- Joined
- Sep 21, 2010
- Messages
- 194
- Reaction score
- 1
I'm gonna preface this by saying it is not my intention to be provocative or critical of PB&R (uy, that's always a good way to start a thread).
I'm starting med school in august and, in the course of investigating sub-specialties (I'm pretty much set on pediatrics) several people have suggested PB&R as a good lifestyle-friendly option. At first I was excited by this option, I have a close friend that is a pediatric PT, I've seen what she does and it seems awesome, and I thought physiatry would be similar but with more versatility.
When I mentioned PB&R to my PT friend she kinda flipped. She said physiatrists don't do anything, she said they're glorified PTs that don't actually do physical therapy. Now, this isn't the first time my friend has shown disdain to another profession or degree (she still thinks DOs are quacks), she's always been a bit close-minded but her opinion does matter to me, so I looked into it.
I read all the stickies on sdn and I'm still having trouble figure out what exactly physiatrists do. I've heard they're like orthopedic surgeons w/o the surgery... uhh, the vast majority of being a surgeon IS surgery last I checked, at best this makes them sound redundant and possessing of a tiny and insignificant role. I've heard they coordinate the rehabilitation of patients by diagnosing, helping with pain and sending them to the appropriate therapist (PT, OT, speach, etc.). Okay, a coordinator could be very helpful in this process, I can see that, but this seems like such a limited role as to be almost absurd. PTs are great at diagnosing MSK disorders and there are lots of docs who can do pain management.
So I'm asking... what am I missing? This is a specialty requiring four years a post-grad training and I refuse to believe it is as redundant and small as I am lead to believe. If I went into pediatric PB&R what would I be to my kids? What would my average day be like? How would I justify the existence of my profession to my hypercritical PT friend? Please know that I am not dependent on the opinions of others for my happiness, but if I can't clearly define and defend my profession well enough to explain it to her then I have to suspect that I will always have my own doubts.
I'm starting med school in august and, in the course of investigating sub-specialties (I'm pretty much set on pediatrics) several people have suggested PB&R as a good lifestyle-friendly option. At first I was excited by this option, I have a close friend that is a pediatric PT, I've seen what she does and it seems awesome, and I thought physiatry would be similar but with more versatility.
When I mentioned PB&R to my PT friend she kinda flipped. She said physiatrists don't do anything, she said they're glorified PTs that don't actually do physical therapy. Now, this isn't the first time my friend has shown disdain to another profession or degree (she still thinks DOs are quacks), she's always been a bit close-minded but her opinion does matter to me, so I looked into it.
I read all the stickies on sdn and I'm still having trouble figure out what exactly physiatrists do. I've heard they're like orthopedic surgeons w/o the surgery... uhh, the vast majority of being a surgeon IS surgery last I checked, at best this makes them sound redundant and possessing of a tiny and insignificant role. I've heard they coordinate the rehabilitation of patients by diagnosing, helping with pain and sending them to the appropriate therapist (PT, OT, speach, etc.). Okay, a coordinator could be very helpful in this process, I can see that, but this seems like such a limited role as to be almost absurd. PTs are great at diagnosing MSK disorders and there are lots of docs who can do pain management.
So I'm asking... what am I missing? This is a specialty requiring four years a post-grad training and I refuse to believe it is as redundant and small as I am lead to believe. If I went into pediatric PB&R what would I be to my kids? What would my average day be like? How would I justify the existence of my profession to my hypercritical PT friend? Please know that I am not dependent on the opinions of others for my happiness, but if I can't clearly define and defend my profession well enough to explain it to her then I have to suspect that I will always have my own doubts.