medic170 said:
It probably depends on the school and the committees reputation. Many schools, such as mine, do not even have these committees, so I would not think they matter to much as long as you have other outstanding LOR's.
Why did they not give you a good rec? Did you make some mistakes in undergrad? Maybe some specifics could help us help you.
Sorry that this is a bit lengthy.
I have about 2 semesters worth of withdrawal F's from 10 years ago that really drag down my GPA, but they didn't seem too worried about that.
They gave me a "Recommended with reservations" their second lowest. Here are their reservations:
#1. Very limited shadowing experiences.
#2. Very little articulated passion for a career as a physician.
#3. Not as aware as most students about the variety of health care opportunities available and how different health care providers work with one another.
I asked the committee chair this: "Could you provide me with a little more quantitative reason behind each so that I can understand how you reached those conclusions? For example: how much shadowing experience would be adequate? Also, I believe I have a superior awareness of the health care opportunities available as compared to other students; would you say that it was like #2 in that I did not articulate this well, or do other students actually shadow a number of different professions?"
Here is her nebulous answer: "Shadowing experiences - enough to give you examples that you can use that will give evidence of passion, enough to show you how various health care providers work together to help people, enough to show you that this is the right career for you. (There is no way to quantify this.) Awareness of health care opportunities may be an articulation issue."
Here are the reasons that their reservations were questionable (respectively)(they were aware of all of this as it was in my application for committee review in one form or another):
1. Shadowed over 14 physicians for more than 81 hours worth of experience.
2. I have demonstrated that I have a lifelong commitment to becoming a physician. I idolized it as a child, I developed a fascination with it that has lasted to this day. I returned to college 7 years after failure and attempts at other careers for the sole purpose of getting into medical school and have not changed my mind from entering freshman 12 years ago to senior and about to graduate now. I have persisted in the face of adversity over the last 3½ years to accomplish respectable grades and outside recognitions in two different majors. I have chosen to work in the medical field over the last 3½ years despite the fact that I could make more money elsewhere, I believe that it is very important to my healthcare education. I chose to apply only to Osteopathic colleges precisely because of my passion for medicine; I believe that the advantages for myself and my patients gained from osteopathy far outweigh the only two disadvantages which are prestige and money.
3. As a pharmacy technician, I work with many other health care providers to provide patient care including but not limited to: other pharmacy techs, pharmacists, educators, physicians, nurses, nurse aids, administrative staff, nutritionists and dieticians, surgery techs, paramedics, etc. I am aware of whom they are and what roles they fill in patient care. I have to answer their questions. I get to learn from them.