I got a B in orgo II and I got into a few programs for next year. I was really mad at the time because my prof didn't give any guy in the class an A and girls who had failing grades received A's. He has since been released from the school for sexual harrassment allegations. However, I never had to mention any of that on any of my applications or interviews and the committees were able to overlook the grade when they saw the rest of my transcript. Like Jeter, no one even questioned or said anything at the schools I interviewed at (half of the ones I applied to), but that doesn't mean that the programs I didn't get interviews at didn't look down upon it.