Forum Members Official "Should I Retake?" Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Status
Not open for further replies.

QofQuimica

Seriously, dude, I think you're overreacting....
Moderator Emeritus
Lifetime Donor
15+ Year Member
Joined
Oct 12, 2004
Messages
18,899
Reaction score
4,295
EDIT 12/21/18: This thread is being retired, as the majority of posts (>80 pages) pertain to the old MCAT that is no longer relevant to current applicants. You can find the current "Should I Retake" thread here: Forum Members - Should I Retake the MCAT?

For those of you who are trying to figure out whether you should re-take, this is the thread for you. Post your dilemma here if you want advice from other SDN folks. Please note that you should take the opinions you get from SDN as one source of advice; you would be wise to also consult your premed advisor before making this decision. Here is my personal advice for those considering whether to re-take:

Definitely DO retake:
-if you scored below a 24. Some allopathic schools will screen out students with scores lower than 24, which is about the mean score for all test-takers.
-if you had some kind of major problem during the test that affected your performance (ex. you started puking or running a 102 degree temperature)
-if you took the test without completing the four pre-reqs (one year each of biology, chemistry, physics, and organic) and/or without studying for it
-if you left large numbers of questions blank​

Definitely do NOT retake:
-if you scored a 30 or better, especially if all of your individual section scores were an 8 or better
-if your section subscores (the numerical ones) are all good, but you didn't perform well on the writing section (the letter score)


Gray area-it's not obvious what to do:
-if you scored 30+ but with one section below an 8
-if you had some minor nuisances (ex. a noisy test room) during the test and you're not sure if it affected your performance
-if you studied thoroughly for the test and you scored within the range of your practice exams, but your score is in the middle range (24-29)​
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Thanks phoenix for the advice. If my practice scores aren't reaching 33-35 range consistently and more like still 29-30's then I won't retake it in the summer. My verbal scores were flip flopping between 9 and 7 right before the exam. My PS was pretty good 10-11 of TPR tests and 11,12's on aamc. There were some hard physics math questions. I'm going to start working on verbal and PS and see how i'm improving. Thanks again!
 
I think my stuff got lost in the mix so I'll post it again.

I got a 27O in January (10/8/9).
I took it back in July and got about the same thing...27Q (9/10/8).

I have a 4.0 from a smaller university (does the school really matter anyways?).

Chemistry major/Biology minor

Some ECs:

Eagle Scout
Shadowing a physician
Honors College
Alpha Chi Member
Assoication of Baptist Students(ABS) leader for 4 years
Chemistry club member
Organic SI for 1 year
Organic TA for 1 semester
Church mission trips

I'm from Arkansas and will be applying to UAMS and schools in neighboring states like Texas and Tennesee (Vanderbilt being my dream school!).

I really don't want to take it again, but I will if I need to. I walked out of the test feeling like I did really good (was expecting at least a 30)...much better than when I walked out the last time in July.

I'm not sure if I can study for the MCAT during the semester with school so busy. I went through a Kaplan book and took practice tests this last time but to no avail apparently, lol. If I do take it again, I'll probably just take a bunch of practice tests and hope for the best.

Please advise!
 
This one got lost too.

Hi. This is m first post! I am trying to decide if I should apply to programs and if I should retake the test. I took the test three times:

Jan 2008: 29O (10PS; 8V; 11BS)
May 2007: 25P (7PS; 8V; 10BS)
Jan 2007: 26N (8PS; 8V; 10BS)

I want to be a physician scientist, but I do not think I will be competitive in the MD/PhD applicant pool purely because of my poor performance on this test. I am from a WWAMI state. Do you think I have a shot at U of Washington's MD program? I may also be able to claim Maryland residency, so do I have a shot at a Maryland school with these scores?

Should I try to retake the test again to get my verbal up or is 4 tries too many? I typically score either 8s (when I do not finish) or 10-11 on practice tests in this section. I did not finish the verbal section the first two times but I did the third time. I took 3 VS the week of my last test and got 11s on all of them, so I was a little disappointed in my last score.

I have a 3.7GPA from an unknown LAC.

Thanks,

Lacunae
 
Hey all. So I am posting again just to get some more input, b/c after being told I am pretty much a candidate for only a DO school, I would like a 2nd (or 3rd or 4th opinion). So My GPA was a 3.14 overall, and about the same for the sciences. I got a 30O on the MCAT (10VR, 11BS, 9PS) & plan to take it again. I also am working full time in a research lab and am tutoring a high school student in physics. I did not have many ECs in college besides volunteering in a hospital once a week (bad I know). Thanks to Phoenix's advice, I am considering taking a class at a college here, like maybe organic again, or a grad class. Do you have any advice about what sort of classes I can take (I think it will just to show my effort rather than boost my GPA since one or two classes can not make that big of a difference). & also, what my chances of getting into school are? Thanks!!

