- Joined
- Apr 2, 2008
- Messages
- 5
- Reaction score
- 0
Do you know or heard of an optometry student dropping out with good academic standing after the 1st year and switched to dentistry?
Do you know or heard of an optometry student dropping out with good academic standing after the 1st year and switched to dentistry?
Why do that ?
hhahha no 🙂 but one of my classmates did two years of dental school before coming to opt school... he said he just got sick of it and didnt want to deal with peoples mouths... lol and that he did not really have the dexterity for dentistry
Partly because of this:
Originally Posted by gochi![]()
OD's need to deal with insurance panels so they can accept a broad range of patients thereby allowing them to increase there earnings. But this is all very complicated as there is some sort of discrimination inflicted upon OD's which limits patient base. When you're patient base is reduced, so is your salary etc...Pharmacists on the other hand do not have to deal with this.
No doubt that OD's are primary eye care provider's but Opthamolgist's are always here to do what OD's do plus more. I don't think a profession exists in this day and age which would replicate a pharmacists task.
Another thing, most of an OD's earning is due to product sales such as contact lenses, glasses, frames etc... Now, imagine this- 1000 OD's graduate. Half of them go into Private practice while the other half goes into corporate optometry (wal-mart) Say the p.practitioner's sell frames for $50 while the corporate optometrists sell them for $25. Everything is going as planned until X years later Z number of schools open up pumping out 1000 more graduates. Again, half of the graduates go into p.p while the other half go into corporate optometry. The p.p can no longer sell the frames for $50 as there are MORE corporate stores selling them for half the price. This would cause either the owner of a p.p. to close down or an associate working for a senior doc to have a reduced salary.
With all this said I can confidently say that there is an extreme saturation of OD's nationwide. Most likely, this will increase due to new school's opening up in the next two years or so. Due to this factor, optometry might not sound financially stable.
BUT, it's whatever you make out of the profession. You can succeed but it will take a lot of effort that pharmacist's don't need to exert in order to be successfull.
The opening of the 3 new schools fall 2009 doesn't help either. I've worked for years as a fabricating and dispensing optician as well as a tech doing pre-screening and some entrance tests. I knew what I was getting into but I contemplated doing dentistry as well. I know I can equally enjoy doing both but choose optometry because of my experience. But with issues above as well as other reasons and the difference in income potential I have to re-evaluate what I'm doing.
To tell you the truth, I'd be happy with this than work in peoples mouths all day.
I don't know about you, but my dentist takes less than a minute looking in my mouth. Even cavities don't take that long.
Also, you see a dentist in every corner of shopping center now adays. Maybe there are too many of them?
Is this some kind of joke?
Come to socal, as you drive down one street you will see in a row a Law Office, dental, optometry, chiro, podiatry, med. Drive a bit further, it repeats as far as the eye can see.
Is this some kind of joke?
No it's not a joke!
I'm in Maryland and I see Dentist offices every shopping center now. There is a huge supply of them.
The grass is always greener on the other side!
yeah, plus some ODs keep dumping grass killer on our side! (Low fees, commercial, low ball insrance, refering everything out.....you name it)
Don't let the most vocal people on this board tell you the field sucks. Optometry is a good profession.
BTW, how many of you have a family owned practice to purchase when you graduate?🙄
That's not the question here though. The original poster was/is pondering switching over to Dentistry. She/he then started receiving naive advice from Optometry students that in all reality have no friggin' clue. The FACT is, there is NO comparison between Optometry and Dentistry when it compares to ease of making a living, future prospects (think socialized medicine and vision plans), earning potential, and prestige amongst other health care professionals. It's not even close, but it's a free country, and if you want to smoke the water bong and convince yourself otherwise, please be my guest.
If you are as unhappy as your posts here and on ODWire make you out to be, what keeps you in this profession?
My wife.😀
Actually I'm not unhappy. I make a good living, enjoy the patient care aspect, as well as being my own boss. However, there are plenty of negatives with Optometry most of you will find out about soon enough, and the point of this thread is advising someone on whether or not they should switch form Optometry to Dentistry.
I guarantee, nearly every person here will be shocked about the state of the profession soon after they hit the work force. You don't realize it yet, but the schools have lied to you. Your national leaders have lied to you. IMO, you should consider a class action law suit against your school and the AOA for fraud.
However, the fact that students are even on this forum should be an indication that they are making an effort to research the profession.
I don't get that feeling. Most of the time the response from students is that the optometrists here are just bitter and upset that they couldn't be successful as an OD. I don't think they REALLY want to listen.
If you are as unhappy as your posts here and on ODWire make you out to be, what keeps you in this profession?
But do you honestly think that bitterness doesn't echo like music on this forum from most of the doctors that take the time to post? There's a big difference between complaining and sounding bitter and complaining while offering constructive help and advice. Most of the docs sound like the former. Listing your grievances and regrets isn't helpful to anybody so why would they listen? Although, you really have to give credit to people like Dr. Elder and Dr. Chunder who still tell it like it is, but then offer a plethora of valuable information on keys to being successful despite some problems.
