Official mafia game thread

Veterinary Science Graduate Programs from U. of I.
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Will trust devyn on this for now. Re-read things quickly and this stood out 'cause his first post after the night results was basically the same as DVMDream's to me:
Sheepdogpsu said:
That works for me, her last post had already threw up a red flag for me so I had just put a little star next to her in my notes.
Click to expand...
:eyebrow: Hmm.
 
cuitlamiztli said:
Will trust devyn on this for now. Re-read things quickly and this stood out 'cause his first post after the night results was basically the same as DVMDream's to me:
:eyebrow: Hmm.
Click to expand...

Fair enough but I there is almost always a post early in the game after night results where someone says "sorry blank" or " oh no blank got killed, sorry" and often those people are wolves. I wouldn't have even brought that up if devyn had not accused DVM of being a wolf. It is early in the game and we have to grasp at straws for clues. That being said I am not changing my vote right now until the anonymous source thing is explained more.
 
Poor IPB 🙁

Sent from my PC36100 using SDN Mobile
 
Sheepdogpsu said:
Fair enough but I there is almost always a post early in the game after night results where someone says "sorry blank" or " oh no blank got killed, sorry" and often those people are wolves. I wouldn't have even brought that up if devyn had not accused DVM of being a wolf. It is early in the game and we have to grasp at straws for clues. That being said I am not changing my vote right now until the anonymous source thing is explained more.
Click to expand...

If we explain what is going on... I will be the biggest target in the world for the mafia...

Trust me, it is a BAD IDEA to lynch me...

I always post the same thing after every night cycle.. That sucks, sorry to whomever so if you think that is suspicious... you need to pay more attention..
 
Sheepdogpsu said:
Fair enough but I there is almost always a post early in the game after night results where someone says "sorry blank" or " oh no blank got killed, sorry" and often those people are wolves. I wouldn't have even brought that up if devyn had not accused DVM of being a wolf. It is early in the game and we have to grasp at straws for clues. That being said I am not changing my vote right now until the anonymous source thing is explained more.
Click to expand...

I would be dumb as bricks to explain my anonymous source to you....I am not going to tell you who gave me the information.... and I find it a bit strange you are asking TBH
 
DVMDream said:
If we explain what is going on... I will be the biggest target in the world for the mafia...

Trust me, it is a BAD IDEA to lynch me...
Click to expand...

I never asked for you to explain your role, just where the anonymous tip possibly came from and why we should/shouldn't trust it?
 
devyn said:
I would be dumb as bricks to explain my anonymous source to you....I am not going to tell you who gave me the information.... and I find it a bit strange you are asking TBH
Click to expand...

Sorry I thought you meant the tip came in a pm or something, so you trust DVM over the tip? If you do I will change my vote
 
Sheepdogpsu said:
Fair enough but I there is almost always a post early in the game after night results where someone says "sorry blank" or " oh no blank got killed, sorry" and often those people are wolves. I wouldn't have even brought that up if devyn had not accused DVM of being a wolf. It is early in the game and we have to grasp at straws for clues. That being said I am not changing my vote right now until the anonymous source thing is explained more.
Click to expand...
Well, yeah, there are usually 3-4 (or more) people who post stuff like that right after night results. The "often wolves" thing has been true for a few games, but not all of them. In any case, by your logic you also fall into this category. As far as DVMDream, I'm willing to trust devyn on this based on some behind-the-scenes PMs.

Lynch sheepdogpsu for now.

I don't want to lynch you if you're a villager, but I sure as heck want to lynch you if you're a wolf.
 
devyn said:
I would be dumb as bricks to explain my anonymous source to you....I am not going to tell you who gave me the information.... and I find it a bit strange you are asking TBH
Click to expand...

I'm just confused...if you trust your anonymous source, why did you unlynch DVM?
 
maybe I should just shut my mouth now, you should know that I never talk this much when I am actually a wolf, just look at last game, the reason I got lynched was because I wasn't being helpful and I barely ever posted except when I was going down
 
cuitlamiztli said:
👍
Click to expand...

Eh, I dunno about that. I asked the same thing last game and was a villager. Mostly wanted to clarify between an anonymous note like the dead people have sent in other games, or something related to gameplay kind of thing (not wanting any specifics).

In this game mostly trying to figure out why devyn was so adamant and then unlynched DVM.
 
Ok so here is the point I have been trying to make, if the tipper says DVM is a wolf, and DVM says she isn't, one of them is obviously lying. If you know who the anonymous tip came from, which it sounds like you do, who do you trust more? There is a 50/50 chance then of lynching the person that is lying and is probably a wolf. If you actually don't know who the tipper is why did you trust them so much to begin with?
 
Sheepdogpsu said:
maybe I should just shut my mouth now, you should know that I never talk this much when I am actually a wolf, just look at last game, the reason I got lynched was because I wasn't being helpful and I barely ever posted except when I was going down
Click to expand...
:shrug: It just seems like you're backpedaling/overly defensive to me. Going to keep my vote for now.
 
