talk about how I learned how to seek support and stay true to myself even in difficult situations which I feel is valuable for med school. (Not sure if not having family support would be a red flag?)

2) I lived in a predominantly white area for most of my life and tried to fit in by changing myself to fit the majority and disregarding my culture. Over time I realized how harmful that mindset was so I started to embrace my culture and appreciate my differences, which has helped me value diversity and self-expression.


Not sure if these would be okay, or if I should go with something more medically relevant like my volunteer experiences? Any advice would be appreciated, thank you!

 

[Mr.Smile12]

What are the specific prompts?

 

[hihihohohaha84]

I think both ideas are fantastic. Mine is very similar to (1). I chose to only write briefly about the homophobic part (1/4-1/3 of the essay) and I spent the rest talking about how I have changed and how that experience helped me contribute to the community as well as approach relationships in life. I think the advice is to not dive to deep into the traumas and negativity but use it as a tool for reflection.

 

[minnie123]

What are the specific prompts?

Describe a significant challenge that has prepared you for the MD career path.

I do have other challenges I can talk about (becoming the VP of a volunteer organization and learning to navigate a leadership role, or becoming a hospice volunteer and being nervous to deal with a new patient demographic) but these don't really feel 'significant' to me, and I already touched on them in other parts of my application so I was hoping to include something new.

 

[Mr.Smile12]

Describe a significant challenge that has prepared you for the MD career path.

I do have other challenges I can talk about (becoming the VP of a volunteer organization and learning to navigate a leadership role, or becoming a hospice volunteer and being nervous to deal with a new patient demographic) but these don't really feel 'significant' to me, and I already touched on them in other parts of my application so I was hoping to include something new.

Pay attention to how you connect your answers to preparing you for becoming a physician. See which topic you feel more comfortable sharing after you write them.

 

[minnie123]

I think both ideas are fantastic. Mine is very similar to (1). I chose to only write briefly about the homophobic part (1/4-1/3 of the essay) and I spent the rest talking about how I have changed and how that experience helped me contribute to the community as well as approach relationships in life. I think the advice is to not dive to deep into the traumas and negativity but use it as a tool for reflection.

That's very helpful, thank you! In my draft I definitely kept the 'challenge' part short and used the majority of the word count to talk about how I dealt with the situation and what I learned. I will most likely go with #1 then, thanks again : )