Neurosurgery Vs Interventional Radiology

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Alright guys. I saw the light, or in this case the dark. I will be only applying to DR, and if i still have the interventional bug I will apply DR->Neuro Rad->NIR.
Members don't see this ad.
 
  • Like
  • Wow
  • Love
Reactions: 19 users
libertyyne said:
Alright guys. I saw the light, or in this case the dark. I will be only applying to DR, and if i still have the interventional bug I will apply DR->Neuro Rad->NIR.
Click to expand...

What made you change your mind??
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Chlorini said:
What made you change your mind??
Click to expand...
I looked at the primary literature for spine. I had a hard time thinking i would have to do 80% spine in my career going forward with that in mind.
I dont like that i would essentially be incentivized to do as much spine as i possibly could.

I have financial responsibilities towards my parents and a family, rads programs tend to allow a good amount of moonlighting which would help me fulfill those obligations a lot sooner than Neuro.

NIR would be a shorter pathway from rads 5+2 vs the 7+1 for neurosurgery.

Rads flexibility allows me to have some side gigs i have been interested in pursuing and obviously spending more time with family.

I also think , Rads is inherently undervalued at this time due to overblown fears of AI.


I am kinda over medicine. i know that sounds crazy, and maybe that is just a temporary depression associated with the loss of something that i wanted for a few years. Or maybe just burn out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 16 users
Members don't see this ad :)
libertyyne said:
I looked at the primary literature for spine. I had a hard time thinking i would have to do 80% spine in my career going forward with that in mind.
I dont like that i would essentially be incentivized to do as much spine as i possibly could.

I have financial responsibilities towards my parents and a family, rads programs tend to allow a good amount of moonlighting which would help me fulfill those obligations a lot sooner than Neuro.

NIR would be a shorter pathway from rads 5+2 vs the 7+1 for neurosurgery.

Rads flexibility allows me to have some side gigs i have been interested in pursuing and obviously spending more time with family.

I also think , Rads is inherently undervalued at this time due to overblown fears of AI.


I am kinda over medicine. i know that sounds crazy, and maybe that is just a temporary depression associated with the loss of something that i wanted for a few years. Or maybe just burn out.
Click to expand...

I relate to that haha. I just finished an inpatient medicine rotation (I'm in my transitional year) and let me tell you--there have been exactly 0 times that I wished I pursued internal medicine or any of its subspecialties.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
libertyyne said:
I looked at the primary literature for spine. I had a hard time thinking i would have to do 80% spine in my career going forward with that in mind.
I dont like that i would essentially be incentivized to do as much spine as i possibly could.

I have financial responsibilities towards my parents and a family, rads programs tend to allow a good amount of moonlighting which would help me fulfill those obligations a lot sooner than Neuro.

NIR would be a shorter pathway from rads 5+2 vs the 7+1 for neurosurgery.

Rads flexibility allows me to have some side gigs i have been interested in pursuing and obviously spending more time with family.

I also think , Rads is inherently undervalued at this time due to overblown fears of AI.


I am kinda over medicine. i know that sounds crazy, and maybe that is just a temporary depression associated with the loss of something that i wanted for a few years. Or maybe just burn out.
Click to expand...

What gaming chair are you going to buy when you do telerads from your vacation home
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: 8 users
aaronrodgers said:
What gaming chair are you going to buy when you do telerads from your vacation home
Click to expand...
1602724412646.png

There can be only one.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 9 users
libertyyne said:
I looked at the primary literature for spine. I had a hard time thinking i would have to do 80% spine in my career going forward with that in mind.
I dont like that i would essentially be incentivized to do as much spine as i possibly could.

I have financial responsibilities towards my parents and a family, rads programs tend to allow a good amount of moonlighting which would help me fulfill those obligations a lot sooner than Neuro.

NIR would be a shorter pathway from rads 5+2 vs the 7+1 for neurosurgery.

Rads flexibility allows me to have some side gigs i have been interested in pursuing and obviously spending more time with family.

I also think , Rads is inherently undervalued at this time due to overblown fears of AI.


I am kinda over medicine. i know that sounds crazy, and maybe that is just a temporary depression associated with the loss of something that i wanted for a few years. Or maybe just burn out.
Click to expand...
Rads to NIR will be 1 (internship) + 4 (DR) + 1 (diag neurorad) + 2 (NIR; 1 nonaccredited year, 1 accredited year) = 8
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Cognovi said:
Rads to NIR will be 1 (internship) + 4 (DR) + 1 (diag neurorad) + 2 (NIR; 1 nonaccredited year, 1 accredited year) = 8
Click to expand...
I am not well versed on this but there are some programs that will only be 1 year post neurorads training .or that have combined 2 years of neuro rads and nir. Also would love to hear some recs from you in the wamc thread in radiology with my interest in nir in mind .
 
