Official LOST WW Game Thread

Veterinary Science Graduate Programs from U. of I.
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
orcagirl said:
Alright. Unlynch SnS Maybe SOV was just trying to vote to lynch someone since he can't talk in anything other than dog pictures. My original post did say I have no reason. Going to read through this all again and then vote.
Click to expand...

Woof!

dalmatian.gif
 
krist said:
elect krist

We're just in a new block of school so lots of free time and I'll be at my grandma's all weekend with not much else to do so pick me!

Small caveat, I know nothing about Lost (tried to watch the pilot once 😕) but I do know lots about catching wolves. :meanie:
Click to expand...

Growl!
 
that redhead said:
This early, I don't think anyone does. But we do have to vote - don't want the mod island angry with us.
Click to expand...

I just really don't think I can do it. Don't want to get anyone upset with me. What if I lynched the wrong person?
 
Now it sounds like SOV doesn't like krist. I'm so confused.

lynch wildcat no reason, but I wish I had some sort of clue.
 
unlynch jojo, lynch krist I don't know where the tally is at, but think I might getting up there in votes and you don't want to lynch me. I am Naomi, sure hope the wolves are feeling generous tonight.
 
DVMDream said:
unlynch jojo, lynch krist I don't know where the tally is at, but think I might getting up there in votes and you don't want to lynch me. I am Naomi, sure hope the wolves are feeling generous tonight.
Click to expand...
Not sure what to think of you being Naomi, or even what that should mean for the villagers or what you can do... But I guess Naomi should be a villager role from what I've read on the wiki...
 
that redhead said:
I'm not ok with it, but at least for the immediate future I'm willing to let it slide because he makes it seem like his role is important. I'm curious enough to let it play out for another few rounds.
Click to expand...

DVMDream said:
Then we have LIS admitting to killing a player and saying that it is very possible that he will do this again in the game. But everyone seems to be ok with this? Am I missing something crucial here?
Click to expand...

You're not reading closely enough. I very carefully chose my words: that if I am *unable to* (or choose not to) perform my role things will happen. Those are the words I used. So think it through and realize that if I'm dead I'm unable to perform my role. So by your own logic, if you're NOT ok with that crap happening (which seems to be what you're saying above), then you want me alive so I can prevent it.
 
I really wish I could bring myself to vote, but I just can't. I'll leave it up to ya'll to decide who to lynch.
 
DVMDream said:
1. My vote yesterday for you was not based on absolute crap. You have many times singled out a group of people as a wolf in order to draw attention away from other groups and yourself.
Click to expand...

Bull****. I've done it MORE often as a villager. It's just the way I play - if I get a suspicion I go after it. If my suspicion suggests someone in a particular group, I go after the group. Trying to claim I do that "as a wolf" is utter crap. I know it, you know it, and it makes it pretty obvious that you're trying too hard.

DVMDream said:
2. What argument about you is weak? You admitted to killing WS, then admitted that there is a good chance you will kill again in the game.
Click to expand...

You're twisting things, which also is suspicious. First, I didn't say there is a "good chance I will kill again". Show me precisely where I said that. Second, you clearly didn't bother to read what I actually said (per my last post regarding what will happen if I'm unable to perform my role, which includes being dead).

You're being irrational in more ways than one. So either it's just you being normally irrational, or it's you trying hard to steer suspicion onto certain people. I don't have a clue which. But I *do* know that you're full of crap.
 
LetItSnow said:
You're not reading closely enough. I very carefully chose my words: that if I am *unable to* (or choose not to) perform my role things will happen. Those are the words I used. So think it through and realize that if I'm dead I'm unable to perform my role. So by your own logic, if you're NOT ok with that crap happening (which seems to be what you're saying above), then you want me alive so I can prevent it.
Click to expand...

The bolded part is what concerns me. I read what you posted just fine, but it appears as if you "chose" not to perform your role last night as you aren't making any mention that you were unable to. How can we trust that you won't keep "choosing" to not perform your role but claim that you were "unable" to? Seems like too many variables to me. I also think that the mod probably has some mechanism in play for if you should die what will happen, I highly doubt that she will have one player die every night simply because you aren't alive, as that would severely unbalance any ww game. What mechanism this might be, I don't know.
 