I'm assuming you already have all the prereqs done. If so, then taking a class here or there probably isn't going to help that much. I think you'd definitely benefit from doing an SMP. It's a Special Master's Program, and you'd basically be taking med school classes to show you can hack it. Many schools that have SMP programs take a decent number of their SMP students into their med school. And I certainly know people who had a low gpa like yours who didn't get in on multiple tries, but did get in the year they were doing an SMP. Alternatively, if you're in a state with very friendly state schools that have accessible stats, then you could consider just doing a couple of recent upper level science courses and just apply with that to see how things go this year. Perhaps you'll get lucky if your research, LORs, and personal statement are stellar. But I don't think that retaking the MCAT is going to do much for you, unless you hit 35+. And even then, I still think you'd have to do something to offset your low gpa to show med schools you've got what it takes in coursework (not just a one time test). I honestly think you'd be better off with an SMP, or if you're really averse to that, perhaps taking a bunch of undergrad upper level science courses to raise your gpa. Also, you need to try to get more clinical experience, but obviously you know that already.

Here are the straight, not-so-great stats:
cumGPA:3.345
science GPA: around 3.2 :scared:

Took the MCAT twice, both with the exact same breakdown (except WS)
August 07 PS/VR/BS 9/10/10 WS O = 29O
January 08 9/10/10 WS R = 29R :scared:

I know I already have it tough because of my horrible GPA... I was scoring a lot higher on practice AAMC PS sections (scoring 12-13) so I do not know what happened and am very very frustrated. 😡

Should I risk taking the exam again this May? Most stuff is still fresh in my memory and I think I have a better idea as far as what I need to concentrate on. I know they say that it's bad to take the exam more than twice... but do I even stand ANY chance of getting into ANY school with my current stats???

Thank you...

Well, you took it twice already and got the same exact score. I'm assuming you tried studying hard the second time, so do you think you'll end up improving your score that much more the third time? Perhaps it's just a case of text anxiety? Who knows? Regardless, I think that your score is good, and is nicely balanced. Granted, your gpa is on the low side (the science gpa will be the problem), but it could be worse. If you're in a state with stats-accessible schools, I think you've certainly got a shot. If you're not (i.e., you're a resident of CA), you still might have a shot. You'll just have to write a great personal statement, have excellent LORs, very good ECs with lots of clinical experience, and apply EARLY and BROADLY. I've certainly seen people with your stats get in. It just depends on the total package. For instance, you'll definitely need to show a strong upward trend in your grades. if your lower grades where from a couple of years ago, and you've been getting good grades recently, you're good. If you got Cs in science courses recently, you'll definitely need to remedy that or it will hurt you.

Regardless, rather than beat your head against the wall trying to raise a pretty good score, see if the other aspects of your application will support your lower gpa. If I were you, and the rest of my app were strong (with an upward trend as well), I'd apply with that MCAT and see where things stand this cycle. If you're open to DO school, I'd add some of those to your application if you'd rather get a DO than wait another year. Regardless of whether you apply this year or not, I think you should strongly consider taking some recent upper level science courses if you don't have a strong upward trend, so that schools can see that you can handle med school science courses. And even taking those classes during your application year may help since you can update schools with your new grades - hopefully all As.

I think my stuff got lost in the mix so I'll post it again.

I got a 27O in January (10/8/9).
I took it back in July and got about the same thing...27Q (9/10/8).

I have a 4.0 from a smaller university (does the school really matter anyways?).

Chemistry major/Biology minor

Some ECs:

Eagle Scout
Shadowing a physician
Honors College
Alpha Chi Member
Assoication of Baptist Students(ABS) leader for 4 years
Chemistry club member
Organic SI for 1 year
Organic TA for 1 semester
Church mission trips

I'm from Arkansas and will be applying to UAMS and schools in neighboring states like Texas and Tennesee (Vanderbilt being my dream school!).

I really don't want to take it again, but I will if I need to. I walked out of the test feeling like I did really good (was expecting at least a 30)...much better than when I walked out the last time in July.

I'm not sure if I can study for the MCAT during the semester with school so busy. I went through a Kaplan book and took practice tests this last time but to no avail apparently, lol. If I do take it again, I'll probably just take a bunch of practice tests and hope for the best.

Please advise!

Given your state of residence, Arkansas, and that you're also interested in Tennessee schools, I think you've definitely got a shot. I could be wrong, but I think I recall those schools have more accessible stats. So if you really don't want to take it again, give it a shot and apply this cycle and see what happens. Also, you should check with those schools and see how they calculate multiple MCAT scores. Some schools will actually take the highest section from each test (Tufts and a couple of others), while some don't. Regardless, I think you should definitely try to get more clinical experience than just shadowing. I would recommend volunteering at a free health clinic or at a hospital. If you don't want to apply to DO schools as well, then just be prepared to apply again next cycle (after retaking the MCAT) if you don't get in this round. But I think that if the rest of your app is solid, and you apply EARLY, you've got a shot at your target schools.
 
This one got lost too.
Hi. This is m first post! I am trying to decide if I should apply to programs and if I should retake the test. I took the test three times:

Jan 2008: 29O (10PS; 8V; 11BS)
May 2007: 25P (7PS; 8V; 10BS)
Jan 2007: 26N (8PS; 8V; 10BS)

I want to be a physician scientist, but I do not think I will be competitive in the MD/PhD applicant pool purely because of my poor performance on this test. I am from a WWAMI state. Do you think I have a shot at U of Washington's MD program? I may also be able to claim Maryland residency, so do I have a shot at a Maryland school with these scores?

Should I try to retake the test again to get my verbal up or is 4 tries too many? I typically score either 8s (when I do not finish) or 10-11 on practice tests in this section. I did not finish the verbal section the first two times but I did the third time. I took 3 VS the week of my last test and got 11s on all of them, so I was a little disappointed in my last score.

