- Joined
- Feb 19, 2009
- Messages
- 291
- Reaction score
- 9
PAYE vs IBR
This last December a new federal loan payback program was passed called Pay As You Earn (PAYE). It's the successor to Income Based Repayment (IBR), that allowed students to have loan payments at 15% of their discretionary income and if they couldn't pay it back in 25 years, the balance of the loan was forgiven and counted as taxable income.
PAYE makes it much easier - now your loan payment is only 10% of your disposable income and the loan is forgiven at 20 years. I think "Disposable Income" is calculated by your adjusted gross income minus the poverty level for your household size. Others have said that it's your after-tax income minus the poverty level, but the website wasn't clear. You can play around with the calculator below.
There are a few requirements to PAYE. The first is that you can't have any loans from before Oct. 1, 2007. This disqualifies some people who took loans to finish undergrad. The second is that you must have take out a new loan after Oct. 1, 2011. Lastly, your PAYE payment must be less than what your 10 year repayment plan payments would be – at my school everyone who used loans as their main funding source would qualify for this.
Here are the .gov sites for IRB and PAYE:
IBR - http://studentaid.ed.gov/repay-loans/understand/plans/income-based
PAYE - http://studentaid.ed.gov/repay-loans/understand/plans/pay-as-you-earn
PAYE Calculator - http://studentaid.ed.gov/repay-loans/understand/plans/pay-as-you-earn/calculator
For Example: if your adjusted gross income is $120,000 (the 2011 median income for a dental associate, according the new ADA report) and you have a family of 3, the calculator spits out a monthly payment of $756/mo. This is independent of your loan balance - no matter if you owe $200,000 or $500,000, your payment is $756/mo. and scales as your income increases.
Standard 10-Year Repayment Plan
At my school, if you take the full loan disbursement each year: $100,000, you walk out of school with around $440,000 because of fees and interest accumulated during school. To pay it off in 10 years your monthly payment would be right around $5,000. By the end of those 10 years, your cumulative payments would total to $607,000.
PAYE as an Associate making $120k/yr
In contrast, if you were an average associate, making $120k/yr for those 20 years, your payment would stay at $756/mo. At the end of the 20 years your loan balance would be forgiven, even though it had ballooned to over $1 million. Your total out of pocket would be $181,000, less than the original loan balance!
PAYE as a Solo Dentist making $165k/yr
Now, I admit that it would be rare if a dentist stayed an average associate for 20 years, so what if that dentist went on his or her own? The ADA says in 2011 the solo doc would make $165,000. Plugging that into the calculator gives us a monthly payment of $1131/mo. The total payed over the 20 years would only be $271,000 – still less than the original loan balance.
PAYE as an Above Average Dentist at $300/yr
Lastly, lets say the new doc goes on their own, reads Dentaltown, takes a bunch of CE, hires an associate, and makes 300k/yr (which is higher than the new ADA average of $220k for a dentist employing associates). The calculator gives us a payment of $2256/mo., less than half of the 10 yr repayment plan. This still doesn't cover the interest, but it's enough to stop the loan from ballooning to $700K-$1mil+. Over 20 years the dentist will pay $541,000, which is less than the $607,000 they would pay if they had done the aggressive 10-year plan.
What is the disadvantage?
At the end of the PAYE description, it says, "you may have to pay taxes on any loan amount that is forgiven after 20 years." To me that sounds like they're going to count your loan forgiveness as taxable income at year 20, but it's a pretty ambiguous statement. If that's the case, in the first two scenarios with payments well below the interest accruing the final loan balance is anywhere from $600,000 to $1,000,000. So would you be liable for taxes as if you earned $1mil plus whatever you are making as a dentist at the time? What are taxes on $1.12 million? What happens if you can't pay that, does the IRS seize your practice and home? Or do you take out a new loan and repeat the whole cycle?
I want to make sure that my classmates understand this program correctly, one classmate proposed that you should take out the max loan amount every year even if you don't need it since your payment will stay the same and it will all be forgiven. I don't want him to shoot himself in the foot if there are some unforeseen tax implications to this.