LetItSnow said:
Bull****. I've done it MORE often as a villager. It's just the way I play - if I get a suspicion I go after it. If my suspicion suggests someone in a particular group, I go after the group. Trying to claim I do that "as a wolf" is utter crap. I know it, you know it, and it makes it pretty obvious that you're trying too hard.



You're twisting things, which also is suspicious. First, I didn't say there is a "good chance I will kill again". Show me precisely where I said that. Second, you clearly didn't bother to read what I actually said (per my last post regarding what will happen if I'm unable to perform my role, which includes being dead).

You're being irrational in more ways than one. So either it's just you being normally irrational, or it's you trying hard to steer suspicion onto certain people. I don't have a clue which. But I *do* know that you're full of crap.
Click to expand...


Stop all this fighting. I don't like it. Just STOP.

Though can't say I'm surprised at all that LIS and DVMD are ALREADY getting into it. :laugh:
 
Official Lynch Talley:

krist 6 (Escalla, SnS, DVM, SOV, jojo, devyn)
DVMD 3 ( kaydubs, lissa, LIS)
devyn 1 (FFM)
wildcatj 1 (orcagirl)
Allie 1 (TRH)
SnS 1 (dyachei)

Votes Cast: 13 of 25.

Day is Closed. Results pending.
 
LetItSnow said:
Bull****. I've done it MORE often as a villager. It's just the way I play - if I get a suspicion I go after it. If my suspicion suggests someone in a particular group, I go after the group. Trying to claim I do that "as a wolf" is utter crap. I know it, you know it, and it makes it pretty obvious that you're trying too hard.



You're twisting things, which also is suspicious. First, I didn't say there is a "good chance I will kill again". Show me precisely where I said that. Second, you clearly didn't bother to read what I actually said (per my last post regarding what will happen if I'm unable to perform my role, which includes being dead).

You're being irrational in more ways than one. So either it's just you being normally irrational, or it's you trying hard to steer suspicion onto certain people. I don't have a clue which. But I *do* know that you're full of crap.
Click to expand...

Yes, I am always "twisting" things, I have no reading comprehension abilities at all and I obviously didn't read what you said because I didn't mention that you can either be "unable" to or "choose not" to perform your role, clearly I am making some huge obvious mistake. Clearly I am putting words in your mouth and clearly I am just dumb and irrational. Whatever. And clearly I have never played ww with you before and have not seen how you play. 🙄
 
DVMDream said:
The bolded part is what concerns me. I read what you posted just fine, but it appears as if you "chose" not to perform your role last night as you aren't making any mention that you were unable to.
Click to expand...

First, you still haven't answered me. I asked you where, specifically, I said that I am likely to kill again. You distorted my words, and now you don't want to admit it, and you know you can't actually find a quote in this thread from me that supports what you said.

Second, why would it concern you? I'm being very specific in explaining my role: if I'm unable to fulfill it, or choose not to, bad things happen. That's not a threat, it's just an explanation of how my role works; I have to intentionally act to prevent the badness.

DVMDream said:
I also think that the mod probably has some mechanism in play for if you should die what will happen, I highly doubt that she will have one player die every night simply because you aren't alive, as that would severely unbalance any ww game. What mechanism this might be, I don't know.
Click to expand...

I tend to agree. But first, that's really speculative. And since I'm a villager, why bother finding out if the mod has some mechanism in place? And second, just because the mod might (probably? may? likely?) have a mechanism in place doesn't mean there won't be repercussions. If it were me modding I'd have someone replace my role ... but it'd take a day or so of nastiness to happen. I wouldn't just immediately pop a new player in place.
 
DVMDream said:
Yes, I am always "twisting" things, I have no reading comprehension abilities at all and I obviously didn't read what you said because I didn't mention that you can either be "unable" to or "choose not" to perform your role, clearly I am making some huge obvious mistake. Clearly I am putting words in your mouth and clearly I am just dumb and irrational.
Click to expand...

All of the above, as far as I can tell, is accurate. I agree with you.

And once again - I asked you to point out where I said what you claimed I said ... and for two posts in a row now you've ducked answering that. Instead, you've favored vague attacks on me.

