Overall (mind you it's only been 6 weeks) I've been pretty happy with 'Natti COM. I can't really speak to what other schools are doing and I imagine that a lot of things I like will be true for most other med schools.
Things I like:
1. Block curriculum. Seeing the same things from different angles in different classes really helps. All this memorizing would be more excruciating without the redundancy between physio, histo, biochem, and gross.
2. Free tutoring (the best thing I ever signed up for.) They pay second years to be tutors. It'll be a nice perk and easy review if I qualify to tutor next year.
3. Weekly content review and pre-exam review sessions with professors (scheduled)
4. Tons of online resource material provided by professors including quizzes, tests, and self-assessment software.
5. The second years TA our small groups, which I imagine will make step I review a lot easier when we're second years
6. Recorded lectures
7. I'm interested in Peds so having Children's hospital right across the street is a plus
8. The CARE building is kind of cool.
9. $75 worth of free printing at the library
10. Tons of free food from student groups (although we do pay a $90 activity fee)
11. Block Exam weeks
12. Professors are pretty on top of making sure you know what you should be studying and focusing on
13. Lots of opportunities for ECs like free clinic, H1N1 vaccine, shadowing, research, mentoring, etc.
14. So far I haven't met anyone that I don't like. (though I gotta admit that I haven't spent much time with my classmates)
15. Tons of pre-exam prep like a practice practical the day before our Gross practical exam, practice labs before our HISTO lab exam, etc, etc.
16. I'm pretty certain that we'll be well prepared for step 1. The average score last year was 233 (SD 19) compared to 221 (SD 23) for the national average. The curve was bimodal with 30% in the 216-230 range and 30-35% in the >245 range. 25-30% were in the 230-245 range. 2 people had to retake and 1 didn't pass out of 150.
Things I don't like (mostly minor):
1. The building is FREEZING. And I'm told it gets worse in the winter.
2. This is more a non-trad gripe. They scatter small group and clinical skills stuff through-out the week so you pretty much have to go to school almost everyday. I'd appreciate it if they clustered them on certain days so I could stay home and just study somedays. Being a family guy, I would have appreciated being able to stay home to help out my wife and play with my daughter.
3. I would have appreciated more direct instruction for Clinical skills, rather than a lecture and learn-it-yourself approach they seem to have. Though I'm told that you pretty much pick this stuff up as you go along anyway. It just seems like a very low yield use of our time. I'd almost just rather spend a day at a clinic each week or every other week. Seems like you'd learn better than the way they're teaching it.
4. Gross lab. It's probably just me, but I feel like we're constantly lost and begging for help on the dissection from the proctors. And our group actually has one of the better dissections. Maybe it just takes some time to get used to.
5. Small groups are painful and boring. I'd almost always rather be studying.
6. The way things are structured I think the curriculum is more time consuming than it needs to be. (sort of goes to point 2) I think they could streamline things more so we had more time just to sit with the material and learn it. I think I would have appreciated the independent study curriculum they have at OSU.
7. It ain't easy getting to school in the morning if you have to drive.