This last December a new federal loan payback program was passed called Pay As You Earn (PAYE). It's the successor to Income Based Repayment (IBR), that allowed students to have loan payments at 15% of their discretionary income and if they couldn't pay it back in 25 years, the balance of the loan was forgiven and counted as taxable income.
PAYE makes it much easier - now your loan payment is only 10% of your disposable income and the loan is forgiven at 20 years. I think "Disposable Income" is calculated by your adjusted gross income minus the poverty level for your household size. Others have said that it's your after-tax income minus the poverty level, but the website wasn't clear. You can play around with the calculator below.
There are a few requirements to PAYE. The first is that you can't have any loans from before Oct. 1, 2007. This disqualifies some people who took loans to finish undergrad. The second is that you must have take out a new loan after Oct. 1, 2011. Lastly, your PAYE payment must be less than what your 10 year repayment plan payments would be – at my school everyone who used loans as their main funding source would qualify for this.
Here are the .gov sites for IRB and PAYE:
IBR - http://studentaid.ed.gov/repay-loans/understand/plans/income-based
PAYE - http://studentaid.ed.gov/repay-loans/understand/plans/pay-as-you-earn
PAYE Calculator - http://studentaid.ed.gov/repay-loans/understand/plans/pay-as-you-earn/calculator
For Example: if your adjusted gross income is $120,000 (the 2011 median income for a dental associate, according the new ADA report) and you have a family of 3, the calculator spits out a monthly payment of $756/mo. This is independent of your loan balance - no matter if you owe $200,000 or $500,000, your payment is $756/mo. and scales as your income increases.
Standard 10-Year Repayment Plan
At my school, if you take the full loan disbursement each year: $100,000, you walk out of school with around $440,000 because of fees and interest accumulated during school. To pay it off in 10 years your monthly payment would be right around $5,000. By the end of those 10 years, your cumulative payments would total to $607,000.
PAYE as an Associate making $120k/yr
In contrast, if you were an average associate, making $120k/yr for those 20 years, your payment would stay at $756/mo. At the end of the 20 years your loan balance would be forgiven, even though it had ballooned to over $1 million. Your total out of pocket would be $181,000, less than the original loan balance!
PAYE as a Solo Dentist making $165k/yr
Now, I admit that it would be rare if a dentist stayed an average associate for 20 years, so what if that dentist went on his or her own? The ADA says in 2011 the solo doc would make $165,000. Plugging that into the calculator gives us a monthly payment of $1131/mo. The total payed over the 20 years would only be $271,000 – still less than the original loan balance.
PAYE as an Above Average Dentist at $300/yr
Lastly, lets say the new doc goes on their own, reads Dentaltown, takes a bunch of CE, hires an associate, and makes 300k/yr (which is higher than the new ADA average of $220k for a dentist employing associates). The calculator gives us a payment of $2256/mo., less than half of the 10 yr repayment plan. This still doesn't cover the interest, but it's enough to stop the loan from ballooning to $700K-$1mil+. Over 20 years the dentist will pay $541,000, which is less than the $607,000 they would pay if they had done the aggressive 10-year plan.
What is the disadvantage?
At the end of the PAYE description, it says, "you may have to pay taxes on any loan amount that is forgiven after 20 years." To me that sounds like they're going to count your loan forgiveness as taxable income at year 20, but it's a pretty ambiguous statement. If that's the case, in the first two scenarios with payments well below the interest accruing the final loan balance is anywhere from $600,000 to $1,000,000. So would you be liable for taxes as if you earned $1mil plus whatever you are making as a dentist at the time? What are taxes on $1.12 million? What happens if you can't pay that, does the IRS seize your practice and home? Or do you take out a new loan and repeat the whole cycle?
I want to make sure that my classmates understand this program correctly, one classmate proposed that you should take out the max loan amount every year even if you don't need it since your payment will stay the same and it will all be forgiven. I don't want him to shoot himself in the foot if there are some unforeseen tax implications to this.