Pediatric Interview Impressions Thread 2013-2014

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

oldbearprofessor

Full Member
Staff member
Administrator
Volunteer Staff
20+ Year Member
Joined
Mar 14, 2002
Messages
5,015
Reaction score
1,586
Well, it's that time of the year again...

Here is the link to the sticky above with links to previous impression threads.

Really we can do better folks!

We all realize that many of you want to post your impressions anonymously. As I admittedly am part of my program's review committee, some might not want to send those to me. I assure you that if you do, I'll not try to figure out who you are. I further assure you that I'll have submitted my interview review before you walk out of the hospital anyway.:p So, you're welcome to PM them to me. However, if you would prefer not to, in the past J-Rad has agreed to handle them as well and I suspect any of the mods would do so as well.

Members don't see this ad.
 
It seems like a lot of people are interested in sharing their interview info with everyone so we can all benefit! It really is a valuable resource for everyone, especially for programs that don't have much info already available on the forums.

Would any mod like to volunteer to field the PMs so we can post anonymously? (Or does it not have to be a mod?)

Below is the typical format:

Program Name
Structure:

Faculty:

Housestaff:

Program:

Facilities:

Misc:

In sum:
Pros:
Cons:
 
Or if no mod wants to do it you can PM me I guess.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
Golisano Children's Hospital - University of Rochester
Interview Day:
- social at a resident's house the night before, a lot more residents than interviewees
- intro by PD, attend morning report, intro to CARE and tracks, 2 interviews, meet alumni and chiefs, lunch and hospital tour
- hotel shuttle to social and to hospital for interview

Faculty:
- approachable, interactive with residents and seemed to enjoy teaching
- faculty were really involved in morning report, good turn out
- dedicated hospitalist group as well as subspecialists

Housestaff:
- medium size (16 residents)
- very nice, mostly from upstate NY
- fellows in almost all subspecialties but feel they have autonomy

Program:
- hospital within a hospital, opening a brand new children's hospital tower (connected to strong hospital) in 2015
- have CARE track (advocacy), primary care and research track
- very well developed advocacy/community outreach programs through Hoekelman center, work with underserved urban area in Rochester
- have CCU and allow residents to rotate in for 1 week
- night float system
- continuity clinic in hospital, focus on teaching and being "cutting edge" for primary care

Facilities:
- really old and beat up building, only 1 floor in the hospital
- will be moving into a brand new tower in 2015
- really small ED (will not be in new tower)

Misc:
- the weather is less than desirable but great location if you are interested in upstate

In summary...
Pros:
- great community advocacy/outreach opportunities
- excellent teaching model, faculty really interested in teaching
- happy residents
- very affordable
- brand new facilities soon

Cons:
- really cold and snowy location, lake effect, not much to do
- may have to deal with any bumps that come from the transition to the new space
 
Come on guys, help us future applicants out :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
QUOTE:

Program Name: Seattle Children’s

Interview day:
- Social at a bar the night before with great resident turnout.
- Chief resident welcome, meeting with PD/Chair, morning report, two interviews in the morning, program overview, noon conference, tour, another interview, wrap-up. Done by 3:30.

Faculty:
- Friendly, seemed to enjoy working with the residents.
- Attending at morning report had to solve a tricky case presented by the residents; good dialogue.

Housestaff:
- Large program (38/year, up from 33 a few years ago). Were very enthusiastic and friendly. They seem to do a lot of socializing and activities with each other (hiking, traveling) with each other outside of the hospital.
- Majority from Pacific NW/California, but the west of the country is well-represented

Program:
- WWAMI is a highlight; you spend 2 months during your second year as a working member of a pediatric practice in a rural setting. Most residents picked that out as the most memorable part of their training.
- Graduates go on to do a good mix of primary care and fellowships. Fellowship placements were impressive, including Boston Children’s, CHOP, etc.
- Lots of exposure to subspecialty care as they are the main referral center for the WWAMI region as well as bread-and-butter peds, being the main pediatric hospital for the Seattle area.

Facilities:
- Hospital is beautiful. Gorgeous new ED/PICU with more room for expansion. 24 hour Starbucks.
- You do some time at UW and Harborside hospitals but those seem close.
- The hospital is in a suburban area and parking is easy, which is good since nobody seems to live close to the hospital.

Misc:
- Thursday lunch sessions reserved for confidential “intern support group”
- Continuity clinics are structured so that you do 1 day/week during elective months and none during your ward months.
- Currently progress notes are on paper but they are phasing that out (everything else is EMR)

In sum: Great program with a mix of primary care and subspecialty pediatrics.
Pros: Diverse patient population from huge catchment area, WWAMI rotation, beautiful facilities
Cons: Suburban setting, Seattle weather, not great public transportation
 
QUOTE:

Program Name: OHSU

Interview day:
-Dinner at a bar the night before.
- Intern presentation, morning report, PD presentation, tour, interviews, noon conference, meeting with the residents, PD wrap-up.

