Sure, but those classes aren't requirements for medical school matriculation, which the post I quoted was referring to. We were talking specifically about the prerequisite courses for PA school vs. medical school, which do, in fact, differ, regardless of what pre-health students actually choose to take. There are plenty of people in my class who haven't taken the classes I listed.
Also, (this part is to
@Mr. Hat as well) I never said that undergrad A&P is equivalent to medical school phys and anatomy, and that's not what my former advisor said either. What he/I meant was that less time spent in the classroom during PA school is
to an extent accommodated by having more prerequisites, not that it was "made up for" by the prerequisites. It was an offhand comment about the tradeoffs in timing for the MD/PA routes, and he/I certainly didn't mean to say that the coursework is equivalent. I can see that my last post was unclear about that point, so sorry about the confusion.
TL;DR I was simply correcting the misconception that the prerequisites for medical and PA school are identical...objectively speaking, they're not. I said nothing about the difficulty of the courses compared to medical school. You guys read a bit more into my post, so I apologize for any lack of clarity on my part.
I'll admit that it does vary by school but here's an example from Iowa's PA program (widely considered to be one of the best in the country)
PA pre-requisites:
- 2 years of Biology (1 intro and 3 upper division biology courses) (1 course must be animal, human, or exercise physiology)(anatomy not required)
- General chemistry 1 and 2
- Organic chemistry 1
- Introductory Biochemistry
- Statistics
That's it. Now you've also got to have over 1,000hrs of patient care experience, but that should be the standard for any PA program.
MD pre-requisites:
- 1.5 years of Biology (2 intro and 1 upper division course)
- General Chemistry 1 and 2
- Organic Chemistry 1 and 2
- Introductory Biochemistry
- Statistics
- General Physics 1 and 2
- 1 year of English
- 2 years of social or behavioral sciences (psychology, sociology, anthropology, foreign languages)
The only real difference is that PAs take 2 extra upper division biology courses while MDs take an extra intro to biology course, organic chemistry 2, general physics 1 and 2, 1 year of english, and 2 years of social/behavioral science.
Overall the MD students have more hard science prereqs. In any event, taking an extra 1 semester basic physiology course then another upper division biology course (anatomy, cell biology, or microbiology) doesn't really give you any significant medical knowledge or allow you to condense or shorten the curriculum. Not to mention that most MD students are Biology/Biochemistry majors which require way more upper division courses than either of the prereqs stated above. That being said, so are PA students. In the end, both students have similar science backgrounds.
Now, if PA students were required to take a full year of upper division anatomy and physiology, plus genetics, immunology, microbiology, virology, histology, cell biology, and epidemiology (similar to M1 courses but in significantly less depth) then it might be a different story.