Sheepdogpsu said:
Ok so here is the point I have been trying to make, if the tipper says DVM is a wolf, and DVM says she isn't, one of them is obviously lying. If you know who the anonymous tip came from, which it sounds like you do, who do you trust more? There is a 50/50 chance then of lynching the person that is lying and is probably a wolf. If you actually don't know who the tipper is why did you trust them so much to begin with?
Click to expand...

The problem here is that there has been something else tossed into this game that makes this not true... I get where you are coming from and I wish I could tell you more, but I can't...
 
Sheepdogpsu said:
Ok so here is the point I have been trying to make, if the tipper says DVM is a wolf, and DVM says she isn't, one of them is obviously lying. If you know who the anonymous tip came from, which it sounds like you do, who do you trust more? There is a 50/50 chance then of lynching the person that is lying and is probably a wolf. If you actually don't know who the tipper is why did you trust them so much to begin with?
Click to expand...


Let's just say this game is different from ones we have played in the past... new info came to light that I never would have considered before.... it might be helpful in the future.
 
Ok thank you for some sort of explanation, that is all I wanted and then my questions just kept getting flipped and used against me.

unlynch DVM
 
I really hope that wasn't our only 'seer'! 😡 (I'm assuming 'detective' would mean seer?) IPB, that sucks you were first to go 🙁 (but better you than me :laugh: I want to make it at least 1 cycle this time guys👍)

Don't have to be to work for a few hours, so I'm going to wait to see if anyone else comes up with some info. Something to go on at least.

Sidenote:
I don't think I'm going to like not being able to post during the night. What if someone gets vital information, but can't get online during that 'day' and we aren't allowed to post during the night. They can't communicate with the rest of us! Will definitely make this game interesting. I found myself reading a lot of other threads last night because I couldn't post in here.

Also, Krist, do you have a general idea of deadline times? Is it going to stay at 10am and 5pm or are we going to have more cycles in a 24hr period? I ask, because I dont want to have to RNG an item because I received after going to work. I know it happens all the time, I just don't want to do it. :laugh:
 
wolfspeaker said:
Sidenote:
I don't think I'm going to like not being able to post during the night. What if someone gets vital information, but can't get online during that 'day' and we aren't allowed to post during the night. They can't communicate with the rest of us! Will definitely make this game interesting. I found myself reading a lot of other threads last night because I couldn't post in here.
Click to expand...

Um, generally if they get info during the night they can't post about it until the day has started anyways...worst case they can message a group-mate.
 
Sheepdogpsu said:
Ok thank you for some sort of explanation, that is all I wanted and then my questions just kept getting flipped and used against me.
Click to expand...
Well... it's WW, and there's the whole catching wolves in a lie thing. Which is all I was trying to do since the thread and my group are my only ways to get information. Like I told my group, my suspicion of you isn't super strong (it's the first lynch cycle after all) but I still think you're being overly defensive about being questioned.

I'm willing to change my vote if something more definitive comes up.
 
************
Seriously, mafia guys? 🙁 Not cool, I really wanted to play.

wolfspeaker said:
IPB, that sucks you were first to go 🙁 (but better you than me :laugh: I want to make it at least 1 cycle this time guys👍)
Click to expand...
:laugh: I'm not strategizing, but good luck with that! Dying early sucks.
************
 
nohika said:
Um, generally if they get info during the night they can't post about it until the day has started anyways...worst case they can message a group-mate.
Click to expand...

What I mean was, say someone got information Night 1, couldn't get online Day2, we aren't allowed to post during Night2, couldnt' get online Day3. We missed lynching a wolf because of it, or someone else being able to protect/block the correct person on Night3. I know it's basically the same as being silenced, but still would suck. I don't trust any of my groupmates, yet, to trust them with vital information. :laugh:

This is just how it will be, not complaining. Just musing aloud I guess.
 
Ok - I am going to take my dogs out for a W.A.L.K. - Roc is pacing....:laugh:

Will be back on a little later to figure out what to do...
 
Just an FYI...the night curfew will not be in place EVERY night, it's something that may happen along with other lockdowns etc like have happened in previous games when certain groups can't pm/post etc. but for now it stays 😛 makes you PM your group a bit more if you have something important to say!

If you have into that you don't even trust a single group member with, why would you share it on the thread? Just saying 🙂


Sent from my iPhone using SDN Mobile app
 
Lucky hit for the wolves, killing our possibly only seer.

Not sure who to lynch... Will wait to see if anyone found out anything before I decide to RNG.

Sent from my DROID RAZR using SDN Mobile
 
krist said:
If you have into that you don't even trust a single group member with, why would you share it on the thread? Just saying 🙂
Click to expand...

Uhhh, if you entrust your info to a wolf(you thought they were innocent):scared: and they kill you, and either don't pass on what you said, or twist it to suit them. That's why!

Sorry, my imagination runs wild sometimes! 😎
 
wolfspeaker said:
Uhhh, if you entrust your info to a wolf(you thought they were innocent):scared: and they kill you, and either don't pass on what you said, or twist it to suit them. That's why!