Faculty:
-Didn’t interact with them much. The residents say they have a close relationship (they’ve gone out for happy hour as a group).
-The PD was very energetic and involved in the educational conferences.

Housestaff:
- Close group from all over the country.
- They seem very supportive of each other and family-oriented; there is no problem getting maternity/paternity leave or personal time.
- 17 residents per year

Program:
- Good mix of subspecialty and general peds. Not many fellows.
- They seem to do a ton of clinic/outpatient rotations.
- 3-week rotations instead of 4

Facilities:
- Two separate floors in a big medical complex. The facilities are about 10 years old. Big, open spaces with a beautiful view. Connected to the adult hospital for NICU/ED/nursery rotations.
- The medical education department was in another building. Have to go outside several times a day for conference.

Misc:
- Stressed that many of the residents see the same psychiatrist. I thought that was kind of weird.
- Were very into biking to work. You park your bike at a “valet” and take a tram to the hospital. Not for those with fear of heights. Parking is tough at the hospital.

In sum: Small program with tight group of residents and faculty who seem to love the program and Portland. Quirky schedule with short rotations.
Pros: Portland is great, and it seems like the residents get out of the city a lot. The metro area is beautiful, close to mountains and beaches. I drove but other applicants said the bus/train system worked well.
Cons: Parking at the hospital seems like a pain. Lower salary than I’ve seen elsewhere ($51k)
 
Does anyone have any information/impressions for Southwestern from this year?
 
does anyone have any info on the NYC programs (particularly Columbia vs Montefiore vs Cornell)?
 
Anyone at baylor? Would love to hear about the schedule since I've heard mixed things about the workload
 
Members don't see this ad :)
does anyone have any info on the NYC programs (particularly Columbia vs Montefiore vs Cornell)?

I would also love to hear what others thought of the NYC/close-to-NYC programs. I interviewed at a bunch of them, but I'm particularly interested in what people thought/know about Mt Sinai- prior to my interview I'd heard vague negative things about the program, but I had a really positive interview experience and would love to hear from others...
 
Last edited:
Does anyone have any input on Mt Sinai vs. UT Southwestern Children's vs. Loma Linda for pediatrics residency? Need help with rank list and not sure how to rank these 3 - I liked all 3 but they are so different that I don't know which to put in what order...I am hoping to pediatric cardiology.
 
is this it? pretty weak turn out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
is this it? pretty weak turn out.

What would you like to know? I found these forums helpful and want to give back in any way I can for the med students who will follow.

Here's the thing: so much of interviews is subjective. For instance, I thought poorly of one program because only one resident came to the dinner, but that could have just been a one-time thing and so it's not fair of me to tell you which program that was. Most of what went into my rankings was based on how much I liked the "vibe" or "feel" of the place. That is completely subjective and not easily communicated through an online forum.

Honestly, many programs are very similar in a lot of ways and many of the things that applicants think matter probably don't. Most children's hospitals are very attractive buildings. I couldn't care less about how many rotations have night float vs. Q4 call. If they have an EMR, I don't really care which one it is. At every program you'll be doing 2-3 months of PICU and 2-3 months of NICU. You'll have to do a bunch of floor months. You'll have continuity clinics roughly once a week. Pretty much everywhere has fellows and most of the places (except for one or two very notable example I can think of) will tell you that their hospital is "resident run". Everywhere will talk about how one of the greatest parts of their program is the people, and they'll pretty much all be right.

Most of the decision will come down to: where do you want to live and what kind of co-residents, attendings and fellows do you want to work with and learn from? You'll also take into account rankings, cool misc features at each place, freestanding vs. not, and how academic a program is it. You'll figure that out on your interview day. I spent a lot of time talking with faculty mentors at my school about my rank list, and so will you. I also spent time thinking about research opportunities and other resources at each place.

I interviewed at all seven peds-anesthesia programs (Stanford, UC-Irvine, Medical College of Wisconsin, UNC, Hopkins, Boston Children's/Brigham, Pittsburgh) and eight other categorical peds programs (CHLA, OSHU, Seattle, Colorado, Utah, CHOP, Dartmouth, Baystate). If anyone has specific questions about my impressions of these program, I'm happy to share those. I just think it's important to understand the limitations of the impressions I (or anyone else) got from a program after interviewing there for 1-2 days.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
thanks for the reply @physicsnerd42. i still think it's good to see the various descriptions of programs according to individual interview experiences. guess it's just not a big thing in the peds forums. appreciate your response though.
 
thanks for the reply @physicsnerd42. i still think it's good to see the various descriptions of programs according to individual interview experiences. guess it's just not a big thing in the peds forums. appreciate your response though.