I have a 3.7GPA from an unknown LAC.

Thanks,

Lacunae

Lacunae: Sorry, I don't know enough about md/phd programs to give you any advice there (although I agree that it sounds like you wouldn't be too competitive there unless you had some truly phenomenal research/publications), but it does sound like you should stop taking the MCAT. Instead, I think you should put together the best app you can, with a great personal statement, excellent LORs and some thorough clinical experience that you can really talk about in your personal statement and secondary essays. Sounds like you've got a shot at both Washington and Maryland, so you might as well give it a try. But you should definitely get your application in EARLY. Also, I think you should contact both schools and find out how they calculate multiple MCAT scores. I've heard of schools that just take the most recent score, schools that take the highest of each section, and schools that average the scores. If those schools average, that's not to your advantage, and it'd be good to know going into it. While it may feel like this whole process is about stats, it's not. You basically need a certain general minimum (this varies school to school and year to year), and if you attain it, you can get an interview at many schools if the other aspects of your application are compelling. So, if you have amazing research, or really unusual ECs, as well as a compelling personal statement and shining LORs, there's absolutely nothing wrong with a 29 on the MCAT. And even that 8 in VR wouldn't tank an otherwise competitive application. Anyway, that's my opinion on the matter.
 
Hey all. So I am posting again just to get some more input, b/c after being told I am pretty much a candidate for only a DO school, I would like a 2nd (or 3rd or 4th opinion). So My GPA was a 3.14 overall, and about the same for the sciences. I got a 30O on the MCAT (10VR, 11BS, 9PS) & plan to take it again. I also am working full time in a research lab and am tutoring a high school student in physics. I did not have many ECs in college besides volunteering in a hospital once a week (bad I know). Thanks to Phoenix's advice, I am considering taking a class at a college here, like maybe organic again, or a grad class. Do you have any advice about what sort of classes I can take (I think it will just to show my effort rather than boost my GPA since one or two classes can not make that big of a difference). & also, what my chances of getting into school are? Thanks!!

I think Phoenix. answered your questions to the best of our ability here. I think your MCAT looks fine- it's the GPA that could use a bit of a boost. Since your issue now is about raising your GPA, I think your best bet is to get some help from the "What are my chances?" threads in pre-allo and pre-osteo.

Here are the straight, not-so-great stats:
cumGPA:3.345
science GPA: around 3.2 :scared:

Took the MCAT twice, both with the exact same breakdown (except WS)
August 07 PS/VR/BS 9/10/10 WS O = 29O
January 08 9/10/10 WS R = 29R :scared:

I know I already have it tough because of my horrible GPA... I was scoring a lot higher on practice AAMC PS sections (scoring 12-13) so I do not know what happened and am very very frustrated. 😡

Should I risk taking the exam again this May? Most stuff is still fresh in my memory and I think I have a better idea as far as what I need to concentrate on. I know they say that it's bad to take the exam more than twice... but do I even stand ANY chance of getting into ANY school with my current stats???

Thank you...

PnB- My stats are VERY similar to yours (MCAT 1 point lower, GPA 0.1 and 0.2 higher, respectively). I've had a few interviews, and even have an acceptance. So it CAN be done. I'll reiterate that if you choose to go with this MCAT score- and I'm not really sure you need to retake because it's a pretty balanced score- apply early and broadly across MD and DO. Have a killer PS, fabulous LORs, and let the chips fall where they may.

I got a 27O in January (10/8/9).
I took it back in July and got about the same thing...27Q (9/10/8).

I have a 4.0 from a smaller university (does the school really matter anyways?).

Chemistry major/Biology minor

Some ECs:

Eagle Scout
Shadowing a physician
Honors College
Alpha Chi Member
Assoication of Baptist Students(ABS) leader for 4 years
Chemistry club member
Organic SI for 1 year
Organic TA for 1 semester
Church mission trips

I'm from Arkansas and will be applying to UAMS and schools in neighboring states like Texas and Tennesee (Vanderbilt being my dream school!).

The long and short is.. you have a huge advantage in that you have a state school that takes almost exclusively state residents. You have an excellent GPA. Your neighboring state school is friendly toward bordering states. Phoenix is correct that some schools will look at your score and see "29" rather than 27. (I don't know if UAMS does this or not.)



Again, for any questions other than MCAT scores, please go to the "What Are My Chances?" threads-

Pre-Allo: http://forums.studentdoctor.net/showthread.php?t=483601

Pre-Osteo: http://forums.studentdoctor.net/showthread.php?t=461082
 
I appreciate the advice guys!

One more thing...I really do want to do more than shadow, and I plan to do so. This coming year is going to be easy class wise, and I am planning on volunteering at the local hospital. But the thing is, I can't do anything else until after this semester, and I'm applying in July. Is there a place on the AMCAS application where I can put that I PLAN to volunteer. Will it matter if I say at the interview that I have more clinical than what's on my application? I'm kind of in a bind until summer...after my application, lol.
 
Thanks a lot for the advice you two, I really appreciate it. I guess I was thinking a 38 MCAT (if I got one) could make up for, or help, my low GPA, but I guess not. This may also be a dumb question, but how can I get more clinical experience? Are the only ways to shadow someone/volunteer in a hospital? Thanks!
 
