MD Preparing to reapply, advice?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Otterly

Full Member
7+ Year Member
Joined
Feb 1, 2015
Messages
96
Reaction score
529
This cycle I applied to 21 MD schools and got 5 interviews. Out of those I sitting with 1 waitlist and 1 rejection, and 3 I've yet to hear back.
Thus, I'm preparing to consider re-applying. My sense of what my weaknesses are is possibly 1) MCAT, 2) clinical experience, and 3) schools list.

1. MCAT
I took the MCAT and scored a 516. However my sciences were 126 C/P and 127 BB, while I got 132 P/S and 131 CARS. My dilemma at the time was that I had practiced scoring higher on the sciences, but had not practiced that high in the other two sections. I decided not to retake because I felt there was a good chance of getting a lower total score. And I think I felt (perhaps falsely) reassured that my overall score was high enough to make me a viable applicant.
So I could re-study, perhaps coughing up the money for a course this time instead of self-studying, and try to get more consistent with having higher section scores.

2. Clinical Experience
Due to some personal factors and also my location, I didn't have a lot of clinical experience during my undergrad years. I had one summer that was spent shadowing and assisting full time for 10 weeks at a primary care clinic but that was limited to that summer. I applied at the end of my senior year, and I'm spending my gap year working as a mental health technician. However I hadn't yet been hired when I submitted my primary, so though I included it in all secondaries/update letters, it may be missing from adcoms calculations of clinical hours. I also wonder if there is stigma towards the mental health field, and so adcom members may not see it as truly clinical (though it is...med management, taking and monitoring vitals, first aid, etc not to mention tons of direct patient interaction).

3. School list. I don't really know what I might've done wrong with my list, but I know that this is a common answer when people with otherwise solid apps have a rough cycle. I applied to 21 schools:
-all 6 CA state schools (I'm a CA resident, rejected pre-II at all 6)
-Kaiser- a wild card honestly (silence)
-3 "reaches": Icahn (pre-II R), Case Western (pre-II R), Pitt (II, waitlist)
-11 mid-level: Rochester (II), USC/Keck(pre-II R), Jefferson/SKMC (II), Tufts(pre-II R), Georgetown (II, R), NYMC(pre-II R), Albany (silence), MCW (silence), SLU (II), Drexel (hold), Temple (silence)

If you've read this far thank you for taking the time, and I'd appreciate any feedback you have!
 
I don't think the MCAT is the problem, 516 is a good score regardless of the sections and it isn't like one of the sections was 124 or lower. I also would not assume the cycle is over. Waitlist is certainly better than being denied and you have 3 interviews that have yet to make a decision. When were those interviews that have not gotten back to you yet?
I do However think you need to address the EC side of things if you have to reapply. I would definitely highlight the mental health technician and would not worry about it not "counting", I think it is very apparent it was a good experience. I also don't see any reference on your post to research hours, which a vast majority of applicants have in some form. If you could shed some light on that it would make it easier to advise.
 
Thank you very much!

The interviews I haven't heard from were in mid to late february and early March, so I know I probably won't hear much for another 4-8 weeks.

I am pretty confident about my research. I did a funded independent project at my school summer after sophomore year, and then did independent research towards my senior thesis throughout junior and senior year, ~15-20 hours per week. I presented posters at a few conferences, and was accepted to a big national conference that was canceled due to COVID.
 
I think for now you just have to be patient. 5 II's is a good haul, so your application is solid. Plus you just recently interviewed at most of the places.


Also your MCAT is not a problem, that's a good score. Also your mental health technician job is absolutely clinical and 100% a positive addition to your application!
 
Oh with that much research this is a fantastic application! I would just wait and see what happens!
Thank you very much!

The interviews I haven't heard from were in mid to late february and early March, so I know I probably won't hear much for another 4-8 weeks.

I am pretty confident about my research. I did a funded independent project at my school summer after sophomore year, and then did independent research towards my senior thesis throughout junior and senior year, ~15-20 hours per week. I presented posters at a few conferences, and was accepted to a big national conference that was canceled due to COVID
 
Top