Premed Committee Interview problem?

Started by neuro1617
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

neuro1617

Full Member
10+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
I talked to my advisor today about spring classes and the premed committee interview, and he informed me that they do not meet over the summer. I am applying to med schools this spring/summer and am not taking the MCAT until June. The committee will not interview you and write their letter to send to schools until they have your MCAT score. So he said I won't be able to have the interview until September, meaning I won't be complete at schools until September at the earliest! I really want to do everything in my power to have the best application possible and was hoping to be complete by the end of August.

How detrimental is this to my application? I definitely want to use the committee but I can't believe this is the case. When are most other committee interviews? Will schools be able to begin reviewing my app if they have all my supplemental letters in early and just wait on my committee letter?
 
My school holds a commitee interview in May, but only for EDP applicants to our in-state schools. All other applicants must wait until September. You could get the required letters and have them sent to your potential schools early, and in September send the committee letter.

No you are not going to be at a huge disadvantage when applying. I am assuming most schools don't do interviews until the first couple weeks in the Fall semester.
 
My school holds a commitee interview in May, but only for EDP applicants to our in-state schools. All other applicants must wait until September. You could get the required letters and have them sent to your potential schools early, and in September send the committee letter.

No you are not going to be at a huge disadvantage when applying. I am assuming most schools don't do interviews until the first couple weeks in the Fall semester.

True, but the vast majority of these interviews will be going to people who were complete earlier in the summer. Even if you have your committee interview during the first week of September, schools aren't going to be getting their hands on your letter for maybe even a week after that because it takes time to write the letter and have it sent. Furthermore, you aren't instantly deemed complete once your letter arrives, so count on at least a few days after that until you're in the clear.

I'm not trying to dissuade you from applying this cycle, but just know that you will be at somewhat of a disadvantage. Will this keep you from getting interviews you would have gotten if you applied earlier? Maybe, maybe not. Will it keep you from being accepted? Again, nobody can say for sure.
 
You really need to talk to your adviser. Being essentially "forced" to either be complete in September, wait an extra year to apply, or take the MCAT in the spring during classes is pretty ridiculous.

Imo, being complete in September is a very real disadvantage to an applicant. Not as if its a huge disadvantage, but you would surely miss the first round or two of interview invites (and the available spots they can give only gets smaller and smaller as time goes on).

Also, I understand why you would want to wait until June to take the exam. Thats what I did this year because studying for it while you're still in school is tough. Being able to focus on it with less else going on is advantageous.

I think you should talk to your adviser and politely explain the circumstances. Maybe even back it up with some facts from schools (just call them) about the importance of a timely application. That said, don't shoot yourself in the foot by ticking anybody off too much.
 
Its not a problem. Just have your amcas primary application submitted way early. and get to work on those secondaries. You'll be surprised how long all of this takes. If you take the MCAT in june, you wont get ur scores til july. assuming ur happy with them, you can then submit ur amcas in july(when u get your scores back), and the amcas will then be completed and varified in the end of july/beginning of august. After that, schools will start sending you secondaries. So at most you will be a few weeks behind with the committee letter. Just make sure you emphasize that the rest of you application stuff is ready, and the faster they could send out their letters would be of great benefit to you.

Btw, cant you get an interview in the end of august or something, thats usually when schools start up. if you get your secondary apps finished, sent and completed by the end of september you'll be fine.

I personally took a second mcat august 26 (but i was allowed to submit my amcas with one MCAT and a "will take at later date"), and got my score september 30th (which is essentially when my files became complete) and i got interview/waitlists and what not within 2 weeks. My interview is in december (3rd cycle), which isnt too bad.

I recommend asking them the earliest you could possibly interview, and then realize that even if it is the 1st week of september it only matters relative to when you complete the school secondary apps, because even if u had the committee LOR, it wouldnt matter with out the secondary apps submitted.
 
Last edited:
My school schedules committee interviews after we've submitted the super-long questionnaire full of short essays, etc.. in March. So they do interviews from March-early May. They guarantee letters to be out by mid-July to early August the latest.

Being complete in September is not a death sentence. As other posters have said, stuff happens...People take/retake MCATs in August, face sudden family problems, etc.. I think that if you try and do everything that you can to get everything done by September, you should be fine. If you're complete then, you can theoretically still have interviews for late October, depending on the school.
 
My committee did not send letters until september. It hasn't really affected me too negatively so far... I guess it depends where your are applying, rolling vs non-rolling and also some schools decide interview you before you are even complete ie Iowa.
 
I talked to my advisor today about spring classes and the premed committee interview, and he informed me that they do not meet over the summer. I am applying to med schools this spring/summer and am not taking the MCAT until June. The committee will not interview you and write their letter to send to schools until they have your MCAT score. So he said I won't be able to have the interview until September, meaning I won't be complete at schools until September at the earliest! I really want to do everything in my power to have the best application possible and was hoping to be complete by the end of August.