You're right Dwight. You guys know everything. Good luck.
P.S. Ken Elder, and Ben Chudner are a couple of the brightest minds in the profession. My point? Most of you folks won't be as successful as they are because frankly you're not smart enough, and or, don't possess the same work ethic. Also, they've struggled mightily (Ken moreso than Ben) to be where they are today. Whether you want to believe it or not (and I'm sure you don't 🙄), sharp minds in other health care professions don't have to work so damn hard to succeed.
if money is a big factor for making a switch...and you have credentials to get into dentist school....do it.
Don't get a big head K.😀Well....the kind words are greatly appreciated although I can't honestly lay claim to possessing any sort of brilliance. I definately however, did earn a 4.0 at the school of hard knocks, with respect to my career.
No.
If money is a big factor for making a switch and you have credentials to get into "dentist school"....don't do it, instead go into business. Honestly, its not worth it to go through all that s*** just to make a six figure salary.
Don't get a big head K.😀
KHE brings alot of experience here, and is very articulate, but we've talked before about his lack of true detail in his postings. In his opinion, there's no reason to tell the whole story on this forum because frankly, he doesn't think it will matter, and you folks will find out soon enough anyhow. I respect that, and he's probably correct.
I've been more negative here than I should, but no one here, and I mean NO ONE is paiting a real picture of the profession. I figure my little dose of reality (and mark my words they are real) will add to the entire montage of opinions posted. So as KHE said, take them with a grain of salt, but by all means.....take them.
Don't get a big head K.😀
KHE brings alot of experience here, and is very articulate, but we've talked before about his lack of true detail in his postings. In his opinion, there's no reason to tell the whole story on this forum because frankly, he doesn't think it will matter, and you folks will find out soon enough anyhow. I respect that, and he's probably correct.
So as KHE said, take them with a grain of salt, but by all means.....take them.
You're right Dwight. You guys know everything. Good luck.
P.S. Ken Elder, and Ben Chudner are a couple of the brightest minds in the profession. My point? Most of you folks won't be as successful as they are because frankly you're not smart enough, and or, don't possess the same work ethic. Also, they've struggled mightily (Ken moreso than Ben) to be where they are today. Whether you want to believe it or not (and I'm sure you don't 🙄), sharp minds in other health care professions don't have to work so damn hard to succeed.
Ken I was referring to your cover story, which I thought was "light" in realism, but otherwise very well done. I have already discussed this with you.
It's one thing to convince naive students who don't know any better, but to convince another OD that he shouldn't be as happy as he is really makes me question your intentions.
Question away Dwight. Those who know me will tell you I call it the way I see it, and I don't care if you "buy it" or it pisses anyone off. I made no such attempt to "convince another OD he shouldn't be happy" (it is weird you took it that way), I questioned how his experience will relate to the majority of new grads considering he graduated into a family owned Optometry business from day one. His experiences certainly are valueable, as are your's, and maybe even mine🙄, but a little context never hurt anything.
Yeah, screw those vocal people. But listen very carefully to the knowledgeable ones.
BTW, how many of you have a family owned practice to purchase when you graduate?🙄 chirp-chirp-chirp......you know what those crickets sounds mean right? The vast majority of you folks are going to be in a warehouse or mall, spinnin' and grinnin' on the phoroptor 6-7 days per week, or starving for 5 years building a private practice. Might as well get it through your thick skulls now. If you think your medical or dental colleagues are going to have the same trials and tribulations, you're deluding yourself. But hell, deluding ourselves is one thing Optometry does very well.
Signed,
The Reality Monster (aka green grass killer)
Dwight I'm not trying to convinced anyone, just giving the original poster an honest opinion. The lies the AOA and the Optometry schools propagate about the earning potential and lifestyle ODs enjoy, will ensure a steady stream of naive (and defrauded in my opinion) fresh meat. The facts are, most new grads will not come close to 6 figures (afterall...there's only so many WalMart and Lenscrafters leases available😉), and will end up in the commerical meat grinder as independant contractors for the lease holder, never to break free.
NOTHING I repeat NOTHING about Dentistry compares to the above scenerio.
wow, and I thought it was just the chiropractors that had the issues lol. Has anyone hear heard of a site called chirotalk? It's basically a forum for disgruntled chiros who want to vent and bash the profession. Not everything they say is true, but not everything they say is a lie either. Is there such a site concerning optometry?
Dwight I'm not trying to convinced anyone, just giving the original poster an honest opinion. The lies the AOA and the Optometry schools propagate about the earning potential and lifestyle ODs enjoy, will ensure a steady stream of naive (and defrauded in my opinion) fresh meat. The facts are, most new grads will not come close to 6 figures (afterall...there's only so many WalMart and Lenscrafters leases available😉), and will end up in the commerical meat grinder as independant contractors for the lease holder, never to break free.
NOTHING I repeat NOTHING about Dentistry compares to the above scenerio.