Phoenix and Pingiuin, thank you so very much for your kind advice. I think I needed to hear it from someone else that it's probably worth a shot, although I will most likely have to re-apply... So I guess this is the beginning of the end now, application cycle 2008 here I come!

THANKS AGAIN! 🙂
 
I appreciate the advice guys!

One more thing...I really do want to do more than shadow, and I plan to do so. This coming year is going to be easy class wise, and I am planning on volunteering at the local hospital. But the thing is, I can't do anything else until after this semester, and I'm applying in July. Is there a place on the AMCAS application where I can put that I PLAN to volunteer. Will it matter if I say at the interview that I have more clinical than what's on my application? I'm kind of in a bind until summer...after my application, lol.

I remember a place to put intended coursework, but not intended activities. However, even if there isn't somewhere to put it down on AMCAS, many secondaries have a place where you indicate what you're currently doing, or give you opportunities to write an essay about it. Barring that, you could always send a letter of update letting schools know about your new EC and what you're getting from it.

Thanks a lot for the advice you two, I really appreciate it. I guess I was thinking a 38 MCAT (if I got one) could make up for, or help, my low GPA, but I guess not. This may also be a dumb question, but how can I get more clinical experience? Are the only ways to shadow someone/volunteer in a hospital? Thanks!

You're welcome! I think the best place to get clinical experience is by volunteering at a free health clinic. You generally get to do a lot more (I do triage and draw blood) and have a much more meaningful experience than simply handing out blankets or updating charts in the ER of a hospital. But yeah, volunteering in the hospital or shadowing doctors works too.

Phoenix and Pingiuin, thank you so very much for your kind advice. I think I needed to hear it from someone else that it's probably worth a shot, although I will most likely have to re-apply... So I guess this is the beginning of the end now, application cycle 2008 here I come!

THANKS AGAIN! 🙂

You're welcome and good luck! :luck:
 
I have taken the mcat 3 times:

2002 (apr) - 22
2002 (aug)- 25
2008 (jan) - 26

Ugrad gpa - 3.6 bcmp gpa - 3.4
Grad gpa (MPH @ top school)- 3.9

lots of ECs/research and a publication. Good LORs.

I signed up for the May 08' exam, but I am just not sold on whether or not I should take the exam again. I want to apply in June so May is pretty much my last option if I should retake the exam. Any suggestions?
user_offline.gif
 
I have taken the mcat 3 times:

2002 (apr) - 22
2002 (aug)- 25
2008 (jan) - 26

Ugrad gpa - 3.6 bcmp gpa - 3.4
Grad gpa (MPH @ top school)- 3.9

lots of ECs/research and a publication. Good LORs.

I signed up for the May 08' exam, but I am just not sold on whether or not I should take the exam again. I want to apply in June so May is pretty much my last option if I should retake the exam. Any suggestions?
user_offline.gif
Ethnicity and MD or DO?

Caucasian or Asian and MD- retake
Caucasian or asian and DO- you can probably get in
URM and MD-maybe you can get in
 
I have taken the mcat 3 times:

2002 (apr) - 22
2002 (aug)- 25
2008 (jan) - 26

Ugrad gpa - 3.6 bcmp gpa - 3.4
Grad gpa (MPH @ top school)- 3.9

lots of ECs/research and a publication. Good LORs.

I signed up for the May 08' exam, but I am just not sold on whether or not I should take the exam again. I want to apply in June so May is pretty much my last option if I should retake the exam. Any suggestions?
user_offline.gif


If you are doing consistently better on practice exams in April, then I think you should retake if you're aiming for MD schools - bringing your score up two points even would really improve your chances. But if you're not scoring consistently better, then don't risk it. Regardless, apply early and broadly.

And definitely check out DO schools - you have a much better shot at those with a sub 28 MCAT score. If you really don't want to retake the MCAT (or aren't scoring any better in practices), I'd recommend just applying to your state MD schools and some DO schools. You best MD bets will be your instate schools, so, that means that if you're in a state with more accessible instate schools you've got a better shot to get into an MD school than if you're a resident of a state like California.
 
I was wondering if I should take my mcat again as well

I got a:
VR:7
BS:10
PS:10

total: 27Q

gpa-3.75

im hoping for md in the states and am a texas resident
 
I was wondering if I should take my mcat again as well

I got a:
VR:7
BS:10
PS:10

total: 27Q

gpa-3.75

im hoping for md in the states and am a texas resident
You are one of those borderline MCATers. If you scored 9+ on VR consistently on your practice MCAT, then I would retake, If not you might wanna stick with what you got.
 
I got a 31R (11BS 11PS 9VR) on January 25th 2008 with a month of studying.

