New thoughts: CP>AP in the long run?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

LADoc00

Gen X, the last great generation
Removed
20+ Year Member
Joined
Sep 9, 2004
Messages
7,132
Reaction score
1,255
I started thinking yesterday about life in general and the pathologist's place in it all....
My idea of the day: Performance jobs vs. management jobs.
Performance jobs are your surgical path and dermpaths, who work with high volume, high stress cases. Your ability is gauged every single day when you show up to work and start signing out. You cant have an off day. You cant take a month off straight or your eye starts to dull. The pros include you make alot of $$$ but at what cost??

Management job: The archetype is blood banking. You oversee a sizable employee base, typically report to no one but the hospital's medical director and are relatively free from peer review. You are NOT ability gauged everyday. On rare instances, you may need to soothe a clinician's concern or authorize a special blood product, but in essence you are the prince of a tiny medical fiefdom. Cons you make less money, have less interaction with medical staff.

In management you can leave for lunch at that downtown steakhouse, take off 3 hours early to pick up a sick kid or take a blocked vacation period without fear of skill decay (assuming you have coverage). In perfomance, those arent options. You cover frozens, field evaluations of CT needle adequacies and do stat evaluations. Youre physical presence is required in the hospital. Management can function by wireless.

This is how I would divide path:
Performance: Surgical path, dermpath and cyto

Management: Blood bank, chemistry and micro

Gray zone: Hemepath, Forensics

My conclusion is there is a break even point for deciding to go one way or the other. Say if I could land a CP only job and make 120K but can get a performance task for 350K, I would choose performance, but if the difference is less than 50K, management is the way to go. These numbers are arbitrary, but I think one could develop a rough model of where you focus your job searches and what type of lifestyle would best serve you.
 
So what's up with micro? Are there jobs out there? It seems that a lot of these peeps are PhDs or MD + PhD. Any comments or thoughts about this area of path?
 
LADoc00 said:
I started thinking yesterday about life in general and the pathologist's place in it all....
My idea of the day: Performance jobs vs. management jobs.
Performance jobs are your surgical path and dermpaths, who work with high volume, high stress cases. Your ability is gauged every single day when you show up to work and start signing out. You cant have an off day. You cant take a month off straight or your eye starts to dull. The pros include you make alot of $$$ but at what cost??

Management job: The archetype is blood banking. You oversee a sizable employee base, typically report to no one but the hospital's medical director and are relatively free from peer review. You are NOT ability gauged everyday. On rare instances, you may need to soothe a clinician's concern or authorize a special blood product, but in essence you are the prince of a tiny medical fiefdom. Cons you make less money, have less interaction with medical staff.

In management you can leave for lunch at that downtown steakhouse, take off 3 hours early to pick up a sick kid or take a blocked vacation period without fear of skill decay (assuming you have coverage). In perfomance, those arent options. You cover frozens, field evaluations of CT needle adequacies and do stat evaluations. Youre physical presence is required in the hospital. Management can function by wireless.

This is how I would divide path:
Performance: Surgical path, dermpath and cyto

Management: Blood bank, chemistry and micro

Gray zone: Hemepath, Forensics

My conclusion is there is a break even point for deciding to go one way or the other. Say if I could land a CP only job and make 120K but can get a performance task for 350K, I would choose performance, but if the difference is less than 50K, management is the way to go. These numbers are arbitrary, but I think one could develop a rough model of where you focus your job searches and what type of lifestyle would best serve you.


Quite an outstanding analysis LaDOC......you have the true hallmarks of a businessman

Also i think your idea of needing to do an MBA is quite pointless in your case....

Business savvy is an inborn skill. period.
 
bananaface said:
Proof that someopne has hijacked LADoc00's account:



I hereby declare SDN path on RED ALERT!


Im making a career change and am planning on leading a populist revolutionary revolt to overthrow the corrupt oligarchy that is enslaving the common man. Okay, who is with me on this?

Nostradamus_Revolution_400.jpg
 
bananaface said:
Andy skunked you in the UAOPRTP thread

WTF is this about? Is a SDN hook up in my future?
 
Top