Sorry, my imagination runs wild sometimes! 😎
Click to expand...

Then just send it to your entire group. If it goes to a wolf (and odds are it will if you send it to the whole group) and you get killed at least the rest of the group can pass it along for you and the people who are unwilling to do so are going to look hella suspicious. I trawled for wolves this way in a previous game (Star Wars, maybe?) where the first night I had an item that would be high value to wolves, told my group, and lo and behold it got stolen, and pretty quickly we could figure out that there was at least one wolf in my group, and within a couple more days was able to narrow it down pretty well (then I got effing encased in carbonite and killed).

Like krist said, it's not really any different to PM your group with it than it is to post it on the thread.
 
Why do we have a cluster this early in the game? GRRR.
 
nyanko said:
Also, I like the curfew thing personally. 🙂
Click to expand...

Me too, It keeps the random conversations down, there aren't as many posts to go through and like somone said, there isn't any information that gets revealed at night... (except in my games... 😉) so there really isn't much of a need to be posting on the thread during the night cycle. 🙂
 
nyanko said:
Also, I like the curfew thing personally. 🙂
Click to expand...
************
It adds something interesting to the game that we haven't had before. Although now I'm DEAD and can't see for myself if I would have liked it... 🙁
************
 
Good point, Nyanko! :laugh: Hadn't thought that far about it.

K, going to go make food and tea.
 
Hey guys, sorry I've been MIA today, just got home from work. I need to grab some lunch and catch up on (YAY!) only two pages. I'll be back though!
 
Current lynch tally:

Sheepdogpsu: 1 (cuitl)

Waffles: 2

Less than 3 hours remain.

Also, to whoever asked earlier, I'm not sure about the deadlines. If we stick to 2 cycles/day I will probably have the night deadline somewhere around 10 am cst and then day deadline around 7-8 cst to allow for west coasters to get off work and participate.
However, if everyone wants the game to move faster, we certainly can because I am not working anymore! Hence why a perfect time for me to mod again 😀
 
And yes, I think the curfew does help people who play a lot from their phones to not have to read through a bunch of irrelevant posts to catch up. 👍 In addition just makes you have to PM more too which I think helps make the game interesting! :meanie:
 
krist said:
Current lynch tally:

Sheepdogpsu: 1 (cuitl)

Waffles: 2

Less than 3 hours remain.

Also, to whoever asked earlier, I'm not sure about the deadlines. If we stick to 2 cycles/day I will probably have the night deadline somewhere around 10 am cst and then day deadline around 7-8 cst to allow for west coasters to get off work and participate.
However, if everyone wants the game to move faster, we certainly can because I am not working anymore! Hence why a perfect time for me to mod again 😀
Click to expand...

I doesn't matter to me.. I am not working either but I will be really busy next week because I have to pack for Scotland (don't want to forget anything) and I will be completely MIA tonight because I will be out celebrating my Congratualtions/going away party with friends (Good chance I may be MIA tomorrow morning too😉).
 
I am going swimming and will probably not be back for the deadline, so the deadline still 5 pm but results may not be up right at 5.
 
I'm out eating and dont want to get lynched because I am a villager, ill reveal my role if I have to.

Just a guess lynch wldlfstdnt
 
deadline is less than an hour away and there is only 1 vote? I was hoping someone would have something by now that I could go on. I have to leave for work soon and no ideas as to who to lynch. 🙁
 
Getting ready to grill out with some friends that are in town...

RNG says to lynch nyanko

Sent from my DROID RAZR using SDN Mobile
 
Sheepdogpsu said:
I'm out eating and dont want to get lynched because I am a villager, ill reveal my role if I have to.

Just a guess lynch wldlfstdnt
Click to expand...


It may be a bit early for this, but we are both villagers! Don't ask how I know they are, I'm not ready to reveal that yet, this early in the game, but someone please investigate both of us as soon as possible! You just have to trust me. If you lynch me or wldlfstdnt, you will be lynching important villager roles! If this makes me look suspicious, so be it. I can't stay on here right up until deadline, I have to leave about 15 minutes before(in about 30 minutes), but please take my word for it!
 
************
Well, if I wasn't dead, I might've been able to help you guys out a little. 🙁
************
 
Sheepdogpsu said:
I'm out eating and dont want to get lynched because I am a villager, ill reveal my role if I have to.

Just a guess lynch wldlfstdnt
Click to expand...


Sheep, the first thought that came to mind was "you booger".

Why lynch me? Because I am quiet today? I have been busy dealing with a car that just cost me $2500.

Anyways I know I am innocent and I shall put some thought into who I want to lynch.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
54K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
39K
Clem J
Clem J
supershorty
GGoats ThWWee: Here It GGoats Again - GAME THREAD
93 94 95 96 97
Replies
5K
Views
55K
vampyrica
vampyrica
Animal Midwife
Season 12 Mafia Championship Nominations
2
Replies
77
Views
2K
holdthemayo
holdthemayo
WildZoo
Season 12 Mafia Championship Practice - Sign Ups
2
Replies
87
Views
4K
holdthemayo
holdthemayo
Top