It's very clear that you're stretching. My vote stands.
 
LetItSnow said:
First, you still haven't answered me. I asked you where, specifically, I said that I am likely to kill again. You distorted my words, and now you don't want to admit it, and you know you can't actually find a quote in this thread from me that supports what you said.

Second, why would it concern you? I'm being very specific in explaining my role: if I'm unable to fulfill it, or choose not to, bad things happen. That's not a threat, it's just an explanation of how my role works; I have to intentionally act to prevent the badness.



I tend to agree. But first, that's really speculative. And since I'm a villager, why bother finding out if the mod has some mechanism in place? And second, just because the mod might (probably? may? likely?) have a mechanism in place doesn't mean there won't be repercussions. If it were me modding I'd have someone replace my role ... but it'd take a day or so of nastiness to happen. I wouldn't just immediately pop a new player in place.
Click to expand...

Sigh... you are missing the point. It concerns me because of exactly how I explained it. You can CHOOSE not to perform said role, this is bad. Anyway, I didn't vote to lynch you because once more information was revealed I figured you were most likely a villager (which I did post a statement similar to this earlier), so time to move on and discuss other things instead of continuing with this.
 
LetItSnow said:
All of the above, as far as I can tell, is accurate. I agree with you.

And once again - I asked you to point out where I said what you claimed I said ... and for two posts in a row now you've ducked answering that. Instead, you've favored vague attacks on me.

It's very clear that you're stretching. My vote stands.
Click to expand...

Whatever. I revealed my role. If you wiki it you would realize that lynching me is a stupid move and you are just retaliating against me, for what, I am not sure. My guess is because I questioned the reasoning as to why we are keeping someone in the game who can "inadvertently" kill people. But then rojo's post about the button thing made sense so I dropped it, never even lynched you. But not that it matters because lynch is closed today.
 
DVMDream said:
Whatever. I revealed my role. If you wiki it you would realize that lynching me is a stupid move and you are just retaliating against me, for what, I am not sure. My guess is because I questioned the reasoning as to why we are keeping someone in the game who can "inadvertently" kill people. But then rojo's post about the button thing made sense so I dropped it, never even lynched you. But not that it matters because lynch is closed today.
Click to expand...

I don't see where you revealed your role. I see that you dropped hints. I don't know if those hints are enough to clearly identify a single character.

If you're not sure why my vote to lynch you is out there, then it goes back to your reading comprehension. I was very clear about it: you're trumping up nonsense against me, all the way back to trying to claim that I "go after groups" when I'm a wolf. And then you went after Jojo for a pretty weak reason. From where I'm sitting, it looks like you're trying to spread unwarranted suspicion all over the place, which is wolfy.

But, I said all that already. So I'm not sure why you're unclear where my vote is coming from.
 
LetItSnow said:
I don't see where you revealed your role. I see that you dropped hints. I don't know if those hints are enough to clearly identify a single character.
Click to expand...

To be specific: All I saw is that you're claiming to be a villager who wasn't on the plane. I saw where someone else said they could think of 3 (then 5) people that could be. If there were other data points to narrow it down more specifically, then I apologize for missing them. I may have read through the thread too fast if that's the case. But I'm not aware of any other specifics about your "role reveal."
 
LetItSnow said:
I don't see where you revealed your role. I see that you dropped hints. I don't know if those hints are enough to clearly identify a single character.

If you're not sure why my vote to lynch you is out there, then it goes back to your reading comprehension. I was very clear about it: you're trumping up nonsense against me, all the way back to trying to claim that I "go after groups" when I'm a wolf. And then you went after Jojo for a pretty weak reason. From where I'm sitting, it looks like you're trying to spread unwarranted suspicion all over the place, which is wolfy.

But, I said all that already. So I'm not sure why you're unclear where my vote is coming from.
Click to expand...

Post #262, I revealed my role. Look who fails at reading now, should we lynch you for missing something? People miss things, get over it. Move on.
 
Polar bears, unexplained gunshots, and the mute woman speaks. People are pointing fingers, yelling and screaming, and someone is just fed up with all the drama!

Eventually, majority landed on krist. Someone must pay for what is happening.