Just wondering if retaking would be a good idea especially since I want to go to a CA med school (I am a CA resident)

Thanks. 🙂
 
hey! so i'm new to this hold forum thing, but i need some help considering med schools and retaking my MCAT

my current GPA is 3.484
my science GPA is a 3.21, could be a little higher

i just took the january mcat and got a 30R with PS 10, BS 10, V 10

i don't know whether to retake or not. i'm applying this summer, so i'm defiintely working on raising my GPA this semester -- especially my science GPA.

do yall have any opinions on what to do with the mcat? i'm happy with my scores, especially since i got 10's in all the sections. i'm afraid to retake it and go down in any of my sections. but at the same time want a higher score... ahhh suggestions, anyone?
 
hey! so i'm new to this hold forum thing, but i need some help considering med schools and retaking my MCAT

my current GPA is 3.484
my science GPA is a 3.21, could be a little higher

i just took the january mcat and got a 30R with PS 10, BS 10, V 10

i don't know whether to retake or not. i'm applying this summer, so i'm defiintely working on raising my GPA this semester -- especially my science GPA.

do yall have any opinions on what to do with the mcat? i'm happy with my scores, especially since i got 10's in all the sections. i'm afraid to retake it and go down in any of my sections. but at the same time want a higher score... ahhh suggestions, anyone?
The MCAT score is good. I would suggest continuing to raise your science GPA as you are working on, getting great LORs, writing a strong PS, and making sure the rest of your application is strong. Apply early, broadly, and I think you'll get some interest from both some MD and DO schools.
 
I got a 31R (11BS 11PS 9VR) on January 25th 2008 with a month of studying.

Just wondering if retaking would be a good idea especially since I want to go to a CA med school (I am a CA resident)

Thanks. 🙂

That will make you competitive for sure at some of the California schools assuming the rest of your application is solid. If you're applying in June 2008, then don't retake the MCAT and worry about the rest of your application. If you're applying in June 2009 and have extra time over the summer, maybe you should seriously look into hitting the books and getting that 35+ to make you competitive at some of the top-tier California schools like UCSF, Stanford, UCLA, UCSD, etc. Nice work! 👍
 
I have a this or that question:

I can either retake the MCAT or take an anatomy and physiology online course at UNC (which appears on a transcript as a UNC class). I don't have time to do both (i work 40 hrs and volunteer)

Here are my stats so far:
3.2 GPA Science/ 3.15 other, ivy league
30 MCAT (7/11/12)
lots of volunteer work (director of tutoring program for inner city kids, summer at camp for kids with chronic illnesses)
work in hospital as a clinical research coordinator seeing patients (since september)
volunteer in ER dept.

which do you think will help me more? i've been told by a friend the class should be an easy A.
 
I have a this or that question:

I can either retake the MCAT or take an anatomy and physiology online course at UNC (which appears on a transcript as a UNC class). I don't have time to do both (i work 40 hrs and volunteer)

Here are my stats so far:
3.2 GPA Science/ 3.15 other, ivy league
30 MCAT (7/11/12)
lots of volunteer work (director of tutoring program for inner city kids, summer at camp for kids with chronic illnesses)
work in hospital as a clinical research coordinator seeing patients (since september)
volunteer in ER dept.

which do you think will help me more? i've been told by a friend the class should be an easy A.

Depends on your hour/credit count (i.e., how much impact that A will have) as well as the schools to which you want to apply.

In general, I'd say that your 7 on PS is a little troubling. So is my 6 on BS, hence my own retake.
 
I only have 11 science courses, so this would be the 12th and therefore still have a fairly significant impact. (i think my calculation is with an A my GPA would go up to 3.28)

oh and this was already an MCAT retake from 2005 when i got a 29Q (8/11/10).

I think my psci would improve as i didn't score below a 10 on practice exams. but the 12 on bio was higher than my practice tests.

why oh why can't it be simple?
 
I only have 11 science courses, so this would be the 12th and therefore still have a fairly significant impact. (i think my calculation is with an A my GPA would go up to 3.28)

oh and this was already an MCAT retake from 2005 when i got a 29Q (8/11/10).

I think my psci would improve as i didn't score below a 10 on practice exams. but the 12 on bio was higher than my practice tests.

why oh why can't it be simple?

If you find out how to make things simple, please tell me about it... sigh.

Then again, you're saying that this class is supposed to be an easy A. I know you said you bust your *** between work and volunteerism and all that, but are you sure you couldn't do both? May as well have your fluffy frosted dessert food product and consume it as well if it's at all possible...
 
PS: 12
VR: 9
BS: 10
WS: Q

Post-bac GPA: 3.83
undergrad GPA: 2.96
overall amcas calculated gpa approx. 3.2

I tested much higher in Verbal and Bio on my practice tests and I never tested above an 11 on physics. I still think I have a much better score in me.

I took the kaplan course but only sat for 2 aamc practice courses. I did not feel like did a very good job on the real thing.
 
these are my scores:

33M

PS: 12
BS: 12
VR: 9
WS: M

GPA 3.65

1 year of research, 1.5 years of volunteering

what kind of schools would i likely get into?

should i try to retake the mcat?

i know from reading this forum most people would think my scores are fine, but i'm really concerned because many of my friends that applied last summer who have better grades and scores than i do are having a hard time getting ANY interviews...
 
these are my scores:

33M

PS: 12
BS: 12
VR: 9
WS: M

GPA 3.65

1 year of research, 1.5 years of volunteering

what kind of schools would i likely get into?

should i try to retake the mcat?

i know from reading this forum most people would think my scores are fine, but i'm really concerned because many of my friends that applied last summer who have better grades and scores than i do are having a hard time getting ANY interviews...

MCAT: I wouldn't, although - and for whatever it's worth - that writing sample isn't too hot.

Schools: Unsure, consult MSAR (USNews a distant second).

