cali7925 said:
Every M.D./D.O. has to deal with nurse's, P.A.'s, P.T.'s etc. thinking that they could do the job of a doctor...so many of these professionals are p***** off that they dont make the money docs make and claim that they, "know just as much" and would be able to "diagnose just as well". I have this to say, get your heads out of your as***. P.A.'s have so many fewer years of training in physiology and medicine, there is NO WAY they could replace doctors. I mean, I understand docs are arrogant as H*** and it is a real Pain in the a** to work with a lot of them, but when nurse's P.A's and other members of the health care team get just as arrogant, all hell breaks loose and they function as a dysfunctional team providing substandard care. Each member of the team has their own responsibilities....the P.A. is to ASSIST the physician, not compete with them. If you wanted an M.D. or want one, go get one. Nuff said.
P.A.'s have so many fewer years of training in physiology and medicine, there is NO WAY they could replace doctors.
I am not sure where you went to med school, or are attending med school. But, last time I checked, the didactic portion was still only two years tops, a class in every system. Would you agree medical school is a physoligical systems breakdown, then once you know how it's all supposed to work, and what can go wrong with it, then you learn how to diagnose it and fix it? (for about 18-20 months?
PA school is still 12-15 months of didactic. Although the classes are more "generic" where as, instead of having a class in every system, there is a different route to learning the basics, and the intricasies are left out. Your exclamation of "SO MANY MORE YEARS" is far from an acceptable claim. Also, one must realize, to get into PA school, a student must have completed an entire year of physiology in undergrad, which is applicable to learning medicine, although Med students know that physics/chem/ochem have little carry-over application into basic medicine, the Physiology of undergrad DOES, so that can count towards a PA students total time spent learning physiology. So, rejustify your comment about time spent learning physiology.
We all know, the medical education of a physician gets into pathophys at a more detailed level, it's been discussed 100x's.
You rebutted my statement, with an argument that had no application to my comment whatsoever. I simply stated, there are quite a few physicians whom I am aquainted with, who admitted they feel they would enjoy being a PA more so then being a physician, based on their experiences having practiced medicine for quite a while, and what else is involved in owning a medical practice besides just being a good physician.
Nowhere in the statement you so kindly quoted and replied to, did I mention PA's learn everything a physician learns, nor did I mention a PA is better at diagnosis then physicians are, (although team up new and old PA's and new and old MD's and I bet the tendency for proper diagnosis on both sides will prove to be a similar distribution)
Now, you're brain might be totally fried based on your spending WAY MORE YEARS learning physiology then any PA ever does, but might I suggest you read the posts you are quoting, and make sure what you write in response to said post at least has the smallest amount of direct relationship to the words you are trying refute. Or else, people begin to think you are just an idiot, another one of the people that give physicians a bad public image, by jumping onto your soap box and yelling " I went to medical school!!! I went to medical school!!!" in an attempt to have people assume you have credibility and personality. Unfortunately, you are about 20 years too late. The public view of medicine is filled with admiration anylonger
If you spent so many more years learning physiology, be proud of yourself, in your knowledge and your ability, and do your job and don't hire a PA, but don't bitch about it.
By the way, the only PA's that truly, merely "assist" a physician, are people in surgery. Most PA's working in FP,IM,Derm,EM etc, they have their own patient load, and see them independantly, they don't stand next to a doctor and follow orders, they make decisions, and practice medicine. And, as more and more PA's have been in practice for 20+ years, it is becoming quite common, for PA's to help in the education of new medical residents.
Similar in nature to the DA, and Deputy DA dynamic, they do their own things, individually, but the DA is always in charge.
P.S. If I had wanted to get my DO, I would have matriculated to one of the three acceptances I got to Medical school. I headed the warnings from my family friend physicians, and took the PA spot. The more I hear the new med students, and residents talk, the more happy I am about my decision.
What I want to know, is why do med students feel so threatened by PA's and NP's? If you know in your heart of hearts, that you can "school" each and every PA and NP at medicine, then why worry. You ever notice, the more people know, and the more they KNOW, that they know, typically the more humble they become. Yet, the people that aren't bad asses, the ones that don't have it all in their back pocket are typically the ones who must "be better then someone" to justify their own postition. Who are you proving it to, yourself or to others? You want to prove you know more, don't tell people you know more because of how much school you underwent, prove it to people in your skills and professionalism. Sheesh, I think if life has taught me one thing. It's that usually it is the insecure who try to present themselves as being better then any one other person in this world.(goes back to the whole kids teasing kids thing) Those that are truely comfortable with who they are, are accepting of even the most uneducated/fat/ugly/arrogant/ people.
Shoot, maybe i should be a motivational speaker!
*this ramble was not checked for spelling or grammar errors, if you find them, please be happy in your triumph, but realize, they do not alone make me stupid, it's the other aspects of me that truely make me stupid!