When I get home, I can post impressions of the places I interviewed. I pretty much agree with physicsnerd, though I interviewed at many more programs that don't have a lot of fellows.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Obvious disclaimer here: I was looking for a specific type of program, so my pros/cons list reflected this.
MUSC
Interview Day:
- Put us up in a really nice hotel not too far away. Dinner at a local restaurant the night before.
- Day goes until three, total of 2 interviews, lunch at a local restaurant and tour afterwards, followed by quick wrap-up by chiefs.

Faculty:
- Seem to be fairly involved

Housestaff:
- Largely from Southeast
- 19 residents/year

Program:
- Pathways available in primary care, inpatient, and outpatient subspecialty.
- Very strong cardiology program, with I believe the only cardiothoracic surgeon in the state.

Facilities:
- Hospital within a hospital, technically, but in a separate tower, so it almost feels like a stand-alone. Working on construction of new hospital, with projected opening in 2020.

Misc:
- Global health program only has funding to send 2-3 residents per year abroad, so if more than that want to go, you have to do a lot of the legwork to fundraise the funds yourself.

In sum:
Pros:
- Residents are very friendly and really do seem to be a family
- Charleston is beautiful and there's lots to do
- Good interaction with residents outside of peds as well

Cons:
- Limited fellowship opportunities
- It's South Carolina
- No NICU nights. Which supposedly doesn't affect training, but seems odd
- Development and Adolescent in 2nd year
- Not a strong global health program
- Not such a diverse patient population - mostly white and black, with minimal Hispanic and other cultures


Children's National Medical Center
Interview Day:
- A note: they do not provide a hotel, and are not located on a metro line. HOWEVER, they do have a shuttle running from the nearest metro line as well as Union Station.
- A further note: I had a bad experience prior to interview day, which may have colored how I felt about the rest of the day. You've been warned.
- Very little interaction with the residents on interview day itself--you get a 30 minute session with them in the morning, but during lunch you're at noon conferences, and many of their happy hours take place the night after interviews, so it can sometimes be difficult to go to. Otherwise, variable end times depending on your own interview schedule (I had both my interviews first thing in the morning, so I was done after lunch; if you're doing a pathway, you have to travel in the afternoon for your pathway interview).

Faculty:
-Not much interaction with them, so I'm not sure. The PD is a Star Trek fan, though.
- Emphasized that many faculty have teaching certificates.

Housestaff:
- 40 residents/year, roughly--some do Peds Genetics, some do Child Neuro, in addition to the various tracks.

Program:
- Pathways available in community/advocacy and Primary Care
- Heavy on the advocacy in general (since you're in DC), and Residents as Teachers curriculum.

Facilities:
- Stand alone children's hospital, plus community hospital and teaching hospital for NBN.

Misc:
- Lots of benefits for being part of a union, including a lot more vacation and pay compared to other programs in the area.

In sum:
Pros:
- Extra half day per week to do research/clinic/whatever PL2 and PL3.
- highest salary I've seen yet at $56k
- Unionized residents, so they really, really care about feedback
- Holiday bonuses
- Community hospital site, where you act as the pediatrician on call. Med students function as interns there.
- DC, so large young professional community and lots to do in spare time

Cons:
- You have to have a car. In DC.
- It's DC. Which means COL is higher than any other place I've considered
- Food allowance is rolled into salary. Considering how much other programs feed their residents, I'm not sure how much of a plus this is, so I'm considering it a con.
- They have pre-arranged tracks. As in you have to match into them. You can still take some of the track-specific courses from other tracks, but this seems really stringent.

University of Arizona/Diamond Children's Medical Center
Interview Day:
- Do not provide a hotel, but do provide discounts to local places. Dinner the night before at a local restaurant.
- Day ended around 3.

Faculty:
- Seemed nice enough.

Housestaff:
- Large number of IMGs/DOs in program.
- 15 residents/year

Program:
- Huge emphasis on Global Health, since Mexico is a very short distance away.

Facilities:
- Semi-stand alone Children's Hospital attached to main hospital.
- Community hospital
- Various clinic rotations, including predominately Spanish-speaking.

Misc:
- Boards pass rate a couple years ago was at 57%. They made multiple changes in the curriculum, and the pass rate was 100% in 2013.

In sum:
Pros: Lots of global health, lots of opportunities to learn Spanish.
Cons: History of being not such a strong program. Not a lot of fellowship opportunities.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
thank you @mvenus929! reviews like yours DO help us students. much appreciated.
 
Phoenix Children's Medical Center/Maricopa County Hospital
Interview Day:
- Provided a hotel, dinner night before was at a resident's house.
- Very open to second look days.

Faculty:
- The PD was super friendly and welcoming, and the staff at Maricopa were also very nice and welcoming.