And an MCAT+GPA does not a great applicant make. You are more than yo' digits, homeboy. 😀
 
these are my scores:

33M

PS: 12
BS: 12
VR: 9
WS: M

GPA 3.65

1 year of research, 1.5 years of volunteering

what kind of schools would i likely get into?

should i try to retake the mcat?

i know from reading this forum most people would think my scores are fine, but i'm really concerned because many of my friends that applied last summer who have better grades and scores than i do are having a hard time getting ANY interviews...

Your scores are more than fine - they're great. I would not retake. If you end up not getting any interviews, either your personal statement is horrendous, you ended up applying really late to only top tier schools, and/or you have a terrible letter of recommendation in your file. Just put together a great app and I think you'll have options.
 
PS: 12
VR: 9
BS: 10
WS: Q

Post-bac GPA: 3.83
undergrad GPA: 2.96
overall amcas calculated gpa approx. 3.2

I tested much higher in Verbal and Bio on my practice tests and I never tested above an 11 on physics. I still think I have a much better score in me.

I took the kaplan course but only sat for 2 aamc practice courses. I did not feel like did a very good job on the real thing.

Normally I would say you should stick with what you've got. But if you're a CA resident, I'd suggest that you take more practice tests, and if you're scoring consistently higher, go ahead and retake. Just be sure that the retake won't hold your application up (i.e., take it by June).

With your gpa (3.2) you need to apply both super-early and broadly (especially if you're a CA resident). While a stellar MCAT score can help counter a low gpa to some degree (but not completely), you might be fine with what you've got right now if you're in a state with friendly instate schools and the rest of your application is good.
 
Normally I would say you should stick with what you've got. But if you're a CA resident, I'd suggest that you take more practice tests, and if you're scoring consistently higher, go ahead and retake. Just be sure that the retake won't hold your application up (i.e., take it by June).

With your gpa (3.2) you need to apply both super-early and broadly (especially if you're a CA resident). While a stellar MCAT score can help counter a low gpa to some degree (but not completely), you might be fine with what you've got right now if you're in a state with friendly instate schools and the rest of your application is good.

You guessed it. I am a CA resident with some affiliation to IL (grew up there), OH (undergrad), and TX (lived there for a few years and was born there).

Since I already have a score, can't I just apply June 1 with no hold up? I'm planning on retaking June 13th so once I get my scores I'll just decide if I want to apply to more competitive schools. I know UC schools are not rolling admissions so waiting until July to submit shouldn't be a problem, I think.

I'm 5 years out of undergrad and I have a very competitive math and science GPA as well as some upper divisional science courses so I'm hoping I can get some forgiveness on my undergrad performance.
 
You guessed it. I am a CA resident with some affiliation to IL (grew up there), OH (undergrad), and TX (lived there for a few years and was born there).

Since I already have a score, can't I just apply June 1 with no hold up? I'm planning on retaking June 13th so once I get my scores I'll just decide if I want to apply to more competitive schools. I know UC schools are not rolling admissions so waiting until July to submit shouldn't be a problem, I think.

I'm 5 years out of undergrad and I have a very competitive math and science GPA as well as some upper divisional science courses so I'm hoping I can get some forgiveness on my undergrad performance.

When you submit your primary you indicate if you will be taking a future MCAT. All of the schools will then set your application aside as incomplete until that MCAT score is released to them. So, yes, it will hold your application up. But I don't believe that taking a June MCAT will cause any significant delay. I just wouldn't take it any later than June if you want the best shot you can get at OOS schools too.
 
Don't most private schools automatically send out a secondary?

I don't know about public vs. private, but I would say that most schools do send out the secondary without having received your MCAT score. Of the 28 or so schools I applied to (see my mdapps), I only remember a couple waiting - somewhere between 1-3 schools. Generally they'll send you the secondary but put your app on hold. But I do remember that it took quite awhile to get the Loyola secondary because they wait for your MCAT score first, and then send the secondary out a few weeks later. But most schools that were waiting for the scores deemed me complete or sent the secondary ASAP upon receiving my score in July. Regardless, I just used SDN to see what the questions were and had pre-written the essay questions for those secondaries I hadn't received yet - that way there was only a one day turn around time.
 
I'm applying this year and have a 33Q. Normally, I wouldn't think about retaking but since I'm international (Canadian), I think it might not be enough.

Anyone?

I wouldn't. You'll be hard pressed to reliably improve on that, and it's already well above average among MCAT takers.
 
In August 2007, took it for the first time and got a 25 S: VR 6, BS 9, PS 10.

I gave it my all that summer and studied like 10 hours a day every day, and still couldn't pull off a 30. I'm registered for the re-take May 23, and haven't been studying all that much because I'm loaded up with 2 jobs and 19 credits. My practice scores are in the teens... should I retake? Or just settle for a Carib school?
 
In August 2007, took it for the first time and got a 25 S: VR 6, BS 9, PS 10.

I gave it my all that summer and studied like 10 hours a day every day, and still couldn't pull off a 30. I'm registered for the re-take May 23, and haven't been studying all that much because I'm loaded up with 2 jobs and 19 credits. My practice scores are in the teens... should I retake? Or just settle for a Carib school?