How detrimental is this to my application? I definitely want to use the committee but I can't believe this is the case. When are most other committee interviews? Will schools be able to begin reviewing my app if they have all my supplemental letters in early and just wait on my committee letter?

i graduated in 2006, and am applying this cycle. i didn't really understand the whole committee letter thing and didn't realize it was something people had, so i went about my business as i normally would. asked two profs from college to write me recs and my PI and a post-doc. when it came time to get my recs from college they told me about this committee letter thing and said that most schools like to have one, but it's not crucial. the head of the med studies committee said that she would write me a letter of good standing to preface my other recs. basically saying that i had graduated in good standing at bates and that the only reason i didn't have a committee letter was because timing wise it didn't line up for me to get a letter. i sent all of my other recs to bates and they uploaded them all together with the letter of good standing. i don't think it's hurt me at all as i've had interviews at hopkins and umass so far.

you might look into that as an option. have someone write a short thing just saying that you graduated/will graduate in good standing and you don't have a committee letter because you took the MCAT in the summer and the committee doesn't meet until the fall.
 
I think it depends on alot of things, like what schools you are applying to and what your applicant profile looks like. My school started interviewing as early as the end of spring semester, but ran interviews through october-ish. Is being complete in september killer? I'd say definitely not. Of course, it is always to your advantage to be complete as early as possible, but many schools dont even start looking at applicants until september. But this, again, depends on your profile and where you are applying. It is much more beneficial to be early at rolling school than at non-rolling schools. Similarly, being early helps those applicants who feel that they are "on-the-border." If you're a killer applicant with a 4.0 GPA and 45 MCAT score, then applying in September/October versus August wont really make much of a difference, especially at a non-rolling school.

If you want some kind of empirical proof, I sent in my AMCAS in late July, was verified in Late August, had my interview in August, sent LOEs in Mid-Late sept (like 9/20) and was complete at most of my schools from September 25-October 5. You can look at my MDapps but, so far, I don't think it's hurt me very much.

Good luck with everything. It is of course still to your advantage to get everything done as early as possible, but dont let SDN scare you into thinking that completion in september versus august all of a sudden means going from 20 interviews to zero.
 
i graduated in 2006, and am applying this cycle. i didn't really understand the whole committee letter thing and didn't realize it was something people had, so i went about my business as i normally would. asked two profs from college to write me recs and my PI and a post-doc. when it came time to get my recs from college they told me about this committee letter thing and said that most schools like to have one, but it's not crucial. the head of the med studies committee said that she would write me a letter of good standing to preface my other recs. basically saying that i had graduated in good standing at bates and that the only reason i didn't have a committee letter was because timing wise it didn't line up for me to get a letter. i sent all of my other recs to bates and they uploaded them all together with the letter of good standing. i don't think it's hurt me at all as i've had interviews at hopkins and umass so far.

you might look into that as an option. have someone write a short thing just saying that you graduated/will graduate in good standing and you don't have a committee letter because you took the MCAT in the summer and the committee doesn't meet until the fall.

The funny thing is, a lot of committee letters are just glorified cover letters. I wouldn't be surprised if schools saw the blurb and assumed that it was the committee letter.
 
Good point. I might just try what tabrazinski was saying. My advisor is the head of the committee anyway and I could just have him write a letter which would essentially be the committee letter since he writes it.
 
I had my letters done on september 24th so i was complete at most of my schools by october 1st. Since then i haven't heard anything back from any of the schools except my home undergrad that offered me my only -so far- interview and my only acceptance and if i hadn't been that lucky i am sure that i would be on fire right now.
 
If it's an option, I would just forget about the committee and get individual letters from individual faculty. Most schools that I have looked at give you that option. Heck, you might want to get individual letters and a committee letter and then update your file with each school after you get the committee letter.
 
If taking the MCAT in June v. May is going to be a huge difference for you, don't alter your schedule, but since you know this ahead of time now it might be worth it to plan for a May MCAT. Being complete in September v. August is NOT a huge deal, however, an interview in September does not necessarily mean a letter will be produced in September--find out when the letters would actually be forwarded along to all your schools if you interviewed in September with the committee. Get them to be as specific as possible, and maybe even talk to past applicants to your school, because sometimes people like to give overly optimistic projections about these things.
 
I bypassed the committee and got individual letters. I explained about the lateness of the committee meetings on any secondaries that asked about it. I eventually went through the committee, but it was moot because I had acceptances before the letter was written. My state schools told me it would be in my best interest to get in as early as possible. They said that the incoming class may be mostly filled by the time they get the committee letter and get around to inviting later applicants for an interview.

Another benefit is getting rid of the stress of applying, interviewing, etc. as quickly as possible. I was accepted at my top school before anyone else here was complete. Smooth sailing afterwards... At least until med school starts.