Housestaff:
- 32 residents/year, plus Peds Genetics, plus Med/Peds residents.

Program:
- Second continuity clinic offered during second and third year
- Formal teaching curriculum seems well established

Facilities:
- Stand alone Children's hospital, with lots of room for expansion (something like the top 3 floors are currently unoccupied).
- County hospital at Maricopa (more medicaid and Spanish speaking)
- Several satellite clinics for continuity clinic
- Two additional sites for NICU: St. Joseph's and Banner

Misc:
- As of my interview day, they still had paper charts in the primary clinic, Epic at Maricopa, and a custom-built EMR at Phoenix Children's.
- Limited fellowships (EM and Heme/Onc were the only two stated).
- Lots of outdoor opportunities nearby, but also a lot of shopping, theater, performing arts, etc. COL seems reasonable, and people live all over.
- Separated surgical vs. medical PICU teams, and unclear whether peds residents rotate on the surgical team.

In sum:
Pros: Second continuity clinic, stand alone children's hospital, seems to be a lot of autonomy in the ED and at Maricopa,
Cons: Limited fellowship opportunities, Phoenix summers

University of New Mexico
Interview Day:
- Did not provide a hotel room, but I think they provided discounts to local hotels. Dinner was at a diner with residents--there was some awkwardness with my residents at dinner. There was also a lot of overlap between the residents who went to dinner and the ones that came to lunch.
- Interview day consists of morning report, talk with the PD and coordinator, interviews, lunch, and a tour. I think I was done around 2 or 3.
- Of note, the residents supposedly have a lot of say in the rank list, so you really need to be on your best behavior all the time.

Faculty:
- Not a whole lot of interaction with them, but the ones we did meet were very nice.

Housestaff:
- 17 residents/year

Program:
- Huge advocacy program. Every resident writes up a CATCH grant, and many are submitted and implemented
- Large emphasis on rural medicine, with at least one rural rotation during residency
- The way they do morning report is kinda cool: they make it a competition between the med students and each year of residents, and each month, the group with the highest number of points gets a prize.
- PICU rotation during first year. All PICU rotations are shifts, rather than 24 hour call.
- Global health also emphasized, with just about every resident doing a global health rotation.
- Individualized curriculum is a track system, with Primary Care, Fellowship, and Categorical being the tracks.

Facilities:
- Children's pavilion--not entirely stand-alone, but the top two floors are dedicated to peds, and the floor right below is Mother/Baby.
- Several satellite sites available for continuity clinic. Some are in neighborhoods with an interesting immigrant patient mix.

Misc:
- Again, limited fellowship opportunities.
- Patient population is largely Hispanic and Native American. Catchment area is all of New Mexico, some parts of Mexico, and some parts of Texas. Population of New Mexico is about 2 million, with 1 million being in ABQ itself.

In sum:
Pros: Good global health and advocacy program
Cons: Limited fellowship opportunities, not a great individualized curriculum, limited patient population

Colorado Children's/Denver Health
Interview Day:
- Did not provide a hotel, but provided discount codes. Interviews are only on Thursdays and Fridays, so they have a happy hour at one of the bars downtown on Thursday night to catch all the applicants. There are a ton of residents who make it out to this.
- Interview day consisted of a presentation, interviews, and a tour of Children's, followed by a bus ride to Denver Health and a tour and talk with the chief resident there. Day ended around 2:30.
- Some of the interviewers are third year residents.

Faculty:
- The faculty I interacted with were all nice.

Housestaff:
- 29 residents/year (this number may not be right), plus Med/Peds
- First and third years know each other well, second years are more isolated due to electives experiences.

Program:
- Starting an academic half day, a total of twice per month (once with just your class, once with the whole program), in lieu of doing noon conference every day.
- Individualized curriculum is huge, they give you 3 months during third year to schedule basically whatever you want, down to the half-day of scheduling.
- PICU rotation during first year (at Denver Health)
- Second continuity clinic available.

Facilities:
- Stand alone Children's hospital
- Denver Health, which is a county hospital with a primarily Spanish speaking/Medicaid population
- Various opportunities for continuity clinic, from Denver Health to the Children's Hospital to private practice clinics.

Misc:
- Children's acts as a referral center for 6 states
- Opportunity to do a rural rotation or a transport rotation to learn how to manage kids away from Children's.

In sum:
Pros: Lots of opportunities for highly complex cases, as well as the bread-and-butter cases. Second continuity clinic and longitudinal experience during third year.
Cons: Bit isolated in the children's hospital. Lots and lots of fellows, so very little in the way of procedures/autonomy (clearly I can't make up my mind on this point :)). No cap on patients, so can get overwhelming at times, but everyone seems willing to help out.
 
Congratulations to all of you guys and thanks for sharing your experiences!

Does anyone have any feedback about U of Hawai'i's program?

Thanks :)
 
Top