No debate that systemic antibiotics should be Rx-only - but what about actual OTC drugs in the United States? If having a runny nose or having an episode of heartburn can be a symptom of something more serious, shouldn't we remove patients ability to self-treat and self-manage any of those things with OTC products? We should probably eliminate OTC drugs all together, and require anything that is classified as a drug, i.e. approved by the FDA to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent disease, require a visit to the doctor and a prescription. Otherwise, the FDA is taking liability here that it probably shouldn't - giving people the reassurance that they can just self-treat those hemorrhoids or that sore throat. /s
A visit to the doctor and receiving a full physical exam for any and every minor ailment would sure be nice, but isn't realistic. Plus, the waste of resources and potential for overdiagnosing and overtreatment probably outweigh the benefits. I still haven't seen any data indicating pharmacist-facilitated self-treatment of minor ailments leads to fatal missed diagnoses and significant harm to public health. The abx resistance example isn't relevant to US practice since systemic abx are not available OTC, and rightly so. Any condition for which systemic abx is indicated does not fall under the definition of a condition that can be self-diagnosed, self-treated, and self-managed.