You have lynched krist, Danielle Rousseau, who has lived on the island since 1988 when her expedition boat crashed. But was she friend, or foe, to the survivors?

It is Night 3. Please get your PMs in by 8pm EST.


There are 24 players left.


The Hydra
1. Dyachei
2. FH
3. devyn


The Tempest
4. thedrjojo

The Barracks
5. wildcatj
6. cuit
7. FS
8. SOV

The Pearl
9. DVMD
10. nohika
11. SnS
12. KP
13. Lissa


The Swan
14. FFM
15. Orcagirl
16. Dwin
17. Kaydubs


The Flame
18. that redhead


The Looking Glass
19. nyanko
20. jjohnston
21. Allie
22. Alors
23. Escalla


Sandy Graveyard
24. The LIS <--------Not dead. Digging graves.

Goodwin Stanhope
Michael Dawson
Philliab, Mr. Eko
Wolfspeaker, Bernard Nadler
krist, Danielle Rousseau
 
Hmm...guessing not a wolf. Villager or neutral, if neutral/chaos exists.
 
DVMDream said:
Whatever. I revealed my role. If you wiki it you would realize that lynching me is a stupid move and you are just retaliating against me, for what, I am not sure. My guess is because I questioned the reasoning as to why we are keeping someone in the game who can "inadvertently" kill people. But then rojo's post about the button thing made sense so I dropped it, never even lynched you. But not that it matters because lynch is closed today.
Click to expand...

right, and it wasn't even close, so I'm not sure your desire to role reveal particularly if it is really detrimental to the villagers for the wolves to know (still not sure why you have such a vital role as Naomi from my reading on the wiki, someone with more Lost knowledge may better fill in why Naomi would be a huge deal since she was alive a whole 7 days on the island, didn't save the villagers, and the ship she came on exploded... in fact, I would think that Lis's character (again, assuming that he is the original pusher of the button, Desmond) might have reasons to distrust DVMD's character... and I can't find Naomi's true purpose on the island except to protect the scientist team, and the scientists team were suppose to capture Ben and kill everyone else is I am reading correctly... 😕

All this is really befuddling me and I dunno what to think...
 
thedrjojo said:
right, and it wasn't even close, so I'm not sure your desire to role reveal particularly if it is really detrimental to the villagers for the wolves to know (still not sure why you have such a vital role as Naomi from my reading on the wiki, someone with more Lost knowledge may better fill in why Naomi would be a huge deal since she was alive a whole 7 days on the island, didn't save the villagers, and the ship she came on exploded... in fact, I would think that Lis's character (again, assuming that he is the original pusher of the button, Desmond) might have reasons to distrust DVMD's character... and I can't find Naomi's true purpose on the island except to protect the scientist team, and the scientists team were suppose to capture Ben and kill everyone else is I am reading correctly... 😕

All this is really befuddling me and I dunno what to think...
Click to expand...

Honestly, I know nothing about Lost. I don't watch the show. I have never seen a single episode. But your answer to what my character can do is there in the wiki; it really isn't that hard to figure out and the role is quite beneficial to the villagers. So please, use some common sense and don't make me tell you what it actually is tomorrow should I still be alive.
 
thedrjojo said:
right, and it wasn't even close, so I'm not sure your desire to role reveal particularly if it is really detrimental to the villagers for the wolves to know (still not sure why you have such a vital role as Naomi from my reading on the wiki, someone with more Lost knowledge may better fill in why Naomi would be a huge deal since she was alive a whole 7 days on the island, didn't save the villagers, and the ship she came on exploded... in fact, I would think that Lis's character (again, assuming that he is the original pusher of the button, Desmond) might have reasons to distrust DVMD's character... and I can't find Naomi's true purpose on the island except to protect the scientist team, and the scientists team were suppose to capture Ben and kill everyone else is I am reading correctly... 😕

All this is really befuddling me and I dunno what to think...
Click to expand...

i mixed up the mercenary and scientist team... mercenary team was to capture Ben and kill the rest, not entirely sure what the scientist team was to do... still confused
 
DVMDream said:
Post #262, I revealed my role. Look who fails at reading now, should we lynch you for missing something? People miss things, get over it. Move on.
Click to expand...