Best of luck in whatever you end up doing libertyyne, been following your predicament in the last few months. Hope you find what you're looking for out there, medicine is one hell of a beast.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
libertyyne said:
I am kinda over medicine. i know that sounds crazy, and maybe that is just a temporary depression associated with the loss of something that i wanted for a few years. Or maybe just burn out.
Click to expand...

It's funny you mentioned this, because I felt the same way when I pivoted to ophtho. I could have written this exact line myself. I am still super excited for my chosen career, but I'm a bit tired at the moment and there is a feeling of loss associated with letting something go that you held onto for a long time.

I think we will feel better and more of the fire will come back once we have some off time in 4th year and settle in to our new paths.

Edit: If any PDs happen to find this... just kidding about the above. Medicine is life. My passion for eyes never waivers. I will work 16 hour days 7 days a week until I die. Please interview me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 15 users
Loving all the discussion about NIR in this thread. Def a pathway I'm considering which doesn't get discussed enough on here. Wish there were some NIR attendings active on the forum
 
Members don't see this ad :)
Cognovi said:
Rads to NIR will be 1 (internship) + 4 (DR) + 1 (diag neurorad) + 2 (NIR; 1 nonaccredited year, 1 accredited year) = 8
Click to expand...
Not necessarily true. Depends on how much NIR exposure he gets in residency. Might only be one year NIR. You need 200 cerebral procedures, I will have well over that when I graduate.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
NDcienporciento100 said:
Not necessarily true. Depends on how much NIR exposure he gets in residency. Might only be one year NIR. You need 200 cerebral procedures, I will have well over that when I graduate.
Click to expand...
Some programs have a lot of elective time. hoping i can squeeze in some of the requirements.
I would be ecstatic if i could squeeze training in 7 vs 8.
 
Crazy, this thread is 6 pages long!!!!!

Neurosurgery is great field and so is IR or NIR. I would never switch out of IR but that said if someone told me I had to and I could pick any field it would probably be neurosurgery. Both fields on the cutting edge. When it comes to those people writing posts about the bad parts of each specialty. All fields!!! And I do mean all fields, have things that are not glamorous and not fun. For me it’s putting drains in surgical nightmares or doing a picc no one else can. You have to decide if you can live with that. I personally think drains and picks are kinda fun and don’t mind them and if somehow I could find a way to do them without having to talk to the general surgery team I’d actually look forward to them lol. For those that have there mind set on NIR really look at the three specialty’s that do it Neurosurgery, neurology, and radiology a whole and decide what things you can live with from each specialty that have nothing to do with NIR.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
libertyyne said:
Some programs have a lot of elective time. hoping i can squeeze in some of the requirements.
I would be ecstatic if i could squeeze training in 7 vs 8.
Click to expand...
Go to a program with no NIR fellows that is comprehensive stroke center.
 
NDcienporciento100 said:
165 comprehensive stroke centers in US and 30 something NIR fellowships I’ll leave the rest in your competent hands.
Click to expand...
Here's what I got

Duke
Mayo Rochester
Cornell
Mount Sinai
UCLA
Cleveland Clinic
UAB
Northwestern
Yale
Colorado
Georgetown
UChicago
Tufts
Boston Medical Center
U Maryland
UNC
Brown
 
Cognovi said:
Here's what I got

Duke
Mayo Rochester
Cornell
Mount Sinai
UCLA
Cleveland Clinic
UAB
Northwestern
Yale
Colorado
Georgetown
UChicago
Tufts
Boston Medical Center
U Maryland
UNC
Brown
Click to expand...
Would not go to Brown . IR does all there Strokes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Cognovi said:
Here's what I got

Duke
Mayo Rochester
Cornell
Mount Sinai
UCLA
Cleveland Clinic
UAB
Northwestern
Yale
Colorado
Georgetown
UChicago
Tufts
Boston Medical Center
U Maryland
UNC
Brown
Click to expand...
Northwestern has a great NIR program....
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
NDcienporciento100 said:
Go to a program with no NIR fellows that is comprehensive stroke center.
Click to expand...
oh wow. I was thinking of going to a program based on them having fellowship. Because i reasoned that i would be able to network internally and get the appropriate research exposure for fellowship. This thinking throws that out of the window.
 
libertyyne said:
oh wow. I was thinking of going to a program based on them having fellowship. Because i reasoned that i would be able to network internally and get the appropriate research exposure for fellowship. This thinking throws that out of the window.
Click to expand...
You can do that but you won’t get to do any of the procedures, the fellow will be doing them. You need at least 200 cerebral cases to shave a year off training.
 
NDcienporciento100 said:
You can do that but you won’t get to do any of the procedures, the fellow will be doing them. You need at least 200 cerebral cases to shave a year off training.
Click to expand...
this is some 4D chess. Thanks , i will go to a smaller university program then. i was getting excited about duke,emory but i guess not then.
 