If you can't get your practice scores into the upper 20s, there's a very good chance you could end up with a lower score than you've got now. In that case DO NOT RETAKE. If you plan on retaking in the future when you have more time to study, great. If not, then I'd suggest you apply EARLY to your instate MD schools (you're in FL - gotta try), any DO schools you'd be interested in attending, and any carib schools you'd like to go to. From what I've read, going the DO route is generally a much better idea than going to an international school (i.e., for purposes or residency). Check out the pre-osteopathic forum to learn more about DO schools before you discount that as an option.
 
In August 2007, took it for the first time and got a 25 S: VR 6, BS 9, PS 10.

I gave it my all that summer and studied like 10 hours a day every day, and still couldn't pull off a 30. I'm registered for the re-take May 23, and haven't been studying all that much because I'm loaded up with 2 jobs and 19 credits. My practice scores are in the teens... should I retake? Or just settle for a Carib school?

Bien sûr! You're already registered. Don't blow $110 for nothing.
 
If you can't get your practice scores into the upper 20s, there's a very good chance you could end up with a lower score than you've got now. In that case DO NOT RETAKE. If you plan on retaking in the future when you have more time to study, great. If not, then I'd suggest you apply EARLY to your instate MD schools (you're in FL - gotta try), any DO schools you'd be interested in attending, and any carib schools you'd like to go to. From what I've read, going the DO route is generally a much better idea than going to an international school (i.e., for purposes or residency). Check out the pre-osteopathic forum to learn more about DO schools before you discount that as an option.


Thank you for the advice, Phoenix and Exi. I'm actually applying to medical school this summer, so this is my last chance to take it.

Btw, gpa is 3.6. Double major in Neuroscience and French with Music performance minor. And tons of clinical experience, research, etc. Again, MCAT is 25S. So, are my chances at medical school that bad?

Correct me if I'm wrong, but I actually don't see the Caribbean schools as such a bad idea. Every fellow Miami-an Pre-Med I know has gone to the Caribbean (Grenada, Dominica & Puerto Rico) and they seem to be doing well. As for residency spots, I don't know. But I think it's better to be an M.D. in the end and have lived by the beach on an island for 4 years than to have never been an M.D. at all. Any opinions? 😉
 
Thank you for the advice, Phoenix and Exi. I'm actually applying to medical school this summer, so this is my last chance to take it.

Btw, gpa is 3.6. Double major in Neuroscience and French with Music performance minor. And tons of clinical experience, research, etc. Again, MCAT is 25S. So, are my chances at medical school that bad?

Correct me if I'm wrong, but I actually don't see the Caribbean schools as such a bad idea. Every fellow Miami-an Pre-Med I know has gone to the Caribbean (Grenada, Dominica & Puerto Rico) and they seem to be doing well. As for residency spots, I don't know. But I think it's better to be an M.D. in the end and have lived by the beach on an island for 4 years than to have never been an M.D. at all. Any opinions? 😉


First off, the Puerto Rican schools are considered domestic MD schools, not international like the other carib schools. By all means, apply to the Puerto Rican schools and enjoy your island lifestyle! I don't think that's a bad idea at all.

There are people who have gotten into an MD school with a 25 on the MCAT, but the numbers really aren't in your favor. I think the vast majority have a 27+. That's why I was suggesting that you make some alternate plans just in case. Get an MSAR and look at the stats for the schools. I think your best bets will be Florida schools and Puerto Rican schools. Also, in the event this applies to you, you'll have a better chance of getting in with a 25 if you're a URM. Go check out the URM forum if you are.

Also, definitely check out the FAQ in the pre-osteopathic forum. From everything I've heard, getting a DO is absolutely the easier path for getting residencies in the US than going to an international school. There are supposedly many fewer spots for international MD graduates. And from what I recall, a DO graduate can apply for both DO and MD residencies if they take the applicable MD tests (I'm assuming it's step I and II, but I'm not certain).

I think I've also heard that going to the carib is can be more of a weed out experience - definitely read up carefully on each of the carib schools before applying as some are considered much more reputable than others. There's an International Forum on SDN where you can read up on some of that, and probably find some threads by people asking your very questions (i.e., about carib schools and how that would compare to getting a DO).

Sounds like the rest of your app is very good, so perhaps you'll get into an instate school. But I definitely wouldn't retake the MCAT if your practice scores aren't above 25. You'll be in a much worse position if you end up doing worse.
 
Thank you so much for your great advice! I really appreciate it. It's been more than helpful. I will definitely check out the DO and Caribbean forums (I already checked out the Caribbean forums and the impression I got was that going to a Caribbean school isn't a bad idea at all.) I certainly didn't know that you could apply to MD residencies after graduating from a DO school.

One problem that I'm finding with applying to Puerto Rican schools is that all 4 schools require 12 credits in English (which is 6 credits more than the usual American schools require) and 6 credits in Spanish. Which I think should be voided if you're a native Spanish speaker like myself, but oh well. Can't live in a perfect world.

Thanks for suggesting the URM forum. I am a URM, but living in Miami, it sure doesn't feel like it. lol. So I tend to forget that it works to my advantage.
 
One problem that I'm finding with applying to Puerto Rican schools is that all 4 schools require 12 credits in English (which is 6 credits more than the usual American schools require) and 6 credits in Spanish. Which I think should be voided if you're a native Spanish speaker like myself, but oh well. Can't live in a perfect world.

I would definitely call the schools directly, explain you're a native Spanish speaker, and see what they say. One of them may make an exception - you never know.