Yup. The difference between us is I can say "I may have missed it. Sorry." Whereas you just get snarky, insulting, and refuse to acknowledge a mistake.
 
DVMDream said:
Honestly, I know nothing about Lost. I don't watch the show. I have never seen a single episode. But your answer to what my character can do is there in the wiki; it really isn't that hard to figure out and the role is quite beneficial to the villagers. So please, use some common sense and don't make me tell you what it actually is tomorrow should I still be alive.
Click to expand...

no, i don't want you to tell me, and I'm trying to figure it out in the wiki, but in general, your character it seems does not help out the villagers as much as you are making it seem. some of the scientists (particularly the dude that can figure out info from the dead), would be very useful...
 
thedrjojo said:
right, and it wasn't even close, so I'm not sure your desire to role reveal particularly if it is really detrimental to the villagers for the wolves to know (still not sure why you have such a vital role as Naomi from my reading on the wiki, someone with more Lost knowledge may better fill in why Naomi would be a huge deal since she was alive a whole 7 days on the island, didn't save the villagers, and the ship she came on exploded... in fact, I would think that Lis's character (again, assuming that he is the original pusher of the button, Desmond) might have reasons to distrust DVMD's character... and I can't find Naomi's true purpose on the island except to protect the scientist team, and the scientists team were suppose to capture Ben and kill everyone else is I am reading correctly... 😕

All this is really befuddling me and I dunno what to think...
Click to expand...

And as for the first part, I had no idea where the lynch tally was. The mod was gone and I knew that there were votes for me and votes for krist and I didn't know how close I was vs. how close she was. I didn't have the time to actually tally up the votes. Not only that, but I guarantee that people would not have dropped the whole being suspicious of me until I said something. So I revealed since I thought the votes may have been close. Was it the best idea in hindsight? No, probably not. Would I have had to reveal eventually? Yes, most likely the next lynch cycle.
 
thedrjojo said:
right, and it wasn't even close, so I'm not sure your desire to role reveal particularly if it is really detrimental to the villagers for the wolves to know
Click to expand...

I think that DVMD, if she is a villager, was in a position where she had to role reveal. The issue wasn't going away.
 
DVMDream said:
Yes, and you were a complete angel and didn't insult me at all. 🙄
Click to expand...

What's your problem, DVMD? Why can't you let it go. I never made a claim to being a complete angel. I said I can (and did, if you read back) admit when I may be wrong. I pointed out that you never do. You just attack and keep attacking. And when it's shown that you're wrong, you make all sorts of excuses. Just like this post of yours. All I did is point out that at least I can admit to being wrong. Instead of saying "Yeah" you just find some other reason to attack. You're like a pissed off cat in a clinic.
 
DVMDream said:
Yes, and you were a complete angel and didn't insult me at all. 🙄
Click to expand...

And reading back, you put words in my mouth as well. There were things you claimed I said that I did not say in the way you are claiming them. But I am willing to drop it and move on, because it doesn't matter any more. Because I have already stated multiple times that I think you are most likely a villager due to rojo's post.
 
DVMDream said:
And reading back, you put words in my mouth as well. There were things you claimed I said that I did not say in the way you are claiming them. But I am willing to drop it and move on, because it doesn't matter any more. Because I have already stated multiple times that I think you are most likely a villager due to rojo's post.
Click to expand...

Whatever. I'm done with you. You're an irrational beeyatch who can't admit when she makes a mistake.
 
LetItSnow said:
I think that DVMD, if she is a villager, was in a position where she had to role reveal. The issue wasn't going away.
Click to expand...

i guess you have a point. I am always pivoting between if what I am saying on the thread is ever too much or not enough information (which gets people to lynch me sometimes when they think I'm being purposely confusing)...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
51K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
37K
Clem J
Clem J
WildZoo
Noob WW Game 2025 Sign Ups: All New WW Players Welcome! (CLOSED)
2 3 4
Replies
157
Views
9K
samac
samac
kaydubs
Melee WW Game Thread-April 2024
27 28 29 30 31
Replies
2K
Views
30K
Sandy Dikson
Sandy Dikson
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mystery WW Signs Ups - Game Start May 25th
2
Replies
79
Views
3K
KayJayQueue
KayJayQueue
Top