I thought MCW had a NIR fellowship program.
 
dr_kateb said:
Damn I thought something looked off about that photo. This is the one I meant to post lol.

control_large.jpg


Pssst it's only 10k.
Click to expand...
i heard the computer was worth 6 by itself . So not a bad deal.
Edit :that was the 20k model. This pc is just kinda meh.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
NDcienporciento100 said:
I would try and do some intern year if you can.
Click to expand...
Cognovi said:
You also need to spend at least 6 months clinical time on neurosurgery, vascular neurology, or neuro ICU.
Click to expand...
Based on this , do you think a surgical intern year would be beneficial for meeting some of these requirements ? I think I am leaning ty or surg intern considering it would allow me to get some of these requirements in.
 
libertyyne said:
Based on this , do you think a surgical intern year would be beneficial for meeting some of these requirements ? I think I am leaning ty or surg intern considering it would allow me to get some of these requirements in.
Click to expand...

I did an IR rotation here and some of the residents seemed to appreciate having done a surgical prelim year, not just for things like this but in general having better procedural skills
 
^ I got a different take from my IR department when I asked them about medicine vs surgery vs TY for PGY-1. Unanimously told me that it doesn't matter at all, you don't get to operate much as a surg intern anyways, so go for the TY or a chill medicine prelim instead.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
efle said:
^ I got a different take from my IR department when I asked them about medicine vs surgery vs TY for PGY-1. Unanimously told me that it doesn't matter at all, you don't get to operate much as a surg intern anyways, so go for the TY or a chill medicine prelim instead.
Click to expand...
My IR PD said that a surgical intern year would look favorable come fellowship match time. I guess in my instance it would help me get to the 6 months of vascular/nsx rotations required for NIR fellowship, but im not sure if they would take it into consideration when the time for fellowship arrives.
 
libertyyne said:
My IR PD said that a surgical intern year would look favorable come fellowship match time. I guess in my instance it would help me get to the 6 months of vascular/nsx rotations required for NIR fellowship, but im not sure if they would take it into consideration when the time for fellowship arrives.
Click to expand...
So never thought about it from this standpoint. That is someone only interested in NIR.... I would say medicine or whatever internship will get you the most Neurology time. Neuro critical care , vascular neurology those would be the money shots. General surgery is necessary. for body IR it is but not for NIR. Actually think it would be detrimental.
 
NDcienporciento100 said:
So never thought about it from this standpoint. That is someone only interested in NIR.... I would say medicine or whatever internship will get you the most Neurology time. Neuro critical care , vascular neurology those would be the money shots. General surgery is necessary. for body IR it is but not for NIR. Actually think it would be detrimental.
Click to expand...
the fellowships however require 6 months of nsx or vascular surgery not general neurology or neuro critical care, to essentially shave time off.
 
NDcienporciento100 said:
You will likely not do any neurosurgery as an intern. At most 1 month.
Click to expand...
I guess, i was thinking about TY years and 4 months of electives. I mean would they really say no to vascular surgery or NSX?
It is not clear from the the surgical intern year curricula what duration of electives is allowed.

here is an example
1603242692796.png


The t"these rotations may be changed piece is what is what i am trying to get. And at my home program the NSX interns rotate on NSX for 4 months.
 
Last edited:
NDcienporciento100 said:
You will likely not do any neurosurgery as an intern. At most 1 month.
Click to expand...
libertyyne said:
I guess, i was thinking about TY years and 4 months of electives. I mean would they really say no to vascular surgery or NSX?
It is not clear from the the surgical intern year curricula what duration of electives is allowed.

here is an example
View attachment 321008

The t"these rotations may be changed piece is what is what i am trying to get. And at my home program the NSX interns rotate on NSX for 4 months.
Click to expand...
No what I’m saying is vascular surgery does not qualify as part of the 6 months required.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
libertyyne said:
the fellowships however require 6 months of nsx or vascular surgery not general neurology or neuro critical care, to essentially shave time off.
Click to expand...
These are the current requirements for radiologists entering the CAST accredited NIR programs:

"Satisfactory completion of an ACGME-accredited neuroradiology fellowship including, or in addition to, at least 6 months of clinical service in a neurological surgery, vascular neurology, or neurocritical care program before entering the advanced year of NES fellowship."

Your best chance to get rotations in those fields will be a prelim medicine year or a TY.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
You must log in or register to reply here.
Next unread thread

Similar threads

M
Interventional Radiology Electives Advice
Replies
0
Views
344
mshalom13
M
N
Ortho vs Radiology
Replies
34
Views
3K
Splenda88
S
m2regen
Choosing between Vascular Surgery vs. Neurosurgery
Replies
21
Views
4K
m2regen
m2regen
M
Peds neuro
Replies
8
Views
754
babybrains
babybrains
B
Radiology signals
Replies
2
Views
832
bigM6029
B
Top