Thanks for suggesting the URM forum. I am a URM, but living in Miami, it sure doesn't feel like it. lol. So I tend to forget that it works to my advantage.

Since you're a URM, you should definitely apply broadly to a lot of MD schools (in addition to any DO and International schools that you're interested in). I think as a URM with an otherwise excellent application, and only one mark against you with a 25 (especially since it's only the VR that's low), that you definitely stand more of a chance than I previously predicted. Your application fees will be high, but I think it'll be worth it to apply incredibly broadly if you get an MD acceptance. You might want to check out mdapps and see how other applicants with your stats fared in FL.

So, my advice is not to retake unless you're doing better than 25 consistently on practice tests, and to be sure to apply super early to any MD school you'd be interested in attending (as well as some DO and/or international schools). I've certainly heard of non-URM applicants getting in with a 6 in VR (although it's rare), so I would think that if that's the only negative on your application, you've got a shot. I'm not sure, but I thought I'd heard that they go a little easier on how they view VR if you're not a native English speaker (not sure if you are or not). Good luck!
 
Thanks, Phoenix! You're the best!!!! 🙂 That was so uplifting. Up until now I've been thinking I don't even have a shot at MD schools in the U.S. But you're right. Maybe as a URM, I have much more of a chance at medical schools. And yes, I speak perfect English but it's not my first language, so maybe a 6 in Verbal isn't the worst if I explain that in my application. I've also been looking into the URM forum and the DO forums like you suggested. Thanks again for your advice. And good luck to you too!
 
PS- 10
VB- 12
BS- 11
Writ - O

Debating on retaking because I was slightly higher on practice tests and can def do better in Bio...
 
First attempt: 7 VR, 8 PS, 9 BS, M
Second attempt: 8 VR, 10 PS, 12 BS, N

3.54 BCPM
3.5 AO

Withdrew application first cycle due to low mcat.
Applied late second cycle due to being in hospital for a month from accident.

Only got one interview from my state school.
Good research and clinical background.

Should I retake or not? I am afraid that 8 will hurt me.
 
PS- 10
VB- 12
BS- 11
Writ - O

Debating on retaking because I was slightly higher on practice tests and can def do better in Bio...
I really don't see a retake as necessary. It's a good score.

First attempt: 7 VR, 8 PS, 9 BS, M
Second attempt: 8 VR, 10 PS, 12 BS, N

3.54 BCPM
3.5 AO

Withdrew application first cycle due to low mcat.
Applied late second cycle due to being in hospital for a month from accident.

Only got one interview from my state school.
Good research and clinical background.

Should I retake or not? I am afraid that 8 will hurt me.

My opinion only, but I think if you make sure you apply early this year, and apply broadly, you'd have more luck this year at least getting interviews.
 
so i took my mcat in july of 2007 (end of july) and i ended up with a 27Q.. i got a 9p/10v/8b. I was really bummed out about this, especially bio. I took kaplan last summer to prep for it and seriously took 10 practice exams. On the last 4 or 5 I was scoring between 30-33 so I was feeling pretty good, and then when I got the 27 i was really shocked. So now i'm signed up for the june 13th administration, but i'm really scared about it. After studying so much last year (seriously devoted my entire summer to it, all my friends never saw me) i'm worried the same thing might happen again this year. Does anyone have any advice/study tactics/inspiration for studying again for the mcat?? I'm not taking a class again, and i'm planning on using examkrackers mostly with some kaplan books too. Also any ideas for how to study for verbal now that I don't have the online kaplan module?
Thanks in advance !
 
I'm a 23 y/o Masters in Biotechnology student and a Research Assistant in Neuroscience. I took the MCAT twice.

MCAT August 06: 27R (10B, 8P, 9VR)
MCAT April 07: 29P (13B, 8P, 8VR)
Undergrad GPA: 3.75
Grad GPA: 3.5

I want to apply this summer because I'm finally sure that this is what I want to do and I don't want to spend more time doing anything else.

Both times I took the MCAT I had a very very busy schedule (FT student, PT work, honors thesis, ncaa athlete). If I retake the test I will clear my schedule this time. I was upset after the april mcat results because I was getting 11-12 VR scores and 32-33 total scores on the practice tests.

Should I retake the test? Will I have a decent chance with these scores for MD schools? DO schools?

I can only afford to apply once so I need to make sure I have a good chance. Also, I want to go into psychiatry, do I need to go to an MD school for this specialty? What do you think of DO schools for psychiatry?
😕
 
so i took my mcat in july of 2007 (end of july) and i ended up with a 27Q.. i got a 9p/10v/8b. I was really bummed out about this, especially bio. I took kaplan last summer to prep for it and seriously took 10 practice exams. On the last 4 or 5 I was scoring between 30-33 so I was feeling pretty good, and then when I got the 27 i was really shocked. So now i'm signed up for the june 13th administration, but i'm really scared about it. After studying so much last year (seriously devoted my entire summer to it, all my friends never saw me) i'm worried the same thing might happen again this year. Does anyone have any advice/study tactics/inspiration for studying again for the mcat?? I'm not taking a class again, and i'm planning on using examkrackers mostly with some kaplan books too. Also any ideas for how to study for verbal now that I don't have the online kaplan module?Thanks in advance !

I thought the EK VR and EK 101 VR Passages was great VR practice. Good luck.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top