There are too many posts to read in this thread, and I'm sure many of them echo sentiment that I am about to share. I personally have always been a believer in N2O and try to use it whenever possible, unless there are specific contraindications, which include:
1. Any case in which the surgical field is above the level of the heart (ie, sitting cranies, C-section, etc) due to risk of air embolus. Even here, once the pt is supine and closure has started, I usually turn on N2O.
2. Any patient who has a congenital heart defect, due to risk of paradoxical embolus.
3. Any pregnant patient, due to risk (albeit questionable) of birth defects. In C-section, once the baby is out, I'll turn on N2O.
4. Any case that goes longer than 3-4 hrs due to risk of bone marrow suppression, etc. For that matter, any chemo patient with baseline bone marrow suppression should not have N2O either.
5. Any case in which N2O interferes with neuro-monitoring. Once the neuro monitors are off, I turn on N2O.
6. Any patient/case in which oxygenation is compromised (lung isolation, any pt with problems oxygenating, etc)
7. Any open bowel surgery. Again, once bowel has closed, N2O goes on.
8. Any laparoscopic/robotic procedure which involves insufflation of the belly. Again, once the scopes are removed N2O goes on.
9. Any cranies due to increased CMRO2 and cerebral vasoconstriction.
Those are the big ones I can think of. Most of these are conditions inherent to the procedure itself, which usually go away once the procedure is done and the closure starts. There are few instances in which I would avoid N2O altogether for the entire procedure (2, 4, 6).
I really don't buy the PONV argument, it's kind of a moot point when you've been using volatile gas the entire case and plan to administer anti-emetics. I also have rarely seen significant diffusion hypoxia in the absence of pre-existing problems with oxygenation. As far as methionine synthase inhibition for the fetus, I really couldn't see it being an issue by the 3rd trimester. Remember, once that baby comes out, we almost universally use N2O to mask them down. (in addition to volatile gas). Then again, if a C/S comes down to GA, the fetus probably isn't doing too well to begin with.